Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Landfill Sites (PE541 and PE543)

Wednesday 23 June 2004 Communities Committee Petitions 15 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

Item 4 is petitions. I welcome Mark Ruskell, who will attend for the item. We will deal first with PE541 and PE543. Do members have any comments?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have a suggestion. The paper on the petitions says that petition PE541 asks us to investigate"the impact of landfill sites on … health and environment … the rationale behind the proposed expansion of landfill sites … given the … EU landfill directives … more sustainable solutions to waste management and … the planning process".However, this committee does not deal with health or the environment. I noted somewhere that the Health Committee will appoint a reporter. I do not see in our papers a report from the Health Committee. I suggest that the clerks liaise with the other committees that have responsibility for the matters within the petitions, and put the information from other committees into a paper that we can agree on.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

The Health Committee said that if we wish to conduct an inquiry, it will give us a reporter. It has not expressed a view on whether we should have an inquiry or on whether it would do anything to assist us, other than to appoint a reporter. There is no indication from the Health Committee that it is prioritising the matter in its work load.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am just not minded to dismiss the petitions or refer them on. We need to collate the information. There is so much of what people might call scaremongering, nimbyism or general concern about the effect of landfill sites. We have a responsibility to review the evidence and bring together information on the four strands that we are asked to consider; otherwise I see no basis for referring the petition on.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

I understand the strong feelings that are held by those who live in communities that are close to landfill sites. I have experience of such a situation in my constituency, where people in one small village have lived with landfill sites on their doorstep for years as a result of the quarrying that had gone on around them. I know what it is like and I know people's concerns. Whether the health issues are real or perceived, the situation is a worry for people who live near landfill sites.We should pay heed to landfill sites when we examine the forthcoming planning bill. Just because there is a hole in the ground that has been quarried over a period of time, it is unacceptable for us to expect that that hole has to be filled in and that the community that happens to live close the hole has to live with that. We have to put in place a mechanism to protect such communities. We should examine the matter closely when we deal with future planning legislation.As I understand it, planning processes have been adhered to in the two areas referred to in petitions PE541 and PE543, but that is not to say that the processes are right for the times in which we live.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

I seek advice on dealing with a petition through an inquiry. If we agreed to hold an inquiry and the Health Committee appointed a reporter, would that enable us to address the health questions? If so, I would be keen to argue that we should do that. To argue that we should ignore the issue because it is low down on another committee's agenda could be seen as a double insult to the people who lodged the petitions.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

I was not arguing that. We have been asked to consider the planning elements of the petitions. If an inquiry were to be held, we would need to do an awful lot more than simply have a reporter from the Health Committee come along, because we would be looking at the planning bits. It is for the Health Committee to determine what priority it gives to the health aspects. I am not dismissing anybody's concerns. We could not include the health issues in an inquiry; we could do that only in liaison with the Health Committee.

Patrick Harvie Green Glasgow
link

What is the function of the Health Committee's reporter participating in our inquiry?

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

Perhaps in our discussion of the planning issues we would flag up health issues that the reporter would report back on.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link

I was going to make that point. I presume that the Health Committee has decided that, if this committee considers the aspects of the petition that relate to this committee, the reporter will report back to the Health Committee on any concerns for it. However, the letter from the convener of the Health Committee does not indicate whether, if we decided to purse the matter, it would take up the health issues. I do not see the point of the Health Committee appointing a reporter only to report back to it what has been said at this committee. If we decide to have an inquiry, the situation will be complex because the Environment and Rural Development Committee has already considered the petitions and concluded its consideration of them because it believes that it has examined the issues in its national waste plan inquiry.Cathie Craigie is right to say that, rather than keep the petitions live for the sake of it because they contain significant issues, perhaps the best way to deal with the matter is to ensure that we consider the issues thoroughly when we examine the changes that are likely to be introduced on planning regulation. She is right to say that the petitions have shown up weaknesses in the current planning regime; the decisions that have been made are in no way wrong in law, but perhaps the law has not kept up with current practice. We should consider the issues that petitions PE541 and PE543 flag up when we consider the planning legislation rather than have a specific inquiry on them.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link

My proposal is on the same lines. Provided that consideration of the planning bill is months rather than years ahead and provided that we can give a guarantee that the people involved in those two communities will be invited to come to give evidence when we carry out pre-legislative scrutiny of the planning bill, we should pursue the issues that have been raised then. Although that involves a delay, the petitioners will get a better kick at the ball than they would if we rushed through an inquiry, which might not be terribly satisfactory.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

The message that the committee wants to give is that we take the issue seriously and understand the concerns of local communities. We can best help them by informing ourselves of their views when we deal with the planning legislation. If, by the time of our away day, we are getting signals that the planning bill will not be before us until much later, we could put one of the suggested courses of action into the forward plan for the following year. At this stage we can give a commitment not to let the issue lie. Our preferred option is to address the issues in our consideration of the planning bill but, if we cannot do that, we can explore our options when we come back after the summer recess.I note that, although the Environment and Rural Development Committee has concluded its consideration of the petitions, it has said that it will continue to consider the issues raised in them as appropriate. Therefore, that committee has not dismissed the issues raised in the petitions; it has also woven them into its work. Is that an acceptable approach?

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Yes.Scott Barrie's point about the petitions is relevant. As he said, we can of course take on board the planning issues that they raise in our scrutiny of the forthcoming planning bill and we would be minded to do that. We note from the Environment and Rural Development Committee that it is keeping a watchful eye on the issues raised that relate to it, so the only outstanding issue—I do not know whose responsibility it is—is the health concerns.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow Pollok
link

We have drawn those concerns to the attention of the Health Committee and we can do so again.We are agreeing that we will not consider the petitions further at this stage but that, on the issues highlighted in the petition that impact on planning, we will ensure that the petitioners have a role in our pre-legislative scrutiny of the planning bill. However, if the bill is not timely, we will come back to the issue at our away day. It would also be helpful, as the clerk has suggested, for a note to be prepared that outlines for the committee all the issues that have come through in petitions that we have said we will consider when the planning bill comes to us. That will concentrate our minds and ensure that we consider the issues at that time and that we are making a real commitment to the petitioners. Is that acceptable?

Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Communities Committee Wednesday 23 June 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Items in Private Procedure · 13
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 60
  4. Planning Committee business · 60
  5. Petitions Petitions · 15
  6. Petitions Petitions · 17
  7. Away Day Committee business · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.