Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Hepatitis C

Wednesday 11 December 2002 Health and Community Care Committee Committee business 261 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

261 contributions · showing 1–200
Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Item 3 is on hepatitis C. For some time, the committee has been considering the position of individuals who were infected with hepatitis C as a result of contaminated blood products and other health interventions. In October 2001, we published our report. One of the report's recommendations was that the Executive set up an expert group to consider not only financial assistance to those who had been affected but the wider issue of the national health service making no-fault compensation payments. I am delighted that Lord Ross, the chair of that expert group on financial and other assistance for NHS injury, is with us. Thank you for attending, for your expert group's work and for your written submission, which we have in addition to the expert group's interim report. I suggest that you make a short statement to the committee, after which we will ask questions.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

That is very kind of you. Needless to say, I am pleased to have the opportunity to appear before the committee. As you can imagine, I wish simply to support the contents of the preliminary report. I stress that the report is only preliminary—I am sure that the committee appreciates that we are still working on the final report. I am also sure that you know from the preliminary report that a number of issues have been left over. No doubt they will appear in our final report, which we hope to present at the end of the year.As the committee is aware, we made three preliminary recommendations. As far as I understand, the minister accepted recommendations 2 and 3 and said that they were already being implemented or that steps were being taken to implement them. The minister did not accept the main recommendation, which was for payments to be made to those who can demonstrate that they became infected with hepatitis C as a result of receiving blood or blood products from the NHS in Scotland.That is all that I wish to say. Members have my written statement, but I thought that it might be helpful to indicate some additional views. If I can help by answering questions, I would be happy to do so.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

We will ask you questions on the basis of your preliminary report, but focus on financial and other assistance to those who have been infected with hepatitis C, rather than consider the broader question of no-fault compensation, on which you are still working. We might return to that at some point.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

Would you be so kind as to outline how you arrived at the lump-sum figures that are outlined in recommendation 1? Do those figures adequately take into account the level of loss, including psychological distress, that some sufferers experienced?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I can tell you roughly how we did that exercise. We had the assistance of advisers, who are also the minister's advisers, and a lot of information on the sort of payments that had been made by the Macfarlane Trust. However, there is no precise way to arrive at a figure. Damages and compensation can never fully compensate anyone for their loss; in some cases, they are not much more than recognition that the recipient has suffered loss.We recommended the initial lump sum of £10,000 because we considered that every person who had been infected with hepatitis C from blood or blood products deserved something for what is sometimes called the psychological effect. Groups that represent those people also placed information before us, in addition to which some others and I had the benefit of meeting one or two individuals who had suffered. It was brought home clearly to us that once any sufferer has been told that they have been infected, even if they show no active symptoms, they are concerned about whether they may transmit hepatitis C to their families—their spouses or their children. They are anxious about whether their condition will deteriorate and what will happen if it does. That was brought home to us by one individual whom we met, who said that there was a social price to be paid. That individual had found that people who had been friendly before no longer wished to know them, and that there is public fear and stigma.As the committee will no doubt have heard before, people with the condition also had problems getting mortgages, insurance and so on. We thought that everyone deserved something, and the £10,000 is simply a recognition of that.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Your supplementary written evidence goes into more detail about the number of people whom you estimate may have been infected by hepatitis C. You come to a figure of about 4,000, many of whom are already deceased. You say that the figures are based on "numerous assumptions" made by one of the advisers to the group. How robust are those figures?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

They are the best figures that we could get. As my written statement says, they are based on many assumptions. Those assumptions may be misplaced, but I repeat that they were the best figures that we could get. They are partly based on figures from England, which may be a criticism of them as the proportions will not necessarily be the same up here but, on the whole, we regard them as robust. The working group was reasonably satisfied that it was putting forward the worst-case scenario, and it did not think that there was any likelihood that the figures would be exceeded. In fact, the figures may well not be attained. That is all that I can say about the reliability or robustness of the figures.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Are you equally confident about the estimate that the take-up rate among the people who are infected would be about 31 per cent?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Again, we based that estimate on the information that we received, particularly from the Macfarlane Trust, and we have explained why we think that the take-up figure would be as low as 31 per cent. That might be a surprising figure, but many people who were infected do not know, and perhaps never will know, that they were infected. Some people who were infected may have died for reasons unconnected with the infection. That is why the figure is so low, and we are reasonably satisfied that that is a proper estimate.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

The report said that everyone infected with hepatitis C should get some form of financial assistance as a matter of principle. From what you have said, both today and in the expert group report, that appears to be an important principle. What is your response to the Minister for Health and Community Care's suggestion that assistance should be directed only at those who have suffered long-term harm or hardship?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I do not agree with the minister. I do not think that I am speaking out of turn if I say that he was good enough to see me before the report was published and to tell me what his decision was going to be. From that discussion, my impression was that he was not very sympathetic to the idea that there is a psychological effect on everyone who develops the infection. We think that such an effect exists, which is where we differ from the minister. He is not as impressed by that aspect as the group, which unanimously concluded that everyone should get compensation. That said, there is no doubt that the people who are severely infected and have developed cirrhosis or liver cancer are the worst cases, and one would certainly want them to be compensated. We felt strongly that everyone should get a lump sum.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In point 12 of your written statement, you mention the initial lump sum of £10,000, which you say would be "a first step in righting the wrong done to these people". Does that mean that you would be likely to overrun the estimated £89 million?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

No. Perhaps I could have expressed myself more clearly. I felt that the first step towards righting the wrong would be to give a lump sum to everybody who was infected. The next step would be to consider those who develop chronic hepatitis C, who would get an additional £40,000. After that, we would consider the worst cases. Those are the three suggested steps.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Your preliminary report states that the second step would be to give"an additional lump sum of £40,000 to those who develop chronic hepatitis C."What time scale do you envisage for that payment?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I cannot give a time scale because it would depend on when sufferers develop additional symptoms. I stress that our figures are total figures that would not come from one year's budget but that would be spread over several years. I cannot tell you how many years because it would depend on when people develop the symptoms. Some people might develop symptoms quickly, but they might take years to develop in others.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Are you recommending that, because people might develop chronic hepatitis C in 10 years' time, a sum of money should be set aside in a trust to make payments in, for example, 10 or 20 years' time?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

The mechanics of such a system would depend on the minister, of course. For example, he might want to pay money into a discretionary trust all in one go, or drip-feed the money into such a trust over successive years, as required. Our point is that if somebody gets the lump sum of £10,000 and goes on to develop chronic hepatitis C, he or she should get an additional £40,000.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am concerned about the time scale because we are discussing something that happened 14 years ago. We are talking about many people who are deceased but whose families still have a claim. I am concerned about the accuracy of medical records and about the litigation that is associated with claims, not just for the past but well into the future.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I do not expect any litigation because the payments would be ex gratia payments from a discretionary trust. The supposition is that there will be no litigation because there is no legal liability on the national health service. We accept that the NHS has no legal liability, but we believe that it has a moral obligation. The cases should be an exception to the general rule that the NHS does not pay unless it has legal liability.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So you are satisfied that those who would be entitled to the payments, including past cases, would be able to access them. I think that your report states that 2,800 of those who were infected are deceased. Are you satisfied that their families would still have the evidence to make out a claim?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I do not know. The first paragraph of recommendation 1 states that payment should be made to "all people who can demonstrate, on the balance of probabilities, that they received blood … and were subsequently found to be infected."I acknowledge that it might not be easy for some people to establish that. However, we decided that it would be necessary for anyone who claimed to show that, in all probability, they received infected blood and subsequently developed the condition.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Many people who are unaware of their infection could be entitled to the payments. In some cases, other medical conditions may have taken their lives.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

That is right.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Your preliminary report pointed out that the cost would be between £62 million and a worst-case scenario of £89 million. However, you made it clear that the Scottish health budget has a £120 million surplus. Indeed, you referred in your written submission to the £40 million budget for the Holyrood building, which went wrong, but which is nevertheless being bailed out—that budget is now more than £300 million. Your submission has an almost puzzled tone about why the Minister for Health and Community Care did not decide to pay out right away when your report was issued.One factor to which your submission refers is that Westminster has decided not to pay out to similar hepatitis C victims. You say:"However, there is no reason why a different view should not be taken in Scotland. Indeed that is something that can, and in appropriate cases, should happen when powers have been devolved."Will you expand on that point? How strong a feature of the Executive's thinking was the argument that it should not pay out to the victims because England has not done so?

