link
We will now consider two further draft instruments under the affirmative procedure. Members have a note on the draft orders. I ask the minister to speak to the motions.
Official Report · Committee
Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Human Intelligence Sources – Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003 (Draft) Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Surveillance – Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003 (Draft)
link
We will now consider two further draft instruments under the affirmative procedure. Members have a note on the draft orders. I ask the minister to speak to the motions.
The two draft orders before the committee are the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Surveillance – Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003 and the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Intelligence Sources – Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003. Subject to approval by a resolution of the Parliament, the orders will bring into operation revised codes of practice on the use of covert surveillance and covert human intelligence sources by a number of public authorities in Scotland. The codes set out the various factors that are to be considered by the relevant public authorities in relation to directed surveillance, intrusive surveillance or covert human intelligence sources.Section 6 of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Act 2000 provides for the authorisation of directed surveillance by the public authorities that are listed in section 8 of the act. Those include the police, the Scottish Executive, local government, the national health service in Scotland and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency.Section 7 of the act provides for the authorisation of the use or conduct of covert human intelligence sources by those authorities. Directed surveillance can be authorised only if it is necessary on one or more of the statutory grounds that are listed in section 6(3) of the act, proportionate to what is sought to be achieved by that conduct or use of a source and if arrangements exist for the security and welfare of the source.Section 10 of the act provides for the chief constables of Scottish police forces to carry out intrusive surveillance. An authorisation for such surveillance can be issued only if that surveillance is necessary for the purpose of preventing or detecting serious crime. Serious crime is defined in the act as an offence for which a person who has attained the age of 21 and has no previous convictions could reasonably be expected to be sentenced to imprisonment for a term of three years or more. All authorisations for intrusive surveillance must be proportionate to what is sought to be achieved by carrying it out and may be granted only if the information sought could not reasonably be obtained by other means. These forms of surveillance are not new—public authorities have been able to use them for some time. The 2000 act regulated the use of powerful investigative tools where they assist in preventing or detecting crime, preventing disorder, ensuring the interests of public safety and protecting public health.As a further safeguard to ensure their proper and appropriate use, section 24 of the act requires the Scottish ministers to issue one or more codes of practice that cover the powers and duties contained in the act. Any person or body undertaking the surveillance activities covered by the act will be required to have regard to those codes of practice, which will be admissible in civil and criminal proceedings in court and published and accessible to the public.As required by section 24(3) of the act, we first published draft codes of practice for consultation between October and December 2000. At the same time, those draft codes were issued as interim codes of practice for use by relevant public authorities pending the outcome of the consultation. The draft codes were sent to more than 100 bodies and stakeholders, from which we received 14 responses. In general, respondents welcomed the codes. Where comments were submitted, they were mainly of a technical nature. All comments and representations were carefully considered in producing the final versions of the codes. A summary of the responses and changes that were made as a result is contained in annexe A to the Executive notes to the draft orders.We have taken care in the preparation of the codes. The consultation exercise raised a number of complex issues. Moreover, we needed to ensure consistency and compatibility between our codes and those issued by the Home Office under the United Kingdom Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000. That point is particularly important because of the surveillance commissioners' UK-wide function—they provide oversight for all UK surveillance legislation. I stress that the codes are not a new imposition on public authorities. They build on our interim codes of practice, which were issued in winter 2000, and provide an important framework for relevant public authorities to exercise the powers and duties under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Act 2000. In the intervening period, public authorities and others have not made us aware of any difficulties that arise from the operation of the interim codes. The revised codes are intended to be self-explanatory. As required by the legislation, all 102 consultees have been sent copies and members of the public can access both codes on the Scottish Executive website. Do you want me to run through the content of the codes, convener?
link
Yes, please.
Chapter 1 of the covert surveillance code is an introduction. It sets out the scope of the code, including its admissibility as evidence in criminal and civil proceedings. Chapter 2 explains the relationship between the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Act 2000 and the UK Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000. Chapter 3 provides general rules on the authorisation of directed and intrusive surveillance under the act. Chapter 4, coupled with annexe A, provides special rules on the authorisation of directed and intrusive surveillance under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Act 2000, particularly in cases in which confidential information is involved. That includes matters that are subject to legal privilege, confidential personal information and confidential journalistic material. The code requires that, in cases in which confidential knowledge will be acquired, the authorisation of directed or intrusive surveillance is subject to a higher level of authorisation. Annexe A lists the authorising officers for each public authority. Chapters 5 and 6 explain the statutory requirements and authorisation procedures for directed and intrusive surveillance. Chapter 7 details the authorisation procedures for entry on or interference with property or wireless telegraphy under part III of the Police Act 1997. As such, the code, and particularly chapter 7, supersedes the code of practice that was issued in 1999 pursuant to section 101(3) of the 1997 act. Chapters 8 and 9 detail the oversight and complaints arrangements provided for by the Office of Surveillance Commissioners and the Investigatory Powers Tribunal.Chapters 1 and 2 of the covert human intelligence code deal with general points as well as the code's relationship with the UK act. Along with chapters 6 and 7, which deal with oversight and complaints, the chapters cover the same areas as the equivalent chapters in the covert surveillance code. Chapter 3 provides general rules on the authorisation of a covert human intelligence source.Like the equivalent chapter for the covert surveillance code, chapter 4, coupled with annexe A, provides special rules on the authorisation of a covert human intelligence source, particularly in cases in which confidential information is involved. Chapter 5 explains the statutory requirements and authorisation procedures for covert human intelligence sources. In conclusion, the codes are an important safeguard in ensuring that the covert surveillance provisions under the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Act 2000 are used fairly and proportionately.
link
Thank you. Do members have any questions?
