Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Act 2003 (Amendment of Specified Authorities) Order 2008 (Draft)

Wednesday 24 September 2008 Local Government and Communities Committee Subordinate legislation 32 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

32 contributions
Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

The first agenda item is subordinate legislation. The committee will take evidence on the draft order. I welcome John Swinney MSP, the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth. Accompanying Mr Swinney are Paul Gray, the director of change and corporate services; Colin Spivey, the head of resourcing; and Carol Snow, a solicitor to the Scottish Government.The Subordinate Legislation Committee has not drawn the committee's attention to the draft order. Members have received electronic copies of the publicly available material on the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee's web pages regarding its consideration of the issue. The draft order is laid under the affirmative procedure, which means that the Parliament must approve it before its provisions can come into force.It is normal practice to give members the opportunity to ask questions of the minister and his officials before the start of the formal debate. First, I invite the minister to make some introductory remarks.

John Swinney SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth · North Tayside
link

I welcome the opportunity to discuss with the committee the amendments that are being made to the Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Act 2003.As members will know, the approach to public appointments is structured around the work of the Office of the Commissioner for Public Appointments in Scotland, which provides important scrutiny of the public appointments process in Scotland. The purpose of the work of OCPAS, under the 2003 act, is to ensure that the public has confidence in the public appointments process and that the process is open, fair and transparent. No significant structural changes to that approach are envisaged in the draft order. In order to ensure that schedule 2 to the 2003 act is kept up to date, the draft order reinstates four bodies, removes two others, changes the category of three bodies and amends the entry for one. Such periodic changes are proposed by ministers as required. Essentially, the draft order tidies up schedule 2.I look forward to addressing any points that the committee wants to raise in the first part of our discussion this morning.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. Can you explain why there is an intermediary role for the minister in the process of appointments to the national park boards? I suppose that you will answer that that is what the law says. In terms of the construction of the legislation, why is it deemed appropriate that a local authority nominee can join a board only through the intercession of an appointment by a minister? Could the drafting not say, "The board will comprise A, B and C people nominated by a minister and 1, 2, 3 and 4 people nominated by the relevant local authorities"? Why is the minister in the middle of the appointment of elected representatives to those public bodies?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

My answer is probably the same as the one that you offered, which is that Parliament set out why that was to be the case, for which I do not think that there is a particularly compelling reason. The law could be amended, if it was considered appropriate that ministers should not be involved in the process and that there should be a sort of passporting approach so that a local authority that was entitled to nominate an individual to the board of a national park would be able to do so.I suppose that ministers interceding in the process gives a certain extra imprimatur of order and administrative assurance. That is my explanation, other than giving my view about what is in the National Parks (Scotland) Act 2000.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

After the draft order comes into force, such nominations must still go through an intermediary, who is the minister. Theoretically, at least, could the minister still refuse to appoint a councillor whom a local authority had nominated?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

In theory, yes. I have read the correspondence that was exchanged between officials, ministers, the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee and the Commissioner for Public Appointments in Scotland about the particular circumstance that influenced the appointment of members to the national park boards. It is clear from all that that there has not been the greatest of clarity, or, rather, the greatest of consistency between two pieces of legislation: the Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc (Scotland) Act 2003 and the National Parks (Scotland) Act 2000. That has left us in a situation that has had to be resolved by ministers deciding to confirm the appointment of local authority members to the boards without putting them through the OCPAS choice process, as I would characterise it. That issue has obviously had a significant effect on how the matter has been handled.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

Thank you for that. I want to move on from the specific issue that concerned the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee to other aspects of the draft order. I am interested in the reclassification that is going on and the categorisation of various entities. Can you hazard an explanation as to what the difference is between "Nationalised bodies" and "Public corporations"?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

As I reflected on my papers last night, Mr McLetchie, I wondered whether you and I might discuss the merits of "Nationalised bodies" and "Public corporations". I am glad that my predictions have proven to be correct—I must put a bet on a horse every so often.To give a representative feel of the organisations that we are talking about, it is probably best to use a couple of the examples in the draft order: Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd and David MacBrayne Ltd. Essentially, they are organisations that operate in the public interest and deliver a form of public service. However, we recognise that the focus and outlook of those companies and their relationship to other players in the transportation system might change, depending on decisions that are taken at a contractual level. Nationalised bodies would be defined as key, directed components of the infrastructure of the state, whereas public corporations act in the public interest, but their perspective and outlook may change on the basis of contractual decisions that may be arrived at through the competitive tendering process that is undertaken in relation to ferry contracts.

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

That was a good effort, cabinet secretary. Can you perhaps tell us then where Scottish Water fits into all this? Is that now a public corporation for the purposes of the schedule 2 list?

David McLetchie Con Edinburgh Pentlands
link

That is fine. Can you volunteer some information as to where the Scottish Futures Trust will fit in? Will that be a public corporation?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

The Scottish Futures Trust is not yet a regulated body, but it will become one. I imagine that it will fit into the public corporation category, but I want to give the committee a definitive view on that in due course.