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Lord Ross can give his understanding of that issue.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I cannot speak for the Executive, but my working group considered many matters and was aware that a different view had been taken in England. We all felt strongly that it would not be a good answer to our recommendations—although I do not know whether it has been put forward as an answer—to say that because it has been decided south of the border not to give compensation, we should do the same. We must think about what is appropriate for Scotland and we have the power to do so.You said that there was some puzzlement in my paper as to why the minister did not accept our recommendation, but that is only partly true. I went out of my way to say that the working group recognises that the decision is political and is not for the group to make. We also appreciate that many competing demands are made on the health budget. That was why we insisted on being advised what the measures would cost. We did not want to make a firm recommendation if the figures appeared to us to be unreasonable. However, we felt that they were reasonable and that it ought to be possible for them to be accommodated in the health budget.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

So the group had a clear feeling that the minister was influenced by the fact that Westminster decided not to pay out.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I would not say that. I do not know whether that matter weighed with the minister. We knew that that decision had been taken in England and, in case anyone said we should follow the same line, we wanted to make it clear that we felt we were perfectly entitled to take a different view.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

As the convener said at the beginning of the meeting, we intend to discuss the matter and to sign off on it today, but as we have only your preliminary report, I am worried that the committee might not have sufficient evidence. I know that this is a difficult question, but how much is the report that you will produce at the end of the year likely to change from the preliminary report? Is that final report likely to contain anything that is important, appropriate or significant to the committee's deliberations today?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

No, I do not think so. We have indicated that we still have to consider a number of issues. As you know, our remit was to report by the end of the year and I am hopeful that we will do so. Obviously, our final report is fairly far forward, although we have not concluded it yet. It would be wrong for me to disclose the direction that the working group is taking with that report. I do not think that anything in our final report will bear on the matter that we are discussing today. I anticipate—I put it no higher—that our final report will reinforce the preliminary report. We certainly have not reached any different views.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So it is unlikely that there will be any changes or additional recommendations.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

None that will have a bearing on the issue that we are considering. There will be additional recommendations because we said that we would return to a number of issues that we highlighted in the preliminary report.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Those issues are not related to the issue that we are considering.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

They are not related to that particular matter.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I have a couple of points for clarity and for the record. One is to clarify that, although we have only the preliminary report, it is the final one on hepatitis C because the final report will deal with other issues.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

That is right.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I want to be absolutely clear about the costing of the recommendations. Is it fair to say that £89 million would be the maximum cost to the Scottish Executive? The period over which sufferers would draw down the money is difficult to determine, but it might be several years.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

It will be over some years, yes.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

In your view, then, there would be no problem if the Scottish Executive decided to make the £89 million available over a period of years—three years, for example.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

That is correct.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

That would not cause the trust any problem in beginning to make payments.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

No, it would not. That is precisely right. The estimate is our best one. We cannot guarantee this—no one can—but on the information that we have, we regard £89 million as the maximum figure and it would be allocated over a number of years. I anticipate that, if a discretionary trust were set up, there would be no problem if the money were given to it over a number of years.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I understand that that is what happened with the Macfarlane Trust.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Absolutely.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

Lord Ross, you mentioned that your advisers were the same as the Executive's advisers. From your discussions with the Minister for Health and Community Care, is it clear that he accepts the figures, especially the £89 million?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I could not say that that is the case. When I met the minister, we did not go into detail about that. He certainly did not suggest to me that our figures were inadequate, but only he can say whether he has received any other advice on, or refinement of, our figures. He did not suggest to me that our figures were wrong.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

You rightly point out that this is a devolved decision—it is a matter for the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Executive. Did your panel consider the possibility that Westminster might not agree with the Parliament's decision and could use its powers over the social security budget to claw back payments by withdrawing benefit from people who receive payments?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Any clawback would indeed depend on the United Kingdom Government. As I understand it, a derogation was granted in favour of the Macfarlane Trust, and one was certainly granted as far as CJD was concerned. A derogation would be one way of dealing with the matter. That is, as John McAllion says, within the power of the UK legislature. Our committee being composed as it was, we felt that the argument about social security payments was a technical one. The minister may raise the issue later—he raised it with me. We did not think that it was right that people who we felt were entitled to some payment should be denied that payment because of an argument over which fund the money should come from.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

It is entirely practical, in the devolved situation in which we find ourselves, for Scotland to make the payments and for a derogation to be granted, so that the money is not clawed back through social security.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Yes. That is how it seemed to us.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

How would you respond to fears that the awarding of ex gratia payments to those infected by hepatitis C through blood or blood products would set a costly precedent, which could lead to claims from many other groups or individuals?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Obviously, we thought of that possibility. It has been said that, if the award went through, we might find that people who had been in hospital and who had contracted some infection would claim that they, too, should be compensated. We did not think that that was really a risk, however. The Macfarlane Trust provision was introduced in 1988 and it did not lead to a flood of claims from other people who thought that they had been affected.We are suggesting that ex gratia payments be made. As we say in our reports, there are other cases in which ex gratia payments have been allowed. Those are very few in number and are very special. They form exceptions to the general rule that the health service pays only where there is legal liability. We did not feel that a dangerous precedent would be set in this case any more than was the case with the Macfarlane Trust. This is a very special situation and experience shows that cases such as Macfarlane or the compensation of people with CJD have not led to a flood of further claims. We do not believe that an acceptance of what we are proposing would establish a precedent leading to a flood of other claims.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I do not know whether you wish to comment on this. Since the publication of your preliminary report, it has been revealed that a number of haemophiliacs might also have been infected with new variant CJD through contaminated blood. Do you have any comment on the way in which that situation has been handled or on the delay in informing those patients?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I do not think that I could comment on that. That matter has come to light since our report was published.

Shona Robison SNP North East Scotland
link

Let me ask a slightly different question. Do you think that that information lends weight to the argument for a compensation package, given that it is yet another psychological blow to the group of people about whom we are talking?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

I suppose that is right. There is provision for compensating people who contract CJD, which we have mentioned. However, as you rightly say, that news must be yet another source of anxiety for those who know that they have contracted the hepatitis C virus.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Your third recommendation concerns legal aid. We seem to be talking about a group of people who have been let down by the legal system. Those whose cases come after 1988 have recourse to the Consumer Protection Act 1987, although that is a bizarre way in which to have to gain some kind of justice for contamination by a blood product. However, there is a history of problems in accessing legal aid for pursuing class actions. Our legal system does not seem to have stood up in comparison with the systems south of the border and elsewhere in the world. Can you give us a flavour of the kind of evidence that you took on that issue and of what you are suggesting, bearing in mind the fact that you have said that the minister appears to have accepted what you are suggesting?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Yes, I can. I find myself in the unusual situation of having to say that, in relation to part of the legal system, people seem to do rather better south of the border than we do here. Nevertheless, that is true in the case of legal aid. The legal aid authority in England is different from the legal aid authority here. For example, in England the authority can grant a sort of interim legal aid certificate that covers all the work of preparing the case and getting medical reports. We cannot do that here, as legal aid can be granted only once probable cause has been established. Therefore, legal aid cannot be granted until all the preliminary inquiries have been made. The preliminary inquiries have to be covered by advice and assistance.As we say in the report, we received evidence from the Scottish Legal Aid Board and solicitors that successive applications have to be made for funds to get new experts, to have the patient examined and to get the records collated. All those issues lead to successive applications being made. Sometimes they are granted; sometimes they are not. Our impression is that the process is much better in England, where people can be given an interim legal aid certificate to cover all that, so that they do not have to keep coming back to ask for additional money. For that to be done here would require primary legislation, as the Legal Aid (Scotland) Act 1986 provides that legal aid can be given only once probable cause is established.We discussed the matter with the Scottish Legal Aid Board and felt that it must try to improve the giving of advice and assistance. That is what it is doing. It is developing a template to make it easier for solicitors who want to make applications electronically, for example, to speed up the process. Steps are being taken. They will not lead to a situation that is as good as the one in England. Nevertheless, it should be possible to improve the provision of legal aid.We are satisfied that there is a problem of access, as you say, and that it is more difficult to get a clinical negligence case off the ground in Scotland than it is in England. That might be one reason why, as our figures show, far fewer actions are raised in Scotland. Our group includes solicitors who deal with such claims. As well as receiving evidence from solicitors, we have seen the Scottish Legal Aid Board and we are satisfied that the problem exists. That is why we have made certain suggestions for improvements.One suggestion is that, instead of using probable cause as the test for an application for legal aid in such cases, the test that applies in criminal legal aid should be introduced. That test states that legal aid can be granted in the interests of justice. That would avoid having to establish probable cause before one could obtain a legal aid certificate. That is why we made the suggestion.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Primary legislation would be required to make the system as good as the one in England.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Yes.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Your second recommendation is that the Scottish Executive should fund and develop other mechanisms for supporting people who suffer from hepatitis C. That has been the main thrust of the Executive's approach all along. The Executive has resisted the financial assistance route and has said that it would give assistance in other ways. Is such assistance being provided in practice or is the process still at the planning stage?

