Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Children (Scotland) Act 1995 (PE124)

Wednesday 8 October 2003 Justice 1 Committee Petitions 22 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

22 contributions
Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

For petition PE124, we have a paper that sets out the background to, and correspondence on, the issue of grandparents' rights of access to their grandchildren. The paper presents a number of options. I invite Bill Butler to comment.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I am very keen that the committee agree to the proposed action that is laid out in paragraphs 13, 14 and 15. In the previous parliamentary session, various organisations made submissions to the Justice 1 Committee that said, basically, that they were content with the current legislation. The action that is proposed in paragraphs 13, 14 and 15 would ensure that the petitioners' concerns—with which, I am sure, we all have sympathy—were progressed in some fashion.I would be grateful if the committee would agree to make a slight change to paragraph 13. If we agree to write to the petitioners, we should say that the current legislation "would seem to be sufficient". If we say that current legislation "is sufficient", why should we adopt the proposals in paragraphs 14 and 15?There is no evidence that the legislation is insufficient. However, the Grandparents Apart Self Help group has raised concerns, with which I sympathise. If we are minded to support the proposed amendment to paragraph 13, I suggest that we add the words "notwithstanding the above" to paragraph 14. We could advise the petitioners of the Executive's plans to consult on its forthcoming family law bill and suggest that they may wish to make representations at the appropriate time.In the previous session, the Justice 2 Committee suggested that a review of the effectiveness of the Children (Scotland) Act 1995 could be conducted. We should consider undertaking further work in that area, if there is a time slot for it. I ask members to consider taking all the action that is proposed in paragraphs 13, 14 and 15 of the note from the clerk.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Margaret Mitchell, who is not here today, asked that I mention to the committee that, in her view, if we are to widen access under the 1995 act we should do so to include fathers. I do not know what members think about that suggestion.I note the points that Bill Butler has made. I am never clear about what GASH wants from the law. I understand that in the petition the group's members are saying that, as grandparents, they feel excluded from the system. The Justice 2 Committee's preliminary report on the petition indicated that people believe that they must pay for any action that they want to take in the justice system. Although there is provision for fathers, mothers or any person to apply for access, if that is in the welfare interests of the child, we do not know whether people believe that the costs of paying a solicitor and getting through the courts act as a barrier to that element of justice.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Part of the problem is that there may often be a substantial cost to be met. As I understand it, GASH members want the automatic right to have contact with their grandchildren. That change has been seen as unnecessary, because people are content with the law as it stands. However, it is still a matter of concern to the folk in GASH to whom I have spoken. Perhaps they should make a submission to the consultation on the forthcoming family law bill, to ascertain whether there are ways in which their problems may be addressed. I do not know whether that would be possible, but we should at least suggest to GASH that it may wish to explore that option.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

I have dealt with a number of cases of people seeking representation in relation to this issue and recently I have been in correspondence on the matter with the Minister for Justice. The cases that have been brought to me suggest that it tends to be the parents of the father who have lost access to the child, because the father has also lost access.The minister has suggested that, under Scots law, if the parents are not married when a child is conceived or born, the father has no rights or responsibilities in relation to the child. A fortnight ago, the minister told me in writing that the Executive intends to address that issue in the family law bill and to ensure that if, at the time of birth, someone registers that they are the father of a child, they will be granted responsibilities and rights. That may deal with part of the problem.The other main difficulty that I have identified in the cases that have been brought to me is access to justice. Under the welfare provisions of the 1995 act, grandparents can go to court to request a right of access. However, there is a problem with legal aid and the cost of going to court. The family law bill may not address that issue, which relates to legal aid provision more generally. However, the matter may be addressed as an aside to the family law bill. If we are to give responsibilities and rights to fathers, we ought to consider giving access rights to grandparents. The main issue is provision of legal aid that would allow grandparents to seek access rights through the courts.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That is the key issue. Indeed, we should specify to the Executive that we think that the issue is worthy of examination.That said, the question of granting an automatic right of access is difficult to resolve, given that no one—not even the mother or father—has such a right.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

With respect, convener, I am not suggesting that. Instead, I think that we should go ahead with the proposed action as set out in paragraphs 13, 14 and 15 of the paper.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Yes, but I am simply addressing your comments about GASH's call for an automatic right of access to grandchildren.We need to respond to the petitioners. Like Bill Butler and Michael Matheson, I am very sympathetic to their aims; however, I would like to pin them down a bit more. If we were to legislate in this area, we would need to give more thought to the precise provisions that would be required. For a start, we would not be able to legislate for an automatic right of access. Instead, we might be able to widen access for a range of family members or other people who are important to a child. In doing so, we could obtain better justice for grandparents, aunts, uncles and other family members and the principle of the interests of the child would remain. Moreover, we could examine the experiences of grandparents and others in trying to use the 1995 act. I have absolutely no information about that subject.

