Item 2 is consideration of subordinate legislation. The first instrument to be considered is the draft Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 Fixed Penalty Order 2008. The draft order is subject to the affirmative procedure. To speak to it this morning, we have Kenny MacAskill MSP, the Cabinet Secretary for Justice. Good morning, cabinet secretary.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 Fixed Penalty Order 2008 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kenny MacAskill SNP 13
- Bill Aitken Con 6
- Cathie Craigie Lab 3
- Mike Pringle LD 2
- Nigel Don SNP 2
- John Wilson SNP 1
The record
29 contributionsGood morning.
The cabinet secretary is accompanied by Gerard Bonnar, who is the head of the Scottish Government's summary justice reform branch.I refer members to the order and the cover note, which is paper J/S3/08/5/1. I invite Mr MacAskill to speak to the order and to move motion S3M-1186.
The draft order is being made using an anticipatory exercise of power under section 302 of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995, as amended by provisions that are contained in section 50 of the Criminal Proceedings etc (Reform) (Scotland) Act 2007, which will come into force on 10 March 2008. Section 302 of the 1995 act, as amended, will allow the Scottish ministers to prescribe a scale of fixed penalties to the maximum level of £300. The draft order prescribes the scale of fixed-penalty offers at £50, £75, £100, £150, £200, £250 and the maximum £300, as provided for in the act. The new scale will afford procurators fiscal greater flexibility in determining the most appropriate and effective offer of a penalty for an alleged offence. That will allow more cases of a less serious nature to be dealt with quickly and proportionately and will release the courts to deal with more serious offences. The new scale comprises an essential part of the overall aims of improving the summary justice system's efficiency and effectiveness. Fiscal fixed-penalty offers have proved an appropriate and efficient way of dealing with low-level offending over the years, and prosecutors are experienced in their use. The extension of the scale will increase the usefulness and flexibility of fiscal fixed-penalty offers, and separate provisions in the 2007 act that come into force on 10 March will improve their enforcement. Taken together, the changes will ensure that they play a key role in our reforms to the summary justice system.I move,That the Justice Committee recommends that the draft Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 Fixed Penalty Order 2008 be approved.
Thank you. What steps will be taken to ensure that fixed penalties are paid?
I know that you have raised the matter previously—and correctly so—and we will monitor it. The fines enforcement system and other aspects of summary justice are changing. We seek to free up the system but, equally, we must ensure that it is not flouted. I give you an undertaking that we will monitor the matter to ensure that fixed-penalty offers are being dispensed and paid. They are not meant to be tickets that somebody can use to wallpaper their house; they are meant to register society's opprobrium, and we expect them to be paid.
I am just a little concerned that some houses are remarkably well wallpapered. Do you have any indications of how the present collection system is working?
Our understanding is that the present collection system is working reasonably well. It is changing because of measures that the previous Executive brought in and which we supported in opposition. Fines enforcement officers are being rolled out and other matters are coming through. They will help to provide focus. If people cannot pay because of a change in circumstances, we will have to consider and address that. However, we must equally remember that people who are given fixed penalties are expected to pay them and we must ensure that they do so. That is why we will seek to monitor how the introduction of FEOs works out. That is the direction of travel that the previous Administration decided and it is the correct way to go. We are happy to review the matter but, at the moment, the system is not too bad and we need to consider how to make it better.
Do the fixed-penalty offers relate to bail orders that are imposed in court and those that are imposed by the police? I know that there has been some disquiet in the Glasgow Bar Association and the Edinburgh Bar Association. I believe that John Scott expressed some concern about bail orders being issued by policemen. Do the fixed-penalty offers relate to both?
They do not relate to bail orders. The police have fixed-penalty notice powers that the previous Administration introduced and which are now being rolled out. A review is under way to determine how effective they are, taking into account the matters that the convener raised, and to explore whether we should reduce the number of offences that fall within the criteria for the use of fixed-penalty notices or, indeed, whether we should bring in new offences. We will review and scrutinise those matters.The order relates to a situation in which the procurator fiscal receives a report directly from the police, who have decided not to impose a fixed-penalty notice. In its wisdom, the Crown can decide whether to cite somebody for court or offer them the opportunity to make a payment at whatever level the fiscal thinks appropriate. That will be beneficial. I am aware of some concerns from the bar associations, but the Government's view is that there is protection and that people are not required to accept the offer and can seek to have their day in court. However, to be frank, far too many cases go to court in which a plea of guilty is tendered, the sheriff simply rubber stamps it and the system grinds to a halt. I come back to proportionality and putting some trust and faith the Procurator Fiscal Service. The Government is satisfied that the Procurator Fiscal Service is not simply a prosecution service but acts in the public interest and has the skills and talents to make a judgment. If somebody refutes an allegation, they can refuse to accept the fixed-penalty offer and the case will go to court, where it will be decided. If they do not feel that they have committed an offence—which is perfectly understandable—they can refuse to accept the offer and will have their day in court.
What are the bar associations' concerns?
