Under agenda item 3, we will take evidence on the draft Housing Grants (Assessment of Contributions) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2008 from the Minister for Communities and Sport, Stewart Maxwell. I welcome the minister and his officials. He is accompanied by David Fotheringham, who is a team leader in the Scottish Government's housing markets and supply division, and Derek Willis, who is a policy executive in the division.The Subordinate Legislation Committee did not draw the attention of the Local Government and Communities Committee to the draft regulations. They were laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that the Parliament must approve them before they may come into force. As is normal practice, members will have an opportunity to ask the minister and his officials questions before the formal debate on the draft regulations. I offer the minister an opportunity to make any introductory remarks that he wishes to make.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Housing Grants (Assessment of Contributions) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2008 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Stewart Maxwell SNP 16
- Duncan McNeil Lab 9
- John Wilson SNP 5
- Bob Doris SNP 3
- Dr Alasdair Allan SNP 2
- David McLetchie Con 2
- David Fotheringham Scottish Government Housing and Regeneration Directorate 1
The record
41 contributionsThe Housing Grants (Assessment of Contributions) (Scotland) Regulations 2003 set out the rules under which local authorities determine the applicant's contribution towards the cost of works for which the authority proposes to give a housing improvement or repairs grant. The rules include an arrangement to "passport" applicants who receive certain benefits to a 100 per cent grant. The purpose of the draft Housing Grants (Assessment of Contributions) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2008 is to amend the 2003 regulations to take account of a new benefit—employment and support allowance—that was introduced by the Welfare Reform Act 2007.From 27 October 2008, ESA will replace incapacity benefit and income support paid on incapacity grounds to become the main income-replacement benefit for people with a disability or health condition. People who are already in receipt of incapacity benefit or income support will continue to receive the benefits, but new applicants will receive ESA. The draft regulations add the two forms of ESA—income-related ESA and contributory ESA—to the list of allowances and benefits that passport an applicant to 100 per cent grant. They also insert definitions of those allowances into the 2003 regulations. The amendments ensure that people in receipt of ESA as a result of the implementation of the Welfare Reform Act 2007 will be able to be passported to 100 per cent grant. ESA does not have precisely the same effect as the benefits it replaces. Information from the Department for Work and Pensions suggests that, over seven years, a total of around 1,900 people in Scotland who would not get incapacity benefit or income support paid on incapacity grounds should receive ESA, but that around 7,700 people who could expect one of those benefits under current rules will not get ESA.It is not possible to say how many of those 7,700 people would need an adaptation to their home to suit their disability, do not receive other benefits that passport them automatically and would rely on the passporting to 100 per cent to be able to afford the adaptation, nor is it possible to take account of the transition to ESA in any more precise way to reduce the number who might be so affected. However, the switch to ESA will not have any impact on numbers until the financial year 2009-10, by which time we expect to have changed the grant rules as a result of implementing the Housing (Scotland) Act 2006. Although separate regulations for that purpose have still to be laid, I expect grants for adapting houses to suit disabled people to be a minimum of 80 per cent rather than the current minimum of 50 per cent. In addition, local authorities will have discretion to top up the amount of grant. The amendments made by the draft regulations will ensure that people in receipt of ESA will have access to passporting for grant for adaptations to their houses. Because of the change in definition of benefits, a small number of people who might currently expect to receive passported grant will not in future receive ESA and as a result will not be passported. However, their grant for adaptations will, we expect, be a minimum of 80 per cent and local authorities will have the discretion to top up if necessary. I ask the committee to recommend that the draft regulations be approved.
You outlined the fact that some people who would receive income support under the present system will not be entitled to income-related ESA and touched on some of the consequences of that. Will you elaborate on how you will address that situation and provide for those people?
