Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Clydesdale Horses (Couping) (PE347)

Tuesday 4 February 2003 Justice 1 Committee Petitions 35 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

35 contributions
Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Petition PE347 is on the couping of Clydesdale horses. Members will note the options that are set out in paper J1/03/3/14. Does the committee agree that existing guidelines are sufficient? Are members content with the responses that we have received so far? If not, should we write to the minister asking him to introduce legislation to order the banning of the practice of couping? The alternative is for us to ask the Scottish Executive to extend the Farriers (Registration) Act 1975 to include the Highlands and Skye, as requested by the Farriers Registration Council, which wants all farriers in Scotland to be registered. I ask the committee for its views.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

Submissions to the committee included evidence from veterinary experts that suggested that couping was harmful to Clydesdale horses. Although I was persuaded by the evidence, I do not feel that I have been able to go into the issue in sufficient detail. I do not feel that the responses that we received from the farriers and the Clydesdale Horse Society were very helpful. There is a need for us to examine the matter in greater detail. If anything, I am inclined to suggest that, before we recommend the need to introduce legislation, this or another committee should consider the matter in greater detail.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am of the same mind. We have not taken oral evidence on a subject that is niggling away at us. There seems to be truth in the petition's request, but we have not yet tested the evidence.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

I raised the wider issue of animal neglect. I appreciate the fact that the petitioners feel strongly about couping—I share their concerns—but if we are to examine the specifics of couping, other aspects of the showing of animals need to be raised.Perhaps we should say to the Executive that a wider range of consultations is required on the practices that are involved in the exhibiting of animals. Substantial legislation could be required. If we were to include elements other than couping, that would leave the door open to deal with other practices. We definitely cannot deal with the matter in isolation. The Executive will have to consider a wide range of issues concerning the showing of animals.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I share some of Paul Martin and Michael Matheson's concerns. My concern is that there are a million good causes out there. A Parliament should not be measured by when we say no and when we say yes. The fact that something is a good cause does not necessarily make it right for us to deal with it on the time scale or in the way that petitioners demand. I agree with Paul Martin that we should write to the relevant parliamentary committee or to the Executive to say that, the next time they are considering animal welfare issues, they might want to consider this issue.For every piece of business that we offload on to another committee, there is something else that it cannot do. This is an animal welfare issue. It should be addressed the next time animal welfare is considered. We should not put an obligation on another committee or on the Executive to deal with the matter in isolation. It should be discussed in the wider context of animal welfare.

link

All the elements must be assessed objectively. We do not have time to do that through oral evidence between now and 1 May. The issue should be discussed in the next parliamentary session in the context of animal welfare legislation.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am mindful of what you say about animal welfare. It is right to write to the Executive to ask whether it will consider the issue and others that Paul Martin and Lord James have raised, particularly on the showing or breeding of animals involving alleged cruelty. However, it might consult on the matter for four years. We might want to give it a fillip. Michael Matheson said that a member who reads the Official Report of the meeting might consider introducing a member's bill to put a foot on the accelerator pedal for the Executive.

Paul Martin Lab Glasgow Springburn
link

There is an opportunity for the committee, or the new committee after the election, to consider animal exhibition. The petition relates to many other matters. The petitioner raises an important principle. It will not help other animals if we consider it in isolation. We tend to find that when people are prohibited from a particular practice, it creates a loophole elsewhere. I am not saying that that is the case here, but when you legislate for one case, you often leave something open in another area. Exhibition is an important issue, and the petitioners have rightly raised it. This could be the start of the process of dealing with the issue.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Are you saying that our letter to the Executive should be constrained to practices involved in the breeding and showing of animals? Perhaps we should do that, as animal welfare is an enormous issue. The petitioners might want to note that it would be possible for them to find a friendly MSP to introduce a member's bill and accelerate progress on the wider issue—not only Clydesdale horses. I agree that we have not had the chance to take proper evidence and, as Paul Martin says, one approach might open the matter up. Those are two ways of dealing with the matter. Are we content with that? We will write a letter to the Executive and also perhaps write to the petitioners—someone else has picked up the petition on behalf of the original petitioner, who is deceased. They might want to find an MSP to introduce a member's bill—it might even be Sylvia Jackson.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I hear what you say, but I am concerned that that will take a long time. Is there nothing we can do in the interim? For example, paragraph 16 of the note from the clerk states that we could "ask the Scottish Executive to extend the applicability of the Farriers (Registration) Act 1975 to include the Highlands".We could take steps in the interim. I do not want us to do nothing and think that, four years down the line, a member's bill might address the matter.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

