Agenda item 3 is an item of subordinate legislation that is to be considered under the affirmative procedure. It is the first of the instruments that we have before us today. We have several instruments to consider under the affirmative procedure, followed by several to consider under the negative procedure. I ask colleagues to be as focused as possible, so that we make good progress through the instruments.To discuss the draft regulations, we have Tom McCabe, the Minister for Finance and Public Service Reform, who is supported by Rab Fleming and Ken McKenna.First, I ask the minister to give us some introductory remarks on the draft regulations, following which we will have an opportunity for questions and answers. After that, we will move to a formal debate on the motion in the minister's name.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Gambling Act 2005 (Mandatory and Default Conditions) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Tom McCabe Lab 8
- Bristow Muldoon Lab 5
- Paul Martin Lab 4
- Fergus Ewing SNP 4
- Ken McKenna Scottish Executive Finance and Central Services Department 2
The record
27 contributionsThank you, convener, and good afternoon, everyone. This is a good opportunity to say a few words about this affirmative Scottish statutory instrument, which implements some aspects of the Gambling Act 2005. The committee will recall that, back in January 2005, the Parliament agreed that the Scottish ministers could be given certain powers under the 2005 act. Those powers include the setting of conditions affecting gambling operators in Scotland, and the draft regulations effectively put those into effect.The 2005 act gives the Scottish ministers powers to make regulations providing for conditions to be attached to premises licences, under sections 167 and 168. Essentially, two kinds of condition may be attached. The conditions attached to premises licences under section 168 will attach to all specified types of premises licence, unless they are excluded by the licensing authority that is responsible for issuing the premises licence. In Scotland, the licensing authority is the local licensing board, not the Scottish ministers. The conditions attached to premises licences under section 167 will attach to all specified types of premises licence, and can be amended or excluded only by further regulations made by the Scottish ministers.It is worth restating some of the licensing objectives that were contained in the 2005 act. First, the act aimed to prevent gambling from being a source of crime or disorder, from being associated with crime or disorder and from being used to support crime. Secondly, it aimed to ensure that gambling is conducted in a fair and open way. Thirdly, it was designed to protect children and other vulnerable persons from being harmed or exploited by gambling.The Scottish ministers and ministers at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport have stated publicly that increased social responsibility lies at the heart of the new regulatory regime and that protection of the public, especially vulnerable people, is the main priority in implementing the 2005 act's provisions. Within the overall policy framework, the policy objective for the draft regulations is that mandatory conditions will apply basic minimum requirements to all premises licence holders. The draft regulations mostly comprise such conditions. Default conditions apply where a general industry-wide or sector-wide approach is desirable to assist with national consistency. However, it is important to stress that local licensing authorities have the power to respond to local circumstances, and they can alter the conditions if necessary. The default conditions that are contained in the draft regulations relate solely to the opening hours of premises. The draft regulations were consulted on widely. We have tried to strike a balance between the interests of the general public and those of gambling operators. That is a broad overview, but I hope that it is sufficient. If there are any questions, I will do my best to answer them.
The draft regulations cover default conditions, to which you referred. How has the position on the effective operation of opening hours been arrived at? No premises will be open between 10 pm and 7 am, but according to some of the anecdotal evidence that I have received, there can be incidents of antisocial behaviour surrounding betting premises. Could we consider a possible reduction in opening hours to deal with some of that behaviour?
That is a good question and is exactly the sort of issue that might concern people in relation to a variety of types of licence. At the moment, there are winter and summer opening times. As I understand it, the summer opening times—I am not exactly sure in which months they run—already permit opening until 10 o'clock, whereas the winter opening times are shorter. At present, licensing boards have no discretion to alter summer opening times. Under the draft regulations, they would have the facility to reduce opening hours to before 10 o'clock, if they thought that local circumstances dictated that. I appreciate that such a change is strongly dependent on local licensing boards taking cognisance or being made aware of conditions that are having a detrimental impact on people. This is a matter for the committee to consider, but the rationale behind the measure is to give local licensing boards more power. Depending on the locality and the proximity of residential properties, there may be isolated instances in which concern arises about when premises are open. I have indicated that we have tried to strike a balance, without taking a sledgehammer approach to the issue. Members are entitled to form a view on whether we have struck the right balance, but boards will now have the power and authority to take cognisance of local circumstances.
Are you saying that, until the draft regulations are approved, boards will not have the option of reducing opening hours?
As I understand it, at the moment they do not have the discretion to reduce the longer summer opening hours.
I have a technical question. My principles tell me that it would be better to send out a message to premises that the default position should be for them to close at 6 o'clock and to apply for an extension, if they want one. If I were successfully to oppose the draft regulations today, what would the position be? Would that cause difficulties for premises that conduct legitimate business and can extend their opening hours to 10 o'clock without that being associated with antisocial behaviour?
It would cause both an administrative difficulty as the year moves on and a wider difficulty. Applications start to roll in around June, but we have no facility to lay another instrument after today, because only a few weeks of the session remain. The ability of whoever is responsible after the election for laying such an instrument to do so within the necessary timescales will be further constrained by the fact that it will take a number of weeks after the election for the Parliament to settle and to get its first meeting under way. We will then come up against the summer recess. As members know, time during the summer recess does not count for the laying of subordinate legislation. Effectively, it would be September before a new instrument could be laid, which might lead to considerable administrative confusion.Nothing that I have said undermines the basic point that Paul Martin has made—that there can be instances in which there is concern about opening hours. If it is of any help to members, I would be happy to write to local licensing boards specifically to ensure that they are aware that they now have the facility to reduce summer opening hours to take account of local concerns. One of the officials may be able to provide members with more detail on the administrative difficulties that failure to approve the draft regulations would cause.
