Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Community Right to Buy (Definition of Excluded Land) (Scotland) Order 2004 (Draft)

Wednesday 21 April 2004 Justice 1 Committee Subordinate legislation 41 contributions · 3 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

41 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Item 2 is consideration of a second piece of subordinate legislation. I welcome Allan Wilson, the Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development. I know that it is a while since he has been at a meeting of a justice committee and I welcome him back. We will deal with the draft Community Right to Buy (Definition of Excluded Land) (Scotland) Order 2004. Members have a note that the clerk has prepared, as well as some very helpful maps. Although there are not enough maps for everyone, everyone should be able to see one. I hope that they will help to illustrate the order that we are about to discuss.I invite the minister to speak to and move motion S2M-1169.

Allan Wilson Lab The Deputy Minister for Environment and Rural Development · Cunninghame North
link

Thank you, convener. It is indeed good to be back to discuss land reform. We are pressing on with our land reform agenda. I am glad that you find the maps helpful. They will give members a better visual image of what we propose.I welcome the opportunity to contribute to the committee's consideration of the Community Right to Buy (Definition of Excluded Land) (Scotland) Order 2004. I am accompanied by Richard Frew, who has responsibility for the community right to buy in part 2 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003, and the solicitor Ron Grant.I will begin by explaining why the draft order, which is referred to in section 33(2) of the act, was initially laid before Parliament on 9 March, withdrawn and then re-presented on 15 March. That followed discussions between our officials and the Subordinate Legislation Committee's legal adviser. It was agreed that the table, which designates the locations at which copies of the maps showing the excluded land will be held for public access, should be moved from the body of the order to the explanatory note, as the act does not prescribe that such information should be contained in the order itself. One could say that that is a technicality. Members will see that the location details are now contained in the explanatory note that accompanies the order. That has no effect whatever on the order. It was done in the interest of being helpful.From the Executive's consultation material on the draft order under part 2 of the act, the committee will be aware that the purpose of the order is to define land that is excluded from being registered and, therefore, from being brought under the community right to buy. That will be done by excluding all settlements whose population is above a given threshold. The Executive's 12-week consultation on the draft order ran from 19 August to 14 November last year. In the interest of openness, we highlighted our invitation for views on the proposal to increase the population threshold for defining excluded land from 3,000 to 10,000. Our reasons for making the proposal were fully explained in the consultation material and a summary of all responses received was issued on 23 December 2003. From the order, it will be clear to the committee that we decided to increase the population threshold to 10,000. I believe that many rural communities with populations up to 10,000 display the characteristics of smaller rural settlements, including: reliance on the land to deliver community-wide social, economic and environmental benefits; having certain specific areas of land or buildings that are important to community development; and wanting to attempt to address the consequences of land ownership resting in relatively few hands. Increasing the population threshold will reduce the amount of land that is excluded from the legislation. It will enable a further 117 settlements to benefit from the right to buy, ensuring that additional communities are given the opportunity to determine their future when land in which they have registered an interest comes to be sold. I understand the concerns that were expressed during the consultation about a population threshold of 10,000 being too high. However, some people thought that the right to buy should apply to the whole of Scotland. We have struck a balance and have applied the legislation fairly to settlements containing what appears to be undeveloped rural land, which might be exactly the kind of land that communities require. Excluding those settlements would result in communities being unable to benefit from the purchasing of land that appears to be rural in and around their settlement. The maps that I have provided the committee with give a clear definition of the land to which I refer. The Thurso example is probably the most explicit in demonstrating clearly the rural context within which the land is placed. Within the settlement area, a substantial expanse of land can be seen that can be considered only to be rural. Other maps show more built-up areas, such as those in West Lothian. Again, it can clearly be seen that Armadale contains areas of land that could be considered to be rural and that other settlements are surrounded by land that would properly be described as being rural and having community connections. For the reasons that I have given, I invite the committee to accept that the appropriate population threshold for defining excluded land for the purpose of the community right to buy should be 10,000.As I mentioned initially, the order provides for designation maps to be made available in the offices of the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department at Pentland House, in the Executive's library in Saughton House and at our local agriculture area offices that have excluded land in their area. The purpose of that is to give rural communities the same opportunity that members have had today to look at the maps and to enable them to do so in their area without having to travel to Edinburgh. The order refers to the General Register Office of Scotland's report, "Scottish Settlements—Urban and Rural Areas in Scotland", the contents of which I have spent many happy hours poring over. It details the methodology used to determine facts about settlements. It is intended that updated maps will be provided regularly to reflect the changes to settlement boundaries and to population statistics.We welcome the Subordinate Legislation Committee's approval of the order on 16 March, and I hope that this committee will do likewise. We hope that the community right to buy will be in force by the end of May. It will provide an historic opportunity for Scotland's communities to take direct ownership and control of land that is of economic, environmental and social benefit to them. The order is a crucial part of our preparations for that; therefore, I invite the committee to approve it.I move, That the Justice 1 Committee recommends that the draft Community Right to Buy (Definition of Excluded Land) (Scotland) Order 2004 be approved.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I thank the minister for the very visual way in which he expressed the order's intention, which was helpful in addition to the maps that have been provided. I invite committee members to comment on what is before them.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