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Although I do not have a great deal of personal knowledge of the situation, I have spoken to people who suffer from the hepatitis C virus who said that they were not given enough information. That might have been some time ago, however. I am prepared to accept that steps are being taken to improve matters, as the minister said in his letter to me. We thought that it was important to highlight the need to provide assistance. If that is already being done, all well and good. The information that we received indicated that it was necessary.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

As there are no other questions, I thank Lord Ross for his evidence and for the work that he has done with the members of the expert group. I hope that he will convey to the group our good wishes and thanks.

Lord Ross Expert Group on Financial and other Assistance for NHS Injury
link

Thank you very much.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Our next witness is Mr Dolan. We have met before. I hope that we will not need to keep meeting like this. Do you wish to make an opening statement before we ask questions?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Yes, I would like to make a statement. I have a croaky voice and it is getting croakier as time goes on.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Take the time to pour yourself a glass of water, if you want. Please do not feel rushed. I am afraid that we only have water.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

That is all that I need today.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

We are the Health and Community Care Committee—we should take things seriously.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Thank you for giving me the opportunity to meet the committee. I do not consider myself to be in the same mould as members of the Parliament, who are experienced politicians and debaters, or as people in the building across the road—the great orators of the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland. I speak to the committee as a member of the Haemophilia Society. I will endeavour to share with members our reaction to the expert group's report.We welcome the report that was produced by the group that is chaired by Lord Ross. We have just had an elegant explanation of that report. As a member of the expert group, I am aware of the considerable discussions that took place about the situation for those who were infected with hepatitis C as a result of infected blood products or blood transfusions. We do not understand why the minister appears to have rejected the expert group's unanimous recommendation of compensation, even although the group's members have expertise in medicine, nursing, legal services, ethics and health service administration.Yesterday, somebody with haemophilia and hepatitis C asked me why I was wasting my time speaking to the members of the Parliament, because, as I was told, "They don't listen." However, I come here with hope and faith that the Scottish Parliament supports and believes in the cause of compensation for those who have been infected with hepatitis C through blood products. I do not believe that the 80 MSPs from all parties who signed a motion on hepatitis C were wrong. I do not think that that was part of a political game of MSPs signing motions just for the sake of it. I would like to believe that they signed the motion because of their concern and because they recognised the injustice for people who have been infected with hepatitis C.In October last year, I welcomed the committee's unanimous report following its inquiry into why people had been infected by hepatitis C through their national health service treatment. It is sad that, almost a year from that report's publication, Mr Chisholm has rejected its findings. The MSPs who signed the motion and the committee's members seem to have listened, so why is the Scottish Executive not listening?In a recent debate in the House of Lords, Lord Hunt, who is a UK health minister, said:"There is little point in having devolution—certainly for NHS issues—unless the Scottish Executive and Parliament can come to their own view on such matters, as this Government do."—Official Report, House of Lords, 21 November 2002; Vol 641, c 507.We welcomed the Health and Community Care Committee's support following the debate in the Scottish Parliament. We also welcomed the fact that the expert group would include people with hepatitis C and the expert group's preliminary report. The expert group, which Lord Ross chaired, took time to examine seriously the hepatitis C issues and how they affected people physically, socially and psychologically, before it reached its unanimous recommendation that there should be compensation. When the Minister for Health and Community Care welcomed the report on 6 November but seemed to dismiss its recommendations, I was astonished, disappointed and angry, like most people who are affected. What was the point of having an expert group then ignoring its main recommendations?For people with haemophilia, that is yet another mountain to climb. For years, every time we have reached the top of a mountain, we have found that, when the cloud lifts, there is another mountain to climb. However, I—or perhaps we—do not believe that that is insurmountable. The Executive cannot dismiss two unanimous reports and the support of MSPs. If the Parliament is willing and committed, it can find a financial solution and implement the expert group's recommendations. There should be no reason why Scotland cannot lead the way in providing justice for people who have been harmed through use of blood products.I have loads and loads of pieces of paper but I do not think that the committee wants me to read them all out.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

How about us moving on to asking you questions?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Sure.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

If, at the end, you feel that we did not cover something, you can cover it in a short statement.

Shona Robison SNP North East Scotland
link

You told the committee that the Haemophilia Society took a favourable view of the preliminary report. In fact, you put it more strongly: you said that the society supports the preliminary report. Will you say a little more about the report's recommendations that found most favour with the society? The compensation package is the key recommendation, but do you want to draw the committee's attention to anything else that the society felt strongly about?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

We have focused on the main issue of compensation, for which we have battled for years. As Lord Ross explained, the figure that was given is just one figure. However, I do not believe that anyone can put a price on what the effect has been on people's health. Most people who have haemophilia and hepatitis C do not want money; we want our health. We ask why this happened to us. That is the main point.Lord Ross referred to the recommendations. People who have tried to go through the legal system or get class action cases have been thwarted the whole way. Obviously, any change in the legal system would be beneficial, but the legal system has not benefited us.When the committee produced its report in October last year, it recommended that compensation should be given at that time. That recommendation was made on the basis that financial provision should be made for those who were suffering so that they would not have to wait for a public inquiry, by which time they might be dead.However, if the minister now rejects what we have said, there should be a public inquiry. Nowadays, many people agree that there should be a public inquiry because they have seen what has happened in America and other places where charges have been brought against people. For instance, after five years of investigation, the Canadian police recently charged four doctors from the blood transfusion service and a drugs company with clinical negligence.Perhaps our situation should be seen in the same way as that of victims of a criminal offence, who can receive compensation. Last week, a well-known law lord in Westminster asked why, given that the Government does not need to pay money for victims of crime but still does, things should be any different for people with haemophilia.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Mr Dolan, you may to some extent have answered my question. As people know, you have fought this case for many years. What will you do if, after all those attempts, the minister is still adamant that he will not pay out compensation? I know that some people from the Haemophilia Society and elsewhere are prepared to go into the long negotiations of suing the commercial companies in the United States that provided the bad blood products to Scotland. Are you prepared to go down that trail? How long might that take?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I think that the American lawyers who have been over here will represent only the limited group of people with haemophilia who got blood from a particular pharmaceutical company in America. As far as I understand it, all the cases in America that were based on the same complaint against that company have been settled out of court. The pharmaceutical company obviously assumed that, if the cases had gone to court, the compensation awarded would have been greater—something like 10 times greater. The American lawyers came over here not because they wanted to visit Scotland but because they are interested in the 30 per cent of any takings that they could receive. There is also that element.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

However, if the minister does not offer a proper settlement, you might be forced to devote more years of your life to this struggle. How many years—I know that it is quite a number—have you already devoted to it?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I do not want to say my age, but I feel as though I have been doing this for a lifetime. A few years back, the Westminster Government eventually decided to pay compensation to the surviving Japanese prisoners of war—most of the prisoners of war had died. From the way things are going just now, I suspect that most of us will be dead before compensation is awarded. The suggestion that appears in the media—I am sure that the minister will confirm whether it is correct—is that the folk who have reached a more serious stage will be like the prisoners of war, in that they will be given money just at the point at which they are dying. People need financial assistance now. There are issues relating to insurance, but the matter is not just about insurance. I can give examples of losses of earnings.If the Health and Community Care Committee thinks that the issue is important, it can ask for a public inquiry or use rule 9.15 of the standing orders, which is on committee bills. As an all-party committee, it could take a bill to the Parliament. This session of Parliament is approaching the end of its life, but that does not prevent the resurrection of a bill after May.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

