Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Regional Transport Partnerships (Establishment, Constitution and Membership) (Scotland) Order 2005 (Draft)

Tuesday 15 November 2005 Local Government and Transport Committee Subordinate legislation 52 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

52 contributions
Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

I apologise to the minister and his officials for the fact that we are running a little bit later than intended. I am sure that they will appreciate that we got into some detailed and interesting discussion about the Council Tax Abolition and Service Tax Introduction (Scotland) Bill; there will be an interesting debate when the bill comes before the chamber.We move on to another important issue. Under agenda item 4, we will deal with two draft pieces of subordinate legislation on the establishment of regional transport partnerships and the transfer of rail functions to Scottish ministers. We are required to deal with both draft orders individually because they cover separate issues, albeit that they have a relationship to each other. I welcome Tavish Scott, the Minister for Transport and Telecommunications, to the committee for the purpose of addressing the draft orders. Graham McGlashan, Ian Kernohan and Richard Hadfield are here to support him.As usual, I give the minister the opportunity to make introductory remarks on the first of the draft orders, which is the draft Regional Transport Partnerships (Establishment, Constitution and Membership) (Scotland) Order 2005. There will then be an opportunity for members to question the minister and officials on the detail of the contents of the draft order. If members want responses from the officials, they need to ask questions at that stage because when we enter the formal debate only members of the Parliament, including the minister, will be able to participate. As time is moving on, I ask the minister to keep his remarks as concise as possible so that we can make progress with the rest of our business.

Tavish Scott LD The Minister for Transport and Telecommunications · Shetland
link

Thank you. I will do my best to hurtle through my remarks.I am very pleased to be able to bring the draft order before the committee. Parliament gave a clear welcome to the Executive's proposals for regional transport partnerships when it voted through the Transport (Scotland) Act 2005. The scrutiny carried out by the committee and the amendments adopted by Parliament have produced legislation that will and must deliver. Through the 2005 act, Parliament placed a duty on ministers to establish regional transport partnerships throughout Scotland. The draft order fulfils that duty.A first version of the draft order was sent to the committee on 5 April to support the stage 2 deliberations. A revised version was sent to councils on 21 July following Parliament's approval of the bill at stage 3, and a number of further comments were received, mainly on boundaries and membership. We have worked over the summer to resolve those issues.Inevitably, it has not been possible to find arrangements that meet everyone's first preference. However, the draft order before the committee today represents a series of agreements that councils are willing to work with. It is the outcome of consensus working, compromise and a healthy degree of common sense.During the passage of the 2005 act, the committee made a number of important points that are reflected in the draft order. The committee proposed that councils should be able to appoint more than one member to an RTP. The figure was raised at stage 2 to a maximum of 4 and again at stage 3 to a maximum of 5. The draft order uses the full range of 1 to 5 members per council. In each region we have tried, as far as possible, to reach agreement on membership and voting with the councils concerned.The committee also proposed that Dumfries and Galloway should be able to have its own regional transport partnership, and the legislation was amended to clarify that that would be possible. The draft order now proposes the creation of single-authority RTPs in south-west Scotland and Shetland, which will in each case bring together the council, the health board and the enterprise company to develop strategies and deliver public transport services. That is the outcome that both councils sought from the outset. Reaching a consensus was straightforward in the case of Dumfries and Galloway, but less so in the case of Shetland. I am grateful to the six Highlands and Islands councils for working with me on the matter over the summer—the assistance of the six conveners was vital in reaching a consensus. The current proposal to allow Shetland to have its own regional transport partnership was unanimously supported in August by the Highlands and Islands conveners and leaders group, the representations of which were an important consideration in my recommendation to the Parliament.The current proposals therefore give the most balanced strategic transport groupings to meet the needs of each individual area and are based on boundaries that reflect the particular circumstances, including the geography, of both Dumfries and Galloway and Shetland.Since taking on the transport portfolio, I have been impressed by the readiness of councils, the existing RTPs, Strathclyde Passenger Transport and others to work with, and within, the new partnerships and to make them a success. Local authorities, SPT and the existing voluntary RTPs have worked up quite a head of steam in preparing for the new partnerships. Following their advice, I have proposed the creation of statutory RTPs in early December, which will give them a four-month head start over what we had originally planned.There is positive momentum building behind the RTPs and a real desire to use them to bring about significant improvements in transport in Scotland. I encourage the committee to support the motion, to send a clear message to those involved that Parliament is right behind them in this work. I am happy to take questions.

