Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Travel Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2004 (Draft)

Wednesday 21 April 2004 Justice 1 Committee Subordinate legislation 32 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

32 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I welcome Hugh Henry, the Deputy Minister for Justice, and his team.I refer members to the note prepared by the clerk on the draft Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Travel Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2004.

Hugh Henry Lab The Deputy Minister for Justice · Paisley South
link

The draft regulations build and improve on an earlier set of regulations—the Sex Offenders (Notice Requirements) (Foreign Travel) (Scotland) Regulations 2001 (SSI 2001/188). It is unfortunate, but a large body of evidence proves that people convicted of sex offences are among the most difficult and challenging offenders with whom the criminal justice system deals. They can be extremely skilled in avoiding detection and in creating and manipulating situations to their advantage. It is important to set the new regulations in that context. They form part of a package of measures that we and our counterparts in the rest of the United Kingdom seek to introduce under part 2 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003. The 2003 act, which replaces the Sex Offenders Act 1997, strengthens and extends the requirements placed on those convicted of a wide range of sexual offences to register with the police their name and address and any subsequent changes of those. The draft regulations are made under section 86 of the 2003 act, which Parliament approved through a Sewel motion that was debated last year. The strengthened regulatory framework that we are putting in place will further our knowledge of the whereabouts of convicted sex offenders and increase our ability to protect children from sexual exploitation and sex tourism. The 2001 regulations provided that sex offenders had to notify the police when they intended to travel abroad for a period of eight days or more and to provide information on their travel arrangements 48 hours before their intended departure. The practical experience of the police to date has shown that that eight-day period is considered far too long and means that the police can be unaware that an offender has left the country. We must recognise that the advent of cheap foreign travel, linked to the emergence of new sex tourism destinations in eastern Europe and north Africa, has meant that it is relatively easy for offenders to travel to regions where children are particularly vulnerable to sexual exploitation. People could easily do that and return within eight days. By reducing the period of notice to three days, the police will be able to keep a better track of offenders and alert the enforcement authorities in those countries where appropriate. We also seek to increase the period of advance notice that offenders will have to give the police of their travel plans from 48 hours to seven days before they intend to travel. In doing so, we recognise that there could be circumstances in which an offender might have to travel at short notice—for example, when there is a family crisis or a bereavement—and the regulations provide for such circumstances. At all times, we try to strike a balance between enabling the police to administer the sex offender registration scheme to best effect and recognising that there should be no undue restriction on offenders. Equally, we have to give proper recognition to public safety. In that respect, we are satisfied that the regulations are compliant with the European convention on human rights. They do not in any way prohibit offenders from travelling overseas or restrict their movements, although they require those who intend to travel to give due notification of that.The regulations will provide a reasonable and measured step to reduce further the scope for offenders to travel abroad for sexual exploitation. If a registered sex offender fails to comply with the regulations without good reason, they would—as with all other registration requirements—be guilty of a criminal offence, which could carry a sentence of up to five years in prison.A similar set of regulations has been framed for application in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, which would also come into effect on 1 May. We believe that, by having a consistent approach throughout the United Kingdom, we will send a clear message to sex offenders that there is no safe haven in any part of the United Kingdom and, more than that, that there will be no safe haven for them to carry on such practices abroad.In conclusion, the Executive, with the Parliament's consent, is taking a number of significant steps to improve detection, to manage such offenders in order to minimise the trauma of victims, many of whom are—unfortunately—children, and to safeguard the public as far as possible. The draft regulations form part of our efforts in pursuit of those objectives.I move,That the Justice 1 Committee recommends that the draft Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Travel Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2004 be approved.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

Good morning, minister. I welcome the draft regulations, which are a move in the right direction. You said that the previous period of travel was eight days, which will be reduced to three days. On what basis was three days chosen?

