Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Business Improvement Districts (Ballot Arrangements) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 (Draft)

Tuesday 6 March 2007 Local Government and Transport Committee Subordinate legislation 39 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

39 contributions
Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

For the last of today's affirmative instruments, we are joined by Nikola Plunkett. I ask the minister to introduce the draft regulations. We will then take questions.

Tom McCabe Lab Hamilton South
link

The draft Business Improvement Districts (Ballot Arrangements) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 will enable business improvement districts to involve tenants and owners, and domestic rate payers, in voting on BID proposals. The regulations put in place the option for BID proposers in Scotland to seek the participation of tenants and owners in their BID area. The approach was recommended to the Executive by the BIDs working group and has been broadly welcomed by the public sector and the private sector.We recognise that the involvement of owners and tenants is not straightforward because of issues such as registration and the tenure of properties. On the whole, though, we are content that the regulations provide a workable solution that meets the wishes of the business community in Scotland. There is a two-part voting system. The regulations concern themselves only with the second part. The system is designed to protect the interests of large and small businesses. The number voting and the rateable value of the properties involved have to be in the majority for the BID proposal to be approved. That approach prevents one group from forcing unwelcome proposals on another.When only ratepayers are involved in a ballot, there is a simplified voting procedure along the lines of the one that was adopted in England and Wales. However, Scottish stakeholders considered that not just ratepayers benefit from successful BIDs. Owners and tenants also gain through increased property prices and higher rateable values, so it seems fair that, where appropriate, they should participate and have the associated voting rights and liability for a levy. Some of the Scottish BID pilots are investigating the best ways to involve tenants and owners in their proposals. The regulations give them the scope to do that.The regulations complement two other pieces of legislation on BIDs. First, draft regulations on BIDs are being finalised and will be laid before Parliament later this week. Secondly, a draft section 104 order under the Scotland Act 1998 on the reserved aspects of BID policy will be laid before the United Kingdom Parliament later this week. That is led by the Scotland Office with support from the Department for Communities and Local Government.The regulations are part of the partnership agreement to establish business improvement districts in Scotland. We provided funding for six BID pilots to kick-start the process and, with the committee's agreement, we hope to put in place the final pieces of the legislative jigsaw after today's meeting. The challenge will then pass to the Scottish business community to use its expertise to introduce BID projects to boost business areas and add value. There is every indication that they will receive the full backing of local authorities and other stakeholders, such as Scottish Enterprise.I will do my best to answer any questions.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I wish to raise an issue of which I gave the minister's office notice last week and which I raised during the stage 3 debate on the Planning etc (Scotland) Bill. It arises from what appears to be a serious flaw in the bill. I made the same argument in the stage 3 debate, so it will come as no surprise to the minister.The BID scheme is, broadly, one in which the Government puts in half the money for a particular project and the business community in a city centre puts in the other half. The Times Square model is often mentioned. There is a contribution from the public and a contribution from the private sector. That is the idea in outline, although there are variants of it.The flaw that was identified at stage 3 is that a business that rents property—whose tenure is as tenant—will have to pay its contribution, or its BID tax, as a tenant. However, as the minister knows, almost all tenants in Scotland have full repairing and insuring leases. That is certainly true of the vast majority of tenants of more valuable premises. Under such leases, there is routinely a clause that provides that the landlord shall pass on to his tenant liability for all rates, taxes and levies that are imposed by central or local government. I know that because I used to advise clients on commercial leasing.The clause that one tends to find is, broadly speaking, a standard clause. The idea is to pass on all potential liability for public taxes, whether local or national, from the landlord to the tenant. The landlord's motto is, "Let it and forget it." The tenant is lumbered with the local authority rates and taxes. The flaw of the Executive scheme, therefore, is that a tenant in a shop on Church Street in Inverness, for instance, will have to pay his BID tax as a tenant, as well as the landlord's BID tax. In other words, under the planning legislation that was passed by the Scottish Executive but opposed by us, some tenants might have to pay two taxes. That seems unfair in principle.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I just wanted to set out the general argument, so that it is clear for people who happen to be listening, as this is of great interest to the business community. Mr Chisholm, when he answered my point about this issue at stage 3 of the Planning etc (Scotland) Bill, admitted that this situation might arise. Since that time, have you sought to address and remove that flaw, minister? If not, do you accept that it is a fatal flaw for the legislation?