We hope that some life is left in us all.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Yes. A public inquiry would be ideal.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Why has Britain never held a public inquiry, either by order of Westminster or the Scottish Parliament, but Ireland has?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I do not know. Perhaps there are too many skeletons in the cupboard that people do not want to come out. A public inquiry, chaired by Lord Phillips, was held on BSE. The report said that there had been secrecy in the establishment. People received awards as a result of that inquiry.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Big business is also tied up in the matter. People have been infected by bad products from the US and elsewhere.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Yes. We know that faulty blood products from which people have contracted HIV, for example, came from prisoners at the Angola penitentiary in Louisiana. A doctor carried out trials, indicated a problem and suggested to the pharmaceutical company that it should stop what it was doing. He received his P45 as a reward. Cases have been recorded in Arkansas, where the previous President of the United States was governor.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Yes. Clinton was governor when prisoners were bled in the Cummins unit and other jails. Blood licences had to be withdrawn.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

You mentioned that you had information about economic impacts on people in respect of loss of earnings. Will you tell us about that?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Yes. It should be recognised that the payment of sums of £50,000—that is, £10,000 and £40,000—for a middle category case will in many instances be well below what would otherwise be awarded in damages. People who lose their jobs as a result of their condition, for example, would lose future earnings. We could be talking about sums of up to £250,000.The matter is not just about insurance; it is about loss of earnings. We have examples of people who have been in business as taxi drivers and long-distance drivers who could no longer drive as a result of hepatitis and fatigue. They have lost their houses and their families have broken up—such things have happened.There is also an impact on people's employment prospects. Suddenly, when people find out that you have hepatitis C, your promotion prospects or your future in your employment cease, whether it is in teaching or any other field of work. For instance, there are civilian workers in police offices who cannot say anything to their employer about the fact that they have hepatitis C. The police come in and say, "We've got another scumbag drug addict here with hep C." That does not help.On loss of earnings, people lose their employment; insurance and mortgages are additional factors. There was a meeting this week, which I am sure the minister will talk about, with insurance and mortgage companies. The mortgage companies say that there is no problem getting a mortgage and insurance companies say that the questions about hepatitis C and HIV will be removed from their forms. However, removing the questions from the forms does not preclude the fact that if you fail to disclose some medical information on your form, your insurance will, at the end of the day, be void. Most of us know that trying to get insurance is costly. Loadings mean that premiums are two, three or four times as much, or sufferers are told that the amount of money that they will have to pay is so much that it is not in their interest to pay it.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I take you back to the points that you made about loss of earnings. You said that when it is found out that people were hepatitis C sufferers, their employment is terminated or their promotional prospects are curtailed. Can you provide us with evidence that identifies the number of people who have found themselves in that situation? What action did they take against their employers? I ask because such people can complain to an employment tribunal if that is the reason why their employment has been terminated.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I cannot give specific examples of what people have done. Individuals have to make their own decisions and each person who faces such circumstances will, at the end of the day, determine whether he or she is prepared to go ahead and take action.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

How many people out of the 4,000 that you used in the calculation would fall into the category of having been wrongfully dismissed?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I do not have the answer to that question. Margaret Jamieson mentioned 4,000 people; I find the statistics surprising. The author of the paper was Dr Kate Soldan, who is an epidemiologist, and her statistics related to England but were extrapolated to cover Scotland. The paper admits:"Many assumptions are used to generate these estimates - some of uncertain validity."I do not know whether the statistics in the paper have been peer reviewed. The lady who compiled the paper now lives in France. The paper states that although the statistics are based on deceased people, there has been no adjustment to the level of fatality since 1995. Furthermore, the figures include people who died but not from hepatitis C—they might have died from a whole lot of other things. The figure of 4,000 represents a worst-case scenario; the actual figure might be only a quarter of that.

Shona Robison SNP North East Scotland
link

I would like to take you back to your comments on mortgages and insurance. You say that we might get warm words that everything is okay and that questions about hepatitis C will be removed from forms, but you also say that that would make no difference because of the way in which claims operate when one refuses to include certain information. It is clear that you were making a serious point. What should the financial institutions and mortgage companies do to make removal of such questions a meaningful change that will help hepatitis C sufferers?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I do not have a solution; the actuaries and other people involved in that field make their own decisions. As Margaret Jamieson said, there is discrimination. Haemophiliacs are discriminated against but, of course, many other people are discriminated against by the insurance industry.The member asked what the insurance companies could do. The Government could underwrite the companies with an adequate sum of money that would allow those who are affected to get insurance. Also, if their insurance is to be increased by a loading of two to three times the normal rate, the Government could pick up the tab. If it is not prepared to pick up the tab in that situation, it is unlikely that it will pick it up in others.Sometimes it is not hard to find money. The Government found money to bail out a company called British Energy plc to the tune of about £800 million, and it has been able to find such money on several other occasions. In the worst-case scenario, the money that would be required to underwrite the insurance companies will amount to £89 million, which is a small amount in comparison to what the Government has paid out previously. As I said, no amount of money can be set against people's lives.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

If the Haemophilia Society was to accept the minister's argument about the level of costs suggested in its recommendations and had subsequently to prioritise those who received payments, at whom would it direct compensation?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

It should not be an either/or situation. The report mentions £10,000 and a maximum of £40,000. That money goes only a small way towards compensating people who have lost many thousands of pounds in potential earnings because they were forced to give up their jobs. Some people would say that the money that was offered was a token gesture. The committee did not seem to take that view, and the Haemophilia Society assumed that the committee was recognising that harm had been done.The media might be correct in its reporting that money will be paid out only to the oldest sufferers or to those who become most ill. If that is correct, payment at such times is a bit late for most people. They should get the money sooner so that they can help their relatives and families to cope. I would not like to have to decide to give money to one person but not to another. Hepatitis has a massive effect on a young person with a family and that family would need as much help as the family of an older sufferer. A young family has the same right to a house and the opportunity to live a full life.The expert working group produced a figure that, because it is based on research that was done over a long period, should be taken seriously. If the statistics are correct, about 3,000 of the 4,000 people mentioned are already dead, although it might be difficult to determine whether they died of hepatitis.Since 1988, people who receive blood transfusions have been subject to the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act 1987. Therefore, the number of people who are eligible for compensation is small. Although I keep referring to haemophilia, we must remember the people who have been infected through blood transfusions. That a woman can attend hospital for a hysterectomy, receive a blood transfusion, and leave the hospital with hepatitis must not be ignored. There is a range of causes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Therefore, in the light of past and present circumstances and future projections, you do not think that there will be priority categories—instead, everyone will be equal. I know that we must be pragmatic in the light of the minister's previous response, but you do not think that there is any order of priority.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

The report should stand—it recommends that everyone who is affected should be treated. Why should one person receive treatment while another does not? Funding is limited and although it will not solve all problems, it might help to alleviate some of the current difficulties.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

The minister said that he might do something for people who are suffering from long-term harm or hardship. However, is not it difficult to define such terms? For example, although someone who has hepatitis C might not exhibit any physical symptoms, that person might be affected psychologically by the fact that they have the illness. Once we get into that sort of debate, there is a great danger that all that will happen is that we give rise to discrimination and create more unfairness than we get rid of.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

That is correct.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Do the payments that are recommended in the report—£10,000, £40,000 and the amounts that are calculated on the basis of common-law damages—provide adequate compensation for people who are affected?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

