I had hoped that Bill Butler would be present for our consideration of petition PE477, which is about the Miscarriages of Justice Organisation. I will kick off proceedings by reporting to the committee on some of the work that I have done. Bill Butler might appear at some point.Today is not the first time that petition PE477 has appeared on the agenda. A background note has been prepared for members. The petition asks the committee to consider the services that should be available to people who are acquitted on appeal and to assess whether a retreat facility could be provided to meet their needs. Bill Butler and I had a separate interest in the subject before the petition was submitted, which is why we sought a meeting with the minister to discuss the issues that arise from the petition. It just so happened that the meeting that we managed to secure was at 2 o'clock today. I left the meeting early, leaving Bill Butler up there—the meeting will finish shortly. We were interested in discussing miscarriages of justice directly with the minister. Another big issue is the funding of MOJO; it receives no funding whatever and raises money for everything it does by benefits and so on.I do not see any problem with the committee doing whatever it wants to do with this petition concurrently with the work that Bill Butler and I are doing; I think that that would be beneficial. I now want to open up the meeting to allow members to consider their approach to the petition. If I can answer any questions, I will do so.
I come to the issue relatively cold and I do not have any constituency interests that help to inform me. The clerks offer us two ways of proceeding and I am minded to keep this petition—like the previous one—on our books for our own information and to allow us to monitor the issue. I think that that is important, whatever further discussions we might have. Other than expressing that general view, I do not have anything useful to add. I would have to hear from Bill Butler on the outcome of his discussion with the minister before I could be persuaded that the petition had run its course. I expect that Bill will tell us that it has not run its course, although we can only hope that it has.
There was unanimous support for the petition in committee. People felt strongly that it was bad that people had been put in prison for things that they had not done, and that when they come out of prison the system is unfair to them yet again because no services exist specifically for them. They are still treated as if they were offenders even though it had been found that they were the victims of miscarriages of justice.I welcome the minister's letter. There are developments—not only because of the meeting that you have told us about, convener, but because of the work that the minister is doing with Citizens Advice Scotland on a potential new service for victims of miscarriages of justice. We should continue with the petition, but we should attach a timeframe so that the petition can come back on to our agenda in perhaps a month's time; we should not consider it only quarterly. We can guess that there will be developments in the short term rather than the medium term, so I would like the petition to be back on our agenda sooner rather than later. We can hear from our colleague Bill Butler about the meeting with the minister, but we can also ensure that further information comes from the minister on the proposals that she heard from Citizens Advice Scotland last month.
I agree with that. Like Stewart Stevenson, I come to this issue relatively cold. I reviewed the notes that we were given and saw a clear need for an organisation to deal with people who are released from prison having been found to be not guilty of an offence for which they were improperly convicted. That organisation should be separate from the present set-up, which deals primarily with people who are released from prison after serving sentences for crimes of which they were guilty.There should be a timeframe so that we can see how things are proceeding and consider how we intend to proceed. If Bill Butler gains any further evidence as a result of today's meeting or any future meetings, we should obviously hear that information as soon as possible.
It will be extremely helpful if the committee agrees to keep this matter open.Margaret Smith will be aware of the committee's belief that we have forced a subtle change in Executive policy on the matter. It now seems to be recognised that a group of individuals who have been wrongly incarcerated need a different service from those who served a sentence on a guilty conviction. What we are hearing from MOJO—as it is called for short—is that some fundamentally different services are needed by such individuals.We have heard from Paddy Hill, who is well known for his work on miscarriages of justice. He says that, although services exist, it is easier to get access to them if one is a convicted offender—there are probation officers and social work services and so on. However, such services are not open to people who have been acquitted because they are meant to be treated as innocent. A person's mental state can in many cases be affected by having served maybe 15 to 20 years in prison, yet such people come out of prison with virtually no support. Families in particular do not really realise what is ahead of them; they need support too. There is a range of services that should be more specialist. MOJO argues that those services should be in a permanent base, in the form of a retreat. I imagine that Bill Butler will report to us that the Executive is sympathetic to that; however, the cost of providing a retreat is estimated at about £0.25 million. I am sympathetic to that too, but the organisation needs to be funded first because it is surviving on what it can raise through benefits.As individual MSPs, we should do what we can to support the organisation to find its way through the funding streams—we all know how difficult that can be. It is important for the committee to keep up the pressure and to keep the issue live. If we had 45 minutes to spare—I will not look at the clerks when I say that because we probably do not—we could hear from MOJO directly; alternatively, we could arrange a private briefing. I agree that it would be worth while to take the petition further.
I suggest that we put the petition back on the agenda and revisit it in a month. If, in a month, we are content with what the Executive is doing, we can leave it at that. However, if we are still in the position that we are in at the moment we should ask MOJO and the minister to come and talk to us. That would give us a month in which the minister can act in the positive fashion that she has indicated. If we do not need to have that meeting, that will be all well and good, and it will free up the time. We need to focus the minister's mind on the fact that we want action sooner rather than later.
I agree with everything Margaret Smith said, except that we should pin the matter down to a month. I get the impression that the minister wants to respond, so we should not put an unduly prescriptive timetable on what we do. If we do not see substantive progress this year we should raise the subject. I would be prepared to wait for a view to be expressed to the committee—perhaps by Bill Butler and by you, convener—at an appropriate meeting. Indeed, I would be perfectly happy to leave the timetabling with you because you have a personal interest in the matter and will take account of what Bill Butler says. I take Margaret Smith's point, but I do not want to have a meeting in a month when we may not have made progress that would justify spending time on the matter then.
Margaret Smith is nodding in agreement—I think that we have a consensus. We will probably have to write formally to the minister to say that we intend to pursue the matters in the petition; that way, the committee will express its interest and we will get a formal response from the minister. We will say that we want to be kept in touch with progress. We can combine Margaret Smith's suggestion with what Stewart Stevenson has said and consider a time by which we would hope to hear that progress has been made. If we are not satisfied with that, we can pick up the petition in a slot in our work programme. The committee can then decide who it wishes to hear from and whether it we should have a public meeting to do that. If we do not have the time, we can decide whether to hear directly from MOJO about its progress. If there are no further comments on the petition, that is what we will agree to do. We agreed to deal with item 5, on the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Bill, in private.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.