It would cause difficulty with the overall implementation of the Gambling Act 2005, because on 1 September the act will repeal all the existing legislation from the 1960s. If no mandatory and default conditions are in force before then, the industry will be less regulated than it is at present and we will not get the new protections that have been built in to cover various provisions of the 2005 act.
I begin by stating that Carlton Bingo plc has its headquarters in my constituency, so I have obviously been in touch with the company over the years. Initially, it was highly concerned about the impact that the liberalisation of gambling law would have on the bingo sector. Has the Executive considered what effect liberalising the law on casinos will have on bingo in general? Have any specific concerns about that been expressed during the consultation exercise?
The consultations on the liberalisation of gambling have been wide. We are not here to discuss specifically how many casinos there should be or where they should be; we are here for another purpose. Suffice it to say that there has been significant consultation and that, in the draft regulations under discussion, we think that we have struck the right balance between the interests of the general public—and the need to protect potentially vulnerable people—and those of the operators of gambling premises.
Has the Executive carried out any impact assessment of how bingo in Scotland will be affected by the changes in the law on casinos?
It is worth mentioning that of the 17 new casinos permitted under the Gambling Act 2005, which fall into three categories—one regional casino or supercasino, eight large casinos and eight small casinos—only the large and the regional casinos are allowed to offer bingo as well as traditional casino facilities. The committee will probably be aware that, as a result of the casino advisory panel's recommendations to the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport down south, there is likely to be only one new casino in Scotland, which will be in Dumfries and Galloway. As it will be a small casino, it will not be able to offer bingo facilities.
I am pleased to hear that that is the case, although that was also my understanding of the rules on casinos that offer bingo. Does the minister accept as a general proposition that bingo is primarily a social activity in which the gambling element is soft, in that the amounts of money involved in a traditional evening's—or, indeed, afternoon's—bingo are not great and that it is not a form of the hard gambling that one would associate with a casino? Does he agree that bingo performs an important social role, particularly for retired people, and that we should therefore foster, encourage and support it?
I would stop short of saying that we should foster, encourage and support it. I must admit that my knowledge of how bingo impacts on people is rather limited and that my knowledge of exactly what people do while they engage in bingo is even more limited, so I am at a bit of a disadvantage.
On one occasion, I called the numbers rather disastrously, so I am perhaps at a slight advantage. My understanding is that, typically, the people who enjoy a game of bingo are retired, tend to be female, may have been—and probably still are—smokers and regard bingo as a social activity that allows them to meet friends in a safe, warm place and have something to eat or drink. Given that the amount of money that is spent is relatively modest, the bingo industry has presented itself as a leisure industry rather than as an industry the purpose of which is to facilitate the hard gambling that we associate with casinos. Will the Executive take that into account when it makes any future policy decisions about the creation of more casinos in Scotland, which is something that I am not too enthusiastic about?
Mr Ewing has obviously studied the matter in some depth. I am afraid to say that I am at a bit of a disadvantage. We will certainly bear in mind the comments that he has made if and when the Executive considers the social impact of bingo on the wider community.
As there are no more questions, I invite the minister to move motion S2M-5587.
Motion moved,
That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the draft Gambling Act 2005 (Mandatory and Default Conditions) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 be approved.—Mr Tom McCabe.
Do any members wish to speak in the debate on the motion?
As I have already pointed out, my instincts tell me that we should reduce the opening hours of betting premises—otherwise known as licensed bookmakers—due to the incidents of antisocial behaviour that surround such premises in my constituency during the summer months. However, I recognise that other facilities within my constituency run reputable businesses and that those should be able to continue, so I will not oppose the motion.I accept the minister's assurance that he will write to licensing boards to remind them that, where antisocial activities surround licensed premises and cause difficulties, boards should be aware of the opportunity to reduce their operating hours. Although I will not oppose the motion, I want to put on record my concerns about the issue.
No other members want to contribute to the opening debate. Does the minister want to respond to Mr Martin's comments?
To echo what I said a few minutes ago, Paul Martin's point is well made. I am personally interested in ensuring that local licensing boards are aware of their powers to reduce default hours so that particular, localised difficulties can be dealt with. I know that such difficulties affect communities in different parts of Scotland, at least to some extent. As I said earlier, I am more than happy to write to local licensing boards to point out the concern that has been expressed at a parliamentary committee and to remind them that I want them to pay attention to the new powers that they possess.
Motion agreed to.
That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the draft Gambling Act 2005 (Mandatory and Default Conditions) (Scotland) Regulations 2007 be approved.
The fact that the motion has been agreed to will be reported to Parliament. We will pause to allow the minister's two officials for this item to leave before we move on to the next item.
In this meeting
Everything on 6 Mar 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Transport Committee Tuesday 6 March 2007 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 3
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 3
- Petition Petitions · 53
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 27
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 24
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
- British-Irish Inter-Parliamentary Body Committee business · 6
- Annual Report Committee business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.