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link

The minister will know that we did not support the RTPs, but we are now at a different stage. What cost provision will be made for the statutory RTPs? We note that Shetland will have in place a unitary organisation. The minister will remember that I sought to make the Transport (Scotland) Bill permissive rather than prescriptive. What procedures will be followed if a new authority is set up, if a change of administration in an authority takes place or if authorities want to come together? Is the minister minded to consider that point, given that those circumstances could arise at a later date, such as after the 2007 election?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I will get my colleagues to cover technical aspects of the procedures. There is no particular block—nor should there be—on our considering different arrangements. However, I hope that Mr Davidson will accept that we are putting in place a series of groupings that provide the strategic overview that we think is necessary for transport on a regional basis. Any Administration would want that arrangement to settle down to see how it worked over a period of time. In the context of the national transport strategy, on which we are hoping to consult early next year and which is important for the regional transport strategies, it would be odd, to put it mildly, for us simply to rip up the arrangements and start again. I have no proposals so to do. In principle, Parliament can decide anything, but this Administration will not change the arrangements quickly and I rather doubt that a future Administration would choose to do so.We are discussing individual RTPs' running costs with them. We have been clear about assisting RTPs with their formation and with such costs. I hope that Mr Davidson will accept that I do not believe that we want to set up expensive bureaucracies. I want to streamline the arrangements and ensure that they are effective and efficient. That will be the overriding principle in my consideration of submissions on on-going costs.

David Davidson Con North East Scotland
link

Will the partnerships be paid for out of the current budget? Will there be an additional cost?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

We have made provision for the start-up costs of the RTPs. I hope that Mr Davidson accepts that we have discussed the matter with the individual bodies—indeed, such discussions are continuing. I assure Mr Davidson that the figures on individual RTPs will be transparent, in the public domain and in the transport line in our budget.

Michael McMahon Lab Hamilton North and Bellshill
link

During the discussions on the Transport (Scotland) Bill, a number of issues arose in relation to the transfer of Strathclyde Passenger Transport to the new RTP. I know that Paul Martin has a substantive question on that, so I will stick to presentation. Concerns have been expressed about the loss of brand recognition of SPT. What feedback can you give us on the discussions that have taken place on that? Will the SPT brand be identified when SPT is transferred to the new RTP?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I assume that Michael McMahon is talking about the overall transport services that SPT provides. I certainly accept the point about the benefits of a brand that is understood and is relevant to the people who use the service day in, day out when they go to work, take the children to school or for social purposes. It is a fair and relevant point and when I am in discussion with the new west of Scotland RTP, I want to ensure that we use the advantages of the SPT brand as we roll out the system in future. It would not be appropriate if we were to rip up an understood and proven brand that has grown and which has encouraged more people to use public transport in the west of Scotland. I strongly believe that we will work on that during discussions with the new west of Scotland RTP.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I seek clarity on the arrangements that have been entered into under the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations, with particular reference to the new west of Scotland regional transport partnership.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

Which part of the SPT service are we talking about? Obviously, we will deal with rail later.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

You will probably appreciate that there are issues around the future of the staff who are currently employed by Strathclyde Passenger Transport Executive. Will you follow the TUPE arrangements that formed part of discussions that we had at earlier committee meetings?

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

I will expand on that question, minister, because it is probably best if we deal with all the SPT staff in one go. I anticipate that some members of staff might be regarded as part of Transport Scotland, the new strategic transport agency. However, the majority of SPT staff will become employees of the new west of Scotland regional transport partnership. It would be useful if you could clarify whether that is your understanding and expectation of how TUPE will apply to each of the different groups of staff.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

The short answer is yes, it is. My understanding of the arrangements—which have been subject to many discussions—is that the appropriate transfer obligations under the TUPE legislation would apply. Where staff transfer because their responsibilities and functions transfer to the new west of Scotland RTP, TUPE will very much apply, and it is appropriate that it should apply in those circumstances. It is very important that we provide clarity and certainty for staff and that we end any uncertainty as quickly as we possibly can, because I appreciate that there are concerns.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