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

In making that decision, we tried to strike a balance in respect of the length of time that such offenders could travel to the areas that would cause concern. One issue that the police considered and reflected on was whether the period should be reduced even further. The difficulty with that was that it would place significant strains on the police, who might not only have to log and register every movement for a day if a person was to fly to a football match and back, for example, but perhaps think about whether they needed to notify the authorities in those countries. The aim was to try to identify areas of particular concern, how long it would take to travel to and back from those areas, what measures could reasonably be introduced that did not infringe the ECHR and what would be reasonable for the police and other authorities to be able to cope with without causing undue strains on the system. The balance is reasonable and is based on the experience of those who are directly involved.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

Given that the regulations concern the protection of vulnerable people—particularly children—from sexual predators, was the possibility considered that any travel within the UK for periods of several days should also be notified? Obviously, that matter is not covered. If an offender in Glasgow moved to London for a week and came back, for example, is there any reason why that should not be notified?

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

There is a notification requirement when such people move within the United Kingdom. If I can be given a minute, I will double-check with my officials what the period is.Under the 2003 act, there is already a requirement to notify any intention to travel for a period of seven days or more, I think. The regulations are intended to address particular problems relating to what were regarded as sex tourism areas in which children are clearly being exploited. There is a restriction relating to travel within the United Kingdom. However, we believe that the supervisory and legal frameworks are stronger here and that people would not easily be able to take advantage of them and travel for sex tourism purposes within the United Kingdom. For example, if there was an obvious problem in a particular town or city in the United Kingdom and people were travelling to it because it had gained that type of notoriety, we would expect that to be dealt with immediately, rather than for the pattern of sex offences to be considered.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

I accept what you are saying about sex tourism, but it seems, from what I have read, that many such offenders operate in paedophile groups across countries and across the world and that they co-operate in exploiting children. It would be quite simple for such a person from Scotland to travel to London for a week to carry out those offences, but that would not be sex tourism in the sense that we have been talking about, even though an offence would be committed. Would not it be reasonable to reduce the period of travel within the UK that had to be notified, to avoid people travelling to another part of the UK, exploiting children there and then returning home, with no recognition by the authorities that that person had been in the area at the time?

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

I recognise what Stewart Maxwell is saying. That would indeed be of concern. The considerations on the regulations were based on the experience and evidence of practitioners who were knowledgeable about patterns of sex offending behaviour and what was required to restrict such behaviour. It was a matter of trying to strike a balance, with restrictions that protect the public but are not overly burdensome on the police and that do not go so far as to infringe other rights that individuals have under the ECHR. We believe that we have struck a proper balance, but it is always possible to be flexible—today's debate shows how flexible we can be in acting on and reacting to specific problems. If the police and other agencies started to express concern that the time limits were excessive or were leading to the type of problems that Stewart Maxwell identifies, we would seek professional advice on further proposals as soon as possible. At the moment, we see no reason to do that and we have not been advised that that is required. However, I assure members that all the relevant agencies pay close attention to such issues.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Was there the opportunity to make such provision when the Sexual Offences Bill was passing through Parliament last year? If so, why did the Scottish Executive not take the opportunity then?

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

There had been an earlier attempt to introduce regulations, but a problem was identified by the scrutiny committee at Westminster. We have now come up with something that we believe is more robust. We are working in partnership with the rest of the United Kingdom. In fact, the proposed timetable is almost identical and we are aiming for a common implementation date. We are working consistently across the United Kingdom to ensure that provisions apply equally and that there are no anomalies or loopholes and no different time frames in different parts of the United Kingdom. We believe that this is the appropriate time to do that, working in partnership with the UK Parliament.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

You may correct me if I am wrong, but I believe that the majority of the 2003 act applies UK-wide, so the Scottish Executive would have to have exempted itself from being included in the provisions. Here we are, a year later, closing the gap. I just wonder how that came to be, because it does not seem to be the most efficient way of doing business.

