Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Sports Grounds and Sporting Events (Designation) (Scotland) Amendment Order 2007 (SSI 2007/324)

Tuesday 4 September 2007 Justice Committee Subordinate legislation 38 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

38 contributions
Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

The cabinet secretary has been joined by Tony Rednall of the Scottish Executive criminal justice directorate, and Steve Paulding from the directorate of public health and well-being of, as I should say, the Scottish Government. I welcome those two gentlemen and invite the cabinet secretary to make a short introductory statement about the order.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I welcome the opportunity to discuss this order, which de-designates Murrayfield and Hampden—removing the ban on the serving of alcohol at each of the stadia for senior men's international rugby matches. Hampden is mentioned because senior men's rugby matches are occasionally played there, but the order will have no effect on football matches—including the one that I am going to on Saturday. The SSI affects only senior men's rugby internationals.I stress at the outset that we would never have considered any relaxation of the ban if the police were not comfortable with it. That was a prerequisite for us. Rugby has not shared football's history of trouble. With a number of world cup matches taking place at Murrayfield in the coming month, there is an opportunity to present Scotland and its capital city in a positive light to visitors. As part of that, we want to enable our visitors to enjoy a civilised drink during the match—as they would at any other world cup match at any other venue.Murrayfield is not a novice at serving alcohol at events. For example, the rugby league challenge cup finals did not fall within the designated list. As a resident of the city of Edinburgh, I remember significant crowds who came up from Yorkshire and elsewhere and had a fine day out at the stadium. They contributed a great deal to the city's economy and added a great deal of colour. All went smoothly.Alcohol has been sold at major events at Murrayfield stadium; the designation related simply to senior men's Scotland games. However, we are making it clear that the de-designation is not a licence to binge drink or to go to rugby to get drunk. The Government has been emphasising that the issue is not the drink, but how we are drinking. Our message continues to be about sensible and responsible drinking. We have sought and received assurances from the Scottish Rugby Union that it will retail alcohol only when people are drinking in that manner. I am pleased that the SRU has been working closely with health officials, and I am pleased that the SRU will commit the extra revenues that alcohol sales will generate to grass-roots rugby activities. More activities will be provided for young people, who often rightly complain that there is not enough for them to do.At present, supporters will drink in local bars and then arrive late and en masse for a match. That can cause problems for public safety. For example, at the sell-out Scotland v Ireland six nations match on 10 March 2007—which I attended—12,000 supporters arrived at the ground in the five minutes before kick-off. Entry could be phased and could be much more orderly, as would happen if the approach taken at Twickenham were mirrored. From the perspective of the crowd, that would be highly desirable. Given the crowd expected for the forthcoming New Zealand game, I hope that safety can be assured.The de-designation in the order does not guarantee that Murrayfield will be able to serve alcohol; that decision rightly lies with the City of Edinburgh Council's licensing board, which will take its decision on advice from the police. I assure committee members that I will keep a close eye on how the de-designation works in practice. If there is any misbehaviour or cause for concern, we will not hesitate to reintroduce the ban if necessary.I expect that members will be interested to know whether there will be any de-designation for football. The position that I have stated before remains the same: there will be no immediate de-designation for football. That does not mean that de-designation is ruled out entirely for the future. However, before I would consider any relaxation, it would need the backing of the police. I do not have that at present, and accordingly I am not prepared to consider any relaxation at present.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will not inquire, cabinet secretary, what time you arrived at Murrayfield on the occasion you mentioned.Members may have a few questions, but I will put the first one. In general terms, the proscription of drink at football grounds was a result of the appalling events at the 1980 cup final, at which there was a riot at Hampden and mounted police had to come on to the pitch. Understandably, the Government of the day responded by bringing in the legislation in the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 1980. Would you not accept that Scottish society has moved on a bit since then?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I think that Scottish society has moved on. We still have a significant problem with alcohol, which is why we are seeking to promote the idea that it is not the drink but how it is being drunk. To some extent, Murrayfield is an historical anachronism. It volunteered to be prescribed in the Criminal Justice (Scotland) Act 1980. The then Conservative Government had not intended to prescribe it, but it volunteered, and paid the price. Had it not volunteered, it would probably not have been prescribed. However, that was then and this is now, and we are satisfied that de-designation can proceed safely. The police have indicated no cause for concern with regard to rugby internationals. However, although there has been a change in Scottish attitudes towards drink, there is still a problem with and the police remain concerned about football. So, while we are prepared to relax the situation with regard to rugby and to see how matters proceed, we are not yet persuaded with regard to football. The most important players here are the police, who are not persuaded.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do you not think that unless you are careful, you could be accused of elitism, in that you may be applying different standards to rugby than to football?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

