Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Judiciary (Freemasons) (PE306)

Wednesday 30 October 2002 Justice 2 Committee Petitions 9 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

We have three interesting petitions before us this morning. The first is petition PE306, from Thomas Minogue, which members have already seen. When we previously considered the petition, which is about freemasonry and the judiciary, we agreed to consider it again. We have received further information from Mr Minogue about the judiciary and membership of the Speculative Society. Members will note that we have written to the Minister for Justice, whose response is that he sees no need for a change in the current requirements. I invite members to make comments and suggestions on how to deal with the petition.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

I know that we have already written to the minister and received a response from him. However, the committee was not totally satisfied with the response. Without entering into constant correspondence back and forward, I would favour the committee writing to the minister again urging the consideration of declarations of interest by the judiciary, perhaps as part of the new judicial appointments procedure. That would be one way of getting round the problem, as the procedure would be open and might satisfy some of the issues that have been raised, both in the past and today.

George Lyon LD Argyll and Bute
link

I support Scott Barrie's proposal. The petition deals with the serious issue of declarations of interest. Members of Parliament are now required to declare their interests, so I think that we should pursue the matter with the minister and say quite clearly that the practices that have been adopted by the Scottish Parliament should be spread to the judiciary as well.

Bill Aitken Con Glasgow
link

On the basis that I would not join any club that would have me as a member, I declare that I am certainly not masonic. It was Groucho Marx, not Karl Marx, who said that. The situation is somewhat exaggerated. Anyone who takes judicial office has to take the judicial oath, which inter alia requires that individual to do right to all manner of people without fear, favour or prejudice. I would have thought that the judicial oath was a sufficient safeguard. As I say, I have no particularly strong views on the matter, but I wonder where such declarations would cease. Many people are clubbable and join organisations and societies. At what point would one have to cease declaring membership of clubs? For example, I am a member of the Partick Thistle supporters club. How far do we take declarations? That is the sort of difficulty that would arise.We certainly wish to be as open as possible. We all applaud the way in which the judicial appointments system has become much more transparent, open and subject to scrutiny. However, I have some doubts about whether it is worth pursuing the matters raised in Mr Minogue's petition to what might sometimes seem to be infinite proportions.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

It is useful to bear in mind what MSPs are enjoined to do: to declare an interest when it touches on the matter under consideration or might be thought to do so. That latter point is the most important. It is up to all of us who hold public office, of whatever kind, to be absolutely scrupulous and open. Judges should generally follow the same dictum. However, I am reminded of the phrase, "Quis custodiet ipsos custodes," or, "Who will guard the guards?" If I misquote the Latin, I apologise. In other words, there is a point at which we must trust people whom we have put into office to act according to their own code. We should not pursue the matter ruthlessly, but we should certainly take the steps that Scott Barrie proposed, as they would add to transparency and confidence in the system.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I agree with Scott Barrie, George Lyon and Stewart Stevenson. It is not suggested that the judges' oath is not enough, but there is a public perception about members of societies that have a secretive reputation, whether that society is the freemasons or another organisation. If we ask the minister to reconsider the matter, we should be clear that we are talking about any group or society in which there could be deemed to be a perception of secrecy where there could be a declaration. If the committee agrees that we should to write to Jim Wallace, we should refer to all organisations that may fall into that category. Does any member dissent from that?

Bill Aitken Con Glasgow
link

There might be a difficulty in defining excessive secrecy, but I will not fall out with any member over the matter.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

We have not been given a satisfactory explanation of why we are not taking the route that I think England has already taken. There has not been a strong enough answer as to why, in the interests of transparency in the judiciary—which Stewart Stevenson mentioned—there should not at least be a declaration from judges. It remains to be seen whether Bill Aitken is correct in saying that the new system is transparent enough. We have not had an opportunity to consider that matter in detail, but the committee may wish to take it up in the future.How should we proceed with the petition? Is the majority view that we should write to Jim Wallace to say that we are not satisfied that the matter should be closed and that we believe that there should be a review of the declarations that the judiciary makes in relation to the freemasons and any other organisation that may fall into the category under discussion? Bill Aitken's comments about difficulties of definition may be mentioned. We could say that we do not wish simply to end the matter there and that we wish further scrutiny of what is required. Do members agree with that course of action?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 2 Committee Wednesday 30 October 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Petitions Petitions · 9
  4. Petitions Petitions · 7
  5. Petitions Petitions · 10
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  7. Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service Inquiry Committee business · 3
  8. Land Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 2 Bill debate · 282

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.