Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I trust that everybody had an enjoyable summer.I remind members to switch off their mobile phones, please. There is a full turnout of members; thus, no apologies have been received.I welcome the Cabinet Secretary for Justice, Kenny MacAskill, who is appearing before the committee for the second time; Tom Fox, who is head of communications at the Scottish Prison Service; and Ruth Sutherland, who is in charge of legal policy for the Scottish Prison Service.I invite the cabinet secretary to make a short introductory statement on SSI 2007/322, which is a negative instrument.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Discontinuance of Low Moss Prison (Scotland) Order 2007 (SSI 2007/322)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kenny MacAskill SNP 18
- Bill Aitken Con 4
- Paul Martin Lab 4
- Cathie Craigie Lab 4
- Nigel Don SNP 3
- Margaret Smith LD 2
- Stuart McMillan SNP 2
The record
39 contributionsThank you, convener. I thank the committee for the opportunity to explain the background to the order. I will put the issue in its historical context.The decision to close HMP Low Moss was taken about five years ago as part of the SPS estates review. It had been recognised for some time that the accommodation for prisoners and the working conditions for staff at the prison were not fit or appropriate for the 21st century. Members who have passed Low Moss will know that the accommodation consisted of wooden huts that dated from world war two. That accommodation was a fire risk, and the physical security of the prison was poor and inappropriate.On 20 February, the Scottish Prison Service announced that Low Moss would close on 28 May 2007. A closure plan was put in place, which meant a gradual reduction in the number of prisoners at the prison and the transfer of staff to their preferred sites, where possible.Having explained when and why the decision to close Low Moss was made, I should explain why a discontinuance order is required. The reason is straightforward. The Prisons (Scotland) Act 1989 made provision for Scottish ministers to discontinue any prison by way of an order. The order in question takes the form of a Scottish statutory instrument that is subject to negative resolution. That is the parliamentary procedure that the 1989 act provides for and which is described in the Executive background note that accompanies the SSI, which is doubtless before members.Committee members will be aware that, on 24 August, I announced further plans for prisons in Scotland, which included the suspension of the current procurement process for the replacement prison at Low Moss. The private sector will be invited to bid for the design and construction of a new publicly operated prison on the existing site. I am keen to ensure that the retendering of the contract for a prison at Low Moss will not result in any unnecessary delay. I also announced that a new prison will be built in the Peterhead area to replace HMP Peterhead and HMP Aberdeen. That announcement fulfilled a previous commitment to a publicly owned and operated prison service and acknowledged our need for a modern, fit-for-purpose prison estate that plays its role in contributing to public safety and reducing the problem of reoffending.Capital funding of £120 million a year for the provision of a new, fit-for-purpose prison estate has been provided, which will allow not only the construction of a new prison but significant investment in the current estate to replace our ageing prisons.Our commitment is to a publicly owned and run prison service, to more investment in replacement prisons that are fit for purpose and to a fundamental review of the role of prison in modern Scotland. We are committing not to building additional prisons but to replacing capacity that is no longer fit for purpose.The contracts for the operation of HMP Addiewell and HMP Kilmarnock will remain in place due to the complexity and prohibitive costs involved in cancelling them. However, the contracts will be rigorously monitored to ensure that they provide the taxpayer with best value for money.Modernising the prison estate will make a vital contribution to delivering our commitment to a coherent penal policy. I have already announced a review of community sentences to produce credible and tough substitutes for prison. Work on that part of our strategy is already well under way. Alongside those developments is the overarching need to take a serious and holistic look at why Scotland imprisons so many people, often for very short periods. The commission that we are setting up will be asked to challenge existing assumptions and preconceptions about the use of prison. I will announce more details about the commission shortly.I am happy to take any questions that members may have.
Thank you. Few would state other than that Low Moss was an inadequate facility. We are dealing with a historical situation with regard to that institution, which has been closed for some time. However, you have raised issues with regard to the funding of future prison projects that might be a little bit more controversial. Do you feel that the existing private prisons have provided value for money and have been effective in doing what they are there to do?