During any exchanges that have taken place on the issue between yourself and the SPTE, have you been absolutely clear that members of staff can expect to be protected under TUPE?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I have made sure that all the advice that I have received on staff transfer has been discussed, as I am sure Mr Martin appreciates, at official level at many meetings for many months. That advice has been based on staff transferring their rights and being protected under the appropriate employment legislation. Anything else would not be fair on those members of staff. The right arrangements will be in place when the transfers occur.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

This morning I received notice of something about which I believe your civil servants have been advised. Legal advice has been received by SPTE that—Interruption. I am sorry; I have moved on to the next instrument. I had the wrong piece of paper in front of me, so I shall start again.Who will decide which strategic projects are regional and which are national?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

That is a fair question. I have a pretty strong view that in constructing the national transport strategy, we need to set out some clear principles. We must make as clear a distinction as we can.I will use an example to be helpful. Edinburgh sits next to a certain estuary that strikes me as being pretty strategic for Scotland and the UK. Any transport options that we considered for that estuary would be of strategic importance to Scotland. On the other hand, an RTP might believe a local road to be very important and so in need of upgrading. In such a context, you and I might agree that the end of a particular fixed link across the estuary should be an RTP priority, although it would be for the RTP to decide whether it was a priority.Nevertheless, I absolutely accept the point that it is important to try to achieve a degree of clarity around strategic, as opposed to regional, projects. It is, after all, in the interests of the RTPs that we do that through the guidance, which I am more than happy to share with the committee over the coming weeks.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Can you say when the decision will be taken on who will decide which strategic projects are national, which are regional and who will deliver the projects?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

We will do that through the different bodies. There are capital transport investment projects under way—we have discussed them with the committee before and will do so again—that are clearly strategic and, in many ways, of pan-Scotland significance. At the moment, the voluntary RTPs are taking forward a range of transport priorities and capital investments that they consider to be of regional importance. We support those projects financially and we work in partnership with the voluntary RTPs to deliver them.In 2006, we will set out in the national transport strategy the process and the set of principles that will apply. Of course, the national transport strategy will be subject to parliamentary scrutiny and approval by next summer. The RTPs will be very much part of that in setting out how they see things and, more to the point, the projects in their areas that they consider to be of regional importance. As the strategic project review flows from the national transport strategy, that will provide an opportunity to refine and assess the process further. I do not, however, discount the central point that Mr Ewing makes about the need for clarity around the structure of those decisions.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I have listened carefully to what the minister has said and I think that I understand his reasoning. Does he agree, however, that there are concerns—most cogently and directly expressed by Janette Anderson of First Engineering at the business in the chamber event—that the landscape is cluttered? There is a quicksand or quagmire of quangos, and her company—an important Scottish company, which has a turnover of £200 million and wants to get on with the projects—is looking to expand by 15 per cent a year. Will the minister bear in mind—and perhaps meet me to discuss—the offer that has been made by the Scottish National Party, as the official Opposition? We are anxious to see delivery, and if that means scrapping the current byzantine and protracted parliamentary procedure for consideration of the various projects—such as the Glasgow airport rail link, which we want to see progressing soon—we are up for that. I hope that colleagues in other parties will be up for it, too. I know that that is a slight departure from the technicalities of the draft order, but I am sure that we all want to move swiftly towards project delivery, not just the creation of new bodies.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

We all share that aim, although that issue departs quite a bit from the draft order on RTPs that we are considering. The minister can respond to the point if he wants to, but I ask him not to take up too much time in doing so.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I will be brief. I have met Janette Anderson and have discussed those issues with her. I do not wish to disparage Mr Ewing's argument, but I do not think that that is quite her view. However, I would be happy to discuss the matter with Mr Ewing on another occasion.As I said during the debate on rail on Thursday, I am more than happy to work with all parties to ensure that we improve our systems and that we get right the proposed TWA bill—the terminology is unfortunate at times; I refer to the proposed transport and works legislation that is designed to improve the process. As you know, the proposed bill has been the subject of some discussion in the Procedures Committee in recent weeks.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

I refer you to the letter that you sent me today in response to my inquiries about staff transfer. Can you put a number to those who will transfer from SPT to the concessionary travel unit in Transport Scotland? How many people do you envisage will stay with SPT to manage the rail franchise?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

The letter was also sent to the convener and should have been available to all members. I hope that I can give a straight reply to the points that have been raised, although Mr Sheridan is straying slightly into the discussion that we will have on the second draft order. I also hope that he accepts that our discussions with SPT need to be concluded and that, therefore, I cannot give him the numbers—as he puts it—around staff transfers. It would be inappropriate for me to do so until those discussions, which are about specific people—after all, we are talking about working men and women—have been concluded.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

