The second instrument for consideration is the Transfer of Rail Functions to the Scottish Ministers Order 2005. I welcome to the meeting Executive officials Caroline Lyon, Bill Reeve and Ian Turner, who are here to support the minister, who has the opportunity to make introductory remarks about the order.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Transfer of Rail Functions to the Scottish Ministers Order 2005 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bristow Muldoon Lab 11
- Tavish Scott LD 10
- David Davidson Con 6
- Fergus Ewing SNP 5
The record
39 contributionsThis is the final legislative stage of delivering our commitment in the 2004 white paper on transport to transfer the relevant rail powers of SPT to Scottish ministers. In late 2004, Parliament approved the Scotland Act 1998 section 30 order, which provided the required legislative competence. In January 2005, Parliament approved the passage of the Railways Act 2005 and, with it, the most extensive devolution of powers to Scottish ministers since the Parliament's creation in 1999.Throughout 2004 and 2005, Parliament extensively debated and then passed the Transport (Scotland) Act 2005, which will bring a new approach to the delivery of transport infrastructure and services in Scotland. The 2005 act included the power to transfer by order powers from SPT to Scottish ministers. I believe that we need to take a consistent approach to rail and that Scottish ministers should have strong powers over the railways in Scotland. That view was supported in the important and useful debate that we had in Parliament just last Thursday.We already have significant new powers through the Railways Act 2005. The order is the right step to take to ensure further a coherent and consistent approach. We cannot afford to have a fragmented structure as we try to improve railways and their role in Scotland's integrated transport system. The order's main consequence will be that Scottish ministers will have direct responsibility for the ScotRail franchise and its delivery, which will be simpler and more effective than what is in place. When combined with our new powers and responsibilities for transport and rail strategies, rail infrastructure and major rail projects, the planning and delivery of rail services for the whole of Scotland will be brought together for the first time.The lines of accountability, which are a subject that I know is of significant interest to members, are clear. First, ScotRail will be directly accountable to Transport Scotland, which will be directly accountable to the minister with responsibility for transport, who is, of course, directly accountable to Parliament. That is a level of clarity that has not existed before. None of that is to say that we do not recognise the importance of rail to the west of Scotland. On the contrary, we have always been committed to SPT—and, in future, the west of Scotland regional transport partnership—having a role in the development, management and monitoring of rail services. The order provides that SPT can enter into agreements with Scottish ministers to enable it to have that role. We have been discussing such an agreement with SPT and, after discussions with the chairman of its authority and the director general of its executive last week, I believed that we had been able to reach agreement and that SPT would work to support and assist Scottish ministers in the monitoring and management of rail services, which would retain experience and expertise within SPT. As I said last week, I wanted us to move forward together by building on the success of rail services across Scotland, particularly the growth in the use of rail services in the west of Scotland and, as I said earlier, I wanted to end the uncertainty for SPTE staff, which is what I am asking the committee to help me to achieve today. However, despite the agreement at the meeting last week, it now seems that SPT feels that it cannot recommend signature to its authority. That is, at best, unfortunate; it is hugely frustrating and, above all, it is unacceptable, simply because of the impact on staff. If SPT does not sign, it will no longer be able to work on the management and monitoring of rail services. The staff who are involved in those functions will transfer. I reassure the committee that any staff who transfer will not be disadvantaged by the move. Through the transfer of staff to the Executive, we will retain their experience and expertise, which we need to do if we are to continue to improve rail services in Scotland. I have also made that clear in the letter that we discussed in the earlier session. The committee will want to know why this state of affairs has arisen. SPT has lobbied hard for the retention of its statutory powers. However, as I have said—and as my predecessors have said before me—the new structure for the creation of strategy and the delivery of services in rail requires a consistent and strong lead. We have been clear and unambiguous in our statements to Parliament that a transfer of powers would take place. After all, rail passengers want to know that their trains will run on time and will be clean and affordable. That is a shared agenda for this Government and our transport partners. The approval of this order by the Local Government and Transport Committee is an essential step that will enable the Executive to take a strategic approach to rail services across Scotland and to secure the best possible deal for rail passengers.
You referred to discussions between you and the chair of SPT last week. It was reported in the media that there had been broad agreement on the outcomes of the meeting. Obviously, members of this committee have not had full sight of all of those outcomes. Will you explain to members what the broad agreements were? Is it possible to share those fully with us?In the discussions that took place on the new west of Scotland RTP's role in monitoring the rail franchise in that part of Scotland, will you clarify that one of the commitments that was made was that any role that the RTP would play would run at least until the end of the current franchise?
It would be unfair of me to go through everything that was said at last week's meeting without the agreement of the other party, given that, although it was conducted in an appropriate and positive way, the meeting was between two parties of which I am only one. I can say that I thought that we had reached an agreement. In particular, the chairman of SPT sought assistance in providing staff with additional reassurance and, indeed, cover, not just for a short period but for the length of the franchise. I was more than happy to reach an agreement with him on the matter and to move forward on that basis. That answers your second question. I thought that we had a clear agreement, about which I was genuinely pleased—not least because of the questions that were being asked earlier about the uncertainty for staff.The new west of Scotland RTP will have a monitoring role for the period of the franchise. That is appropriate. There is a good balance to the responsibilities that we have placed on the RTP. It will have the necessary expertise and experience. It is important not only that we use that expertise and experience in the west of Scotland but that we use the west of Scotland RTP's good working knowledge to improve services throughout Scotland. Sylvia Jackson asked whether we could use best practice in one part of Scotland to help the rest of the country. That is precisely what I want to achieve.