We accept that they exist and that we have contractual obligations with regard to them. Do I believe the best way to operate the prison estate is through the private sector? The short answer is no. There is good reason to believe that the Scottish Prison Service, which takes a holistic view, represents the best way to provide a prison service as opposed to simply acting as a management agency for the prison estate.We accept the requirements that have been put on us, but it would be disingenuous of me not to say that, across the world, private prisons are being rolled back. Even in the land of the free and the home of the free market—the United States—there is a rolling back of private prisons.We believe that our position best provides for a holistic prison service in which what fundamentally matters is the protection of our communities and the rehabilitation of our offenders, taking into account the requirement to look after the interests of the public purse.
What comparable costings have been made by the Scottish Government, as I must now call it, in respect of the private and public sectors?
We cannot compare like with like in the prison estate, which is why, correctly, that is not done. The cost of an open prison is different from the cost of other prisons in a modern prison estate, and the cost per prisoner in a modern prison is different from the cost per prisoner in an old, Victorian institution that is difficult to secure and operate, of which we have many.An analysis that tried to compare one with another would simply not compare like with like—we are talking about the proverbial apples and pears.
What process did the previous Executive follow in interrogating the various available procurement methods? For example, I understand that the previous Executive interrogated the possibility of a privately built, publicly operated process, but decided that that would not represent best value. If my speculation is wrong, please correct me.
The previous Executive put in place what seemed to be a head-to-head tender process involving private versus public. As far as I can see, that delayed matters for several years. It cost several million pounds for the previous Executive to conclude that it would be better to proceed down the private route.Our view is that prisons exist not for private profit but for the protection of the public. We believe that the best way to protect the public is through having a prison service and not a management agency. I am grateful that the incoming Labour leader accepted that—we are glad that she agrees with us. It is a tragedy, and a matter of regret, that several years have passed—and several million pounds have been spent—when building could have started. We might not have got a wall up, but we would have made considerable progress. We have reached agreement with the SPS, the Prison Officers Association and the leader of the Opposition in the Parliament that the way forward is to have a prison service whose ethos is about protecting our communities and rehabilitating offenders, and which is not driven by the pursuit of profit.
Do you acknowledge that the current Government's ethical opposition to privately run prisons will incur significant expense to the public purse? It is important to clarify that in the public's perception. We could have a privately run prison that would cost less than a publicly run prison.
I do not think that there is any evidence that private prisons operate more cheaply. A few years ago, the New Zealand Government wanted to clarify the issue that you raised. It built two prisons in Auckland, one of which was privately run and the other publicly run. The prisons operated for five years and at the end of the experiment it turned out that the public service was as cheap as, if not cheaper than, the service provided by the private sector.First and foremost, we believe in having a prison service whose ethos is about more than just private profit. We must protect communities as well as the people who work in prisons and seek to rehabilitate offenders. We can get good value from the SPS and we should not simply pursue the chase to the bottom—
Are you saying that expenditure will be the same—
We can be sceptical about many matters when we talk about a 25-year lease. How can we know what the position will be in 15 years' time?Let us be clear about why people operate private prisons and where the profit margin lies. Private prisons make their profits by employing custody officers instead of prison officers and undermining public sector wages—everything else must be operated according to the ground rules that apply to publicly run prisons. If you want a reduction in public sector wages and a change in the nature of the people who are contracted to work in prisons, you pursue the private route. Such an approach has problems—as you know well from the experience of your colleagues south of the border—and does not well serve our communities.A prison's paramount role is the protection of our communities. Community safety is best safeguarded by having a well-funded and well-resourced prison estate, staffed by people whose morale is high and who believe in what they do.
Will any element of the private sector be involved in the maintenance of the prison?
