Item 2 is on petition PE477, which was submitted by the Miscarriages of Justice Organisation—MOJO. I refer members to the paper that the clerk produced, which summarises the correspondence that has been received and the background to the petition. The correspondence gives members some idea of the exchanges that have taken place between MOJO and the Public Petitions Committee.First, I invite comments on the petition. I will then invite the committee to consider the action—if any—that it wants to take.
The petition makes a number of valid points. It asks for assistance in"setting up an aftercare programme in the form of a half way home to help people who have been wrongfully incarcerated".Such a programme should be available, but there is a gap in provision and the Executive's response up to now has not been satisfactory in any way.At the meeting of the Public Petitions Committee on 12 November 2003, Mike Watson said that he was"disappointed with the Executive's response." I echo that. At that meeting, Mike Watson quoted Dr Adrian Grounds, who wrote:"the wrongly convicted suffer the kind of trauma experienced by victims of war crimes."Mike Watson went on to say:"We should not forget that such people are victims. The Executive's response fails to comprehend that we are dealing with different situations."—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 12 November 2003; c 312-313.Unfortunately, we are still faced with the situation that Mike Watson's comments reflect. As a society, we do not provide the necessary help and support in cases such as those of Robert Brown and Patrick Hill—members have seen the psychiatric report that is in the papers, which, I think, is the source of the Dr Grounds quotation. There is a gap in provision and the Executive's response has been wholly unsatisfactory. We should do something about the petition—I know that we will discuss that a little later, convener.
I agree with everything that Bill Butler said and want to add one comment. When I was convener of the Justice 2 Committee in the first session of the Parliament, I was approached by a number of individuals who believed that they had suffered a miscarriage of justice. I considered two specific cases and it was clear that there is no real statutory support for people whose convictions are quashed on appeal. In some cases, people would almost have been better treated if they had completed their sentences without the conviction being quashed. We are getting better at supporting ex-offenders, but there seems to be no separate category for those whose convictions are quashed. For example, a chap told me that he had been handcuffed and taken straight back to prison immediately after his conviction had been formally quashed on appeal. I questioned on human rights grounds whether that should have happened and raised my concerns with the previous Minister for Justice.There are more support issues to consider than just the provision of halfway houses. If we decide to take the matter further, we need to look at the broader picture.
I echo everything that the convener and Bill Butler said. We have a serious responsibility towards individuals who have been wrongfully imprisoned. It is clear from the Executive's response that it does not take that responsibility seriously and has not taken it on board. The situation should be considered in a number of ways. On the issue of aftercare, the briefing paper points out that there is a serious lack of pre-release counselling; people who have said, effectively, that they are not guilty have found serious problems in accessing counselling, yet they are the very people who have a great need for counselling of one kind or another. There certainly appears to be a real gap in the system at present and I would very much welcome the chance to do some work on the matter.
I agree with everything that has been said. A basic principle is involved. One of the toughest sanctions that society can apply to anyone is to deprive them of their liberty. If we get that wrong, we have a responsibility to the wronged individual to right that wrong. That should be done not only through routine compensation but by helping an individual to rebuild their life. If we believe that there are sufficient grounds for establishing a body such as the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission, we should also recognise that there are individuals who require support and assistance when they have been the victim of a miscarriage of justice. Clearly, there is a serious gap in service provision for wrongfully imprisoned people, which must be addressed.
It is clear that the committee wishes to take the matter further. I will summarise some of the issues that are contained in the briefing paper. There is the issue to which Michael Matheson referred, on how the compensation scheme operates. Compensation is not automatic and individuals must apply for it. The scheme has two different elements and how a person's compensation is gauged is a matter for the Scottish ministers. My understanding is that there is no support for directing people on how to complete the application forms in the first place. Bill Butler referred to the psychiatric report on Paddy Hill, which gives us an insight into mental welfare issues that we may need to address. The issue of housing is also specifically mentioned in the petition. I ask members to consider the action that they would like to take.
I want to reaffirm the comments that members have made. I certainly believe that the issue of wrongfully imprisoned people should be dealt with and I am rather disappointed by the Executive's response to the petition so far. However, in proceeding with the issue, it would be reasonable for us to include it in our general discussion on the rehabilitation of prisoners. There is scope to include the issue within that inquiry. I would be reluctant to have a separate inquiry because I believe that it would be difficult to do that given the time available to the committee and that it would be perfectly possible to include the issue in our rehabilitation inquiry. We can make recommendations on the petition on that basis. I would not necessarily want to adopt immediately the petition's suggestions about having halfway houses and so on. We should explore such matters further before taking a position, and the way to do so is through our inquiry.
We must be careful about how we include the issue of wrongfully imprisoned people in an inquiry that is about whether we can rehabilitate prisoners. The petitioners' position might be that individuals who were wrongfully imprisoned should be treated differently. In fact, some such individuals refuse to go on rehabilitation programmes. One of the cases that I dealt with was in relation to a sexual offence. The prisoner involved refused to go on the STOP programme and that refusal was part of his campaign to demonstrate his innocence.Therefore, in some cases individuals would not necessarily have been through rehabilitation programmes. We should not infer a direct correlation with other prisoners, although I take Stewart Maxwell's point that we have a heavy work load and need to find a clever way to incorporate work on the petition. We could begin by making our position clear to the Executive in the strongest terms, which would give us further time to think about how we can incorporate the work.