They do not. After all, across the Irish sea, the minimum payments that were offered were between £200,000 and £300,000.That said, no amount of money can compensate people for what has happened to them and the psychological effects that the illness has on their relationships. We must remember that the youngest person in Scotland with hepatitis C—certainly within the haemophilia population—is 16. He has a life in front of him. He became infected at a time when blood was supposed to be heat treated. In 1985, people assumed that that was the case, but blood products were not heat treated until 1987. The year that that guy first received treatment was the year in which he was infected with hepatitis C. That happened to a whole lot of people who are now teenagers; what will happen when they want to start relationships and have to tell people that they have hepatitis C? We have seen what has happened to people who were already in relationships, married and so on and became infected with hepatitis C. The partner says, "Right, I'm away", and the relationship breaks up. One cannot know how people will relate to each other when they are suddenly faced with such a chronic situation. However, it is devastating for the people affected and for their families.When I gave evidence to the committee a year past March, it was one of the first occasions on which I acknowledged that I had hepatitis C. A few weeks later, I met a friend of mine who said "I didn't know you had hepatitis C. Does that mean that every time you come to the house we'll have to sterilise our cups?" I know that he was being facetious, but that is the sort of comment that people who are affected receive all the time. Other people just do not understand. One of the reasons why I argued for a public inquiry some time ago was that it might have taken the stigma away from the situation, because at least people might find out that they will not catch hepatitis by touching people and so on.I should add that the Scottish needs assessment programme report on hepatitis C that was published by the Government two years ago pointed out that there is a 5 per cent chance of the disease being sexually transmitted. There is a problem with people's emotions about the disease and the way in which the public perceive it.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Over the past couple of weeks we have learned that some haemophiliacs might have been infected with variant CJD. How do you think the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service and the Scottish Executive have handled that information?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

In some cases, the way in which people were told was quite harmful. Children, rather than their parents, received letters that stated "Dear patient, you might or might not have variant CJD"—although sometimes parents were the first people to open the letters. Some people did not receive letters and they do not know whether their letters have been lost in the post—250,000 letters are lost in the post every day.The Minister for Health and Community Care said that he was not told about the situation until about four weeks before we learned of it. Why was information that was known for two years not disclosed? When the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service gave evidence to the committee, that information must have been available to it. The matter has been handled badly.Variant CJD is a problem that people will have to face. There is no test for it and if we believe everything that we hear, everyone who has eaten at a well-known burger house might have the disease in their system. I am bothered most by the fact that information was withheld; information has been withheld on a range of issues. We believed that the only place that used American blood products was the Royal hospital for sick children in Glasgow. We might have been wrong to assume that, but since American lawyers started to talk about knowing the batch numbers, the shipments and the hospitals to which the products went, a number of hospitals in Scotland have suddenly remembered that they used American blood products in the early ‘80s. The issue is how much information is being withheld. We believe in the committee system that operates here and we believe that the Parliament favours transparency and openness. We hope that the committee will eventually reach a decision on the matter.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

Philip Dolan has touched on issues that range wider than the question of compensation. If the minister were to say this morning that he had changed his mind and that he intended to implement in full the recommendations of the expert panel, would that be the end of the matter? Would you continue to press for a public inquiry into all the other aspects of the problem?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

In an ideal world, it would be important to hold a public inquiry. We know that Christmas is approaching, but if the minister were to come here today—

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

If he comes wearing a red and white suit, we might have a clue about what he intends to do.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

It would be very pleasant to know that the minister intended to implement in full the recommendations of the expert panel. However, as I said earlier, when we reach the top of one mountain there is still another to climb.Not everyone would accept the figures that have been cited; some people are not happy about them, so a public inquiry would help. In Ireland, compensation was paid five years ago, but the public inquiry—which took two years—has only just been completed. Because of information that came to light at the end of the inquiry, there is talk of holding another inquiry into international drug companies' provision of products.I would like to be as optimistic as Mr McAllion.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I would like to be optimistic about the minister's intentions.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

I have spent many years in politics learning not to be optimistic.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Even if the full settlement were £50,000, that would not be a great amount of money. If the 16-year-old lad that you talked about got a job, £50,000 is what he might earn in two years. Why are you prepared to contemplate getting such a small amount? It is peanuts.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Lord Ross explained the reason for that. In my opinion, no amount of money will ever compensate sufferers, but at least it would represent recognition that something had gone wrong and it would be of some help. If you were to ask a variety of people how much sufferers should get, you would be amazed at some of the figures you would hear. I am not trying to put a figure on it, though.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Maybe we should all become MSPs.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Recommendation 2 in the expert group's report deals with the position that the Executive has adopted to date, which is not to give financial assistance but to say that it will improve the standard of services, access to information and so on for hepatitis C sufferers. Has there been improvement in those services or is that recommendation still at the planning stage?Recommendation 3 deals with the legal aid system, which appears to have let people down. Because of the date on which they were infected, consumer protection legislation cannot help those people. What are your thoughts on recommendation 3 of the expert group's report?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

I do not have the document in front of me, so I am not sure what recommendation 2 is.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Recommendation 2 reads:"The Scottish Executive should consider how it could fund and develop other mechanisms for supporting people who suffer from HCV".Is that happening quickly enough, or is the Executive's claim that it is doing so simply rhetoric?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

The recommendation goes on to mention counselling, provision of which is hit and miss; few hospitals provide adequate counselling services.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

You have just talked about letters flying through people's letterboxes telling them that they might have a fatal disease. There appears to be no question that those people will be invited in for counselling in advance of being told that they might have a fatal disease, so to say that counselling services are patchy seems to be a little too diplomatic.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

That is correct, but I was thinking about the counselling services that are provided to some people. Little money is provided to ensure that that counselling is adequate.Mr Chisholm talked about what used to be the Department of Social Security and is now called the Department for Work and Pensions. He said that if the awards that we have been discussing were made, people's benefits could be affected. I would counter that, however. When money was given to people by the Macfarlane Trust, the department that was responsible for benefits—whatever it was called at the time—did not have any difficulty in putting in place a waiver to allow that money to be accepted by those people. Such a waiver also applies to people who receive disability living allowance. I do not see the hurdle that Mr Chisholm talked about as being too high to get over.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

However, it is a political hurdle, because Westminster might take a different view to the Scottish Parliament.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Sure—but there are precedents for waivers.

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

Yes, because benefits are a reserved matter. However, if Westminster were willing, the matter could be resolved.On legal aid, some years ago an Edinburgh solicitor wrote an article about the fact that he was being prevented from taking class action cases because of the failure of the Scottish Legal Aid Board to provide finance for them. Because the amount of money that can be made is so low, most sufferers find it hard to get a lawyer to help them. If the legal aid system were changed, that would help a lot. I think that that might be addressed in the final report.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Is there anything else that you would like to say this morning?

Philip Dolan Haemophilia Society
link

If the minister does not accept the recommendations, I ask the Health and Community Care Committee to use its power to introduce a bill that would implement them or, at least, to push for a public inquiry. That would make the situation clearer, even if it took time.

Meeting suspended.