We expect so. We live in a complicated world and the days are gone when the SPS estate employed a maintenance fitter who would deal with broken windows and replace doors. We have sophisticated electronic technology that is not held by the SPS—and probably not by the Scottish Government. We are considering not just the building of the prison, which will quite rightly be done by private operators, but the design and maintenance of sophisticated equipment. Such matters can quite correctly be dealt with by the private sector, but the operation and management of the prison will remain in the public sector.Complicated security and information technology systems probably cannot be dealt with by the SPS without incurring huge costs and are best left to private operators. Many such aspects will probably be dealt with in the tendering process for the prison's construction. When we procure a complicated building we must ensure that appropriate safeguards are in place so that technical issues can be dealt with. Given that this meeting is taking place in the Holyrood building, I can say that the SPS will learn lessons from a variety of past experiences, to ensure that appropriate maintenance can be carried out at reasonable cost.
Who will own the building?
We will. The prison will be built by the private sector and aspects of it will probably be maintained by the people who were awarded the contracts to provide them. That is appropriate, given that those people have the technology to supply the sophisticated software, sliding doors or whatever—in this building the issue seems to be creaking, rather than sliding, doors. Anyway, the Scottish Prison Service will own the building on behalf of the people of Scotland.
I realise that it is early days, but do you imagine that the contract to be signed at the beginning will include a maintenance period of five or 10 years?
That is best decided by the experts on contracts and tendering in the SPS and the Government. Whether the maintenance period is set at five years, 10 years or the lifetime of the facility is determined, to an extent, by the balance of market forces, taking into account the nature and complexity of the sector. Lifespans are limited. It would be correct for me to leave that matter to those who are best suited to advise on it. We are anxious for prisons to be run by people who are committed to them, rather than by people who view them as an adjunct to the operation of a catering business, as is the case elsewhere.
What timescale have you set for the return of bids for the design and construction of the new prison at Low Moss?
We must follow the appropriate procurement rules—we have to start again. It is likely that many firms that have been operating and designing on a design, build, operate and maintain basis will be interested, and they will have the opportunity simply to shift over. There will be a short delay because we had to go back to the start, regrettably. There have been several years of planning delay and footering around the question whether the new prison should be an SPS prison or a private prison. We believe that there should be a new Bishopbriggs prison where Low Moss currently stands. It will be built as speedily and expeditiously as possible by the private sector and it will be operated and owned by the public sector.
You have widened the discussion to the Scottish Prison Service as a whole. You have mentioned a fundamental review of the system—and that is the right way to go. What is the current ratio of prisoners to prison officers, both in the SPS and in the privately run service?
Many of the rules on security apply to both the public and private sectors. The ratios vary depending on the category of prisoner and the nature of the estate. There are approximately 4,500 staff in the SPS. The average prison population is approximately 7,500. HMP Kilmarnock has approximately 550 inmates and around 200 staff. The difficulty is that security requirements vary among prisons. In some Victorian prisons, the sightlines do not allow as many staff to be released as modern prisons do. Some low-category prisons, including those in the open estate, understandably have a different ratio compared with the ratio that applies at maximum-security institutions such as Shotts, where there are people who can be extremely dangerous and where we must be vigilant for the sake of our communities.
I am not entirely reassured by your comparisons between the private and public sectors. My recollection is sketchy, but I remember discussions at the justice committees many years ago, when the previous Administration wrestled with issues around prisons. There was a general thought in that Administration that if the public sector could do the job as well and as cheaply as the private sector, people would feel more comfortable with that. However, it then became clear that proceeding with the private sector was likely to offer better value for money for the public purse. You have told us that we should not compare apples with pears and that it is difficult to pin things down. I would like a straight answer to this question. Putting the ethics to one side, do you believe that going down the public sector route represents better value for money than going down the private sector route?