Their major concern is that there could be a significant drop in the number of cases that go to court and, accordingly, a considerable drop in the work that their members do and the income that they receive. I have a great deal of sympathy for anybody who finds himself in that position but, to be frank, the Government's task is not to be a job-creation scheme for those who are involved in the courts system but to ensure that that system works better for all our communities. If the order frees up resources, it will allow the courts to concentrate on more serious matters. We have logjams in particular courts, and if matters are clearly in dispute—if people feel that they have been cited wrongly and did not commit the alleged offence—we must ensure that the courts can concentrate on those. When dealing with difficult people, we must give our sheriffs time to analyse what needs to go to court and what evidence needs to be brought. We must free up some space so that the courts do the things that they do best and which only they can do. It is not our job to create a system in which cases that do not need to go to court do so routinely.
How many times could somebody be offered a fixed penalty? Should there be a limit on the number?
Those matters are best dealt with by the procurator fiscal. There is no limit, but we must trust the procurator fiscal's good sense. If someone routinely picked up a fiscal fine on a Friday or Saturday night, sooner or later we would find either that they were extremely rich and flouting the law with disdain—in which case the matter would be dealt with much more seriously—or that there was a significant problem, because they would not be able to pay the penalties that were imposed.It is a matter of balance to some extent. Court remains appropriate for people who regularly offend and are much more serious offenders. Fixed-penalty offers are intended to deal with low-level cases that do not routinely need to go to court. It would be wrong to set a maximum number of offers. What number would we fix it at—two, three or something else? We have to leave it to the Crown Office to work with the local procurators fiscal, who deal with individual offenders.Ms Craigie's point is valid. If someone was routinely picking up fiscal fines like some people seem to pick up parking tickets, there would be cause for concern. I have faith that no fiscal would allow that to happen: they would ratchet it up by bringing the person before the court so that the full majesty of the law could be imposed.
If someone with two or three fiscal fines was reported to the courts, would the court be able to consider the fiscal fines?
They are recorded for up to two years, so they would be before the court. A pattern of behaviour that needed to be dealt with would be seen—presuming that there was a conviction.
The fiscal penalty requires an admission of guilt, so at that point there would technically be a conviction, which could be referred to in subsequent proceedings.
The cabinet secretary suggested that some members of the legal fraternity were worried about the amount of work that they would get, but that was not the concern expressed by John Scott of the Edinburgh Bar Association. I quote from a magazine called The Firm, in which he stated:"We are putting more power into the hands of the police, and it is not clear that sufficient safeguards are there".He also said that"the new measures are reversing centuries old principles of the criminal law."His concern is about someone who is given a bail order by a policeman, who has not taken the issues into consideration properly. Are you prepared to comment on that?
You are getting mixed up with a separate matter. Fixed-penalty notices are dispensed by the police; fiscal fines are a different matter, and some members of the bar have complained that fiscal fines impinge on justice.My view is that, first, anybody who does not accept the position that is suggested by the fiscal has the right to reject the fiscal fine and the matter can go to court—they will get their day in court if they so wish. Secondly, we are dealing with summary justice. There must be an element of proportionality. Not every case in Scotland can go before a High Court, a sheriff or a jury. We must recognise that some matters have to be freed up. The maximum level of fine is set at £300. That was debated, because it was suggested that it should be £500, but we decided that it should be £300. It can be reviewed and put up or down, depending on how matters are viewed—a system is in place to allow calibration.We must recognise that some offences that are not heinous have to be dealt with fairly summarily. They are not acceptable and must be punished, and the person's card is marked through a fiscal fine. If the person objects to the allegation, the case goes to court. We must get matters in proportion. If we want to use our court, police and fiscal services appropriately, we must ensure that they are not weighed down by fairly mundane matters that could be dealt with by the offer of a fiscal fine.I come back to the point that the Procurator Fiscal Service is there, always has been there and—under our Administration—always will be there to act in the best interests of justice and to do so without fear or favour. It is not there to be a prosecution agency; it is there to consider whether a crime has been committed, whether it can be proven and whether it is in the public interest to prosecute. We should have some trust and faith in the Procurator Fiscal Service, which in Scotland deals not only with prosecution but with fatal accident inquiries and an array of other appropriate matters.
I return to the point made by the convener. I seek clarity from the cabinet secretary as to whether the acceptance and payment of a fiscal fine is an admission of guilt. My understanding is that it is not. Is it effectively a double-or-quits cop out?
It is not technically a conviction, but it can be brought to the court's attention. The fiscal fine would not appear on a list of a person's previous convictions—if they had previous convictions. For a period of two years from the date on which it was issued and accepted, it could be brought to the court's attention, but it is not on the person's criminal record.
Two years later it is washed out with the tide and gone for ever.
Yes. We think that that is reasonable. We are happy to review how the system works out but, given that we accept that the fiscal fine is for more minor matters, after two years some people seem to be capable of rehabilitation. Even for more serious matters, there is a period after which offences no longer have to be recorded. Two years is the current threshold. If, in due course, it seems that the two years is either excessive or—perhaps more likely—inadequate, we can review it, but it is accepted that a fiscal fine is not a criminal conviction, because the case has not gone through the courts. Criminal convictions arise from offences that have been dealt with in the court system.
Will fixed fines show up for two years in any Disclosure Scotland checks?
They would not appear in the basic disclosure check, but they would be recorded in an enhanced disclosure check for particular types of employment.
Does the cabinet secretary feel the need to wind up?
No. I will decline that kind offer.
Motion agreed to.
That the Justice Committee recommends that the draft Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 Fixed Penalty Order 2008 be approved.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Feb 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 19 February 2008 Committee business · 1
- Declaration of Interests Procedure · 5
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 29
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.