Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Terrestrial Trunked Radio Communication Masts (PE650) TETRA Communications System (Health Aspects) (PE728)

Wednesday 23 June 2004 Communities Committee Petitions 17 contributions · 7 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

17 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

I should mention that a letter from the Deputy Minister for Communities was received yesterday and has been circulated to members. It sets out the Executive's response to a letter that was sent to the Minister for Communities by the Transport and Environment Committee in March 2003, a copy of which is attached, seeking comments on work carried out earlier that year by that committee in relation to telecommunications development. The exchange is relevant to our discussions on the terrestrial trunked radio petitions because it indicates that national planning policy guideline 19, on radio telecommunications, which also applies to TETRA masts, reflects the Transport and Environment Committee's concern that local authority moratoria on applications for mast development could prevent the optimum siting and design solutions from being achieved. The letter from the deputy minister points out that legitimate public concerns about the siting and design of masts are material planning considerations that can be taken into account when determining applications. I hope that that is of some help to members.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I read the Official Report of Mark Ruskell's members' business debate on this matter and, if there is one thing that is conclusive, it is that evidence about the health risks is inconclusive. Iain Smith, for example, said that we should stick to the facts and the evidence rather than scaremongering. It was a responsible and well-balanced debate but, at the end of the day, we still do not have the facts that would enable us to say that the public should not worry. This morning, we received a letter on behalf of people in Fife and Comrie that talks about"reports from Europe (France and Spain) of multiple cases of childhood cancers including leukaemias where masts have been placed on or very close to school premises."The police are conducting research and have some baseline data on the effect of TETRA equipment on policemen—according to the Association of Chief Police Officers in Scotland, the research has been conducted over 10 years and, according to the Scottish Police Federation, it has been conducted over 15 years. However, no research appears to have been done on the effect of the masts. It is impossible to say yes or no when people ask whether the masts are dangerous because the research is inconclusive, as the minister has confirmed.This is a health matter. I appreciate the demands on the time of the Health Committee, but perhaps we could ask SPICe to undertake a review of the available information or ask the Medical Research Council for an update on current research. That would ensure that we were all fully informed. I am simply not in a position to know whether the letter that we received on behalf of the Comrie and Fife residents is scaremongering or not.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

The central point is whether, while we are waiting for that information, the masts can continue to be erected—I understand that there are still some in the pipeline. I would like us to take any action possible to support the petitioners. If we know that some research is due to be published soon, it seems reasonable that there should be a postponement of any pending applications.

Mark Ruskell Green Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Clearly, this issue relates to the planning system as the planning system is approving TETRA masts across Scotland. However, the planning system relies almost exclusively on the guidelines that have been established by the National Radiological Protection Board, which cover the health issues that Mary Scanlon was talking about. The concern that the petitioners have with the NRPB guidelines is that those guidelines do not acknowledge that TETRA masts pulse, despite the fact that scientists have recorded them pulsing. Further, despite the fact that there have been more studies that show that TETRA masts could have health effects than there have been studies that do not, the guidelines do not acknowledge that there could be health effects. The guidelines do not deal with pulsing, which is the key issue with TETRA. They deal only with the heating effects. If the NRPB guidelines are the basis on which 700 TETRA masts are being approved throughout Scotland, there is a problem and a committee of the Parliament has to unpack the issue and the NRPB guidelines.There is a sense of urgency because the first police area in Scotland to use the system will start to do so in July, and the other areas will follow shortly after that. The issue needs to be unpacked.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I take seriously what Mark Ruskell said and I agree with what Patrick Harvie said earlier. The briefing says that the Scottish Police Federation's conclusion is that"no one can categorically state whether the TETRA system is safe or unsafe".We should be adopting the precautionary principle at this stage. In the meantime, I would certainly not like to see the masts being put next to schools, in residential areas or near where children are playing. We should be looking at the Executive's research report but, if the TETRA masts are being rolled out within months, that makes the situation difficult because the programme will have started.At this stage, the precautionary principle would lead me to say that we should be urging the Executive to have a moratorium at least until its report is published and we can have a look at it.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link