We do that anyway. I am not aware of any banning order—sought or existing—for rugby, but we do have banning orders for football, which were introduced by the previous Administration. We fully support the rolling out of such orders. There is a problem with a minority of supporters at football matches that does not apply in rugby or other sports. We need to be meticulous in maintaining pressure on that. As somebody who goes to football regularly and who is going to a game on Saturday, I accept that the vast majority of football supporters do not offend. However, the clear advice from the police is that they would have significant cause for concern if we were to de-designate football stadia; accordingly, that is the advice that I have to accept.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

De-designation seems sensible, given the background that has been explained by the cabinet secretary and outlined in the paper. I have two questions. The SRU says that it will establish a local residents group. Does the Scottish Government have any information about how local residents view de-designation?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

My understanding is that there was consultation by Sheriff Nicholson for the Nicholson report. The residents group is a matter for the licensing board, which will take representations from local members. Your colleague Ms Boyack has made comments, and there have been comments from local councillors. The appropriate division here is that we are simply de-designating. If the council is persuaded by residents groups that that is not appropriate for a particular game, that would be a matter for the licensing board. I will shortly be meeting licensing board conveners to discuss areas in which we have a problem. We have perhaps regressed in the area of alcohol, whereas there are areas in which we have progressed. However, local residents' issues are appropriate for the licensing boards, which are in tune at a local level in the way in which we are at national level.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

You say that ministers will keep the position under review—that is absolutely sensible. Will you explain in more detail how ministers will monitor the success or otherwise of the de-designation? If it were to prove successful, would that have any bearing on whether you roll it out—or at least begin to talk to the police about rolling it out—to football for example?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

We will monitor the situation by keeping in touch through official channels. As a resident of and a constituency representative for the city of Edinburgh, I am in regular touch with the chief constable and will be advised of the concerns of police officers at all levels. Fundamentally, whether a game should be de-designated is a matter for the chief constables, depending on whether they have significant reason to believe that it should happen. If there are problems that are more minor—clearly, we live and learn from game to game—those would be a matter for the licensing board. There is a difference between de-designation, and changing how we operate the matter—that is best dealt with by the council. On the broader matter of whether we roll out de-designation beyond rugby to football, the football clubs have to persuade the police that there is no problem and that de-designation can proceed safely. Sheriff Nicholson suggested a trial period. At present, however, the police believe that de-designating football is not appropriate, even on a trial basis. If the police are minded to support a trial period we will be open to allowing one to proceed—we have no ideological opposition to such a trial. However, I reiterate that at all levels—the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland, the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents and the Scottish Police Federation—the police have significant concerns. I cannot ignore that.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Do you agree that there should be a wide-ranging review of all issues relating to the sale of alcohol at sports grounds, taking into consideration the experience of other countries?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

We did that in the Nicholson report. Sometimes in Scotland we consult ourselves to death. Sheriff Principal Nicholson carried out a full review of matters relating to alcohol licensing, which was rolled out in the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005. There are issues that we are considering and on which we will comment in due course. The 2005 act may need to be tweaked and refined, but we think that it is a step forward for Scotland and that we can iron out whatever problems exist. Sheriff Principal Nicholson conducted his inquiry at great length and expressed the view that at some stage the sale of alcohol at sports grounds could be permitted for a trial period. We know what the situation is. Until the police are convinced that a change of policy would not create disorder or threaten crowd safety, I will not be persuaded of the need for change.Like many members of the committee, I am aware of what happens elsewhere, as I have attended games and events in other countries. The position in Scotland remains that the police have clear concerns about the impact of any change on crowd safety. We do not need a further investigation, but we need to ensure that football continues to improve and that the banning orders that are to be introduced make grounds safer and better. We do not rule anything out, but this is a matter for the police to review. Sheriff Principal Nicholson did a fair amount of work and I see no need for the Government to pursue the issue further.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