I note that the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland highlighted potential difficulties with restricting authorisation to superintendents and suggested that inspectors might be sufficient. The minister has rejected that, except in the case of urgency, which is fine as far as it goes. Paragraph 5.18 of the code provides that authorisations that are granted by"a person who is entitled to act only in urgent cases will, unless renewed, cease to have effect after seventy-two hours".That is fair enough. However, it appears from the wording in paragraph 5.22 that the authorising officer, who in an urgent case can be an inspector, can nonetheless continue the authorisation for the purpose for which it was given for a further 12 months. Does that mean that, under the code as worded, an inspector acting in a case of urgency may initially authorise for a period of 72 hours and on expiry of that renew the authorisation for 12 months?
On your first point, the superintendent rank was deemed the appropriate level to ensure the necessary seniority for granting authorisation, given the proportionality and necessity tests that the legislation imposes. Nevertheless, the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Prescription of Offices, Ranks and Positions) (Scotland) Order 2000 allows for authorisation by an inspector in urgent cases, which goes some way towards meeting the concerns. On your second point, which code are we talking about?
I am in the first instance talking about the covert human intelligence code.
The urgency would apply for 72 hours. In such a case, the inspector could be involved. After the 72 hours, the urgency would have passed, in which case the power to authorise would revert to the superintendent.
With respect, minister, paragraph 5.22 of the code says that the authorising officer—who could be an inspector in an urgent case—may renew the authorisation. Furthermore, paragraph 5.23 says:"Any person who would be entitled to grant a new authorisation can renew an authorisation."The code does not qualify that statement by limiting the ability to renew an authorisation to superintendents; it says "Any person". An inspector is entitled to grant an authorisation, albeit only in urgent cases. However, according to the code as drafted, the power to renew does not appear to be restricted to superintendents.I do not seek to make life difficult by opposing the order. I am perfectly content that inspectors should have that power, but clarity is necessary if the order is to be implemented appropriately. If my concerns about the drafting are well founded but you take a different view from mine, I give you the opportunity to lay an amended order that would give effect to your original intention rather than to my preference.
link
I do not think that there was a question in there.
The arrangements for authorisation are set out in the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Prescription of Offices, Ranks and Positions) (Scotland) Order 2000, which specifies that the rank required is superintendent but that, in cases of urgency, it can be an inspector. The schedule to that order states clearly that, in normal cases, the prescribed office is superintendent and, specifically, that an inspector will be involved only in urgent cases. Stewart Stevenson's point is about what happens when an authorisation is renewed and how long a renewal that an inspector makes can last. Is that correct?
That is the bottom line. I merely suggest—I do not insist—that the drafting of paragraphs 5.22 and 5.23 of the code of practice on the use of covert human intelligence sources appears to confer on inspectors the right to renew for the same periods as would be the case for superintendents because of the power that paragraph 5.18 creates for inspectors to provide the authorisation in urgent cases.
It is our belief that paragraph 5.22 of the code on the use of covert human intelligence sources allows renewals to be granted by an inspector but only in cases of urgency. Such renewals would last for a period of 72 hours.
I think that other committee members share my concern that the drafting does not give effect to what the minister has said. To avoid unduly prolonging our questioning, I simply ask the minister to note the issue and consider taking it away. I shall not oppose the order in its present form, notwithstanding the fact that I think that it is ineptly drafted. I merely seek to draw to the minister's attention the fact that the code appears to work in a way that is different from what is intended.
My contention is that the period of 12 months could be authorised only by the superintendent. The most that an inspector could renew for is a period of 72 hours in cases of urgency. Paragraph 5.23 states: "Authorisations may be renewed more than once, if necessary, provided they continue to meet the criteria for authorisation."Those criteria for authorisation would be the same as those that applied before.I am not sure that the defect that Stewart Stevenson claims to exist exists in fact. The code of practice is already in the public domain. If there is an anomaly, we will look to see how it might be dealt with. I am not necessarily sure that such an anomaly exists, but it is worth looking at.
I thank the minister. I am quite content with that.
link
The committee has an opportunity to debate the motion. I ask the committee to consider the fact that, in 2000, we scrutinised the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Bill. At the time, we were keen to see the code as soon as possible after the bill was enacted, because the code contains a lot of detailed and important information that relates to the act. It strikes me that we should perhaps have been involved at an earlier point in the process. I realise that nothing untoward has happened and that the normal course of events has been followed, but the fact is that our committee scrutinised the original bill and was particularly keen to see the code.I imagine that one reason why we missed out on the consultation was that the consultation period was around the time that the Justice and Home Affairs Committee split into two committees—perhaps that was why we could not reply to the consultation. I put it to the committee that, in future, we may want to be involved in the detail of such an important code at an earlier point, rather than just be presented with the code as part of the procedure for agreeing to the motion to recommend that the order be approved.
