Petition PE438, from George McAuley, on behalf of the UK Men's Movement, calls for procedures to enable children to establish a right of contact with siblings. The committee sought views from various organisations on the adequacy of existing legislation, and the responses are included among the committee papers. What action, if any, do members wish to take?
Once again, despite the various representations that have been made, there appears to be a lack of evidence, apart from that of an anecdotal nature. That said, we all have a degree of sympathy with the terms of the petition. The problem is how we take it further, because the course of action is not at all clear. Existing legislation, which requires the child's views, opinions and wishes to be taken firmly into consideration, is in some respects a little inadequate. Some fairly heartbreaking cases have already been brought before us; we want to do something, but I am not sure of the way forward.
That has always been my instinct. We have previously discussed the Children (Scotland) Act 1995, which is meant to deal with contact with siblings, parents, grandparents and all interested parties in a child's life. I have always wondered whether the act should be strengthened: duties might be put in place to ensure that a child has proper contact with siblings or anyone else in their family. I have no way of knowing whether the situation is monitored once the court makes a decision. If a court decision is made on who should get contact with the child, who monitors whether that has happened?Like Mr Aitken, I am not clear what we can do about the petition, but I certainly do not want to go in the direction suggested by the petitioner. That would be more problematic, as it would effectively create a legal aid system to allow sisters and brothers to take action to get contact. I would have thought that, if there is a problem, there must be a simpler way of solving it.
You have highlighted where the difficulties lie. It is quite clear that, in some regards, the current law on contact is deficient. The difficulty is finding another way of dealing with that problem. The more one legislates, the more cumbersome the legal process would become and the more impediments would be in the way. In general terms—I am not referring to this specific petition—if we were to put into statute that grandparents had an automatic right of contact with grandchildren, that would become problematic in itself, should people want to stop that contact for whatever reason. One can imagine the civil courts becoming absolutely clogged up with inter-family and inter-sibling disputes. We want to keep the courts out of those situations as far as possible. As soon as legal means start to be used to remedy complex, interpersonal difficulties, everything becomes more, rather than less, difficult. The subject matter of the petition is particularly difficult because it is hard to see a legislative way forward. We always want everyone who is involved in a child's life to act in the best interests of the child. However, we know that that does not always happen, which is the difficulty for the committee.
You have particular experience of such situations, Scott, so you will know that the onus is effectively on the other party to seek access. Parents almost have a duty to seek contact with their children, but if that does not happen, there is no way of remedying the situation. I wonder whether a stronger duty should be put on the person who is the custodian or guardian of the child to ensure that the child has access to all family members. Rather than take a roundabout way of creating other ways in which people would be forced into court, that might strengthen the 1995 act. It costs money and resources for those families to go to court.
An advantage of the 1995 act is that it does not have to be brothers, sisters, grandparents or biological parents who seek contact and residence through the courts; the act uses the phrase "any relevant person", which is a wide definition. Anyone who shows that they have an interest in the child's welfare can petition the court, and that is a strength of the 1995 act. It does not limit contact by saying that only certain persons can petition the court, but says that any relevant person can seek contact or residence. Perhaps that is the best that we can get. The legislation is relatively new, but it is certainly better than what existed previously, which was much more draconian.
One of the comments in the response from the Family Law Association struck me as interesting. The second paragraph states that procedures are"in place that enable a person (including a minor child) to make an application to Court to establish contact with a child."Presumably, that also applies to contact between siblings. The response continues:"This would include any application for contact by a sibling. Legal aid is available for minor children to instruct Solicitors if necessary and the Association feels the current arrangements are adequate."I am not sure how many people are aware that the act contains that provision. We may have a job to do to sell the fact that that right is a possibility under current arrangements, to make people aware of it and to tell them that support is available to establish it. That would be different from coming up with a new procedure, and the Family Law Association has said as much.
What about a three-year-old child who has been separated for two years from their five-year-old brother or sister? If nobody took the initiative on behalf of the younger child, who could not possibly know that they were being deprived of contact with a brother or sister, how would the system work?
Presumably, Scott Barrie's point is that the parent or guardian would not be solely responsible. A grandparent could be the "relevant person", and could assume responsibility by telling the courts what is in the best interests of the child.
You are referring to the grandparent effectively suing for access to the three or five-year-old. However, they would not have the right under the act to bring the child and a relevant person together. That is what the petition is about.Presumably, the petitioner feels that there is some detriment to children if there is a gap in their life in that they have no contact with their brothers and sisters. The provision in question allows a grandparent or relevant person to gain access, but it does not necessarily bring the family together. If a child were old enough to know that they would like to see their brother or sister, they could take the relevant steps and someone would act on their behalf. However, I find it difficult to work out how that would work if the child were very young. The Family Law Association has told us about its experiences in court, but we have no information about the real experiences of parents or others who have been affected by the system.
I find Scott Barrie's comments very interesting. Obviously, he has the advantage of dealing with such issues in his previous career. One point that resonates is the fact that the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 is quite new, and it is possible that we have not yet had the opportunity to find out how the provision is working its way through the system.Frankly, I think that the petition has some merit. The question is how we make progress on the matter. Doing nothing is always the easy option, but this might just be one of those cases where we should do nothing. That said, we should perhaps flag up that the matter might need to be revisited in future once the operation of the appropriate legislation can be judged against experience.
There is also the matter of the Law Society of Scotland's response. I take the point that we may need to hear from that organisation and get a definitive statement on the position that Bill Aitken outlined, which we could encapsulate. We should include the proviso that if the family law division of the Law Society of Scotland were to tell us that a major problem existed, the matter could become an early priority for a successor committee.
Just for clarification, I should point out that the Family Law Association's response refers to petition PE413, which concerns parental alienation syndrome. However, we are dealing with petition PE438, which concerns wilful alienation by the parent who has custody of siblings. The focus of that petition is not the separation of siblings.
I am not giving any credibility to the term "parental alienation syndrome" and agree with Fiona Miller from the Scottish Child Law Centre on that matter. However, that is not to say that the principal point of petition PE438 has no merit. How do members wish to proceed?
We should take no action, but indicate to the petitioner that we consider that the issues raised in his petition have some merit and that we would prefer to wait and see how the legislation works through. If the petitioner still feels that a problem exists, he should be encouraged to re-petition the Parliament when the matter might be examined further.
Perhaps we might choose to put on record our recommendation that, in approximately a year, the successor committee should examine whether the implementation of section 11 of the 1995 act has started to deliver any benefits. It would be entirely up to the committee at that time to accept, reject, modify or do whatever it liked with that recommendation.
We will take Bill Aitken's proposal for future action along with Stewart Stevenson's suggestion that the matter would be a good subject for a future work plan. I think that we should phrase it in that way, because it would be difficult to ask a successor committee to undertake such work. Is that agreed?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.