I am more in favour of the second option under paragraph 13a of the paper, which is to pursue the matter with the Minister for Justice in correspondence and to seek the views of an organisation such as Safeguarding Communities-Reducing Offending, which works with ex-prisoners. We should also seek the views of Helping Offenders Prisoners Families—HOPE—which works with prisoners and their families, because there are consequences for the family if someone is wrongly incarcerated. I would have concerns about including the issue in our inquiry into rehabilitation programmes, because there is a danger that it will become an add-on and that we might not give it the consideration that it deserves.
I agree. I know where Stewart Maxwell is coming from and I accept that his suggestion is one way of dealing with the issue, but it is not the most appropriate way. This issue has been going on for some considerable time. We need to go directly to the Minister for Justice. The suggestions in the petition are appropriate and sensible. I would hope that if we approached her, the Minister for Justice would reconsider the response so far. I agree that we should write to SACRO and HOPE. Option ii under paragraph 13a is to the point, and is a quick and effective way of proceeding. We should press the Executive in the strongest possible terms to close what is an unacceptable gap.
I take the same view. I recommend that we communicate with the Executive in the strongest possible terms. The only thing that stands in the way of my saying that we should hold an inquiry on the issue in its own right is our timetable. It is not that such an inquiry would not be valuable or would not be the right way to go; such an approach probably is the right thing to do given the number of issues involved and their complexity. We would benefit greatly from hearing evidence from a range of sources. We touched on housing, but all sorts of issues are involved, including people's mental health and well-being. The petition would benefit from a small and focused piece of work by the committee, and our timetable is the only thing that is standing in the way of that. The Executive should be told in no uncertain terms about the feelings of the committee. It should also be told that we are the final resort, and that we are looking to the Executive to take responsibility where it has not been taken in the past. However, we should not rule out the possibility of our coming back to the issue to examine it properly in an inquiry.
I agree that, ideally, we would hold a separate inquiry, but that is just not feasible given our work load. I have a lot of sympathy with Stewart Maxwell's suggestion for dealing with the petition. I would like to pin down the logistics. If we press the Minister for Justice and go for the second option under paragraph 13a, how quickly will we get somewhere? How far might the issue be kicked into the long grass? If we feel that it is being kicked into the long grass, will there be an opportunity—notwithstanding the sensitivities of referring to prisoners when we are talking about people who have been the victims of miscarriages of justice—to look into the subject separately? We might take the views of the petitioners to see whether they would be happy with that as a way forward, given the fact that we cannot hold a separate inquiry. If we do not get anywhere with the minister, we might then have the opportunity to add the matter to our inquiry into rehabilitation programmes, with the strict proviso that it is understood that these people have been prisoners only because they have been the victims of miscarriages of justice.
That was helpful. I will try to summarise what I think that the committee is saying. First, we should write to the minister in strong terms, saying that we support the basis of the petition and that we are dissatisfied with the response because lots of issues need to be addressed and there should be a proper support mechanism for those whose convictions are quashed.Stewart Maxwell suggested that we include the issue in our inquiry. I propose that, until we receive a reply from the minister, we keep that option open and try to find a way to continue the work. That will give the committee time to consider the remit of the inquiry—we will do that later in the meeting, anyway. It is not impossible for us to chase an issue and raise its profile, as we have in the past, without having to hold an inquiry. For example, we did not hold an inquiry into the petition on asbestos victims, but pursued the matter directly with the Lord President and the petitioners and were able to make progress on it. We also have the facility to appoint reporters if we want to find a way round the problem. I propose that we leave that question open. It would still be possible for the committee to include the issue in its inquiry, if it wanted. However, if it did not feel that that was appropriate, we could find another way of continuing the work.
I agree with what you say about leaving the matter open. My suggestion to incorporate the issue into our inquiry was based on timetabling considerations.I ask for clarification on what we are writing to the Executive about. The first line of option ii under paragraph 13a in the clerk's paper says that the committee may"consider whether it supports the petitioner's suggestions".Are we writing to the Executive in support of the specific suggestion to"provide assistance in setting up an aftercare programme in the form of a half way home",or are we writing in broad terms to support the suggestion that people should have some form of aftercare programme, although not necessarily that specific one? I am not saying that that specific suggestion is good or bad; I am saying that I am not in a position to determine whether an aftercare home would be a good thing to provide.
I propose to incorporate in the letter, as issues to be considered, all the comments that are made by the committee. I do not think that, at this stage, we should pin ourselves down to one specific solution, unless Bill Butler has a different view.
Okay. I confirm that the committee will write to SACRO and HOPE, as Michael Matheson suggested, to get their views on the petition. I will then let the committee see the correspondence.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.