Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 1985 (Low Income, Low Asset Debtors etc) Regulations 2008 (Draft)

Tuesday 19 February 2008 Justice Committee Subordinate legislation 20 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

20 contributions
Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 4 is regulations that are subject to the affirmative procedure. The cabinet secretary is now supported by Gillian Thompson, who is the chief executive of the Accountant in Bankruptcy. I refer members to the regulations and to the cover note, which is paper J/S3/08/5/3.I invite the cabinet secretary to speak to the regulations and to move motion S3M-1230.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

The Bankruptcy and Diligence etc (Scotland) Act 2007 contains the power to make regulations to introduce a new route into bankruptcy. That power is intended to extend access to bankruptcy to people who are burdened by debts that they have no prospect of repaying and who are excluded from seeking debt relief through bankruptcy under current law.Present legislation relies on creditors to take legal action against people who owe them money, and some actions establish what is technically known as apparent insolvency, which a debtor must demonstrate when applying for bankruptcy. However, many creditors are unwilling to incur the cost of pursuing a debt when they see little prospect of recovering that cost and the debt, so debtors in such a situation have no proof of apparent insolvency and cannot access debt relief through bankruptcy. Information from the money advice sector supports the belief that a substantial number of Scottish debtors are caught in that situation.The regulations provide the framework for an alternative route into bankruptcy, on the basis that a debtor has low income and low assets—LILA for short. Debtors who use the new route will no longer have to prove apparent insolvency. The regulations define low income and low assets.All debtor applications will be made to the Accountant in Bankruptcy. The application fee will be £100 and no exemptions or waivers will be given. The fee could be seen as a barrier to some people, but we believe that it will not be insurmountable and that applicants will benefit from the debt relief. We have discussed the LILA scheme with Money Advice Scotland and Citizens Advice Scotland and have taken the view that it is important to have a constraint, to ensure that people consider carefully the implications of becoming bankrupt. Collecting fees will also minimise the burden on the public purse.Debtors who become bankrupt through the LILA route will be subject to the normal bankruptcy rules. The Accountant in Bankruptcy will become the trustee in the administration of all LILA cases. That will require minimum administration, and the cost will be covered by the application fee. If an asset or income subsequently comes to light or the debtor's circumstances change, the AIB will review the administrative requirements. The AIB will also select a random sample of cases for closer scrutiny to ensure that the LILA route into bankruptcy is not abused.Low income means gross weekly income of no more than the standard adult national minimum wage for a 40-hour working week, which equates to £220.80. People will be treated as meeting the low-income condition if they receive income-based benefits, including working tax credits. Any other income from benefits and any income that a family member receives will be disregarded.Having low assets means that the debtor has no asset that is worth more than £1,000 and that their total assets are worth not more than £10,000. Essential items for day-to-day living, such as household appliances, medical equipment and children's toys will be disregarded.Regulation 4 will modify the Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 1985 to ensure that a debtor's family home is not returned to them automatically after three years if a legal ruling on who owns the property is pending.I move,That the Justice Committee recommends that the draft Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 1985 (Low Income, Low Asset Debtors etc.) Regulations 2008 be approved.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

How many applications are expected in a normal year?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

We are not exactly sure. CAS has given the provisional figure of 5,500 debtors whom it expects to apply in the first year of the scheme's operation. It is expected that 3,000 debtors will apply each year thereafter.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I understand the scheme's purpose and the category of folk at whom it is aimed, but I am slightly concerned that the law of unintended consequences might operate. Students who run up considerable debts might find themselves exceedingly impecunious at the point when they should be starting work and they might find the scheme an extremely useful route to becoming bankrupt and getting rid of their debts before they start work. Forgive me if I seem a little cynical about those who are around me, but can you confirm that people will have to have received benefits for a while before they can benefit from such bankruptcy, so it will not be in somebody's interest to manufacture that position?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

