Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Carbeth Hutters (PE14)

Tuesday 4 February 2003 Justice 1 Committee Petitions 13 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

13 contributions
Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I reconvene the meeting—if that is the right phrase. Let us turn to item 5, on petitions, and try to keep within our schedule. I refer members to paper J1/03/3/12, which gives the background to the petition from the hutters. Some of us visited the issue almost four years ago. Members are asked to consider the options that are outlined in the paper or to come up with others of their own. We have received responses from the Executive and the minister. It is a bit rich of the minister to say: "there was very little contribution from respondents as to the content of the legislation."That is not what ordinary people are supposed to come up with.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

I was surprised to find that the issue is still being considered. I thought that it had been resolved. I am sure that it was the subject of one of the first members' business debates that we had in the Parliament. The issue has now been going on for almost four years. Apart from the fact that local negotiations have taken place, we do not seem to be any further forward.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I think—I hope that I am not incorrect—that the minister advised us that the matter might be addressed in the land reform legislation, but that has come to nothing.Members have the minister's response and some options for consideration. Can I take the views of the committee? I appreciate the fact that"legislation to protect hutters would be contrary to the fundamental principles of Scots law".In Scots law, when land is owned by someone, whatever is built on it belongs to the owner of the land. Nonetheless, in its initial report, the former Justice and Home Affairs Committee took the view that, back in the 1930s, the number of huts was restricted and it was clear which properties would come under the definition of huts. We decided that it was not beyond the wit of anyone to come up with legislation to protect those very special things.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

Let me float something. If we write to the Executive, it will perhaps eat a wee bit of humble pie, but it is still a stand-off at the end of the day. I recall trying to deal with the matter when I was the minister with responsibility for housing, but it was batted backwards and forwards between the committee and the Executive. Of course, for reasons of natural justice, I thought that it was a disgrace that people were being thrown off their land. Members can imagine me throwing my weight around, trying to do something about it. The response that I received was that there were going to be four major bills on land and housing, whereas the petition concerned an anomaly that affected one community, and that I should remember that this is a Parliament.If we were Westminster—I say this with respect—how would we handle the matter so as to have it resolved in the next session? Could we explore the possibility of a member's bill for which we could seek the Executive's support?

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I was going to suggest that the committee might consider introducing a committee bill on the subject. The committee report fully supports the introduction of legislation for the hutters, and the former Justice and Home Affairs Committee's bill on domestic abuse, which became the Protection from Abuse (Scotland) Act 2001, has set a precedent. We may want to put that suggestion in our legacy paper.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I agree completely with that. Irrespective of the individual case, as a national Parliament, legislating for the nation—not a souped-up regional council—we should start setting the terms of what is appropriate for members' bills and committee bills and what is appropriate for the Executive. Our legacy paper might make reference to that.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We would have access to the non-Executive bills unit to draft a committee bill, whereas a member's bill might struggle.

Michael Matheson SNP Central Scotland
link

It might help a future Justice 1 Committee to consider the matter if it had a response from the Executive on the specific problems that exist. Therefore, we should write to the Executive and put in the legacy paper what Wendy Alexander has suggested.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Are we agreed that we will not bother going into all the issues, as we have been at this for such a long time, but will ask the Executive what principles make legislation for the hutters impossible and what legislative solutions it can suggest? We can then recommend a committee bill on the subject, given that the former Justice and Home Affairs Committee was unanimous in its initial report.Members indicated agreement.

link

No. I have no direct interest in the Carbeth hutters. However, the small company of which I am an unpaid director has a property that has a ground rent.

Christine Grahame SNP The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I was being mischievous. Of course there are other hutters besides the Carbeth hutters. We have a paper on the subject and we know our way round it. Let us go for the suggested option.

  1. Scottish Parliament Justice 1 Committee Tuesday 4 February 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 3
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Alternatives to Custody Inquiry Committee business · 189
  4. Convener's Report Procedure · 23
  5. Petitions Petitions · 13
  6. Petitions Petitions · 11
  7. Petitions Petitions · 35

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.