It will come as no surprise to the minister that I do not welcome the advent of the new legislation—in fact, I am totally opposed to it. It is not really a community right to buy; it is a community right to pre-emption. It is funded by the taxpayer and lottery money, so we are all paying for it, and it forces landowners to sell at an artificially low price rather than at genuine market value. Were the right to be extended to property rights generally, we would be going back to the dark ages and a Stalinist regime. I do not welcome the new legislation: I am totally opposed to it.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

I suspect that that says more about the contemporary Tory party than it does about the proposals that I have put before you. It surprises me that you continue to maintain what I believe to be unreasonable opposition to a very reasonable measure that will afford communities the length and breadth of the land the opportunity to take direct control of the land in their communities, which will benefit them socially, environmentally and—potentially—economically. It is a tremendous opportunity for communities throughout Scotland. It is sad that the Tory party cannot welcome the opportunity that I am offering the Scottish people.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I have allowed Margaret Mitchell a bit of latitude—

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Let me finish. The order is specifically about excluded land. I ask members to relate any further comments to the order.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

In the past, communities have had the opportunity to do what is proposed without the community right to buy. On what basis does the minister justify the order being passed?

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

The order extends the right to buy to smaller communities that display rural characteristics and which have a population of between 3,000 and 10,000 people, enabling them to take advantage of the community right to buy that we introduced with the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003. The order extends the right to buy to 117 additional communities with a combined population of 675,000. It gives greater opportunity for many more communities to benefit from the provisions of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003. Parliament decided that there should properly be a transaction between a willing seller and a willing buyer: there is no question of compulsion. If more communities demonstrate a desire to own land that is of social, economic or environmental value to them, that is a good thing. That should be welcomed and I encourage them to do so.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

On a point of information, if the communities sell the land on, will it be sold for genuine market prices? In other words, will it be open to auction, not a matter of first emption—take it or leave it—as it is under your proposals?

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

As the convener knows, we had a long discussion in committee and subsequently in Parliament on the need to ensure that no depreciation in overall land value is brought about by the introduction of a community right to buy. I argued then—and I believe now—that the community right to buy will stimulate the market in land and will act as a boon to land values in our communities. I fully expect communities to demonstrate an increasing interest in securing greater ownership of land that is of economic, social or environmental benefit to them, which will stimulate land values in areas that were hitherto derelict or devoid of any interest or speculation over their acquisition.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Can you confirm that individuals will be able to sell on and make a massive profit?

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

As I thought I said when I answered the question, we introduced provisions in the 2003 act to have the land independently valued by a market valuer, so that the amount reflects the market value of the land at the point of acquisition or disposal.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

To whom? I thought that he was a painter.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

The order is before us because it is the remit of the justice committees to examine ownership. Obviously, as the minister has illustrated, there are issues that are vital to the regeneration of rural communities, and those are a matter for the relevant committee. In addressing the question of land ownership, I whole-heartedly welcome the continuation of scrutiny of the 2003 act, which will, I hope, change the profile of who owns land in Scotland. The order is before us because it is about property ownership. I hope that more communities will own land in the future because of the 2003 act. Will the minister share with the committee what led the Executive to initiate in the first place the consultation on making the dramatic change from the figure of 3,000 to 10,000? I know that there was a thorough consultation.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