At the moment, it is difficult to be precise about the exact numbers. The estimates are that, over the seven-year timeframe that I mentioned, up to 7,700 people in Scotland might fall into that category. However, that is the total number and we do not know how many of them would require adaptations or will have other benefits that would passport them. Therefore, the number of people who will actually be affected could be relatively low. It could be zero, but we expect that a small number will be affected. However, we intend that the regulations on the scheme of assistance, which have yet to be laid, will raise the minimum grant level from 50 per cent to 80 per cent and allow local authorities to bring that up to 100 per cent if they so desire. Through that route, conditions for many of those people will be improved.
Different rules apply to people with and without spouses. Are you able to say any more about that and why it is so?
There are differences between contributory ESA and income-related ESA. Contributory ESA is, I think, an exact match for incapacity benefit; there is more of a difference with income-related ESA. It is quite complicated, so it is probably better if I read this out rather than do it from memory:"Contributory ESA will be an individual benefit, and there will therefore be no increases for partners. However, partners will be able to make separate claims for contributory benefit. In income-related ESA couples will have additions made for partners, but only one of the partners can claim income related ESA. Couples can only claim one income-related benefit for day to day living expenses at a time. This means income-related ESA is not payable at the same time as income-based JSA, IS or Pension Credit, since otherwise there would be double provision from public funds."I hope that that covers the question.
We certainly heard what you said. Whether we understood it is another matter.
That is why I read straight from my brief—it is a rather complicated benefit.
These changes have been brought about because the United Kingdom Government has effectively introduced a new benefit. Is it the interpretation of that new benefit that the minister is trying to adhere to and adopt in relation to how we conduct things in the Scottish context?
Yes. The Welfare Reform Act 2007 is a piece of UK legislation that introduces this new benefit. We have two choices. If we pass this Scottish statutory instrumentI, we will ensure that, from 27 October, people who are in receipt of ESA are covered in terms of grants. That may have a negative effect on a small number of people who will no longer be entitled to ESA although they were entitled to it under the previous set-up. If we do not pass the SSI, the number of people who are affected will be much greater because, from 27 October, all those who receive ESA will not be entitled to those grants because they will not be included in the passport benefits.Effectively, our hands are tied in terms of trying to support people: the UK Parliament passed the Welfare Reform Act 2007 and we must update our regulations to ensure that the maximum number of people are entitled to receive support. That is what the SSI aims to achieve.
That clarifies the point. I was just trying to get to the fact that ESA is not something that the Scottish Government can manipulate.
No.
It came through the Welfare Reform Act 2007.
Yes.
Therefore, any impact that it may have on individuals who received benefit under the previous regime is down to the introduction of ESA, not the Scottish Government denying people that benefit.
Let me make it absolutely clear: the people who are currently on those benefits will remain on those benefits; it is new claimants after 27 October who will be affected by the change in the rules.
Let us put this into perspective. I appreciate the fact that the regulations introduce a technical change to reflect changes in the UK benefits system, as you have described to Mr Wilson. How many people currently receive the improvement and repairs grants that are covered by the regulations? Can you give us an idea of how many such grants are being paid by local authorities on an annual basis and what that expenditure is?
Unfortunately, I will have to get back to the committee on that. I do not have that information to hand. The effect of the regulations is to minimise the impact of the change to the ESA. I am sorry, but I do not have the numbers in front of me.
I appreciate that. I recall periods in which councils paid generous repairs grants, which led to substantial runs on their repair grant expenditure funds. Those have been substantially scaled back in the past, in periods preceding the present Government. I am trying to get a perspective on what we are talking about in practical terms—how many grants are being paid and what that is costing the budget. It would be useful to know whether that expenditure and the number of people who are being assisted are broadly static, falling or rising. If that information could be supplied, that would be useful. I appreciate that it is not directly material to consideration of the SSI, but it would provide a useful perspective. Sometimes, in the past, regulations have given people only theoretical entitlements. Unless the money is available, they are not worth the paper on which they are written.