Okay. Will you confirm that, as you state in your letter, we are talking not about redundancies, but about absorbing existing staff on terms and conditions that are no less favourable than those on which they are currently employed? Will you give a commitment that, following actuarial advice, staff will not lose benefits under the civil service pension scheme in comparison with those that they have under the local government pension scheme?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I can certainly give Mr Sheridan an assurance on his second point, as I think I did in my letter. He makes an entirely fair point. We would all expect the pension rights of staff to be protected when they transfer, and my letter absolutely confirms that.On job losses, it is important that the functions and the roles that are being transferred are carefully separated from the individual men and women who are involved, as it would be inappropriate for me to go into issues to do with an individual's employment rights and their current role. We have been clear in our discussions—as I am sure the committee would expect—about the rail and concessionary fares functions that we expect to be transferred. I apologise, but I cannot go any further than that because functions are the issue at this stage and it would be wrong for me to be drawn on numbers or individual circumstances.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

Your letter to me states that you seek to"achieve an outcome which will result in staff transferring seamlessly and painlessly."Do you accept that the concern of the staff who are involved will be more than justified if you are not prepared to give a commitment today that there will be no redundancies? Paragraph 5 of your letter states:"Scottish Executive officials will be holding discussions with their counterparts in SPT and with officials from UNISON and staff representatives to explain in detail the terms and conditions which will be on offer."I understand that the transfer will take place at the end of this month—in two weeks' time. Do you accept that those discussions should have been conducted much earlier and that it is regrettable that they were not?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I could not agree more with that. I assure Mr Sheridan that I am frustrated that we are now into November and the discussions have not been concluded. If I had my way and was allowed to do things differently, they darn well would have finished much earlier. I do not like the uncertainty that staff have been left with and am very frustrated about the time that the process has taken. You should be under no illusion about my desire for matters to be concluded and I am frustrated that they are not.I deliberately used the phrase "seamlessly and painlessly" in my letter, and it is entirely fair of Mr Sheridan to point that out. I mean what I said—I described what needs to happen, and it is important that that happens—but I cannot and will not be drawn into individual circumstances. It would be unfair to pull me into suggesting something that I do not want to suggest—which can happen in politics—and into saying something that Mr Sheridan wants me to say. I will not say that there will be redundancies; to do so would mean not understanding the process that must be gone through for sensibly managing circumstances that involve individual men and women. I can put things only in those terms. I do not want a member to say, "There are going to be redundancies," when they leave the committee room, as that would be a fundamental misunderstanding of the sensible discussions that must take place to deal with functions and employees' particular positions.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

I reassure you that I am not seeking to leave the committee room with suggestions about redundancies or anything else. I have simply been asked by several members of staff to seek the assurances that you have now given fairly and robustly. However, I am sure that you realise that the fact that the transfer is imminent leaves the staff feeling insecure. I hope that you accept that I asked the question in that spirit.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I accept that that is fair, and I can only repeat that I agree with Mr Sheridan and, indeed, every committee member about the length of time that the process has taken. Irrespective of our views on the political and policy context of the matter, we are talking about the jobs of individual men and women. I, too, want to end the uncertainty. I hope that the committee will agree to approve the draft orders, which will allow us to bring that uncertainty to an end.

Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab Stirling
link

On a point of clarification, will you remind us how the process of establishing the RTPs will be monitored and reviewed? Obviously, we want flexibility in the system, but we might want the partnerships to share examples of good practice. How will that happen?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I have two points to make in answering that question. First, each RTP will produce a strategic overview of its area and present it formally to ministers and, by definition, to Parliament. Given the way in which the partnerships have been constructed and will operate, their interaction with local authorities, health boards, local enterprise companies and the private sector will allow a healthy dialogue to take place that should give rise to a good degree of visionary thought about what is needed in certain parts of Scotland. Such an exercise will be open and transparent and provide the local check that I imagine that Sylvia Jackson seeks. I should also point out that the system contains a number of such checks.Sylvia Jackson also raised a good point about best practice. Indeed, I should have said to Mr Ewing earlier that Transport Scotland, which we hope to discuss with the committee more properly and say more about in the coming weeks, will play an important role in that respect. After all, it will be responsible not only for rail services across Scotland but for delivering our strategic capital investment, for example, and what might be called our run-of-the-mill investment in roads and so on. We have set up the agency in a way that allows private sector expertise of the best quality to bring many new disciplines to the delivery process, and RTPs will be able to use that expertise very successfully where necessary and appropriate. I hope that that approach will disseminate good procurement and design practice throughout Scotland, and that RTPs can use it to assist their work.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