The Parliament and the Government are constrained by a growing problem. Part of it is cultural—it relates to how people view ready credit—and part of it concerns consumer regulations over which we have no control. The Government cannot prevent people from getting into financial difficulties; we can only deal with the problems that that causes, which we seek to deal with elsewhere.We must change the culture as well as make the position clear. Student loans will not be written off from 1 April 2008, so instead of suggesting that a laissez-faire attitude will develop, we must spread the message that bankruptcy is not an easy way out. However, we cannot allow to linger in limbo people who cannot obtain the benefit of bankruptcy because creditors who have allowed them to incur debt—for understandable reasons, in many instances—see no point in throwing good money after bad. Such people have debt that they cannot get rid of—they cannot go forward or back—so we are giving them a way out.As for your suggestion about students and others, we must drive a change in the cultural attitude, but the scheme will address a specific problem.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I remain concerned about the creative capacity of folk to make themselves bankrupt. I am not sure that an immediate solution to that exists, but I am concerned that the scheme looks like a route for some people to—dare I say it—maliciously get rid of their creditors.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I have much sympathy with your point. The solution is not simply to deal with getting people out of being impecunious and bankrupt, but to target how people get into debt. Unfortunately, consumer credit is reserved to Westminster, so the Government, the AIB and others cannot act. Until we change not only the culture but how people get into such situations, we will be constrained. The Government faces the problem of the people who are in such situations and we need to provide a way out. Your point is valid, but the solution is to address not simply bankruptcy and diligence provisions, but how people access consumer credit, how it is suggested and promoted to them, and the rates that people are charged.

Nigel Don SNP North East Scotland
link

I do not have a crystal ball and I would not use one if I did, but I wonder whether we are opening a little box and whether lawyers will charge in and find ways of using an admirable mechanism—I understand why we want it and I have nothing against the basic principle or its purpose—to drive a coach and horses through the consumer credit industry. As the scheme stands, there is a real possibility that consumer credit as we know it will disappear, because it appears that a debtor could quite quickly manufacture a situation from which they could become bankrupt and get rid of their debts.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

We are happy to review the position after four months and we will review it again after 12 months.If you speak to some of those who are involved in consumer credit, you will find that they already write off substantial amounts of debt, which is why the rates that they charge anticipate that 40 per cent or more of cases will go sour. That is a problem not just for Scotland but for the global economy, because of the sub-prime lending market, in which people were encouraged to borrow money and acquire things when they clearly did not have the resources to meet the payments. That is a matter for the consumer credit industry and it is beyond the constraints that are on the committee, me and the Parliament. However, we have to alleviate the situation. We make it clear, and we will always reiterate, that bankruptcy is not an easy option. It affects a person's credit rating for many years and it can affect their job, because some jobs cannot be held by people who have been bankrupted or sequestrated.It is appropriate for legislation to provide a mechanism for people who have no prospect of repaying their debts to obtain debt relief. Nigel Don is right to flag up a problem that could be exacerbated by what might happen with the global economy. However, the balance that he seeks is dealt with by making it clear that bankruptcy is not an easy option. It should not necessarily carry the stigma that it had centuries ago, when people committed suicide because they were bankrupt or impecunious, but, equally, we have to get across to people, especially the younger generation, that they cannot just go out and run up debts without facing penalties, sanctions and other problems.We have to face the situation where a substantial number of people are in debt limbo and do not have the same opportunity to get out that exists for others who have some assets. The regulations will give them the same benefit as people whose businesses are in difficulty, perhaps through no fault of their own.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I notice that the Executive note for the regulations states that it will cost £186,000 to set up the scheme. Cabinet secretary, has any budget allocation been made for extra support for CAS and money advice centres, for example? Like Nigel Don, I believe that a number of people will seek advice on this law. Has that been included in the budget for the coming year at least?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

That is a legitimate question, but we are talking about the cost of setting up the scheme and dealing with the cost to the AIB. Most of the costs of the scheme will be soaked up by the AIB because it will deal with the scheme.Cathie Craigie is correct to say that we have a growing problem with indebtedness. However, my department does not deal with organisations such as CAS, Money Advice Scotland and many others; they are dealt with under the social inclusion heading. There are funding mechanisms for them, although I do not know the precise amounts that they have been given to deal with debt problems. That is more to do with the issue that Nigel Don raised. The cost will be soaked up by the AIB because it will deal with the scheme.The only additional cost might relate to information that requires to be made available to CAS or Money Advice Scotland about how the regulations provide a route into bankruptcy. We are happy to consider that possible additional cost, but the AIB sends information to such organisations regularly, and all that they have to do is suggest that contacting the AIB might be the solution to their debt problems.The broad issues around bankruptcy and the voluntary sector are dealt with by another Government department. The costs of the scheme will be met by the AIB. The additional costs to the voluntary sector will be marginal.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