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

I am not quite clear about the point that Margaret Mitchell is driving at. We are not talking about closing a loophole that we failed to identify. With your permission, convener, I would like to bring in one of the officials to see whether we can tease the matter out a bit further.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I am clear that you have brought previous regulations to us as and when issues have arisen and my understanding is that, in this case, having researched the matter, you have proposed a reduction in the number of days.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Paragraph 8 of the note from the clerk says that the regulations were laid"In order to avoid the creation of a loophole in the sex offenders register regime in Scotland and a consequent difference in the regime north and south of the border".There was an opportunity to do that last year and I wonder why it was not done.

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

Convener, with your indulgence, may I bring one of the officials into the discussion?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Unfortunately, officials are not permitted to speak in this debate, but you may take whatever time you need to reply.

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

I apologise for the uncertainty, but I am still not entirely clear what the issue is, although I think that it is the one to which I referred earlier. Regulations were laid previously at Westminster and in the Scottish Parliament and, when the Westminster committee was considering those regulations, it identified a loophole. That loophole having been identified, the Westminster Government withdrew the proposed regulations, and the Scottish Executive withdrew its proposed regulations. The Westminster Government has come back with a new set of proposals and we have come back with a new set of proposals, too, which are the draft regulations that we are considering today. They take account of the identified loophole. I am not aware that there would have been any opportunity for us to act earlier and I certainly would not argue that we should act differently, because we have, at all times, attempted to act consistently throughout the United Kingdom. I believe that we are acting appropriately and I do not think that anything has been missed. If I am addressing a different point from the one that Margaret Mitchell is making, I apologise.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

I am happy to accept the minister's explanation that this is the earliest opportunity at which the regulations could have been introduced.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

Are similar regulations being passed at Westminster? If so, when were those regulations published and when will they be passed by Westminster?

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

Regulations that will have exactly the same effect as the ones that we are discussing are being considered at Westminster. The intention is that those regulations will come into effect on 1 May. I ask for a minute to find out whether we have details of when those regulations were published.

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

The regulations were debated in the House of Commons yesterday; they have still to be debated in the House of Lords.

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

As far as we are concerned, they should be passed in time to have effect on 1 May, but I am not familiar with the procedures in the House of Lords.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

In effect, there is no loophole at the moment in Scotland; the debate is about preventing one. There could be a loophole if the regulations take effect in Scotland at the beginning of May but the Westminster regulations hit some problem and are delayed. However, at this stage, there is no loophole.

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

No. The loophole to which I referred earlier was more of a technical loophole that the Westminster committee had identified, which would have created certain difficulties and anomalies. The new regulations are intended to address that. If the two sets of regulations were completely out of kilter, I would have my worries, but I have no reason to believe that the timescale within which we are operating will produce any great difficulties in relation to what is happening in Westminster.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Okay. I will revert to some of the technical issues. You said that failure to notify is a criminal offence. Would that mean that in every case in which an offender did not give the requisite seven days' notice—if they gave six days', five days' or four days' notice, for example—they would be committing a criminal offence of failing to notify? If not, what would happen?

Hugh Henry Lab Paisley South
link

The offender would be liable to be prosecuted in the same way as anyone would be for committing an offence. They have a requirement to notify and, if it becomes apparent that they have travelled abroad without giving the proper notification, they will be liable for prosecution.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

There are no further questions.We are required to draw up a report, if we have anything to say on the regulations. The points that we want to focus on in the report have perhaps already been made.

Motion agreed to.

That the Justice 1 Committee recommends that the draft Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Travel Notification Requirements) (Scotland) Regulations 2004 be approved.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

We could just use a summary of the debate to compile a report and we could check whether members wish to emphasise any particular points. We will circulate a draft report by e-mail. I ask members to check their e-mail in the next few days to ensure that they are happy with the draft report's contents. Please let us know if you are not. I thank the minister for attending.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Wednesday 21 April 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 32
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 41

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.