Tom McCabe Lab Hamilton South
link

No, I do not accept that it is a fatal flaw, and I do not accept at all that someone will have to pay two taxes. That is perhaps a misunderstanding of how the system will work. Mr Gilchrist can offer some clarification, and I will come back to the question later if necessary.

Colin Gilchrist Scottish Executive Legal and Parliamentary Services
link

In considering a particular property on the roll, we are not talking about two levies. There is one levy, which is allocated to the property. The amount of the levy is allocated between the owner and the ratepayer. Mr Ewing claimed that it is routinely the case that commercial leases in Scotland pass the landlord's outlays in that respect down to the tenant. That is a matter of commercial negotiation between the landlord and the tenant. Let us take the example of a short-term lease of six months or one year. Such a lease would not necessarily be on a full repairing and insuring basis. There might be a provision that the tenant pays the gas and electricity costs and the rates, but no reference to costs relating to the landlord's interests. I do not necessarily accept the argument that has been put.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Does the minister wish to add anything?

Tom McCabe Lab Hamilton South
link

I just restate that there is only one levy on a property. The idea that someone would pay two taxes is flawed. The levy on the property would be the same irrespective of how it might be divided. There may be an agreement between parties on the liability for whatever charges a property attracts.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Suppose that there is one levy in respect of one property—say a retail unit on Church Street in Inverness. That property is leased, so there is an owner—the landlord—and a tenant. How would the one levy be divided between the two parties?

Nikola Plunkett Scottish Executive Finance and Central Services Department
link

The BID proposal—which is voted on—establishes how the apportionment between the non-domestic rate payer and the owner is made.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Well, how would it be made? You tell me.

Nikola Plunkett Scottish Executive Finance and Central Services Department
link

Let us suppose that the levy for a property is £100 and that the BID proposal says that 10 per cent will be paid by the owner and 90 per cent will be paid by the non-domestic rate payer. The owner will pay £10 for that year and the non-domestic rate payer will pay £90.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I think that you would agree that, if the lease provided that the tenant paid the owner's taxes, as I have postulated, the tenant would pay the £90 plus the £10.

Nikola Plunkett Scottish Executive Finance and Central Services Department
link

Our position is that we do not think that that sum would automatically be passed on. When we looked at what has been happening in England, where they did not legislate for the involvement of property owners, we found that property owners have been getting involved voluntarily and have often made quite large financial contributions.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Yes, but it is a matter of simple law that if the tenant leases a property in a place where the BID levy is £100 and he has to pay £90, and his lease says that the owner is entitled to require him to pay all national and local taxation, the landlord is entitled to ask the tenant to pay the £10 as well. The landlord might choose not to do so if he is a philanthropist, but I confess that I have limited experience of landlords operating as philanthropists. The fact of the matter is that in a large number of cases, the tenant will have to pay the whole BID levy.

Nikola Plunkett Scottish Executive Finance and Central Services Department
link

Depending on the contract, it might be true that the cost will be passed on in some cases, but our understanding is that it will not be in most cases, even if the contract provides for it.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

On what is your understanding based? How are you able to conclude today that in most cases the whole BID levy will not be passed on?