On resuming—

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Our next witnesses are Malcolm Chisholm, the Minister for Health and Community Care, and Mr Stock and Mr McLeod from the Scottish Executive health department. I welcome you all and ask the minister to make a short statement before we move on to questions.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Thank you, convener. We published the preliminary report of the expert group on financial and other support last month. You have already heard this morning from Lord Ross, who chaired the group, and from Philip Dolan of the Haemophilia Society, who was a member of the group. I thank Lord Ross and the members of the group for the work that they have done and we look forward to receiving the final report shortly.It is useful to remind ourselves briefly of the group's remit. First, we asked it to look at our existing approach to no-fault compensation. In its preliminary report, it comments that that raises extensive and complex issues and that it cannot make meaningful recommendations at this stage. Secondly, we asked the group to advise whether improvements could be made to the existing system for handling fault-based compensation. That work continues and should be completed by the end of the year.The expert group was also asked to look specifically at the situation of patients who have contracted hepatitis C from blood transfusion, or treatment with blood products, as part of the wider consideration. However, it decided, as you know, to do that first and separately and it has recommended a comprehensive scheme of ex gratia payments for that group.We said in our response to the expert group's report that we share its concerns for those who, through no fault of their own, are suffering "serious long-term harm". Those are the words that the Health and Community Care Committee used in its report last year. We would very much like to find a way of doing something to help those people.However, there are quite complex medical, legal and financial considerations. The way in which hepatitis C presents is variable. Finding a fair set of criteria for making payments and meeting people's needs is not necessarily straightforward. It is also clear that what the expert group is proposing involves a very large sum of money and that it would not necessarily focus help on those who need it most. We must take account of the costs of any payment scheme in the light of our other health priorities, which are vital to the people of Scotland.We are looking very carefully at who needs help and at the best way to design a scheme and to structure payments so that the individuals involved benefit fully. There are two considerations. First, we must act within devolved powers and that might need clarification when it comes to the kind of payments that we are proposing. Secondly, we need to look at the interface with the social security system and devise a scheme that fits it as well as possible, avoiding a situation in which payments lead to social security payments' being withdrawn or reduced.For the Macfarlane Trust and the Eileen Trust, which pay compensation on a UK basis to HIV sufferers, there is specific legislation that allows those payments to be disregarded for social security purposes. That might be more difficult for a specifically Scottish scheme. We are therefore considering with social security officials whether there are ways in which payments could be structured within existing legislation, for example through establishing some form of trust for individuals that would allow payments to be disregarded for social security purposes. My officials have met social security officials to consider those issues and are working with them to identify the best way forward. That will necessarily take some time, but I hope that the matters will be resolved very soon.The expert group also asked us to fund and to develop additional mechanisms for supporting all people who suffer from hepatitis C. I am pleased to say that we have already done a considerable amount of work in that area. We are aware that one of the problems that people have is difficulty accessing financial services because of the perceived health risks that are involved.Earlier this week, I met representatives from the Council of Mortgage Lenders and the Association of British Insurers. They recognised the issues faced by people infected with hepatitis C, but emphasised that, in general, insurance and other products should be available. In some cases, products may cost more to reflect the extra health risks involved, and it is important to ensure that people have the best information and advice to find the products that they need. The industry agreed to work with patient groups and us to try to improve the information and advice that are available. The ABI also said that it would issue advice soon that there should not be a specific hepatitis C question on insurance forms.The Executive has started a range of other initiatives. We recently produced an information pack for professionals and a patient information leaflet on hepatitis C, which have been widely distributed within NHS Scotland, the drugs field and the Scottish Prison Service. In addition, we have offered £40,000 to the British Liver Trust and Mainliners this year to establish a hepatitis C resource centre for Scotland. The centre is intended to be a one-stop shop providing information on hepatitis C infection as well as details of who to contact about testing and treatment in Scotland. The project is expected to secure premises in Glasgow shortly and open early in 2003.We are also in active discussions with the Health Education Board for Scotland and the Scottish centre for infection and environmental health to establish how any public information campaign on hepatitis C could best be handled. Building on recommendations from the joint health department and Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh conference on hepatitis C, which was held on 4 July, the department is in active discussions with clinicians and patient representatives to examine the development of managed clinical networks for patients with hepatitis C. As members know, managed clinical networks have already demonstrated in other clinical areas that they can improve patient care.In preparation for the July conference, we commissioned the SCIEH to undertake epidemiological modelling work. That is now being further developed and will provide us with much more robust data on the numbers who are affected with hepatitis C and, in particular, rates of disease progression, on which we can base future service planning.In conclusion, I hope that those initiatives demonstrate that we recognise the needs of people infected with hepatitis C and that we are serious in trying to tackle them in the best way that we can. We shall continue to take the issues forward with urgency.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

All that you raised will be explored in the next wee while, but it is important that we are clear about the basis on which you decided to reject the recommendation of an expert group that you established, defined the remit for and picked the members of. Is it an objection of principle, or one based purely on financial implications? Do you agree with the principle underlying recommendation 1 of the expert group report, which is that everyone infected with hepatitis C in the NHS should get financial assistance to cover the inevitable stress, anxiety and social disadvantage that they suffer?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

As I said in my statement, we want to concentrate help on those who are suffering, in the words of last year's Health and Community Care report, "serious, long-term harm". That indicates that we want to target the support, and, fortunately, many people who contract hepatitis C either clear the virus or do not go on to develop the symptoms that the majority of people do. We need to concentrate help on those who are suffering serious, long-term harm. That is one issue, and we think that people understand that.The objection is also related to financial considerations; I cannot pretend that that is not relevant. The reality is that the working group's estimates, which were accepted by Lord Ross, would have an impact on the health budget. I cannot disregard that. The Health and Community Care Committee put a proposal before the Finance Committee to take £89 million out of the health service during the next three years. I have talked to people in the health service about the subject. Like me, they are entirely sympathetic to hepatitis C sufferers and want to help those who are suffering long-term harm, but members can imagine the reaction that I would face from the health service if I spent that much money on the issue.To give a bit of context to the amount that we are talking about, the cancer strategy involves £60 million over three years and the coronary heart disease and stroke strategy involves £40 million over three years. Those strategies have been widely welcomed throughout Scotland and are beginning to produce significant benefits for patients. My decision to target support at those who suffer long-term harm is partly for financial reasons, but partly because I think that that is the right thing to do.The committee's report argues that we should follow the precedent of the Macfarlane Trust, but the people who received money through that trust were those who fell ill quickly, as happened with HIV in those days. So, if we follow precedent, the one analogous trust that has been set up was targeted at people who were suffering physically. I believe that, at the point at which physical suffering kicks in, help should be given, which is what I propose.The third factor in the equation is our discussions with London. Members must realise that there are issues that must be sorted out if we are to get the outcome that we want.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

I want to clarify one point. You referred twice to the committee's report. The first recommendation in our report was:"We recommend that the Executive set up a mechanism for providing financial and other appropriate practical support to all hepatitis C sufferers who have contracted the virus".The report then clarifies that further. Recommendation 3 states:"The level of financial assistance awarded to any claimant should be determined on the basis of need, having regard to the physical or psychological loss individually suffered".So we did not simply focus on one group. We covered both groups.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I know that, but by chance the words in my statement were the same as the words in the text of the committee's report.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

I am glad that you have cleared up that deliberate misrepresentation of the committee's report, which saves me making my first point. I have two supplementary questions that arise from what you have just said. As you have not questioned the expert group's estimate of the amount of money that would be required, I assume that you accept that it is roughly accurate. Earlier, Lord Ross said that the maximum total amount that the Scottish Executive would be required to pay would be £89 million. He also said that that sum would not be required to be made available in one year; it could be made available over a number of years.The minister mentioned my proposal. He should read it because it does not suggest that the money should be taken from the health budget, but from across the Scottish Executive budget. That is one proposal as to how the money could be made available over three years. What work has the Scottish Executive done to examine ways in which the money could be made available? As the minister said, it is a large sum of money, although some people might think that, relative to other amounts of money that are spent on certain things, it is not so large.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I am well aware of the recommendations in the committee's report, but I quoted from the body of the text.I am going to repeat myself slightly, but there are three parts to what I am saying and the danger is that people will pull out one of them and say that my decision is only about resources or principles or London. There are three elements, but we cannot get away from the fact that there is a resource issue. I take your point that the figure would not be £89 million in one year, but it is fair to say that the funding would be front loaded because many people would claim quickly if the measure were carried through. We cannot separate out the issue of funding.I have responsibility for the health budget and my decisions are made in that context. There are increased resources for health, but, as you know, on health issues we must make such decisions all the time because of the demands on the system. By chance, this afternoon you will ask for more money for mental health issues, which is another entirely worthy cause that I am pleased to champion generally. The last time that I was at the committee, members wanted more money for other services. All those demands are legitimate.In health, one of the facts of life is that we have a great number of worthy demands. That must be part of our discussion and the people of Scotland would not understand if it were not. I wanted to note that. However, that is only one of the three issues that I want to talk about today.The second issue is one of principle. We must decide whether everybody should get compensation or whether compensation should be focused on those who are suffering long-term physical harm. One positive thing is that, as hepatitis C does not develop in everybody as HIV used to do 10 to 15 years ago, many people can, fortunately, live healthy lives in spite of having the virus. Indeed, 20 per cent of people who contract the virus become clear of it altogether. The expert group's proposal was that everyone who contracts the virus should get money, but I think that it is better in principle to target our resources on those who are suffering long-term harm. That is the second part of what I want to say.The third part is that, given the fact that the issue is interrelated with the social security system, we need to clarify what we as a devolved Administration can do. All those issues are being considered further in discussion with ministers and officials at Whitehall.I hope that people will remember those three elements in our discussion today. We should not say that the issue is all about money or all about principle or all about London. All three elements are important and interact at various points.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Before I ask my last question at this stage, I ask the minister to give a commitment that he will read the proposal that I have submitted. That proposal is worthy of consideration because it would have no impact on the revenue health budget.The minister has continually used the term "serious, long-term harm". Will he define that? Does that harm relate purely to people who suffer physical harm, or would it cover people who have not yet developed physical symptoms but have perhaps been deeply affected psychologically by the fact that they have contracted hepatitis C? For example, earlier this morning, Philip Dolan mentioned a 16-year-old who has the anxiety and worry associated with being at a stage of his life where he is about to embark on relationships and has the concern about the possible sexual transmission of hepatitis C. Will the minister define what he means by serious, long-term harm?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I refer to physical symptoms. I said that in my statement.One of our main thrusts, which I mentioned in the debate earlier this year and to which I alluded in my statement today, is to put in place a range of measures to support everybody with hepatitis C—including the 16-year-old, whom I did not hear about because I was at a Cabinet meeting this morning. A broad range of help must be available. Indeed, the first role of the health service is to provide services and support in the broadest way possible for all who suffer from hepatitis C. That is why the second half of my statement was important. Obviously, I want to do everything possible for that 16-year-old and everybody else with hepatitis C.The issue about whether everybody should get compensation because of what happened leads to the big debate about principle. The Parliament has been considering that debate over the past three and a half years. I know that some will argue about whether the NHS was at fault, but the committee's report did not flag that up as the ground for its argument. The committee found no evidence that there was fault on the part of the NHS. If the view is taken that everybody should get compensation, that leads to the more general argument that, whenever harm is done, everybody should get some compensation irrespective of whether we are at fault. However, in that case, it would be appropriate to talk about ex gratia payments rather than compensation.That bigger argument must still be dealt with. I know that the committee and the expert group had the idea that they were simply following the precedent that was set by Macfarlane, but the reality is that that argument is still there. I am not pushing that argument hard, but I am saying that that is part of the discussion. I want to give help, but I want to target it at those suffering long-term harm, which I have said means physical symptoms.Members might say that I have not accepted the report. It is clear that I have accepted that part of the report that refers to those suffering long-term harm. Perhaps the group to which the report refers in the third part of its financial recommendation could be extended. I am prepared to consider flexibly who might be included in that group. Today, I am stating the principle behind my approach. I would be quite sympathetic to considering whether that group does not have to be exactly what part C of the expert group's financial recommendation refers to. However, the group certainly includes all the people who are referred to in part C. The expert group made those distinctions.The principle is that I want to target support. Under my proposal, perhaps not everybody with hepatitis C would receive help tomorrow, but they might receive it next year or the year after, depending on their medical condition. I accept that a difference of approach exists, which is partly a difference of principle, but that interrelates with the other factors to which I referred.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Are you happy for me to read out part C of the expert group's recommendation 1, to clarify the situation for the people in the public gallery?