You said that there will be an early review of the scheme and that it will be kept under review. Will the justice department liaise with the department with responsibility for social inclusion on monitoring the new arrangements? I have a feeling that local citizens advice bureaux might become busier. You are right to say that people will be referred to the AIB, but staff and volunteers will have to take time to advise individuals, and I am sure that CAS will want to ensure that its volunteers are trained in aspects of the new system.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

There is an implementation group, with which the AIB is working closely, and I am more than happy to undertake to review the situation.I was a lawyer for 20 years and I ran advice surgeries and worked closely with CAS in Wester Hailes, Pilton and elsewhere. Given that 5,500 debtors are expected to use the new system in the first year and 3,000 people annually thereafter, I think that the new arrangements will lead to great savings for CAS, whose staff face considerable difficulties in trying to help people and who must phone numerous creditors to work out debt arrangements.You are right to suggest that nothing is cost free. There is the law of unintended consequences, as Nigel Don said. However, CAS currently deals with people who are in debt and the new arrangements should generate cost savings for the service, because staff will be able to advise people that if they go to the AIB and pay the £100 fee, the problem will be solved. I know from experience that advice workers currently have to write to 10, 12, 15 or 100 credit card companies to ask them to leave a debtor alone because they have a sick granny or are out of work and can pay only 50p a week or whatever. We will monitor the situation, but there are swings and roundabouts, and when the new system is in place CAS will probably be able to do more for other people who need considerable help.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

If there are no further questions, I invite the cabinet secretary to wind up the debate. Perhaps you will reflect on the degree of unease that members have expressed. There might be justification for promising to review the situation in six months' time and report further to the committee, when your department has had the opportunity to ascertain how many applications have been processed.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I happily give that undertaking. We said that we would review the situation in four months' time. We can write to the committee after that and I will gladly give evidence again if you want me to do so. We will review the situation again after 12 months.The committee is right to be concerned. Debt is faced by individuals not only in Scotland but throughout the world, and the global economy could have a significant bearing on what happens. As a result of cultural shifts and attitudinal changes, there are levels of indebtedness in Scotland that are of significant concern to everyone, including the Government and every member of the Parliament.There is no single, easy solution. Some solutions must be dealt with elsewhere. The Government argues that powers to address such matters should be given to us. I do not doubt that that will be considered—whether as part of the national conversation or through commissions—because ultimately we must not only find solutions to problems but address the causes. Currently, the Government cannot deal with the causes of the problems, because consumer credit is reserved to Westminster. We must deal with the current situation, whereby thousands of people in Scotland are in financial difficulty and cannot benefit from the opportunity to apply for bankruptcy.Members are right to say that bankruptcy should not be regarded as an easy option—it will never be an easy option. Bankruptcy should not necessarily carry the stigma that was attached to it in the Victorian era, but it must be made clear that bankruptcy will always have consequences, not all of which will be benign. However, we must get people out of the morass that they are in.I am happy to undertake to review the situation and come back to the committee at an appropriate juncture, when we have more information. As I said, we will review the situation in four months' time and in 12 months' time. To some extent, we are in unknown territory, so we must find out what works, but the status quo is not an option. Time will tell whether the new arrangements alone are adequate, and we will be more than happy to work with the committee on the issue. Debt is a problem that we face as a community. We must find a solution.

Motion agreed to.

That the Justice Committee recommends that the draft Bankruptcy (Scotland) Act 1985 (Low Income, Low Asset Debtors etc.) Regulations 2008 be approved.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

I thank members for their attendance.

Meeting closed at 11:39.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 19 February 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Declaration of Interests Procedure · 5
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 29
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.