The proposal to introduce RTPs flows from the commitment in the partnership agreement for strong regional transport partnerships that will deliver transport systems in their areas. Apart from their responsibility to determine regional transport strategies and to recommend a particular set of transport priorities, what will be the RTPs' functions?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

As you have pointed out before, various models apply in that respect, from model 1, to which I think your question might allude, to model 3, in which the RTPs have a much fuller involvement in the delivery of transport services. I certainly want to encourage the partnerships to develop their thinking and delivery processes through those models. Indeed, I was interested to hear Charlie King, the chairman of the Highlands and Islands strategic transport partnership, say at the Highlands and Islands convention a week past Monday that its regional transport partnership will move towards model 3. That showed that Mr King was thinking about the future of his area, what he wanted to do and how he might suggest such a direction to colleagues. I suspect that that will happen in other parts of Scotland, too.On the basis that, with respect, you and I do not have complete knowledge of the matters involved, the important point is that the partnerships think through how they want to proceed and have a clear vision of where they want to go and how quickly they want to get there. I will be more than happy to encourage that process and to facilitate the move to model 3—to the full transport-service powers—if that is how the partnerships develop.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

Do you envisage the new partnerships, should they wish it, having powers and responsibilities to promote and deliver on a regional basis major improvements to transport infrastructure?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I suspect that the answer is yes. However, as I said in answer to Sylvia Jackson, the new national transport agency will be important in supporting the partnerships. It will not be in any of the RTPs' interests, nor will they be big enough or, most important, have sufficient in-house experience, to procure such projects, but they will have Transport Scotland on which to call. Several other delivery mechanisms exist in Scotland for the procurement of large projects—the one that comes to mind in the Edinburgh and Lothians area is Transport Initiatives Edinburgh. I do not want to get into the issue that was raised earlier about the difference between strategic and regional projects. Enough bodies exist with expertise in large strategic capital projects, road schemes and passenger transport projects to assist RTPs in what they seek to do.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I have a question on the appointment of the non-councillor members of the partnerships. In the appointment process, will the Executive seek individuals who can demonstrate experience of and expertise in transport issues rather than look for people who serve in an ex officio capacity in businesses or other organisations? Has the Executive reached a conclusion about the sort of people whom it will seek to serve alongside councillors on the RTPs?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

That is an interesting question that we could discuss all night, dare I say it. I have a strong desire for the people who sit around the table to take off any other hats that they wear to think about transport in the regions. I will be as open minded as possible when I consider the lists that the shadow RTPs provide to me, as I want the partnerships to be about new thoughts and ideas. We need people who bring something to the table; otherwise, Janette Anderson's concern—that we will simply create bodies whose members sit around the table and talk—might be fair. It is important that we get the membership right. Ian Kernohan is more on top of the details than I am, but I am sure that we can share with the committee the guidance on membership that will be circulated to the RTPs. I give Mr Ewing and the committee an absolute assurance that I want to be open minded and to bring new thinking to the bodies. Perhaps Ian Kernohan can add something on the process.

Ian Kernohan Scottish Executive Enterprise, Transport and Lifelong Learning Department
link

We have prepared draft guidance for local authorities, the existing regional transport partnerships, the new regional transport partnerships and people who might be members of the new RTPs. We would be happy to share the draft, which is being discussed at official level, with the committee if it so wishes.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

That would be useful.We now move to the debate on motion S2M-3510. The Parliament's procedures allow the debate to last no more than 90 minutes, but I am sure that we all expect to get through it in considerably less time.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I do not want to take up any more time than is necessary because we have already discussed the issues. I simply point out that the arrangements in the order represent the outcome of widespread consultation, genuine consensus working and a healthy dose of practical compromise. The order provides a sound footing for the RTPs to get on with the job of improving transport throughout Scotland.I move,That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the Regional Transport Partnerships (Establishment, Constitution and Membership) (Scotland) Order 2005, be approved.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