That takes us back to the old adage about the price of everything and the value of nothing. I believe that our approach is the best one. You talked about the agonies that the previous Executive's Cabinet went through on the issue. Although I do not think that Wendy Alexander was a member of the Cabinet at that time, she clearly accepts that we have made the right decision. The issue depends on how we look at things. Some matters are constrained by Treasury rules. On the actual cost of the proposals, we should be clear that private prisons are not cheap. The prison at Addiewell will cost approximately £25 million per year for 25 years, which to me is not a significant saving.Presumptions can be made on the basis of how matters are written down under Treasury rules and how Governments may be constrained by the availability of funding—I am thinking of procurement, for example. I am fortunate that the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth has made money available to build not only a prison in Bishopbriggs—in the normal way in which such matters are dealt with in most of western Europe—but a further prison in the north-east. If you wish to follow Treasury rules, you might argue that matters are better dealt with in the private sector. However, we do not accept that. If one works on the basis that wages are the major cost impediment in running a prison, one will pursue the private route and prison officers will then become custody officers, to give a cost saving. That is the only real saving that can be made in the prison estate. In the private and public sectors, prisoners must be fed and kept secure in the same way. Therefore, the savings are made in the wage bill.Prison officers in Scotland do an excellent job in difficult circumstances. We must reward them and treat them fairly. A 25-year strategy that is predicated on seeking to reduce officers' pay would damage not only the officers but security in our prisons. If we have a race to the bottom, problems will follow as a result of staff losing the holistic view and ethos of the SPS and the commitment to the job that they do. That would result in the dangers of corruption and so on. We believe that the best approach is to pursue a public service. If others wish to privatise, so be it, but the Government and I believe that having a public service is the best way forward. We are grateful that Wendy Alexander has confirmed that she agrees with us on that.
I will come back on that issue and then move my question slightly sideways. I asked a perfectly neutral question about value for money, but I did not get an answer. I did not ask whether, in the holistic view, it was best to go public or private, although I have my view on that, which is probably not dissimilar to the cabinet secretary's view. My question was about value for money.I accept the cabinet secretary's argument that value for money is about not only pounds, shillings and pence, but wider quality issues. He will not be surprised to know that I support the review of community sentences that he is undertaking. The Howard League for Penal Reform has suggested that if we do not reduce the number of people whom we put into prison, we will need to build another seven prisons, whether in the private or public sector. What targets do you have on the number of prisons that you might be able to save for the public purse? How will the review be followed up to ensure that the people who are in prison are those who should be there and that we make better use of community sentences? What work are you undertaking to ensure that that is a value-for-money operation as well as a policy measure, given that if the value-for-money aspect is not met, that will have ramifications for the rest of the service?
I absolutely assure you that the Scottish Government will always seek to pursue value for money, not only in the prison service, but across the board. In that respect, we believe that we must have a well-resourced and well-funded service whose ethos is centred on protecting our communities and on rehabilitation.As for your question, it is very difficult to estimate prison numbers. It all depends on the organisation that you speak to. However, it is clear that the prison population in Scotland is increasing at the same time that the level of offending is decreasing. Of course, we could extrapolate from that that more people are committing serious offences or that we have been able to capture a number of people who committed offences years ago, but surely such a situation is fundamentally wrong and perverse.We also incarcerate far more people than most other countries. I hope that everyone will accept that we in Scotland are no more genetically programmed to commit offences than anyone else, so why are more people in prison here than elsewhere? We must try to address that problem without attempting to apportion any blame.Of course, if prisons need to be built, then built they will be—after all, we have committed to renewing the estate—but we should try to work out who should be in prison. People feel that there are some who should be in prison but are not, and accept that others who are in prison should perhaps be dealt with in the community.We need a coherent penal policy that gives us protection from serious and dangerous offenders while allowing those who are troubled—in many cases deeply troubled—to be treated in our communities. Our society did not decide to close down mental health institutions and liberate the patients who had been rotting there only to lock them up in prison. However, anyone who has visited a prison will know that a substantial number of people in the system suffer from mental health problems. Some of those people must be incarcerated because they have committed serious or violent offences—of course, that trumps all other considerations—but others have deep problems that cannot be addressed in prison because of the pressures on the estate. We must find a way of treating those people while allowing the SPS to concentrate on the core issue of detaining and dealing with people who are a danger to the public. That is why we need a coherent penal policy.