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

You say that you want to target help at least on the group of people to which part C refers and potentially on more. Part C says that"those who subsequently suffer serious deterioration in physical condition because of their Hepatitis C infection e.g. cirrhosis, liver cancer or other similar serious condition(s), should be entitled to additional financial support (on an ongoing basis if necessary)"—the expert group recommends that those people should also be given £50,000—"as may be assessed appropriate by the Trust. This financial support should be calculated on the same basis as common law damages, taking account of the payments"that the expert group recommends should be made, but which you do not intend to make. That describes your group, and you say that you would be prepared to look beyond the envelope of that group.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

You based your arguments partly on a comparison of the expert group's worst-case figure of £89 million with the three-year cancer strategy's £60 million cost or the three-year coronary heart disease and stroke strategy's £40 million cost. The implication is that £89 million is far too much money to be taken from the health budget. However, you have said that you intend to target ex gratia payments on some sufferers. What ballpark figure do you have in mind, if it is not in the range of the £62 million to £89 million that the expert group suggested? What can the health budget afford? Under your proposals, how much money will be made available to compensate at least some people?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I have no definite figure in mind, but I cannot find the sums to which you referred. As I said, I am happy to be flexible about the number of people.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

What sums can you find? If £62 million is too much, what is not too much?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I am not giving a specific figure. I am saying that the health budget could not withstand such sums in a short period. However, I am happy to consider much smaller sums.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I have deliberately not calculated a figure, because that depends on many factors, such as the exact number of people who are included and how the discussions with the Government at Westminster go. To announce a particular sum would be rather premature.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

You suggest that the health department has no idea how many people might fall into the third category, on which you are prepared to target ex gratia payments, and that you have no idea of the cost of that.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I am not saying that. I am talking about much smaller sums of money, certainly in year 1. Given all the competing demands, it would be hard in one year to find more than, say, £10 million, but I do not have a specific figure in mind.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I am happy to be flexible, but I am putting in the public domain the fact that figures such as those in the expert group's report would have a serious effect on the health budget.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

So you would accept £10 million each year for three years.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

That would remain difficult, but it is within the range that we could consider. The decision would depend on how much money people would receive, the number of people who are involved and other factors.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

So there is a cash limit on the Executive's compassion in dealing with this group of people.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

That is not a fair comment to make about a health budget. You could make that charge if I said that, much as I support mental health services, I could not give whatever sum somebody asks for in this afternoon's debate. Another committee member could raise one of the many other worthy matters that the committee has discussed, such as pain services or epilepsy. We could go on until 12 o'clock with a list of things and with each item you could accuse me of lacking compassion because I was not giving any money to that issue, or because I was giving only £60 million to cancer services instead of £70 million. We know that more than £60 million is needed for those services.However, the fact of life in the health department—and, I submit, in the Scottish Executive—is that we have to make choices. Sometimes we choose one thing and need to compromise. Although that means that we spend less money than we would like to on cancer, on ex gratia payments for hepatitis C or on mental health, it does not mean that we are lacking in compassion three times over. It just means that being in Government requires us to make choices.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

It is about priorities. If the Executive decides that it does not want to make raising taxes in Scotland a top priority, everyone else—including groups such as this one—suffers down the line.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

John, you can pursue that argument if you want. If you are proposing that the Executive should use its tax-varying powers—

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

I have the power to propose that under the standing orders of the Scottish Parliament.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Nevertheless, once we had spent the extra money thus raised, a few weeks down the line we would again be in the situation we are now. We would still need to make choices. I have to make choices every day in the health department; and I suggest that everyone in the Parliament must be in the business of making choices. If we are accused of lacking compassion every time that we do not give all the money that someone wants for some cause, I do not see how we can have a serious discussion about health or anything else.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

But you are thinking about the figure of £30 million.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I am not thinking of any figure in particular. Instead, I wanted to give the committee a rough idea of the figures that I was considering. However, I put a lot of health warnings around that because we have not started pursuing the matter from a particular sum of money. We have started with a principle. We will discuss the matter with the Westminster Government and proceed from there.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Minister, you said that you are starting with a principle. However, the problem is that we are talking about a particular group of people. You say that you are prepared to go beyond those people, but you do not know how many will be involved. Moreover, we do not know what the impact of Westminster on the matter will be, and you cannot give us any figures. One of the reasons why we will ask you for more money this afternoon is that you have proactively introduced a piece of legislation that all committee members feel does not have enough resources attached to it. We did not introduce that legislation; you did.I take your point that you must think about priorities. However, committee members unanimously produced a report that asked you to do one thing. We also asked you to set up an expert group, which you did; and that group has unanimously asked you to do exactly the same as we asked you to do. You have asked us not to accept our own opinion or the expert group's opinion, but instead to accept your position. However, you have not told us exactly whom you would help, exactly how much money you would attach to it or exactly what you would be able to get out of the Westminster Government.You also said in passing that the debate was rather premature. I argue that it is not rather premature to the people who are suffering from hepatitis C. Although it would be nice to put our complete faith in you and give you the time that you need to take the matter forward, we are very keen to resolve the issue before the Parliament and the committee dissolve. After all, we have been working on the matter for a number of years.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I have progressed the matter. However, unless we resolve the issue of the money and the London dimension—if that is what you want to call reserved and devolved matters and the social security aspect—no one will get anything. We are progressing discussions with the Westminster Government. We are the first Government in the history of the UK—if you want to put it that way—and certainly the first Government over the years that this has been an issue to make some movement on the matter. We have unlocked things and the ice has begun to melt.However, as I have said, unless we can identify the money and resolve the issues that are of interest to the Scottish Executive and the Westminster Government, no one will get anything. It would be fine to say that we will give out all this money tomorrow, but we first have to address those two matters before anyone gets anything. I have begun that process.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

I want to probe further about the on-going discussions with UK officials. You have indicated that your officials have met their Whitehall counterparts to discuss the implications that any ex gratia payments would have on social security payments and benefits. Do you have a time frame for concluding those discussions? When do you expect that you and your Westminster counterpart will talk? I know that paths have to be trod first by officials before ministers can follow, but time is running out.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I do not follow those rules. I have spoken to ministers as well. I want the matter to be sorted tomorrow, but that is not under my control. I can have some degree of control of this end of the process, but the Government at Westminster has to do the things that it has to do in relation to the issue. People must acknowledge that there are two issues, both of which need to be explored by the Westminster Government: there is an issue with social security and an issue with devolved and reserved powers.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I do not know how I could have a time limit for the Westminster Government. I know that I used to be a member of it, but I do not have that kind of control over it.