You are right to say that it is a connected issue but not one that directly affects the regulations. We intend to implement the 2006 act, and I mentioned in my opening remarks some of the changes it will make. Our expectation is that the overall number of grants will reduce after those changes come into effect, because of the establishment of the scheme of assistance. We believe that the changes that we hope to make—raising the minimum grant and making entitlement to it automatic—will be beneficial to people with disabilities.
link
You said that your proposal, which involves housing grants, is necessary because of the Welfare Reform Act 2007 and the establishment of the employment and support allowance. At what point in the process did the Department for Work and Pensions contact the Scottish Government to make the Scottish ministers aware of any knock-on effects of its legislation? Has there been a period of positive consultation between the UK Administration and the Scottish Government?
We have been aware of the situation for many months. Officials have been in conversation with their counterparts in the UK Government on this issue for some months. The fact remains that the powers over welfare benefits are reserved to the UK Government and the UK Parliament has taken the decision to make the alteration that we have been talking about. Since becoming aware of the developments, we have been working on regulations that would minimise the effect of the change on people who currently receive the benefits that will be replaced.
link
That is positive, but my point is that when the Welfare Reform Bill went through the UK Parliament, issues would have been raised about the knock-on effects of the proposals. Does the Scottish Government have to monitor what happens at a UK level, or does the UK Government inform the Scottish Government of possible knock-on effects during its scrutiny process?
The piece of legislation that we are discussing was dealt with prior to the election in May 2007. As I was not a minister at the time, I am not aware of the discussions that took place during the passage of the act. I cannot really help you.
Can the officials help Mr Doris?
On the administrative side, through colleagues in other departments we have had links with DWP and we have been informed of the administrative processes. I am not aware that there has been a great deal of engagement on a policy level; I think that that is left to Westminster.
link
I am not sure that that exactly answers my question, but it raises a general point—
It might be that your questions might be better asked of the Minister for Parliamentary Business, who I believe has regular contact with Westminster about the impact of proposed UK legislation.
The employment and support allowance is a new benefit in the sense that it will replace the payments that were previously paid out to new claimants. The Scottish Government has to work through the changes and ensure that its partners in local authorities are aware of the changes and take on board the impact on future claimants. It is important to state that the issue concerns future claimants, not existing claimants.
We are in regular contact with local authorities, through the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities in particular. I am not aware that the regulations will have any financial impact on local authorities—in fact, I do not think that they will—but local authorities are aware of the change. As I said earlier, we think that these regulations are necessary to minimise the impact on people who are affected by the change and to ensure that everyone who is in the new scheme benefits from the passporting effect.
For clarity, I should say that we are dealing with a technical change, not the changes in the benefits system.
Yes, this is a technical change.
The powers for grants and payments flow from the Scottish Government to local authorities, which deliver and manage them. We heard you say that the minimum grant levels are to be examined. We may be getting ahead here, but I think that we would all, as constituency MSPs if not as a committee, agree that that aspect needs to be examined.You mentioned a review. I have come across a small number of people who, despite being given substantial amounts of money, do not have the wherewithal to access the £15,000 or £20,000 that would complete their project—I am talking about the level of grant for modernisation work. Will the examination of minimum grant levels and the review of grants include consideration of how such people could be helped?
The scheme of assistance regulations are still to come. As I understand it, the discussion in the 2006 act is that people will be allowed to use the equity in their property as part of the process, so they can access increased funds through borrowing on their asset. That will help many people who have an asset that has value but do not, as the convener said, have cash in the bank to improve their property. Obviously, local authorities will have discretion to provide grants.
When can we expect news on that?
The regulations are just about finalised and we expect to lay them before the end of September.
Thank you. That concludes our question session.We now move to agenda item 4 and the debate on the draft Housing Grants (Assessment of Contributions) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2008. I invite the minister to move motion S3M-2569.
Motion moved,
That the Local Government and Communities Committee recommends that the draft Housing Grants (Assessment of Contributions) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2008 be approved.—Stewart Maxwell.
Motion agreed to.
I thank the minister and his team for their attendance and their evidence.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Sep 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Local Government and Communities Committee Wednesday 24 September 2008 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 32
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Disabled Persons' Parking Places (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 211
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.