Your predecessor, Nicol Stephen, stated to Parliament that he expected SPT to continue"to have a direct role in the management and development of rail services in the west of Scotland"and said that "passengers in the west of Scotland can look forward to further development of SPT's powers and functions".—Official Report, 16 June 2004; c 9099.Can you confirm that? In November 2003, we were told that SPT would continue to manage, develop and monitor rail services in the area. However, last week SPT indicated that it perceived that there was a written threat that it would be removed altogether from rail operations. Is that a fact, or is SPT wrong?
I have said what the Transport (Scotland) Act 2005 says and what the legislative process is for ensuring that we have a unified system across Scotland. Powers relating to rail in Scotland are vested with Scottish ministers, who are accountable to the Parliament, but will be delivered through the transport agency. SPT's role is to continue to provide services. I am sure that Mr Davidson has been watching developments, so he will know that it always was and still is the case that after 1 April the new west of Scotland RTP will provide monitoring of, assistance to and development of our operations in relation to the franchise. It is important that we move forward in a constructive way. I want the west of Scotland RTP, like the other RTPs, to be at the heart of those matters after it formally takes up its responsibilities.
Do you agree that, given what your predecessor said—his comments are recorded in the Official Report—there has been a change to what the Parliament perceived would be delivered when the Transport (Scotland) Bill was passed?
I do not accept that. Mr Davidson cannot have been listening to the debate that took place either in the committee or in the Parliament during the passage of the Transport (Scotland) Bill. The partnership agreement indicated that there was to be a unified structure. The Government's intention in the Transport (Scotland) Bill, which became the Transport (Scotland) Act 2005, was that that should happen, alongside the transfer of rail powers from London to Edinburgh. It can hardly be a secret that that was the case and that, as I indicated in my opening remarks, the process included the transfer of functions from SPT to Scottish ministers, who are accountable to the Parliament. That was made clear repeatedly. Mr Davidson should not start to suggest that there was any other policy intent behind the proposals or the process that has been gone through. If the Conservative position is to ensure that there is a fragmented system of rail delivery across Scotland, I disagree with it.
We have not yet reached the debate. You must be aware, because it is now fairly common knowledge, that there has been an opinion from senior counsel to SPT regarding its current situation. You referred to that opinion. Have you taken legal advice on that? If so, can you share it with us?
It is important that Mr Davidson should understand the difference between the order that is before him today and the agreement in relation to particular matters. The order was shared with SPT—a draft was provided to it on 2 September—and it provided comments on 6 and 8 September. On 9 September, we incorporated SPT's comments into the order that is before the committee today and, on 23 September, that order was laid. Only today was I told that SPT's legal advice is that it cannot sign the order.I repeat: we provided the order to SPT on 2 September; SPT provided comments on 6 and 8 September; and on 9 September we incorporated SPT's comments. I assume that SPT took legal advice at that time, yet only today did it tell us in a fax that my office received this morning—on the day of the committee meeting—that it cannot sign the order on the advice of legal counsel. I find it difficult to understand how SPT could have agreed the draft order on 9 September—it was laid on 23 September—yet could tell me only today that it has received legal advice that it should not sign it.
I take it that you have not sought legal advice since you received that response this morning.
I have sought legal advice, but as Mr Davidson knows—and I do not wish to bore him—we do not publish Government law officers' advice. One can always obtain legal advice. The important point is that there was any amount of opportunity between 9 September and 23 September, when the order was introduced, and even up to today for SPT to bring these issues back to us, but that did not happen.
I have a final question—
No, I want to make progress.
We are where we are. We have the e-mail about the advice. I have not seen the legal opinion, but its views have been summarised. Can the minister assure us that he is satisfied that what he proposes to do is not unlawful?
That is a fair question. I hope that the committee will approve the order for two reasons. First, it will end the uncertainty for staff involved in rail functions, who will transfer to the Scottish Executive. I repeat what I have said time and time again: I wanted an agreement between SPT and the Scottish Executive on its continuing its role. Today, we can end the uncertainty over the issue and ensure that the position of staff in relation to rail functions is secured. The situation with regard to the legal position will no doubt be on-going.
I appreciate that it is difficult for you to answer the question having received only an extract from the legal opinion that was given to SPT. Is it correct that you have not received the whole of the legal opinion that SPT has received?
With respect, it does not matter to me what SPT's legal opinion says. It is quite entitled to gain its own legal opinion. My concern is the order. The order is legally competent—I should have given you that answer right at the start—and it will allow the appropriate staff to transfer to the Scottish Executive in respect of rail functions. That is what we have said all along. That will end the uncertainty and protect those workers' rights, which are an issue of concern.
