The next petition is PE111, on which members have received papers from the clerks. The petition relates to the Road Traffic Act 1988, which deals with reserved issues. The petition, from Frank Harvey, calls on the Parliament to order a public inquiry into road accidents that involve vehicles that are responding to 999 calls. At a previous meeting, the committee asked me to write to a number of agencies to clarify the procedures that were in place. Members have copies of the replies.One thing that struck me was that the fire brigade has a comprehensive training programme for full-time employees but not for part-time employees. That should be looked into.
I agree. The Fire Brigades Union has raised the issue of the uniformity of driver training across Scotland. Skid-pan training is an issue for all members of staff, and I think that we should raise that with the Chief and Assistant Chief Fire Officers Association.A fire services bill is planned, so I suggest that we also raise the issue with the Scottish Executive to find out its views on driver training. We should find out whether the Executive plans to take any action to improve the uniformity of training for drivers.
I agree. There is no consistency of approach across the brigades in Scotland. Each brigade is left to its own devices in its driver training, as we can see from the papers that we have. There is a particular concern over retained and volunteer drivers, as we have already mentioned.The FBU paper talks about senior officers. Until recently, senior officers had no training at all in driving under blue-light conditions, although now, in some if not all brigades, those officers receive such training. However, that training is limited, in most cases, to those who receive permanent promotions. Those on temporary promotions do not receive the training. That seems anomalous, especially as some temporary promotions to senior officer level last for a considerable time—months or sometimes years. The lack of driver training for senior officers is a clear problem. They quite often come up from station officer level having never driven a vehicle under blue-light conditions. They then become temporary assistant divisional officers and are given a car, a set of keys and a set of blue lights. The FBU expresses very well the clear concerns over that.
I think that Mr Harvey may be referring to a particular incident that he had read about. The committee decided to consider the broader issues that arose and to find out about the legal position of vehicles that are in pursuit or are dealing with an emergency. It is clear that if someone is in a vehicle being chased, it is an offence for them not to stop. However, what are other members' experiences of vehicles getting out of the road of the blue light? In my experience, most people do not know what to do. That is not because they have not seen the blue light; it is because nobody knows who should pull in first. It occurred to me that there should perhaps be some public information. It is all very well having advanced drivers for police or fire vehicles, but if members of the public do not know how to get out of the road without killing somebody, there may be a need for public information. We have to allow flexibility in law to allow some kind of pursuit and to enable emergencies to be dealt with, so we would not necessarily want speed limits to apply. However, neither should those vehicles be beyond the law. I do not think that we will be able to solve the issue that the petitioner raises by suggesting anything in that regard, other than tidying up issues relating to training and emphasising that those vehicles are not beyond the law. As a consequence of thinking about this petition, however, I think that it might be useful if there were public information to make it easier for police or fire vehicles to use their training and their blue light to ensure that they have the clearest path possible.
It would be entirely reasonable to write to CACFOA to seek clarification on the issue of police and fire fighter training, although I understand that it is working on the issue at the moment. I am fairly confident that full-time fire fighters who volunteer for driver training receive quite extensive training, but the issue of uniformity across Scotland has to be addressed, as does the issue of retaining the volunteer and senior officer training. However, that does not preclude our seeking further information about the last time the maximum penalty in the 1988 act was reviewed. That is a valid question to ask.
I agree with that but, as I suggested earlier, I think that we should write to the Executive to raise the issue of uniformity of training. I assume that the Executive is in dialogue with CACFOA to address the issues, but I would like to ensure that that is happening.
We need to come to a conclusion about the petition while taking action. In that letter to the Executive, perhaps we should broaden out the issues that we think need to be dealt with. Stewart, are you suggesting that we write separately to the Executive on the issue that you raised in relation to the fire service?
We need to know what the up-to-date position is, as the situation has been evolving in recent years and training for all the groups that we are talking about has come on by leaps and bounds. Further, I think that we should be recommending that minimum and uniform standards be set for such training across Scotland.
In the letter to the Executive, we can deal with the broader issues relating to all the services and with minimum standards in relation to driving and training and also ask specifically about the current situation with regard to the fire service. If anything comes out of that inquiry, we can pursue it further, but are we agreed that our writing to the Executive on this matter closes our consideration of the petition?Members indicated agreement.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.