The suggestion in paragraph 16 is one of the things that could be done in the short term.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Yes. Do members also want to put the matter in the legacy paper, as unfinished business? We could note that the matter was on the agenda and note our recommendation. The point that I was making is that Sylvia Jackson, who has worked on the matter and has followed it through, might take the matter forward.

Maureen Macmillan Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Yes, as a member's bill. However, I still think that we should write to the Executive to see whether anything can be done in the short term.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

So the legacy paper will suggest to the new committee that it should get the Executive's response to a suggestion in paragraph 16.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

Is that all? Will we not consider the petition further? I do not think that we should hand the petition over to the next committee except to say that we have considered it and believe that the best way to deal with couping is through a member's bill, and to say that we have asked the Executive to extend the Farriers (Registration) Act 1975 to the Highlands and Islands and Skye.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We will ask the Executive to consider consulting on the practices of breeding and showing animals that might be cruel.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

Is that within the committee's remit? I do not think that we should be saying that.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Unfortunately, the petition has come to the committee because it seeks to create criminal offences. It was referred to us by the Scottish Executive justice department because it is responsible for criminal sanctions behind the protection of domestic and captive wild animals. The petition came to us because the committee shadows the minister. I originally thought of the Rural Development Committee—

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

You were talking about the wider issue of animal welfare.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

No, I was talking about criminal sanctions.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

No. Earlier on you were talking about asking the Executive to consider the general issue of animal welfare.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

You must have misunderstood. I narrowed it down and said that we cannot just open up consideration because the issue of animal welfare is so large. Any involvement would be related to the breeding and showing of animals and whether cruel practices are being used—whether docking tails, couping or whatever. I narrowed it down to that. I was not talking about the whole issue of animal welfare because that would involve issues such as animal transportation.We can do that because the remit of the justice department includes responsibility for criminal sanctions behind the protection of domestic and captive wild animals, so that covers domestic animals.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

But all that the committee has considered is the couping of Clydesdale horses.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

I do not understand where you are coming from. I am talking about what we are putting in the legacy paper. All we have to say is that we have asked the minister to consider the option given in paragraph 16 of the committee's paper, and that if couping is to be considered further, it would be best if that were done through a member's bill.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Yes, but the other point I thought we had agreed is that we would ask the Executive to consult and hold its own inquiry into the treatment of domestic animals for show purposes. It does not mean that we will do anything with it. We are not asking for anything to be done about the huge general issue of animal welfare, because it is enormous.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

Exactly. I would not want to give the new committee the impression that that is what we want to happen.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

It certainly came across that way from what you were saying.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We will have to agree to differ because I thought that I had made it clear that we were talking about the breeding of animals for show purposes, which Paul Martin and Wendy Alexander raised. The bigger issue of animal welfare would be something for the Rural Development Committee to deal with.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Okay. Perhaps you missed that.After that little debate, are we agreed that we should note in the legacy paper that we have written to the Executive and that we expect a specific response about the Farriers (Registration) Act 1975? Sylvia Jackson will note that we have recommended that the issue might be a matter for a member's bill, just to keep the foot on the accelerator pedal.Members indicated agreement.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We have already agreed to take the next agenda item on the draft legacy paper in private.

Meeting continued in private until 16:15.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Tuesday 4 February 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 3
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Alternatives to Custody Inquiry Committee business · 189
  4. Convener's Report Procedure · 23
  5. Petitions Petitions · 13
  6. Petitions Petitions · 11
  7. Petitions Petitions · 35

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.