In case members were thinking about this, I clarify that there is no opportunity for the committee to delay consideration of the order. We need to publish a report by 21 November to meet the 40-day deadline for Parliament's consideration of the order on 24 November.
I am grateful for that clarification. I was going to query the position, so you anticipated my question.I appreciate the distinction between approving the order and the legal questions, which I understand relate to whether, after the order is approved, the Scottish ministers have legal competence to enter into an agreement with SPT. I understand that that is where the legal doubt arises. The minister referred to the need to remove uncertainty for staff, which I entirely accept is desirable and should be achieved. However, I feel slightly uneasy that SPTE has not had and—according to what the convener said—will not have the opportunity to put its side of the case, because we always want to listen to the other side in any debate. I am also aware that senior counsel do not always provide opinions swiftly, so the advice might only have been received recently—we do not know and I certainly do not know.In the light of the minister's assurance that what we are being asked to do is legal and necessary, I intend to support the order. However, I hope that, thereafter, the difficulty that has been identified will be dealt with in a direct response to SPTE—difficulties can often be cast to one side—and that an agreement will be reached about the best way ahead.
I cannot say much in response to Mr Ewing. However, I assure him that I do not seek out fights in life. I am interested in finding solutions, which I genuinely thought we had last week. I say with the greatest respect to Mr Ewing's professional background that sometimes lawyers get in the way of, rather than facilitate, these things. I will pay a lot of money to lawyers who help me to sort things—full stop.
That is an offer that I must refuse.
That brings us to the end of questioning, so we will proceed to the debate. I ask the minister to move the motion. Given that we have had an extensive discussion, he need not reiterate the issues.
Motion moved,
That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the draft Transfer of Rail Functions to the Scottish Ministers Order 2005 be approved.—Tavish Scott.
I am sorry, minister, but having listened to your answers, I intend to oppose the motion. I will do that not merely because I oppose the transfer of SPT's rail powers to ministers, but because I believe that the Executive—whether on purpose or not—misled the Parliament on SPT's future in the stage 3 debate on the Transport (Scotland) Bill. I agree that it would help if SPT were here to give its view and to back up the allegations that its local council has made, but it has not been able to appear. On that basis, I simply say that I will not support the motion.
For clarity, I draw to the committee's attention the fact that this draft of the order was laid before Parliament on 30 September and is close to the end of its 40-day period. I understand that an affirmative resolution on the order is due to be considered in a meeting of the Parliament next week. The order has been in the public domain for quite some time. The minister has given his assurances about the legality of the order. It would have helped to make any challenges far earlier in the process. We need to make progress on the matter. Another issue that we missed in the discussion is the fact that the transfer of rail functions to the Scottish ministers, of which the order is part, is extensive. It is the biggest transfer of power to the Scottish ministers since devolution. In the overall scheme of things, in years to come, the devolution settlement will benefit considerably from the additional powers that the Parliament will have. I intend to support the motion in the minister's name.Does the minister wish to respond to any points?
I do not accept that Parliament has not known in any way that the order was coming. I apologise to the committee, but I can only repeat what I said at the start. The order represents the last legislative stage of delivering the commitment that we gave in the 2004 white paper to transfer the relevant rail powers of SPT to the Scottish ministers. In late 2004, Parliament approved—I presumed that the committee had oversight of it—the order under section 30 of the Scotland Act 1998 that provided the legislative competence. Throughout 2004 and this year, Parliament has extensively debated and passed what became the Transport (Scotland) Act 2005. There can be no doubt whatever about the policy intent, which flows from the partnership agreement. I defy anyone to argue that the policy intent and thus the procedures and appropriate mechanisms that we would follow to achieve it were not absolutely clear.
The question is, that motion S2M-3442, in the name of the minister, be agreed to. Are we agreed?
No.
There will be a division.
ForEwing, Fergus (Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber) (SNP)Jackson, Dr Sylvia (Stirling) (Lab)Martin, Paul (Glasgow Springburn) (Lab)McMahon, Michael (Hamilton North and Bellshill) (Lab)Muldoon, Bristow (Livingston) (Lab)Sheridan, Tommy (Glasgow) (SSP)AgainstDavidson, Mr David (North East Scotland) (Con)
The result of the division is: For 6, Against 1, Abstentions 0.
Motion agreed to.
That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the draft Transfer of Rail Functions to the Scottish Ministers Order 2005 be approved.
Our decision will be confirmed in the report that we will submit to Parliament before the debate next week.That brings us to the end of the agenda items in public. I thank for their attendance the minister, his officials and members of the public or press who have been present for our proceedings.
Before we go into private session, I belatedly offer Bruce Crawford's apologies. I think that he could not attend the meeting because he had to attend an appointment this afternoon. I, too, offer apologies. I have another meeting that I must attend now, so I cannot stay for the rest of this meeting. However, I support the budget paper.
That will be recorded.
Meeting continued in private until 17:58.
In this meeting
Everything on 15 Nov 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Transport Committee Tuesday 15 November 2005 Committee business · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 4
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Council Tax Abolition and Service Tax Introduction (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 301
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 52
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.