Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Carbeth Hutters (PE14)

Wednesday 8 October 2003 Justice 1 Committee Petitions 15 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I have to declare a sort of interest in the petition from the Carbeth hutters, which calls for protection for hutters, as I think that it was the first petition that I ever dealt with, away back in the days of the original Justice and Home Affairs Committee. The background papers on the petition will bring you up to date with the situation. I have had a number of letters from groups in a similar position to that of the Carbeth hutters, in that they have semi-permanent homes and their landlord has offered renewal of their lease at extremely high terms that they are unable to meet. This seems to be a general issue affecting semi-permanent homes. The committee will know that in, I think, 2000, the Executive completed a report on the position across Scotland. Nothing further has happened, although the committee made some recommendations that further action should be taken.I have been involved with the Carbeth hutters, as have other MSPs. There is an update on the situation at paragraph 7 of the paper. If the committee wanted to recommend legislation, it would have to broaden that out to encompass the Scotland-wide situation rather than just a local case.

Mrs Smith
link

I have had constituents to whom the same thing has happened. Their rent has been put up to such an extent that they have been forced out of places where they have lived, at least partially, for 20 years or so. There is a great sense of grievance at such action. I was a bit dismayed by the report on what the Executive has done, or not done, on the issue. Obviously, practices are going on that may be within the letter of the law but which are outwith the spirit of the law. There seems to be no recognition of that in the Executive's action. Can we have clarification on what action the previous committee asked the Executive to take, because you said that some outstanding issues had not been addressed by the Executive?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Yes, we can get clarification on that. I wrote to the minister, and I recall that there was scope for some kind of regulatory regime over leases and rents. It is a difficult area, because we are talking about owners of land who have granted leases on certain terms that have now run out. The question is whether there should be measures in law to prevent landlords from having unfair terms in the first place.We already have that principle in Scots law, because a person cannot sign up to a contract if it contravenes the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977. There are minimum provisions in that act that prevent a person from signing such a contract and contractors have to abide by that. That was the principle that we had in mind at the time. There is no doubt that it is a difficult area in which to legislate, because every situation is slightly different.There has been a lot of negotiating over Carbeth. I have no doubt that negotiations have been strengthened by the fact that Parliament has discussed legislation. The parties may have satisfactorily negotiated an end to the situation.We have had correspondence from chalet owners in Lochgoilhead on the Drimsynie estate. Action is being taken there to evict chalet tenants and demolish their chalets without their permission. It is grossly unfair.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

It is outrageous that in this day and age anybody is behaving in such a fashion. I am pleased that there has been progress with the Carbeth case, which looks to be in the interests of all parties. However, when I go through the report I cannot help but feel that the Executive is fobbing us off. It is not doing anything about the issue. We have a moral responsibility, given what has happened to the folk on the Drimsynie estate, to ask the Executive whether it is happy that this sort of thing is happening. If not, something has to be done to deal with it. I know that it might be complex, but something has to be done when a landowner can behave in such a high-handed fashion.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I am pleased to say that, following negotiation, the Carbeth situation seems to be reaching a positive resolution. However, as Michael Matheson said, the Drimsynie situation is, on the face of it, outrageous. We are duty bound to write to the Executive asking whether— notwithstanding the fact that it is difficult to legislate in this area—it has any thoughts on what it might do to resolve the Drimsynie situation and to prevent any other such outrageous situations from occurring. We must do that at the very least.

Mrs Smith
link

One of my constituents owned one of the chalets, as their property on someone else's property. They were told that, unless they got their property off that other person's property, it would be destroyed. That situation leaves people with the cost of moving their chalet and the problem of where to put it. It really is a totally impossible situation for people to find themselves in.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

The owner has a right to determine what they want to do with their land. However, when they contract with somebody else for the use of their land—whether as a site for a chalet or something else—there should be some framework to protect the person who enters into that contract. The only other option would be some kind of rent control. I cannot think of another measure that would protect somebody in that situation. I presume that, in the cases under consideration, the people have signed something.The history of Carbeth is that part of the land was gifted to the people of Clydebank. The people have huts on the estate that have no running water or electricity, but they are perfectly happy with that. However, three generations on, the new landowner obviously thinks that they can do something better with the land. The Carbeth situation is, therefore, slightly different. The Carbeth people faced dramatic changes in their lease terms—extra charges for roads that were not up to scratch, and for this, that and the next thing—which would price them out of the market.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

On the question of what can be done, you suggested that some sort of legislation dealing with the rental situation might be one of the few options. However, in the light of what has happened at Carbeth, perhaps there is a role for slightly tighter regulations on compulsory arbitration between parties in such situations. Perhaps there should be a presumption that, when such a situation occurs, the case should go before a body that will arbitrate between the two parties. That may not resolve all situations, but it has done so in the case of Carbeth. Rather than going into the problems of land ownership and rent control, perhaps forcing the two groups to come face to face through professional arbitrators may resolve such situations, as it has in the Carbeth case. Perhaps that avenue could be explored by the Executive.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

For the record, I am not opposed to that suggestion. However, although we can threaten to legislate if the parties do not sort the matter out, once we have done that, we cannot do the same for anybody else. The fact that we have resolved the Carbeth situation does not necessarily mean that we could get a resolution in all situations, unless we pursue Stewart Maxwell's suggestion that, as part of the legal process, the two parties would be forced into arbitration. We would have to think about what would be the conclusion of that and how it would be enforced.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

I am familiar with the Drimsynie estate, as I used to be an instructor at the outdoor centre in Lochgoilhead. I do not know the exact situation, but I am familiar with the estate. It is a large, commercial development with a hotel, chalets and a caravan park. I am not sure what has happened, but I suspect that—for commercial purposes—the landowners have decided to get rid of the wooden chalets that used to be near the foreshore and to do something else there. That is very different from the Carbeth situation. If the landowner thinks that a commercial interest is at stake, I do not think that he will be open to arbitration. I also know that, historically, the landowner in question does not have a reputation for dealing with things in the best of ways.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That is helpful. How does the committee feel about writing to the Executive, saying that it should pick the matter up again? Our suggestion would be that it consider compulsory arbitration—as suggested by Stewart Maxwell—and/or some regulatory framework that would apply fairness to leases, along the lines of the Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977. The UCTA could be used as a model. Those two suggestions are not mutually exclusive and could be used together as a way forward. We would have to make it clear that they would have to apply in a number of situations, rather than be tailored to the specific situations at Lochgoilhead and Carbeth. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I propose that we break for five minutes, for coffee.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Wednesday 8 October 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  8. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  9. Petitions Petitions · 34
  10. Petitions Petitions · 22
  11. Petitions Petitions · 15
  12. Work Programme Procedure · 47
  13. High Court of Justiciary (Reform) Committee business · 62

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.