I want to go back to the basic numbers. Could you confirm that the replacement for Low Moss prison—when we do it publicly rather than privately—will be the same size and will, in effect, be the same prison?
Absolutely. Our understanding is that many of those who have tendered on a design, build, operate and maintain basis will probably seek to tender on a design, build and maintain basis, leaving the operation and management to the SPS. We are perfectly relaxed about that; we simply want a prison that is adequate. It is irrelevant who builds it, as long as the prison provides the best value that Ms Smith correctly highlighted and we are sure of its operation and management. Our understanding is that it will be exactly the same size as the current facility.
In that light, will you break down the numbers with regard to the proposal for the prisons at Peterhead and Aberdeen? Will the capacity of the replacement prison match the capacity of the two existing prisons?
We are looking to provide a replacement in the Peterhead area that will meet the north-east's needs. It will not necessarily be on the site of the current prison—that matter has still to be decided. The point is that we need to work out how to deal with people in the north-east who are remanded in custody, particularly young men who have to be transported to Polmont and women who have to be taken to Cornton Vale. As a result, we want a prison that meets the requirements of the north-east of Scotland, with not only a separate secure facility for sex offenders, but the facilities that are currently available at Craiginches prison for dealing with those who have been convicted and are serving sentences.We must also deal with the problems and attendant difficulties faced by Reliance and highlighted by HM prisons inspectorate of moving women and young men from the north-east of Scotland to Cornton Vale and Polmont respectively. For example, the families of those people can find it difficult to stay with them. Instead of dealing with matters in such a disparate way throughout the country, we want a prison that appropriately meets the north-east's requirements.
That suggests that the total number of cells will increase.
We are currently operating 500 cells in the Peterhead area. The number of cells needed depends upon where people are remanded, but that number will provide what is necessary for the north-east. At the moment, we shuffle people around prisons in the country because of the problems faced by the prison estate. We believe that a capacity of 500 cells will allow us to deal appropriately with the existing requirements.
link
Cabinet secretary, you will be aware of Bishopbriggs community council's submission on the planning application for the prison previously planned for Bishopbriggs. The community council had various concerns such as the inadequacy of the existing road system, traffic congestion, road safety, and a lack of community involvement. Will you guarantee that those issues will be looked at and addressed with the building of the new prison?
We understand that the plans have been signed off and we are now seeking to build the prison in the way in which it would have been built earlier, with the single change that it will be managed by the SPS, not by a private company. We can therefore assure the local authority that there will be no change to what has been signed off and agreed, albeit after some delay. I do not know what problems exist beyond that but we certainly accept the planning constraints and the agreed position and we will abide by them.
link
There appears to have been some controversy over community involvement. The people of Bishopbriggs seem to feel that they were not fully consulted and that their concerns were not taken into consideration. I would particularly like to see their concerns addressed so that the prison can be seen as a local facility rather than something that has just been put there.
The planning position has been ratified. Consultation took place. I will be happy to listen to any representations that people might care to make, but we need that prison to be built as expeditiously as possible. Delays have been caused by planning issues and what I believe is a flawed tendering process for the SPS and the private sector, but we expect the prison to be built as speedily as possible to relieve pressure upon the prison estate elsewhere, not just for those who are incarcerated but for those who are required to work in it. Speed is of the essence, but I will be happy to listen to any concerns from representatives or constituents.
It goes without saying that not every member of the committee has been entirely persuaded by the extraneous matter that you quite properly introduced and to which the committee quite properly responded.However, the SSI is on the table today and, as no member has any problems with it, we will move on to agenda item 2, after a short suspension so that the minister's team can change.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 4 Sep 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Justice Committee Tuesday 4 September 2007 Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 39
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 38
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.