I have supported the introduction of regional transport partnerships, and we will have to wait and see whether the partnerships lead to enhancements in Scotland's transport infrastructure. I hope that the RTPs will build on the past success of organisations such as SPT in the west of Scotland, and will ensure that all the regions of Scotland have substantial improvements in their transport infrastructure.As the minister knows, I was originally sceptical about the proposal to have an additional single RTP for Shetland. However, I would not want to hold up the process of establishing RTPs just because I am concerned about that area. We should look into whether that RTP can make things better for the people of Shetland in the way that they believe it can. If it does, I will be pleasantly surprised and give credit where it is due. If it does not, we should be open-minded about whether the RTP should rejoin the Highland RTP. However, I will support the motion.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I will support the motion but with some reservations. As the minister says, there is much more work to be done. Detailed discussions will be required with the shadow RTPs on a number of matters such as budgets, which are not as clear as I might have expected at this stage, although I appreciate that there have been many changes.We do not really know how much it will cost each RTP to produce a regional transport strategy and I hope that that cost will be looked into closely in assessing the budgets. We are not quite clear whether RTPs will function as agents of the Scottish Executive and, because we do not know what the RTPs' powers will be, we do not know whether they will be—to use a phrase that I have used from time to time—tigers with teeth or tabbies with dentures.Looking on the positive side—as I always seek to do—I would say that RTPs offer an opportunity that I have always said we should grasp. We have argued that the model with strong powers is appropriate. I am encouraged by Charlie King's views. HITRANS has produced an excellent body of work and has a proven track record of delivering important local projects.I do not wish to be churlish about the minister's pan-island proposal. I can quite understand why the proposal was made and I know that some people even on the Western Isles felt that the minister's idea was good—even if that was not the official view that emerged. There is a real risk that people on the islands will feel that decisions are taken elsewhere. There has also been a particular fear in relation to voting. HITRANS has worked on a non-voting basis and the islands have been comfortable with that. There is a fear that voting will leave people in a constant minority. We will now never know whether there are grounds for that fear. However, I welcome the proposal that has emerged.I wish Shetland well. I am a soothmoother, and I point out that I do not confuse my estuaries with my firths.

Tommy Sheridan SSP Glasgow
link

I, too, will support the motion. I hope that a robust mechanism will be put in place for future reviews of how the RTPs are working, and I hope that the RTPs will draw heavily on what has worked in the past—in particular, the practices of Strathclyde Passenger Transport. SPT has been very effective for many years.Another reason for supporting the motion is what the minister said about staff in his letter. When we talk about strategic proposals we sometimes forget that there are men and women behind them who have given many years of commitment, particularly to SPT. I will take the minister's commitments in the spirit in which he made them. I am sure that he will stick to the letter that he has given us and that he will ensure that there will be no diminution in wages, conditions or pension rights for any staff who transfer.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

Do you want to respond to any of the points, minister?

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

I have just two or three points to make. I agree with Mr Sheridan's point. If I put my commitment in writing, I expect him to hold me to it. I also give that commitment to the entire committee. On Mr Ewing's points, I, too, am positive about HITRANS and what it has achieved, which is no mean achievement, given the disparate areas that are covered. I believe that HITRANS will continue to play a strong role in the future. On voting, it is important to recognise that there will be one member from each council, and they will have a weighted vote. Again, that arose through debate of how the arrangements in the north would work. In addition to that check, the transport minister of the day will have to approve any proposals. Let me be blunt: if there is a bun-fight over something, I rather suspect that Mr Ewing—or, indeed, any member from that area or whatever area—will be chapping at the minister's door saying, "For goodness' sake, sort this out." Therefore, there are a number of parliamentary checks in the system.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

If there is a bun-fight, Fergus will be in the middle of it.

Tavish Scott LD Shetland
link

Finally, convener, I take your point about the particular island group. If it does not deliver, I will be the first to knock on its door.

Bristow Muldoon Lab The Convener · Livingston
link

Thank you for those final remarks, minister.

Motion agreed to.

That the Local Government and Transport Committee recommends that the Regional Transport Partnerships (Establishment, Constitution and Membership) (Scotland) Order 2005 be approved.

  1. Scottish Parliament Local Government and Transport Committee Tuesday 15 November 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 4
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  5. Council Tax Abolition and Service Tax Introduction (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 301
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 52
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.