It is important to recognise that Sheriff Principal Nicholson produced his report before the 2005 act was passed. I am glad that you welcome the 2005 act, because the Local Government and Transport Committee, of which I was a member, rejected a proposal by David Davidson, a former MSP, to introduce the sale of alcohol at sports grounds. Bruce Crawford, who is now your Cabinet colleague, said at the time that the Executive should"carry out a proper review to examine the matter as a whole, to consider experience from other countries".—Official Report, Local Government and Transport Committee, 3 October 2005; c 2938. In 2005, your Cabinet colleague advised that we did not have enough evidence on the matter and that we should look at sports grounds as a whole, rather than in isolation. Why is the situation now different, given that the Parliament and the Local Government and Transport Committee rejected David Davidson's proposal?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I do not see what a review would provide. The obstacle to allowing the sale of alcohol to be trialled at football matches remains the view of the police. If that were removed, I can envisage circumstances in which we would allow alcohol to be sold for a trial period. We all know that representations have been made now and in the past by various football clubs that have shown how well run they are, what they would do, how they could do it and where money would be spent. However, there is no point in our carrying out a review until we are satisfied that the police have been assured that public safety is not threatened. It might be enjoyable for me to visit the Nou Camp and Bernabéu stadiums and to travel down under to Sydney, but that would not advance matters. I would be correctly criticised for going on a junket.We need to solve the problem that exists in football. Football clubs must work on that problem in conjunction with the police and must use the legislation that is in place. The overwhelming majority of supporters who enjoy a game and have no intention of causing trouble must continue doing what they are doing. If and when the police are satisfied that matters can proceed, they will be pushing at an open door. I do not need to be persuaded of what life could be like in Scotland if there were no problem; I need to be persuaded that there is no problem.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

Are you happy to dismiss the view of the previous Parliament, which opposed the principle of introducing the sale of alcohol at sports grounds? Your colleagues Fergus Ewing and Bruce Crawford agreed with that view and opposed David Davidson's proposal.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I am agnostic. If the police said that they had no problem with the sale of alcohol at sports grounds, if clubs made representations to that effect and if it was clear that the licensing boards agreed—various parties would be involved—I would have no objection to it. However, the police at all levels have made it clear that they object to the licensing of football grounds to sell alcohol during matches, so I am not prepared to do it.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

So it is the police, not the Parliament, who decide the policy. It is clear that the Parliament rejected the proposal to introduce alcohol sales at sports grounds. However, if alcohol sales are to be allowed just because Lothian and Borders Police says that that is a good idea, then policy is being dictated to the Parliament by the police and not by the Local Government and Transport Committee or other members who contributed to the debate.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

No. As Cabinet Secretary for Justice, I would be being negligent and would be rightly pilloried if I ignored the advice of chief constables, the Association of Scottish Police Superintendents, the Scottish Police Federation and just about every police officer whom I bump into who believes that it would be wrong to de-designate football stadiums at present. However, if and when circumstances change and the police no longer object to that, the appropriate people to make the decision will be members of the Scottish Parliament. In that event, I will doubtless be back before the Justice Committee. It is not true that the chief constable of Lothian and Borders Police dictates policy. Ultimately, if and when circumstances change, the people who make the decision will be those who are sitting where you are sitting today. It would be fundamentally wrong for me to ignore the clear advice of police officers.

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link

I want to pick up on the points that my colleagues have made. I refer in particular to the issue of residents' involvement. You are quite right to say that many of the issues involved are for the licensing board to consider. Many years ago, I, for my sins, sat on the Edinburgh licensing board, so I know the kind of things that boards will take into account. You said that there will be a review. What assurances can you give local residents that their views will be taken into account in such a review, if and when the de-designation goes ahead and is sanctioned by the licensing board?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I will be more than happy to take such views on board, both as Cabinet Secretary for Justice and a resident of Edinburgh. If there are problems, we will seek to review the decision. Residents' views should be filtered through the licensing board. I will monitor what happens, given the impact on public safety.

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link

Like Paul Martin, I was a member of the Local Government and Transport Committee. I was on the committee only briefly but, in that time, I was involved in considering the Licensing (Scotland) Bill. I recall that when David Davidson's amendment was defeated, no staunch argument was made that the police were content for de-designation to take place. If that had been the case, we would probably have given the amendment the general support that you will get from this committee today. Why has the police's view changed in the past two to three years?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

