Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Members of the Parole Board (Removal Tribunal) Regulations 2003 (Draft)

Tuesday 18 February 2003 Justice 2 Committee Subordinate legislation 8 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

The Members of the Parole Board (Removal Tribunal) Regulations 2003 are to be considered under the affirmative procedure. Members will have in their papers note J2/03/5/1, which has been prepared for them by the clerks. Members should note that the Subordinate Legislation Committee asked the Executive to explain the legal basis of regulation 5(3), given that there does not appear to be any flexibility in the parent act. The Subordinate Legislation Committee states that, although the parent act states that the tribunal shall consist of three members, regulation 5(3) makes provision for the tribunal to operate with fewer than three members. I ask the Deputy Minister for Justice to speak to and move motion S1M-3904.

Hugh Henry Lab The Deputy Minister for Justice · Paisley South
link

The regulations set out the procedure under which the tribunal of the Parole Board for Scotland may investigate the conduct of a member of the board with a view to his or her possible removal as a member of the board.The background to the regulations goes back to the temporary sheriffs case of Starrs and Chalmers in 1999. As the committee will be aware, the decision in that case prompted changes to the tenure of certain persons exercising judicial functions. As a result the Bail, Judicial Appointments etc (Scotland) Act 2000 created—among other things—a framework for the removal of part-time sheriffs and for the removal and restrictions of functions of justices of the peace.In recognition of the court-like functions of the Parole Board when considering certain categories of prisoners for release, notably life prisoners, it was considered that a similar framework should be created for the removal of Parole Board members. That was done in the Convention Rights (Compliance) (Scotland) Act 2001. Section 5 of the 2001 act, which amends provisions of the Prisoners and Criminal Proceedings (Scotland) Act 1993, deals with the arrangements governing the removal from office of members of the Parole Board if they are found to be unfit for office by reason of inability, neglect of duty or misbehaviour. Prior to the arrangements set out in the 2001 act, board members could in theory be removed at will by the Scottish ministers and therefore did not have the security of tenure that the courts in Starrs and Chalmers considered appropriate for judicial members. The 2001 act makes provisions for the Scottish ministers to request the Lord President of the Court of Session to convene a tribunal to conduct an investigation of a member of the board. We have no reason to suppose that the measure would require to be used other than very rarely. However, there may be occasions on which it is required. The board undertakes a vital role in our criminal justice system; it decides about the release of prisoners on licence. Membership of the board requires an individual to maintain high standards both in their professional and private lives. It is not possible to specify exactly what circumstances would result in the procedures being invoked. They are flexible and allow for a range of circumstances. The key aspect of the process is that an independent tribunal carries out any investigation into fitness for office. The tribunal will consist of a High Court judge or sheriff principal in the chair, a second person who has been legally qualified for at least 10 years and a lay person. The 1993 act, as amended by the 2001 act, states:"Regulations, made by the Scottish Ministers—(a) may make provision enabling the tribunal, at any time during an investigation, to suspend a member from office and providing as to the effect and duration of such suspension; and(b) shall make such further provision as respects the tribunal as the Scottish Ministers consider necessary or expedient, including provision for the procedure to be followed by and before it."The regulations are in exercise of those powers. I should indicate, in passing, that they mirror those already in force as respects part-time sheriffs and justices of the peace.The regulations provide that, before an investigation into the conduct of a Parole Board member commences, the Scottish ministers shall give the board member written notice of the investigation and of the reasons for requesting it. As I have mentioned, the tribunal shall consist of three members, but provision is made in the regulations for circumstances in which a member becomes incapacitated to act. As the convener indicated, the Subordinate Legislation Committee has commented on that part of the regulations, which I will return to in a minute.The tribunal will be able to determine its own procedure, subject to the provisions of the regulations. However, the person being investigated has the opportunity to make written or oral representation, either personally or through a representative, on the matters that are subject to investigation. The tribunal will sit in private and the proceedings will be confidential.The tribunal will have the power to suspend the board member from office, if it sees fit, and to end the suspension. It will also have the power to lift the suspension temporarily to allow the board member to complete a case in which he or she is involved. Once the investigation has been completed, the tribunal must send a draft of its findings to the board member, who will have the opportunity to comment. That will give the member the chance to challenge any aspect of the tribunal's findings with which he or she is dissatisfied. The report of the outcome of the investigation will be sent to the Scottish ministers. It will indicate whether the tribunal has decided to order the board member's removal from office.I am aware that the Subordinate Legislation Committee has expressed some misgivings about regulation 5(3), which will provide that where the number of tribunal members is reduced for one of the reasons that are mentioned in regulation 5(1)—provided that the president of the tribunal is not the member concerned—a new tribunal member need not be appointed unless the board member under investigation so wishes. The Subordinate Legislation Committee has questioned whether we have the power to include such a provision in the regulations, given that paragraph 3B of schedule 2 to the 1993 act requires the tribunal to consist of three members. As we said in our response to the Subordinate Legislation Committee on 6 February, we are satisfied that regulation 5(3) is intra vires, because of the provisions of paragraph 3D(b) of schedule 2, which enable the Scottish ministers to make such further provision as they consider necessary or expedient. In our view, the term "expedient" is sufficiently wide to support the approach that we have taken.The key feature of the arrangements is that an independent tribunal—not the Scottish ministers—will take the decision on whether a Parole Board member is unfit and should be removed from office. We are happy to propose an important safeguard that will protect the Parole Board from political interference and maintain its independence.I move,That the Justice 2 Committee, in consideration of the draft Members of the Parole Board (Removal Tribunal) Regulations 2003, recommends that the Regulations be approved.

Bill Aitken Con Glasgow
link

The regulations are another example of legislation that has been necessitated by an aspect of Starrs and Chalmers. They are a classic illustration of a sledgehammer being used to crack a nut. However, I accept that the minister has had no option and I have no objection to the regulations.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I want to be clear about the effect of the regulations. Does the fact that they will give powers for the removal of members of the Parole Board mean that they will have a similar effect to provisions in the Bail, Judicial Appointments etc (Scotland) Act 2000? Why did we not tackle the issue sooner? Did we think that such powers would not be necessary?

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

I am not immediately familiar with the reason why the matter was not dealt with earlier. As Bill Aitken said, we have been obliged to act. We think it right to ensure that the proper statutory provision is in place to ensure the independence of the Parole Board when it comes to removing a member of the board. The regulation closes a potential loophole, which could have left us open to accusation had we not moved in this way.

Motion agreed to.

That the Justice 2 Committee, in consideration of the draft Members of the Parole Board (Removal Tribunal) Regulations 2003, recommends that the Order be approved.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 2 Committee Tuesday 18 February 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 3
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 8
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 54
  6. Annual Report Committee business · 100

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.