You make a reasonable point, convener. The code went out for wide consultation. In such cases, the committee might find it useful to be able to reflect on the consultation and on its implications. Committee members would then be able to influence the process before any final decision was taken. That point is well made.
I want to ask a further point of clarification. At paragraph 2.1, the code refers to the relationship between the code and the UK Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000. What processes or procedures would be followed if, at the point that the authorisation was granted, paragraph a did not apply? In other words, if it was believed that the covert human intelligence would operate mainly within Scotland but, as the situation developed, it emerged that it would take place mainly outwith Scotland, would that change the authorisation that was required? Would the authorisation be invalidated? If there were an honest belief at the outset that the monitoring would take place mainly in Scotland but things transpired otherwise, would the authorisation be invalidated?
You referred to paragraph 2.1. However, paragraph 2.2 states that, "Where the conduct authorised is likely to take place in Scotland, authorisation should be granted under the … Act, unless"it has been"obtained by certain public authorities".The conduct would be covered within and outwith Scotland. I am not aware of any anomalies if the authorisation for the conduct started in Scotland and then moved beyond Scotland.
Does paragraph 2.3 cover those circumstances?
Paragraph 2.3 would apply, for example, to a source that started outwith Scotland and then moved to Scotland. It would allow the authorisation to continue for up to three weeks, not indefinitely. That may partially cover your point.
Okay. Finally, I have a point on the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Surveillance - Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003.
link
We will deal with that in a moment. Do you have any further questions on the CHIS code?
No.
link
I have a question. In the consultation, the Law Society of Scotland remarked that the provisions relating to legal privilege seem to be tighter than the Home Office guidance. I do not have a clue what that means. I am just reading through the section entitled "Communications subject to Legal Privilege". Was that issue resolved? Can you comment on whether the Law Society of Scotland was right to be concerned?
Yes. We accepted some of what the Law Society of Scotland said. There is now absolute consistency in both areas.
link
It strikes me that the issue of communications that are subject to legal privilege is straightforward, but we have not had the opportunity to examine it, because it did not come up when we were scrutinising the Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Bill. Anyway, the point has already been made. Are there any further points?
No, the order seems okay.
link
Do you wish to say anything in conclusion, minister?
No thank you, convener.
Motion moved,
That the Justice 2 Committee, in consideration of the draft Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Human Intelligence Sources – Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003, recommends that the Order be approved.—Hugh Henry.
Motion agreed to.
link
Members also have a note prepared by the clerks on the draft Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Surveillance – Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003, which we will now consider.
Paragraph 3.6 of the covert surveillance code of practice is on collateral intrusion. Particularly when the surveillance is of electronic communications systems—I am thinking of electronic mail systems—what steps is it envisaged would be taken to prevent the loss of privacy of anyone who was not directly the subject of surveillance? How would their privacy be protected?
That is outwith the scope of the codes and is covered by the UK act. It is a reserved matter.
link
That is because it deals with telecommunications.
That is a fair comment.
Motion moved,
That the Justice 2 Committee, in consideration of the draft Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Covert Surveillance – Code of Practice) (Scotland) Order 2003, recommends that the Order be approved.—Hugh Henry.
Motion agreed to.
link
I thank the deputy minister and his officials for coming along this morning.Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Prescription of Offices and Positions) (Scotland) Amendment (No 2) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/50)
link
Item 5 is consideration of an instrument under the negative procedure. The committee has a note on the order. The Subordinate Legislation Committee considered the original instrument at its meetings on 21 and 28 January. It considered the replacement instrument at its meeting on 4 February. During the consideration of the original instrument, the Subordinate Legislation Committee raised concern that the effect of the order would be to lower the rank of the officer who could authorise directed surveillance or the conduct or use of covert intelligence sources, as detailed in sections 6 and 7 of the parent act. Members have a copy of the Executive's response. However, the Executive has since advised us that the supplementary response on page 8 of the note that is headed "Scottish Executive Justice Department" is inaccurate and should be ignored.
I do not want us to trawl through the details of the matter. However, documents that arrive here should be accurate.
link
There is no explanation of how the response is inaccurate. As the instrument is subject to the negative procedure, all that we can do is express our deep concern that we do not have a note that is accurate.
I seek clarification. The instrument was laid on 30 January. When would be the last date on which we could move for it not to proceed?
We are required to report to the Parliament by 3 March.
Could we invite the minister to lighten our darkness before our next meeting and put the matter on the agenda once again?
We will not have another meeting until 4 March, unless we arrange a special meeting.
The minister could write to us individually. We could act as individual members of Parliament, in any event.
link
I suggest that I write to the Executive, asking it to provide us with the information that we need. When we get a response, it can be circulated to members. We are not meeting until 4 March, so we will have to incorporate our concerns in our report and clarify the information that Parliament might require in making a decision. Are there any other comments?
No, except that we should stress that this situation is not clever and should have been sorted out.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.