Margaret Jamieson Lab Kilmarnock and Loudoun
link

Are UK ministers aware of the importance of the issue in Scotland?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

As I have spoken to several of them about it, I think that I could answer yes to that question.

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

How tough are you being? I seem to remember you sitting before this committee discussing free personal care. You said that you were in delicate negotiations with Westminster about the potential clawback of attendance allowance, that we were to have faith in you and to trust you, and that everything would be okay. That ended with a complete climbdown and the clawback of the attendance allowance. Will you stand up for the will of this Parliament on this issue? Surely, as Scotland's Minister for Health and Community Care, you will not tolerate a situation in which the will of this Parliament, which is to provide justice for hepatitis C sufferers, is in effect subverted by the intransigence of Westminster officials or ministers.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I would always support the will of this Parliament, although the precise will of Parliament on this issue in terms of what kind—

Nicola Sturgeon SNP Glasgow
link

Let us start with the will of the Health and Community Care Committee.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

We do not know whether the will of Parliament is inclined to what you are saying or to what I am saying. Assuming that the will of Parliament is to do something, of course I stand up for the will of Parliament—I will always do so.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Is your reluctance to implement recommendation 1, on paying up in full, influenced by a perception that it would cause inequity in relation to English sufferers?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

We are a devolved Parliament and I am never influenced by the fact that something is being done differently at Westminster. That is self-evident from some of the things that we have done in Scotland in my portfolio.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

You referred to having discussions with ministers in Westminster about this subject. Have you discussed it with the Secretary of State for Health and with other relevant ministers? Were they enthusiastic about your coming to a proper settlement in Scotland, or were they reluctant, and did they point out that Westminster would then have to consider paying out in full? What was their attitude?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

The attitude of the UK Government is evident, because there was a debate at Westminster recently—I do not recall the precise day, but I think that it was in October—at which its view was made absolutely clear. I do not think that it is any great secret that it does not support going down either the route that Dorothy-Grace Elder advocates or the route that I advocate. That is clear.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I do not think that it would be right to give a verbatim account of what individual ministers say to me, but it is clear from what has been said publicly that the Westminster Government does not support the policy. That is on the record at Westminster.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Is the UK Government attempting to pull strings in Scotland to prevent a full pay-out, as Lord Ross described in his report?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

No, it is not pulling strings. In so far as we have devolved powers, we can do what we like. We have shown that in relation to more than one issue in this Parliament. The complication is that there is an interrelating social security dimension, but a further issue that has to be taken into account and to which thought must be given is the issue of devolved and reserved powers. If a matter is within devolved competence, we can do what we like. I do not think that I need to spend too much time here arguing that point, because what we have done, even just within my portfolio, has illustrated that point time and again.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

In his submission, Lord Ross says quite a lot about finance, which is a key issue, and points out that you have enough money to pay out. He mentions the surplus of £120 million in the Scottish health budget and the Scottish Executive's surplus of more than £700 million. In the light of that, why do you not simply pay out speedily, as Lord Ross recommends after years of study by various groups?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I will become boring by repeating that I have made three different points, but you have homed in on one of those points—about money—which is fair enough. In health, the largest part of previous underspends consisted of money within boards' revenue and capital budgets. That money would perhaps be spent in April rather than in March. It did not lie around with no one knowing what to do with it—it simply slipped a bit and would perhaps be spent two months into the new financial year.Perhaps a more fundamental point relates to the amount of effort that the Administration has put into addressing underspends over the past year. I cannot say today, on 11 December, what the underspend is in the health department or any other department, but I am confident that the underspend in the health department this year will be significantly less than it was last year. I must repeat that, even last year, it was not a case of people not knowing what to do with money. It was going to be spent on a capital project that had slipped or spent by a board in a revenue budget that had slipped slightly. As you know, no spare money is lying around in the health service that people do not have a clue what to do with. The opposite is true. It is in the nature of health that there are many more demands than we can meet.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

Lord Ross also makes the point that if the Executive thinks it necessary to find money, it finds it. He gives the example of the cost of the new Scottish Parliament building increasing from an estimated £40 million to more than £300 million and says that the Executive somehow managed to obtain money for that. Do you accept that there is a public perception, led by patients who have suffered, that you are dragging your feet on the issue and that you could find the money? Are you simply reluctant to pay out because of the implications for Westminster in that it would have to pay out to English sufferers?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Not for the first time, I categorically deny that I would be influenced by the Westminster Government in the way that you describe.On your first point, the Parliament building project has obviously been a disaster, but that is not the Executive's responsibility—I suppose that it is the collective responsibility of the Parliament. The Executive has not led on the Holyrood building—the project is steered by the Parliament and the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body in particular. We must all learn serious lessons from the project and we all wish that it had been handled better. Indeed, we all wish that it could be controlled now, but contracts have been signed. The reality is that we do not have a choice with much of that money, although we would like to have a choice.

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

But you managed to make a choice. You managed to invest hundreds of millions—

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I am afraid that the contract was signed a long time—

Dorothy-Grace Elder Ind Glasgow
link

The patients had no choice—they were infected by the national health service.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I have had no more personal involvement in the matter than many committee members have had. The Holyrood project is a collective parliamentary project. A contract has been signed and money must be paid. There is no choice; if there were, I am sure that many of us would not want to spend—

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

We should make a distinction between where we have a choice and where we do not. We do not now have a choice in that area, which is regrettable, but that is a fact of life that we must accept; we cannot do anything about it.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

I would like to return to what was said about Westminster. In response to an allegation that Dorothy-Grace Elder put to you that you will do what Westminster tells you to do on the matter, you said that you would not be influenced by the Westminster Government in the way that she described.To give credit where credit is due, it is obvious from what you have said that you will not do the same as Westminster is going to do, so we will see a different solution in Scotland. However, it is the case that, because Westminster is deciding not to go down that route, it can obstruct us in doing what we want to do—whether we go down the route that you are suggesting or whether we go down the route that the committee and Lord Ross are suggesting. It is not a question of your being politically influenced by Westminster, but it can practically obstruct the will of this parliamentary committee. On the basis of previous motions that were signed by the majority of members of this Parliament, I guess that the will of the Parliament would be at least to go down the route that you are suggesting, which is to take a different view from Westminster. Do you believe that the Westminster Government is being obstructive in not allowing specific legislation or derogation of some kind, as there has been in the past with the Macfarlane Trust?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I do not think that Westminster is being obstructive, and what you said in that regard was premature. We obviously do not know what will transpire in the coming period, but Westminster has engaged at official level and is seriously looking at the issues. I have certainly had constructive conversations with more than one minister, so I do not think that it is fair to say what you are saying. You may have that fear or concern, but our Westminster colleagues are constructively looking at the issue. I must remind you that they are looking at two issues—the social security dimension and the complex issue of devolved and reserved powers.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Could you expand a little more on the second of those two points?

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

It is well known that social security is reserved under the Scotland Act 1998. I am flagging up the fact that the relationship between any payments and the social security system is an issue that Westminster colleagues are giving thought to. I am not saying that they have come to a conclusion on that, but it is right to put that into the public domain as an area that is part of what they are considering.

  1. Scottish Parliament Health and Community Care Committee Wednesday 11 December 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  5. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  6. Hepatitis C Committee business · 261
  7. Petition Petitions · 3
  8. Cancer Services Committee business · 1
  9. Meeting in Private Procedure · 3

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.