We obviously have to pay attention to the Executive's research, which comes out on the unhelpful date of 2 July.I am not clear what our powers are. We are not a planning authority so if, for the sake of argument, we passed a motion today that no more masts should be built until everything was sorted out, what would happen, if anything? I do not think that anything would happen. I do not think that the Executive can stop councils from giving planning permission. I would like to have some information about the planning side of the problem.This is an important issue and we should run with it. The first thing that will happen is that the Executive's report will come out on 2 July and, if we are unhappy with that when Parliament resumes in the autumn and, as Mark Ruskell has said, the Executive has not paid attention to some of the main issues, we can pursue that then. However, there is no point in rushing out to commission lots of research if the Executive has been researching at least some aspects of the issue.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

We are saying that we want planning authority to be refused while the masts are investigated further, but we do not have the authority to do that. It would also be misleading for us to say that if we held an inquiry, that would be the effect, because it would not. Given that, at best, the jury is out on the evidence, I do not think that it would be appropriate for the committee to make that decision at the moment without having more information. It is the same old argument about planning authorities not being able to stop telecommunications masts from being put up in response to perceived fears about health because that issue is dealt with elsewhere. Planning authorities can deal only with the planning criteria.The evidence comes out on 2 July. Mary Scanlon has talked about gathering any other evidence that might be available and we could reflect on that at our away day. That might be a reasonable idea. Planning facilitates policy views that are taken elsewhere and I think that that is why we are having difficulty with this issue because the health and other issues have to be addressed elsewhere.That would not stop those who feel strongly about those issues from continuing to push them in any way that they can. Would that be acceptable?

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

We cannot really do anything else, given that the report will be published very soon. I am not usually minded to keep continuing petitions, because I do not think that it is fair to the petitioners, who might think that we are discussing a petition and keeping it live because we do not want to do anything about it or do not know what to do. In this case, however, I do not think that we have any other choice, given the imminence of the report. If we continue our consideration until our first or second meeting back after the summer, that will be a fair way of proceeding, given that we are not in possession of the full facts and given that a report will be published in the next couple of weeks.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Scott Barrie has just said what I was going to say. We cannot make a decision because we do not have enough evidence. We are getting evidence on 2 July and the only decision that we can make, as responsible parliamentarians, is to examine that information and make the matter an agenda item at our away day.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

However, it would be reasonable to alert the petitioners to the fact that, if health issues emerge from the evidence, they cannot be dealt with by this committee looking at the planning aspects of the matter. That dialogue would have to be opened up again. However, we should, as a minimum, make a commitment to examine the evidence when we are preparing our forward work plan at our away day.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

That is something that the petitioners could reflect on. The previous petition on landfill had four elements to it, which covered the remits of four committees. That can raise difficulties. These petitions on TETRA masts have two elements—health and environment. As we do not control the Health Committee, perhaps future petitioners should submit separate petitions relating to specific aspects of their concern.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

That is a reasonable point to make. We could say that those are issues for another committee, but it is entirely a matter for that committee to decide its own priorities. Although petitions are an important part of the process, it is legitimate that the committee should decide itself what it is going to look at. I would contend that this committee has to steer a course according to what we consider to be the big issues. We should remain flexible enough to take on petitions at certain times, but we should not always feel obliged to move with the agenda of the petitioners as against the other agendas that the committee has developed. It is always a difficult balance to strike, but it is still reasonable that we should try to do that.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I understand the difficulties that members have in identifying specific actions that we can take that will be effective. I would like to suggest that, at the minimum, we should write to the Executive and explain our concerns about being unable to take a position on the petition because of the lack of evidence and the imminence of evidence becoming available. We should ask the Executive to consider what actions it could take to achieve a postponement until evidence is available to judge those questions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

To me, that would be going a step further than has been suggested. We could not make that judgment until we had seen the evidence.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

Even if the evidence were with us today, we would not be able to consider the matter seriously and make a decision about it today. We would need to be a bit more thorough than that. If the evidence had been published yesterday rather than being published on 2 July, we would not be making a decision today anyway, although we might have a bit more of a focus about how to take the petition forward. It is reasonable to suggest that we should await the publication of the Executive's research and that we should make a commitment to consider the issue in discussions on our work programme at the away day—whether we decide to reflect our views back to the Health Committee or to do something separately from that. Is that agreed?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Communities Committee Wednesday 23 June 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Items in Private Procedure · 13
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 60
  4. Planning Committee business · 60
  5. Petitions Petitions · 15
  6. Petitions Petitions · 17
  7. Away Day Committee business · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.