The paper is useful and gives us a good outline of the tensions that we face in drawing up our work programme. We will hear feedback from the Scottish Civic Forum event shortly. By necessity, we need to take on board what members are telling us, because we are here to make procedures work best for them. However, we also have to think about people outside the Parliament.My perception of last week's debate—I do not know whether Richard Baker will share this view—was that the time scale for bills, particularly at stage 2, was a primary issue. Points were raised about whether stage 2 was too quick, whether there might be ways to do it smarter and how we can involve people more by giving them feedback. That issue should be a priority.I am not sure whether the issue of Sewel motions is as high up the agenda as it was previously, because we have a generally agreed procedure for dealing with such motions. I am not diminishing the importance of Sewel motions, because there are issues around them that we have to consider. We also have to consider members' bills. Two issues that arose in the chamber debate and the Scottish Civic Forum event could take higher priority in our work programme than options 2 and 3 in the paper. One of those issues is committees meeting in private, on which there was a lot of discussion and divergence during last week's debate. There was also discussion at the Scottish Civic Forum event about the difficult problem of whether we should provide general guidance for committees on how they should deal with issues in private and when that would be appropriate. I do not know whether we could take action on that quickly, but we should not sweep the matter away just because it is not easy. I do not feel comfortable with the issue, but it has been raised so we have to think about it.Secondly, a number of members commented last week on whether the Parliament is in control of its procedures to the extent that it should be and on matters such as what we call ourselves. Given that the Scotland Act 1998 is about to be reviewed, there might be no better chance for us to sort out a matter that is not politically sensitive—it should not be politically sensitive if what everyone said in the chamber was true about our needing to take more control of our procedural affairs. If we can get that on the agenda now, given that the Scotland Act 1998 is about to be amended, we might be able to deal with the matter. If, however, the matter was seen to be political in the context of the Scotland Act 1998, it would not have a hope in hell of flying and it would not be worth doing. Others might think that it is not worth dealing with such procedural matters now; I think that it is, but I recognise the constraints around me.It would be useful to add those two matters to a discussion about where our priorities lie.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Bruce Crawford only · show everyone- Iain Smith LD 21
- Mark Ballard Green 11
- Karen Gillon Lab 8
- Bruce Crawford SNP 7
- Cathie Craigie Lab 6
- Andrew Mylne Clerk 5
Bruce Crawford’s contributions
7 contributionsCan I just reverse a wee bitty? I threw in private stuff because I know that we will have to discuss it at some stage. I share a lot of Karen Gillon's concerns, but if we are not going to produce guidance on committees meeting in private, we must reach a firm conclusion on that.Mark Ballard raised an important issue on Sewel motions. The other issue on Sewel motions is the financial implications that the Westminster bills will have on the Scottish Executive's budget. Although the Executive's memorandums have improved considerably, they do not yet tell us in a significant way what the bill's implications will be for finance, sustainability or equal opportunities. We could do a bit more work on those three areas before we say whether a Sewel motion is acceptable or not. We need a bit more information, and we could still usefully do some work on that.
I am reasonably content. However, there is one issue that I want to come back to: whether we have enough powers to do what we should be doing. Would it be possible for us to ask Westminster what the time scale for the lodging of an amendment to the Scotland Act 1998 is likely to be? If the amendment needs to be lodged soon, we might miss out on influencing that debate.
We need that information before we can make a decision.
Sometimes, ye dinnae get if ye dinnae ask.
Is your advice that the Scottish Senior Citizens Unity Party could sit on the bureau?
So when there are four of them they can get on the bureau.
In this meeting
Everything on 2 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Procedures Committee Tuesday 2 December 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Non-Executive Bills Committee business · 82
- Work Programme Procedure · 58
- Scottish Civic Forum Committee business · 20
- Item in Private Procedure · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.