Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Budget Process

Wednesday 3 May 2000 Health and Community Care Committee Committee business 296 contributions · 11 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

296 contributions · showing 1–200
Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Good morning everybody. We are here to investigate the Executive's budget. The First Minister and the Executive have called upon the parliamentary committees, and indeed the whole population of Scotland, to examine the budget. The Health and Community Care Committee must consider the health budget in particular.Do the witnesses intend to give a brief presentation on the figures, or would they prefer to go straight to questions?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I have not prepared a presentation, but I would like to clarify a couple of points.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Perhaps you could give us an explanation of what you do before we begin our questions.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Thank you. I am the director of finance in the Scottish Executive health department. On my right is Mrs Sarah Melling, who is head of the financial monitoring and control division of my directorate.The departmental report that you have before you is the descendant of a long line of documents that goes back to something called the "Scottish Commentary on Public Expenditure"; it seeks to explain spending across the Scottish Executive's block of expenditure. It tries to adopt a consistent approach across all programmes, which means that, occasionally, compromises must be made since what would be ideal for one programme might not be ideal for another.The targets in the health and community care chapter have been picked to tie in with the commitments that were set out in "Making it work together", the Executive's programme for government, which are the most important commitments that the Executive has made. It is clear that the programme for government commitments do not cover the health department's whole range of activity. We might want to revisit that in future to ensure that the targets, aims and objectives that we include in the departmental report cover the full range.I apologise for a typographical error. On page 48, footnote 3 of table 4.1, which refers to pre-natal illness specific grants, should read "the above figures exclude mental-illness specific grants".

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

There are those of us who say that you would have to be mad to have children, but I think that that is taking things a bit too far.We will try to restrict our questions to the presentation of the figures, the technical aspects of the budget and the figures that you have presented to us. We might query the way in which aims, objectives and targets and so on are thrown about in a haphazard way at points. There are questions about why issues are raised at one point when they might fit better elsewhere. We will raise a number of such presentational issues with the Finance Committee. We are aware that the document is for consumption by the population at large—not that I am suggesting that you would have seen 20 people reading it on the bus today—and should be as transparent and accessible as possible. Because of time constraints, we will not touch on a number of issues today but will comment on them at another time.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