I do not think that I can be asked to speculate on the position of chief constables. However, I assure you that I have not railroaded chief constables and they have indicated that they are perfectly relaxed about the de-designation of Murrayfield stadium. It is inappropriate for me to speculate on why that is, but I can confirm that there is no opposition from the police to the proposal, which is why I am willing to proceed.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I am concerned that football is not being treated in the same way as rugby. It is estimated that the de-designation of Murrayfield for the purposes of the laws governing the sale of alcohol will bring about £1 million into the game of rugby union in Scotland. It is understandable that people who are involved in football would like that kind of income to be brought into the game of football in Scotland. I am sure that you, as a Scotland fan, would like to see that sort of investment. You rightly placed the views and advice that you were given by the police high on the agenda when you made your decision. Can you advise the committee how you consulted the police? Is there paperwork? Is there a paper flow that we can see in order to become more informed about the reasons why the police are not backing any pilot scheme within football?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

Our officials would have spoken to the appropriate ACPOS officer when the matter was dealt with. I also met the chief constable of Lothian and Borders Police—indeed, I have met every chief constable. Discussions took place between our officials and ACPOS regarding the matter, and it was clear that ACPOS was relaxed about it.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

Is there a written record of the responses that the police have given?

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

The convener reminded us why the ban was introduced. Has there been any recent history of violence that could be related to drink at football matches—particularly at international matches—that persuades you that the ban must remain?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

There is clear evidence of a resurgence in what is described as casual disorder and violence not just among youths but among middle-aged men. Banning orders are, correctly, being introduced. Not just as Cabinet Secretary for Justice, but as a resident of Edinburgh, I remember detentions in recent months relating to crowd disturbances in Lothian Road following Hibs-Hearts games. There is clear evidence of a resurgence of a hard core of violent hooligans who, sadly, use the sport to perpetrate violence for fun. They besmirch the name of the good supporters and undermine the ethos of the game of football.There is still a significant problem that we must address. It is a matter of regret, but that problem exists and it is why the ban is still in place. I cannot recall what reviews have taken place, but the police have information—it is also a matter of public knowledge—that organised crowd violence is being carried out by those who describe themselves as casuals.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

If the law were relaxed at men's international football matches, would that not provide an opportunity for the police, you and others who are involved to monitor the situation and inform any future decision that you might have to make?

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

That may be, but the position of the Union of European Football Associations is also a factor. UEFA has imposed a ban at men's international fixtures, including the match that I am going to watch on Saturday between Scotland and Lithuania. It is not simply about laws that are made in Scotland; it is about the laws that are imposed by the football authorities.There are still matters that we must address, and the concerns of the police remain. It would be unfair of me not to say that there is a difference between the situation at international games and the situation at club games. However, there remains a problem at international games, as has been seen throughout Europe, and there is a UEFA proscription.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

I want to follow up a point that Cathie Craigie made. I accept that there has probably been an increase in the involvement of so-called casuals in football hooliganism. Nevertheless, my experience in such matters indicates that that type of offender is seldom inebriated and acting under the influence of drink—a fact that makes their behaviour even more chilling and reprehensible. I therefore question whether such behaviour is an argument against extending to football grounds the facility to sell alcohol.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

You are correct that such people tend to act soberly, cold-bloodedly and out of malice and malevolence. However, the police would argue that their actions can affect others, who may be encouraged to participate in matters that they might not participate in if they were not under the influence of alcohol. We must also consider safety. There is clear factual evidence that those who are under the influence of alcohol are more likely not only to perpetrate offences but to be the victims of offences. In dealing with a significant crowd—whether or not disturbances are generated by a small, sober crew intent on violence—the difficulties for those who are seeking not simply to police but to ensure safety are made much greater when alcohol is a factor.The logic of what you say is correct but, from a policing perspective, the problem is not simply the alcohol that is consumed by those who seek to perpetrate violence but the alcohol that is consumed by others who may be caught up in the mêlée as they seek either to join in or to get out. That is where the police see the problem.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

As someone who has managed to travel through Europe and enjoy a low-alcohol beer at football matches, I look forward to the order being a success at Murrayfield and to football stadia in Scotland being included at some point in the future.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Edinburgh East and Musselburgh
link

We have made it clear that we rule nothing in or out. What matters is the position and advice of the police, and their current advice is that they do not want football stadia to be de-designated. That is how it stands.

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

Once again, we have possibly strayed from the agenda item, which is the specific SSI. If no one has any further points to make on it exclusively, I thank the cabinet secretary and his official for attending and suspend the meeting briefly while they leave.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

Bill Aitken Con The Convener · Glasgow
link

There are 10 negative instruments before us this morning. When the committee papers were issued, each was accompanied by a report from the clerks.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 4 September 2007 Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.