Nikola Plunkett Scottish Executive Finance and Central Services Department
link

It is based on what we have heard from all our stakeholders, almost all of whom support the proposed way of providing for the involvement of property owners. It is also based on our understanding of how the situation is playing out in England at the moment.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

My specific question is, how do you conclude that in most cases the tenant will not have to pay the whole BID levy? How can you provide any evidence that gives you confidence that in most cases in which landlords are legally entitled to pass on a responsibility under a lease with a routine clause—I assure the minister that such a clause is commonly employed in respect of properties, particularly those of great value—the tenant will not have to pay the whole BID levy?

Tom McCabe Lab Hamilton South
link

There are different drivers at work here. We are introducing a new concept and a new opportunity in Scotland for people to contribute to improving their environment and business trading conditions. Clearly, if tenants felt that they would be responsible for 100 per cent of the levy, that might influence how they would vote on the BID proposal. That could be a driver that says to tenants, "Well, if I'm going to be responsible for 100 per cent of the levy, I don't favour that BID proposal." That is another driver that certainly has not been part of the dynamic between tenants and owners so far.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I think that I have put all my questions, convener.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

As there are no more questions, I invite the minister to move the motion before we proceed to the debate.

Motion moved,

That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the draft Business Improvement Districts (Ballot Arrangements) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 be approved.—Mr Tom McCabe.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I move against the motion, because of the arguments that I have just set out. It is clearly the case that there is a serious flaw in the legislation, which was identified during consideration of the primary legislation under which the regulations are made. I raised that flaw at stage 3 with the then Minister for Communities, Mr Chisholm. To be fair to him, he acknowledged that it was a serious problem that those businesspeople who rent property will find in many cases—I believe in most cases—that they will have to pay the landlord's share of the BID levy as well as their own.My evidence for that is simply two decades of practice in the legal profession, when I dealt routinely with commercial property. I see one of the civil servants shaking his head, as he is entitled to do, but it is routinely the case that commercial leases pass on liability from the landlord to the tenant. Landlords are not in the business of being philanthropists and they are entitled to enforce contracts. I know that the Scottish Executive supports and often has supported such an argument. Those who are entitled under the law to pass on liability will do so—that is the point of having contracts and paying expensive fees to lawyers.I will address briefly some of the arguments that were put in response to me. First, Mr Gilchrist said that some premises might be let under a short-term lease on a six-month or one-year basis, which is true. However, such properties are relatively few in number in city centres, they tend to be the smaller retail properties and, I believe, a clear majority of them tend to be occupied under the commercial leases that will pass liability for everything to the tenant.Be that as it may, even if some tenants do not have to pay the whole bill, an awful lot of them—I believe it will be most of them and the officials believe that it will not—will have to pay the whole bill. Surely that is unfair.The second argument, put by Nikola Plunkett, was that there is evidence that most owners will not seek to pass on liability to their tenant. When I asked her for the basis for that belief, she said that it was twofold: first, because she understood from stakeholders that that is the case; and secondly, because of the practice in England. I would like to know who the stakeholders are. I am not aware of anyone who has specifically said that landlords will not pass on legal responsibility to the tenants under their contract. I am not aware of any business organisation that would advise its members to give up legal rights that they have won in a contract that they have paid lawyers to draft and execute. I am therefore interested in knowing who the stakeholders are. I know that there are stakeholders who have expressed broad support for BIDs, but that is an entirely different matter.Ms Plunkett's second assertion was that in England, landlords refrain from passing on responsibility for this tax to their tenants, presumably out of a sense of public-spiritedness. Again, I would like to see the actual evidence for that, if there is any.Convener, I am not persuaded that the BIDs levy is anything more than a back-door tax on business at a time when we want business rates to be reduced, especially for small premises that are competing against internet-based businesses that do not have to pay business rates. However, the issue that I have identified today is a fatal flaw that the Executive could have addressed by preventing the passing on of such liabilities. That might have been difficult or impossible to achieve, but the fact remains that there is a fatal flaw in the draft regulations and that is why I will vote against them this afternoon.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