Jim Tolson LD Dunfermline West
link

Good morning. In your opening statement, you said that various bodies are being added to or removed from the list. Obviously, the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee expressed concern about the rationale behind the decision on which bodies are to be added or removed. Can you outline which bodies are to be added or removed and the rationale for the changes?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

Yes. Quality Meat Scotland is being added as a new body. Essentially, that relates to the transformation of a private organisation into a non-departmental public body, which took effect on 1 April 2008. Skills Development Scotland is a new body that was created out of the shell of the Scottish University for Industry Ltd. As I am sure you are aware, Skills Development Scotland was created to draw together into one organisation a number of public bodies: the skills elements of Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise; and Careers Scotland. That work was completed in April 2008. The draft order makes the appropriate designation for Skills Development Scotland.The other body that is being added to the list is the Scottish Local Authorities Remuneration Committee. The Office of the Commissioner for Public Appointments in Scotland regulates the committee as if it were included in schedule 2 to the 2003 act, so the draft order includes the committee for the purposes of good order in the process.As I discussed with Mr McLetchie, the draft order makes changes to terminology. On that basis, under the draft order, Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd, David MacBrayne Ltd and Highlands and Islands Airports Ltd, which were called nationalised bodies, will now be called public corporations.The draft order amends the designations of the Cairngorms National Park Authority and the Loch Lomond and the Trossachs National Park Authority to take into account the exclusion of local authority nominees from OCPAS regulation. The draft order also reinstates the Common Services Agency for the Scottish Health Service as a body listed in schedule 2. We have done that because of the return to use of the body's statutory name. Two bodies are being deleted from the list. The first is the Scottish Hospital Endowments Research Trust, which has had its status as an NDPB removed, given that it is now an independent charity. Secondly, the Scottish Advisory Committee on the Medical Workforce is being deleted, as the body no longer exists; it met last in the spring of 2002.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

The report that we are considering this morning states:"The Commissioner confirmed thatthe approach in the draft order would resolve the current situation and that it"would avoid a recurrence … but stated that it would not address her concerns about the fairness and transparency"with regard to appointments by local authorities.Has any discussion been held with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities or local authorities on how they propose to proceed, given such an exemption? I note from our papers that at least two authorities—Argyll and Bute Council and Moray Council, I think—offered more than one nomination in order to give some sort of choice and to comply with the process. However, the majority—six out of eight—did not. Have such discussions been held? Should the issue be looked at?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

Obviously, the issue does not affect all local authorities. Only a proportion of local authorities are involved, so a discussion with COSLA may not be appropriate. However, there has been a great deal of discussion about the issue, because it has been difficult to resolve. As I said to Mr McLetchie, there is not a very consistent fit between the public appointments legislation and the national parks legislation. We have not legislated with absolute consistency.The issue can be handled in one of two ways. One way is to look to local authorities to select experienced individuals who are suitable to take part in the work of the national park authorities. The papers that I have—I presume that members of the committee also have those papers—contain copies of letters from the convener of Highland Council and the chief executive of Angus Council, who have commented on the appropriateness and experience of the individuals whom they have nominated to take part in the work of the boards of the national park authorities.The other way of handling the issue is to go down the route that the convener suggested. Authorities could be invited to provide more than one nominee whom ministers could consider—I do not think that there is any statutory basis for requiring them to do so. My concern about that approach is that it would limit a local authority's ability to choose an individual to be a member of a national park authority board, as it is legally entitled to do. I understand that we would be constraining without statutory cover a local authority's ability to decide its nominee. We would be encroaching without statutory authority on a local authority's right to choose a person whom it considered fit.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

I was exploring a general procedural point rather than a point about the Cairngorms national park. You have outlined several considerations in relation to whether best practice should be pursued. Is it best practice to have more than one nomination? Is the procedure in Highland best practice? There, nominations come with a full curriculum vitae—a person who has been nominated has some experience, so there is justification for that nomination. Alternatively, are we content, on balance, with the current nomination procedures? Therefore, does no action need to be taken?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

We should always be prepared to consider such questions, but we must avoid second-guessing local authorities when they are perfectly entitled to exercise their statutory functions in appointing individuals to boards. However, local authorities do not have an unfettered right. They must ensure that their selection process is open, fair and transparent, and they will be quite familiar with undertaking such processes in appointing members to various external organisations within their locus. I am certainly happy to discuss the matter with them, but we must be careful to avoid intruding on their statutory right to appoint, through an open, fair and transparent process, an individual whom they consider fit to be a representative on a board.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Most of the questions that I was going to ask have been covered. My understanding is that ministers make appointments to a number of public bodies, and local authorities can make nominations. The convener has hinted at where there may be a dispute about the manner in which a local authority has made an appointment. Who would oversee such a dispute or intervene to ensure that the transparency that the cabinet secretary is talking about is adhered to?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

The answer to Mr Wilson's question essentially rests within individual local authorities' procedures and operating approaches. Local authorities have an obligation to operate in an open, fair and transparent fashion in their decision making. As members of the committee know, if there is any doubt or uncertainty about how local authorities have gone about making their decisions, there are plenty of avenues for scrutiny of how they came about.Some of that scrutiny is at a more generic level. For example, external organisations and investigatory bodies such as Audit Scotland, Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education and the Social Work Inspection Agency can consider such matters. At the level of individual conduct, the Standards Commission for Scotland can consider whether individuals have acted appropriately. There is no lack of opportunities for scrutiny of local authorities' decisions.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

That concludes the question session. We move on to agenda item 2, which is the debate on the draft order.

Motion moved,

That the Local Government and Communities Committee recommends that the draft Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc. (Scotland) Act 2003 (Amendment of Specified Authorities) Order 2008 be approved.—John Swinney.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

Cabinet secretary, do you wish to speak to the motion?

John Swinney SNP North Tayside
link

I planned a three-hour address, but I will spare the committee that. I am happy to leave things as they are.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

Thank you for that. I invite members to debate the motion. Does anyone want to speak to it?

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

I do not suppose that the minister wants to wind up, as he did not have any opening comments.

Motion agreed to.

Duncan McNeil Lab The Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
link

I thank the minister and his team for their time.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Local Government and Communities Committee Wednesday 24 September 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 2
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 32
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. Disabled Persons' Parking Places (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 211

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.