I must take considerable responsibility for that because it was during our stage 3 deliberations on the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill that I began to think about how we might ensure that more communities could benefit from the opportunity that we were affording to the smaller communities that are rural settlements of 3,000 people or less. Subsequent examination of the maps and of the register to which I referred demonstrated clearly that many other communities display the same rural land characteristics as the smaller communities. Consequently, I believe that they ought to be included in the 2003 act's provisions, to allow them the opportunity to buy land for community purposes, whether those are economic, social or environmental.Margaret Mitchell is wrong, because taxpayers' money is not involved in the community purchase of land. The communities themselves must raise the necessary funds to purchase land that is of value or interest to them. When I examined the pattern of applications to the Scottish land fund, I saw that the majority of applications do not involve the crofting estate buyout that the Tory party so hates. Most of the applications are from communities that come together to buy land for community ownership to provide, for example, a playpark or other recreational facility for the community that might not otherwise be provided. That is a right and an opportunity that deserves to be afforded to more of our fellow citizens.We looked at the maps and the core definition of rural land and concluded that, although there must be a cut-off point, and exclusion or inclusion based on the core definition, extending the cut-off point from 3,000 to 10,000 would bring in a further 117 communities and increase the number of our fellow citizens who would be given the opportunity of community land ownership to more than 3 million. I believe that that is a good thing.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

What you are saying makes perfect sense to me. I support the order. I just wanted an insight into what sparked off your thinking about changing the cut-off point from 3,000 to 10,000. I wondered whether any representations were made to you that sparked off your thinking.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

Members will probably recall that there was a debate on the matter at stage 3 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Bill, when I indicated an interest in extending the definition of excluded land. I wanted to consult widely on how we would define that. As I have said, during the consultation, a sizeable number of people said that they wanted to extend the opportunity to the whole of Scotland. As members know, that is not possible under the current Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 because of the way in which the act refers to rural land. However, by defining rural land in a better way in this order, we can extend the provisions to many more of our fellow citizens. It was the stage 3 debate before the passing of the 2003 act that set us off on this road.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

It appears that no other members wish to speak so I will allow the last word to Margaret Mitchell—as long as she does not mention Jack Vettriano.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

I would like the minister to clarify something: initially, is it not taxpayers' money and lottery money that will fund this?

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

No. It is for communities themselves to raise funds to secure the opportunity to buy land that is of interest to them. Obviously, those communities can apply for lottery funding and I hope that they will. That would obviously assist them in bringing more land into community ownership.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Is it merely lottery money that they have access to, and not taxpayers' money?

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

They are at liberty to apply to the New Opportunities Fund's Scottish land fund, and I hope that many more people will do so to take advantage of the opportunity to bring land into community ownership.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

At least some of us think that there will be benefits for communities that take advantage of the land fund. Does the Executive intend to monitor that benefit in years to come? I believe that, following some community buyouts, people are already starting to pay back some of the money that they were able to raise.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

Lottery money is not the same as taxpayers' money. People contribute to the lottery voluntarily; there is no compulsion. However, as members know, the Executive liaises with colleagues in DCMS on the best use of lottery funds, which are raised for good causes. I believe that extending community ownership to more communities is a good cause. It will allow communities to take a direct interest in land, which could lead to social, economic and environmental benefits. With my colleague Frank McAveety, who is the minister responsible, I will be liaising with colleagues at DCMS. Like the convener, we will want to consider how communities respond to the new opportunity. We will want to assist them, in any way we can, to buy land for which they have registered an interest and from which they may gain social, economic and environmental benefits.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

We were wondering what you meant by "DCMS", but I take it that it is the Department for Culture, Media and Sport.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

Yes. Sorry. It is easy to fall into acronym-speak.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

As there are no further questions, I will put the question.The question is, that motion S2M-1169, as printed on the agenda, be agreed to. Are we agreed?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

In that case, there will be a division.

ForButler, Bill (Glasgow Anniesland) (Lab)Glen, Marlyn (North East Scotland) (Lab)McNeill, Pauline (Glasgow Kelvin) (Lab)Matheson, Michael (Central Scotland) (SNP)Maxwell, Mr Stewart (West of Scotland) (SNP)AgainstMitchell, Margaret (Central Scotland) (Con)

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

The result of the division is: For 5, Against 1, Abstentions 0.

Motion agreed to.

That the Justice 1 Committee recommends that the draft Community Right to Buy (Definition of Excluded Land) (Scotland) Order 2004 be approved.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I thank the minister and his officials for their attendance this morning.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That brings us to the end of our agenda. I remind members that the next meeting of our committee will be on Wednesday 5 May in committee room 2. At that meeting, we will have an informal briefing from the Scottish Executive on the Civil Partnership Bill; we will take evidence on the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Bill from the bill team; and we will consider a statutory instrument.We will now take a short break before our joint meeting with the Justice 2 Committee to discuss the budget.

Meeting closed at 10:19.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Wednesday 21 April 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 32
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.