At least Fergus Ewing is being consistent in his opposition to business improvement districts. However, just because he is consistent does not mean that he is right—his argument is fundamentally wrong. I say so because, first and foremost, business improvement districts are not about philanthropic gestures by businesses; they are about businesses entering into relationships with other businesses and local authorities to improve the business prospects of an area. If businesses vote for a business improvement district, they do so on the basis that they think that the proposals for the BID will be good for their businesses. That can apply equally to people who are renting a property for the purpose of doing business and people who own a property that they wish to let for the purpose of doing business.Fergus Ewing seems to want to deny Scottish businesses access to a tool that is available to English businesses and that has been used successfully in several towns throughout England. It has been used successfully because businesses have voted for it. It is not, therefore, a tax on businesses—businesses have chosen to go into partnership with the public sector to improve town centres or business districts to enhance their own prospects.Fergus Ewing's question about tenants is also a red herring. Either tenants will be aware that they have a contractual obligation to pay the business improvement district levy because of the contractual relationship with their landlord or they will be aware that they do not have such a contractual relationship. They will, therefore, be able to make that decision when they sign the contract in the first place, when they vote on the business improvement district or when their lease comes up for renewal.If Fergus Ewing is concerned about the impact of costs and taxation on businesses and small businesses, the best that he could do is not concentrate on the costs of business improvement districts, which will be a relatively small percentage of any business's turnover, but tell his party leader to drop his policy of a local income tax that would hit local small businesses very hard indeed.Do any other members wish to contribute?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I was with you all the way, convener, until then. As we all know, a local income tax would help a great many people, but that debate is for another day. Although I disagree with your final comments, I will support the motion.

Tom McCabe Lab Hamilton South
link

You are right, convener, to say that businesses do not propose BIDs for philanthropic reasons. A BID proposal is designed to improve the business trading conditions, and people want to improve the business trading conditions because they see the potential for more profit and a more viable business by creating an area that is more attractive not only to the businesses but to the population in general.We seldom have much choice over taxes, but the individuals who involve themselves in a BID proposal have a choice. A democratic vote takes place, and if people do not want to take part in the BID proposal they can cast their votes accordingly. I do not think that anyone is saying that we have created Shangri-La with this piece of legislation or that everything is perfect and tied down, but on the basis of evidence from other parts of the United Kingdom and around the world, this kind of initiative has proved to be successful and worthwhile in growing and improving businesses at a local level. It encourages greater symmetry between the activities of local business and local governance, which can only be a good thing.Although I appreciate that Mr Ewing expresses genuine concerns, I believe that they are ill-founded. I therefore urge committee members to vote for the instrument.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

The question is, that motion S2M-5585, in the name of Tom McCabe, be agreed to. Are we agreed?

ForMartin, Paul (Glasgow Springburn) (Lab)McMahon, Michael (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab)Muldoon, Bristow (Livingston) (Lab)Rumbles, Mike (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD)AgainstEwing, Fergus (Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber) (SNP)Watt, Ms Maureen (North East Scotland) (SNP)AbstentionsTosh, Murray (West of Scotland) (Con)

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

The result of the division is: For 4, Against 2, Abstentions 1.

Motion agreed to.

That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the draft Business Improvement Districts (Ballot Arrangements) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 be approved.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

That brings us to the end of this marathon session of affirmative instruments. I thank the minister for his attendance. I also thank Colin Gilchrist and Nikola Plunkett, and the other officials who assisted the minister with the previous instruments.

Tom McCabe Lab Hamilton South
link

Thanks very much, convener. I think that that brings to an end my appearances before the committee in this parliamentary session. I thank you for the way in which I have been received every time that I have come along.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

Thank you, minister, for the way in which you have always presented your case.

  1. Scottish Parliament Local Government and Transport Committee Tuesday 6 March 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 3
  3. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 3
  4. Petition Petitions · 53
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 27
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 24
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8
  8. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
  9. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
  10. British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body Committee business · 6
  11. Annual Report Committee business · 8

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.