Petition PE438, from George McAuley, on behalf of the UK Men's Movement, calls for procedures to enable children to establish a right of contact with siblings. Again, there is correspondence for members to study, including correspondence from the Public Petitions Committee.Members will note from the Executive's correspondence in particular that the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 makes provision for siblings or any other person with an interest to gain access to a child through the courts. The question that members must consider is whether that provision is easy enough to operate in order to achieve the desired result of sisters and brothers being able to make contact with each other if they live in different families.
I do not doubt the difficulties that siblings and half-siblings have in trying to maintain contact if they live in different households and if legal orders, such as residence orders, are in force. However, I understood that the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 sought to make such situations easier to resolve. Any person can make an application under section 11 of the act, not just a parent. A sibling can apply. In Scotland, siblings have instructed legal proceedings. I am not suggesting that that is the route that we ought to go down, as such matters are better resolved without seeking access through the courts. However, in complex and difficult situations, a young person does not have to be 12 to be able to instruct a solicitor. They can be younger than that. I know of an eight-year-old who instructed a solicitor independently of their parent.Section 11 allows legal redress. I think that that is sufficient. What we always want in such situations is that people do not have to go to court. The presumption must be that siblings should have contact. That would be the best way of proceeding. I am not clear about what we could do in legal terms to make the situation any easier than it is, given that the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 is a recent piece of legislation and a vast improvement on what existed before.
It is difficult to see what can be done. There will be unanimous sympathy for the aim of the petition to make contacts easier, but I am not sure that we can do anything. The legislation is comparatively recent and seems to be working. I do not think that we can advance the matter much further. However, if something were to come to light, we would want to respond.
I am reluctant to leave our consideration of the petition at this point because I am unclear about the practical effect of the provisions in the 1995 act. I have not had the opportunity to talk to people who have had experience of how the act operates. Like many MSPs, committee members will have received correspondence from Grandparents Apart, which makes similar points about the difficulties of using the provisions of the act. The legal advice that I have had is that the same provisions apply in both cases—for grandparents and siblings. I do not know whether the presumption for access is strong enough. It applies for parents in terms of custody and access, but I am not clear about whether it applies in relation to siblings and other family members.Does the committee think that it might be useful to seek a view from practitioners about how the 1995 act operates in practice? It might not be possible to get such information but, before we leave the matter, we should be sure that the provisions of the act are adequate to cover the subject of the petition.
The Children (Scotland) Act 1995 states that anyone who can demonstrate that they are a significant person can make an application under section 11. That clearly applies to siblings, grandparents and other significant adults in a young person's life.An organisation such as the Scottish Child Law Centre might be a useful port of call in order to seek further information. Given that we are talking about children seeking contact with grandparents, siblings or significant others, we should find out what experiences such organisations have had in using the legislation. They may be able to indicate whether there is a difficulty or some way in which we could go forward.
That is a helpful suggestion. We could then find out whether the provisions are adequate and take the matter from there. Does the committee agree that we should take that course of action?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.