Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Legal Profession (Regulation) (PE763)

Tuesday 5 October 2004 Justice 1 Committee Petitions 9 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I refer members to the note that has been prepared by the clerks, which sets out the background to PE763. The petition calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to implement urgently the findings of the Parliament's Justice 1 Committee inquiry into the regulation of the legal profession. I should emphasise that when I say "the Justice 1 Committee" I mean the previous session's committee. The current committee adopted the inquiry to ensure that the recommendations are pursued.I invite the committee to consider the contents of the paper and what action to take in respect of the petition.

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link

I am the new one here, so clearly I have to catch up on several issues. However, I have some difficulty with the action that is proposed in the paper. The proposal is to kick the matter into the long grass, if not to let it disappear into the ether. Clearly the issue has been considered before and the former Justice 1 Committee made a particular decision.Concerns have been raised again in relation to there being a single gateway for people who have a complaint to make about their lawyer or about associated services. I am particularly unhappy about, for example, the police investigating complaints against the police and the Law Society of Scotland investigating complaints against lawyers. I have a personal difficulty with that because there can be conflicts of interest.I am not entirely sure what the way ahead is; however, rather than take the matter off the agenda, we should consider it further. I do not know whether another report on the subject to show where we are at would be appropriate. Although there was a move in June to address some of the issues, it is pretty clear that some fairly substantial issues are outstanding. I would not be happy for us to dismiss the matter at this point.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banff and Buchan
link

In the discussion that the Public Petitions Committee had on Wednesday 15 September 2004, Jackie Baillie made some useful comments about the response to the petition being a two-stage process and about the need for primary legislation. She recommended that the petition be passed to the Justice 1 Committee"to monitor progress and ensure that its recommendations are implemented".—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 15 September 2004; c 990.That is a proper role for the committee to fulfil. To do that and to respond to what Jackie Baillie said in the Public Petitions Committee, we should not take the recommended action of closing the petition but should keep it open for a period to see what progress can be made.At this stage, I do not have any specific period in mind before we would start to jildi up people to take the actions required. I would be uncomfortable—as Jackie Baillie would be—in closing the petition at this time, when issues that it raises still require to be addressed. It is expected that those issues should be and will be addressed; I would like to keep the petition on the books until they are.

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link

I understood that we had agreed previously to keep the petition on the books and to continue to monitor progress generally anyway. I understood that we were writing to the Executive, the Law Society and others about the matter because we were monitoring progress on it. I do not think that the proposed action—it sounds as if it is to do nothing about the petition—reflects what the previous committee agreed to do. Perhaps you can clarify that for me, convener.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I shall do so now. The committee has agreed to pursue the recommendations in the former Justice 1 Committee's report as part of its work programme. The committee will come back to that.The second issue is the current committee's work in examining the transparency of legal fees, which is not addressed specifically in the former Justice 1 Committee's report. That issue arose in correspondence that we received from Margo MacDonald about a constituent, and I thought that it was a matter that the committee would want to pursue. We agreed that, when we have time, we will ask the Scottish legal services ombudsman to appear before the committee so that we can pursue that issue with a view to deciding whether the ombudsman requires more powers to deal with the issue. Margaret Smith is right to suggest that the committee's work on that is on-going.As far as I know, the Consumers Association, which lodged the petition, did not make a submission to the previous committee's inquiry. The petition has appeared quite late in the day; nevertheless, I agree with Stewart Stevenson's proposal. There would be no difficulty in our keeping the petition open as long as it is understood that we are already undertaking work on the matter and that it would have been helpful if some of the issues that we have been asked to consider had been raised with the former Justice 1 Committee. I hope that that provides the clarification that Margaret Smith sought.

Bruce McFee SNP West of Scotland
link

I want to be clear about the situation. I read the Official Report of the Public Petitions Committee's consideration of the petition, in which reference is made to the fact that the Consumers Association did not give evidence or make any representations to the inquiry that our predecessor committee carried out. However, I seek assurance that the points that the petition raises will be addressed in the course of action and monitoring that this committee has said that it will undertake. There may be a difference between what the petition seeks to do and what our predecessor committee agreed to do—some issues might fall between two stools. My concern is that, if we simply note the petition and say that we are monitoring the situation, we might never get the chance to explore some of those issues.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That is a matter for the committee. I was simply pointing out for the record that, as far as we are aware, the views of the Consumers Association were not submitted to the previous Justice 1 Committee for its consideration in the first place. To be fair to that committee's report, we must acknowledge that.Bruce McFee is right that the petition raises matters that the report did not address, one of which is the proposal that the ombudsman be granted powers to investigate decisions, but we are pursuing that matter. My proposal is that we should not close our consideration of the petition, because there might be some residual issues that are not covered by the report or by our work. As part of the work programme, we could compile a briefing about the report's recommendations, what we said we would do and which issues in the petition have not been covered. That will allow members to identify the issues that they want to pursue further. We will leave open our consideration of the petition so that we can pick up any outstanding issues.

Margaret Smith LD Edinburgh West
link

I would be happy with that. It would also be useful to have a general update on where we are with the components of our predecessor committee's original recommendations.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I think that I am right in saying that we are still waiting for a detailed response from the Executive to the previous Justice 1 Committee's report. Interruption.We now have that response, which the committee will get to see when we have more time to devote to it. For today's purposes, we need to materialise our quarterly review of petitions in our work programme. Does the committee agree to do that?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Tuesday 5 October 2004 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 2
  3. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  4. Petitions Petitions · 1
  5. Petitions Petitions · 9
  6. Petitions Petitions · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.