Mrs Smith
link

I concur strongly with Michael Matheson's comments. However, I know of cases in which it was found to be in the child's interests not to allow the father access, which meant that the grandparents were not allowed access. As a result, there would be problems with giving grandparents an absolute right of access.If members feel able to do so, we should perhaps write to the petitioners about the upcoming family law bill and also ask the Executive to consider the Official Report of this meeting and some of the other work that has already been done by the Justice 2 Committee. That would make it clear that we feel that there is a presumption of support for the arguments that we have heard from grandparents. However, we should point out that we understand that we cannot pursue an automatic right of access for the reasons that have been discussed, but that we are quite keen for the Executive to address the matter in the proposed family law bill and to find out whether we can secure an extension of access rights. That would go some way towards assisting the majority of grandparents in such situations instead of perhaps helping cases that raise issues of child safety.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Michael Matheson and Margaret Smith have made excellent suggestions. We should incorporate their comments, particularly Margaret's comments, in any action that we take.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I just need to go through all the action points to make everything clear.Although I know that there are some additions and amendments to make, I think that in principle members are happy with the proposed action that is outlined in paragraph 13 of the clerk's note. I think that Bill Butler suggested an amendment to that paragraph.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I suggest that we change the phrase "is sufficient" at the end of the paragraph to "would seem to be sufficient". I know that the current legislation is sufficient, but we should not send such a bald statement back to the petitioners. It is simply a gentler way of putting the matter.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

As far as paragraph 13 is concerned, we should write back to the petitioners to explain what has happened and give them an update on the situation. We will also forward to them a copy of the Official Report of this meeting, which will contain our discussions of the matter, and include a summary of our proposed actions. Does that sound all right?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Paragraph 14 of the clerk's note mentions that"the Scottish Executive plans to consult on its forthcoming bill on family law".We will advise the petitioners of that avenue. In addition, however, we could write to the Executive with some action points. Margaret, could you specifically state the action that you would like to be taken?

Mrs Smith
link

Work has been done by the former Justice 2 Committee and we acknowledge that the reasons why the right of grandparents to have access to their grandchildren cannot be absolute have been expressed. However, the committee is generally supportive of the group's main aim, which is to ensure that the majority of grandparents have on-going access to their grandchildren. We should ask the Executive to consider the issue in the context of the family law bill and to consider whether it might be possible to extend the rights of grandparents—and perhaps other people, as the convener said—in the way that the petitioners suggest.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

That suggestion encompasses a number of points that have been made by others. We could write to the Executive to say that we would like it to consider this issue in the drafting of the family law bill and to examine the question of access to justice, which Michael Matheson and I raised, and the question of whether the law could be strengthened in relation to grandparents and other groups to ensure that they had easier access to the children, which Margaret Smith raised.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I agree with that suggestion, but I think that we should also write to the petitioners to say that we strongly advise that they consider not so much the automatic right of access, which seems to be a dead end, but the issue of wider access for a range of family members and access to legal aid. We must give them a steer, but whether they take that steer is entirely up to them.

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

I propose to include Bill Butler's comments in the letter that we discussed in relation to paragraph 13 of the note on the petition.We could say that our view is that an automatic right to access might be difficult to secure and that the petitioners might want to consider framing their request differently.It has been suggested to me that we might want to ask the Executive to review the 1995 act as part of its work in relation to the family law bill. In effect, that is what we have said we should do.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Are we simply amending the wording of the proposed action as outlined in paragraph 15 of the note? Are we going to ask the Executive to consider the matter but not undertake work ourselves?

Pauline McNeill Lab The Convener · Glasgow Kelvin
link

Our comments will be contained in a letter to the Executive. We are asking it to do the work but we will have to keep an eye on the situation. We might get a response from the petitioners as well.Are we agreed that we will follow that course of action?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Wednesday 8 October 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 2
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  6. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  7. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  8. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
  9. Petitions Petitions · 34
  10. Petitions Petitions · 22
  11. Petitions Petitions · 15
  12. Work Programme Procedure · 47
  13. High Court of Justiciary (Reform) Committee business · 62

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.