We are supposed to have an informed and reasoned input to the budget process, as are the people of Scotland. To enable us to do that, you need to speak a language that we—and the people of Scotland—understand, and to present the information in a way that allows us to make informed decisions about priorities.I have a copy of the Highland Health Board health improvement programmes and trust implementation plans. The long and boring five-year plan and ten-year plan documents are of great interest, but how do we know that they are following the Scottish Executive's spending plans, commitments, aims and objectives? I see those in the HIPs and TIPs, but I do not see the equivalent information in your document, so my first point is, where is that information?My second point follows on from that and gives you an example of why we need that information. Last week, we had two excellent submissions that made it clear to me that we must put more resources into preventive care. On pages 56 and 60 of "Investing in You", where do I see that we could shift resources from x to y to put more emphasis on preventive care? The figures are not given to us in a way that reflects the aims and objectives, or that allows us to shift resources to meet the priorities that we feel are not being resourced adequately.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Thank you, convener. I will deal with those questions in turn. The first was about the Scottish Executive equivalent of HIPs and TIPs, and where to find the national guidance that sets the scene for development of those programmes and plans. That guidance comes from a number of documents. There is the "Priorities and Planning Guidance for the National Health Service in Scotland", which is produced from time to time. The most recent one was produced the year before last, and was reinforced last year, following the election of the new Administration. It sets out the priorities for the health service across Scotland, and identifies the three clinical priorities of cancer, coronary heart disease and mental illness and the new focus on children's services. It also sets out the broad areas in which health boards and trusts must direct their activity, which are towards developing primary and community care, restructuring hospital services and, crucially—the point that you mentioned in your second question—improving health and preventing ill health.The priorities and planning guidance document sets the guidelines, or the broad parameters, within which HIPs and TIPs should be developed. Successive Administrations have taken the view that it is important to leave a fair amount of discretion to the health boards and trusts to take account of local circumstances in responding to the national priorities, which must be set out clearly. As I said, the Administration attempts to set out those priorities in the priorities and planning guidance. The Administration is considering what process should be gone through to produce the next version of the priorities and planning guidance—should it be the same kind of document, or how should it be developed? I am sure that the committee will be asked for its views on that in due course.That is where the national picture comes from. I am not saying that there is not room for improvement, but that is the current situation.Your second question was about resources for preventive action in health. You will be aware that, following the Chancellor of the Exchequer's budget announcement, the Minister for Health and Community Care in Scotland announced that £26 million of the additional resources will be devoted to the health improvement, public health agenda. That reflects the minister's clear view that more emphasis must be put on health improvement and illness prevention.As you said, the amounts that are listed under other health service expenditure on page 56 of "Investing in You" are not the only expenditure on preventing ill health and improving health. Much of the expenditure that goes to health boards is also used for that purpose, to meet local priorities. Many health boards have imaginative and positive initiatives to tackle those issues.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I did not really want the 42nd or 99th announcement about the £26 million that depends on people smoking more cigarettes to have more preventive health care.You mentioned a number of documents that provide the background to the budget figures, in particular the priorities and planning guidance document that is two years old. I come back to my initial point: this consultation is open not just to the committee, but to the people of Scotland. Do you expect those people, and every community council in the country, to get your plethora of glossy documents and examine all the spending announcements and re-announcements on hypothecated taxation? Do you expect them to plough through the document on priorities and planning guidance to find out whether their health board is spending their money properly? You said that things could be done better; this is an opportunity for us to do that. How can the information be presented to us, and to the people of Scotland, in an open, transparent, honest and easy-to-understand way that will allow us to have an informed input?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I certainly have no quarrel with the idea that the information should be presented as openly and transparently as possible. However, because of the wide range of information involved, that is not easy. It would be difficult and possibly not helpful to present all the figures in one document—that document would be very large—and we must ensure that the information, which is in the public domain in one form or other, can be brought together more effectively to enable people to make the contribution that you describe.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You are the guys who put together the figures; you can make things easy—or impossible—for us. If the process is to be inclusive, your challenge—indeed, your responsibility—is to produce figures that allow us to participate. We do not yet have such figures.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We would be very happy to take on board any of the committee's suggestions to improve the presentation of figures.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Okay.I am still not clear about the preventive thing—the £26 million that is going here, there and everywhere. However, on the HIPs and TIPs, we are interested in a one-year informed input to the budget process, not in whether Susan Deacon provides a few glossy brochures at £7.95 a time to tell women in Govan how to stop smoking or in constant announcements or re-announcements throughout the year. How do you monitor whether the health boards are following the spending priorities that you set out in the documents? How can you be sure that what you and Susan Deacon have said is implemented at the grass roots?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The system of performance management that applies across the health service in Scotland provides a range of different ways of monitoring. Each year, the health board produces a health improvement programme and each trust produces a trust implementation plan—the HIP and TIP. They are submitted to the department and form the basis of the monitoring process that happens over the year. Beyond that, the health boards and trusts in any health area sign a corporate contract with the health department, which commits them to specific aims for the year. Such aims might vary from area to area, but they must be consistent with the national priorities that are set out in the priorities and planning guidance and other documents.The priorities and planning guidance document provides the basis of the year's performance management and monitoring, which is conducted through phone contact and formal and informal meetings between representatives of the health department and the health boards and trusts. That is how we monitor what the health boards and trusts are doing and ensure that they are in line with the priorities.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Finally, you say that the three priorities are cancer, heart disease and mental illness. Can you tell me where, in the figures in "Investing in You", I can identify those priorities? How can I tell that money is going to them?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The three clinical priorities?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

That is not clear from the figures in "Investing in You", because of the need to allow for local discretion in the way in which resources are spent. If the Administration said that a certain percentage would be spent, in future, on cancer, coronary heart disease and/or mental illness, and that that was the only amount that could be spent on each priority, that would call into question the discretion to deal with local priorities that the Administration believes that health boards should have. For example, in one health board area heart disease might be a particular problem and mental illness might be less of a problem. The balance would need to be slightly different from that in another health board area, in which mental illness was the most important of the three priorities. It is for local authorities to set their own priorities.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am not satisfied with how we consider clinical priorities in a health budget. No committee member would disagree about the three main priorities, yet I cannot say that I have had input in ensuring that those priorities are being met. I return to the relationship between the health department and the health boards, and the monitoring. You are not presenting figures in a way that ensures that we are meeting clinical priorities.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

There might even be a case for making absolutely clear within the text the reason why an objective—the three disease priorities, children's services, strategic aims, or whatever—sometimes cannot be met. There is a need for some background information for a layperson who might read the document, to explain that a certain priority is not being met for the reason that you have given.There is also a case for providing a historic example. You might not be able to say what Lothian Health will spend on cancer care in a year's budget, because that is for the health board to decide, but you could say what it has spent in previous years. From that information, a trend could be plotted that would be even more effective several years into an Administration.About four of us want to say exactly the same thing. We recognise the disease priorities that the Executive has set, and I do not think that anybody would object to them. The same could be said of the flagship policies that the Executive trumpets—possibly quite rightly—such as NHS Direct, ambulatory care and diagnostic units, and walk-in-walk-out clinics. However, a whole series of policy developments are mentioned in passing, in "Investing in You", for which we have no idea of the cost; nor do we know where the money comes from or where it goes, or how expenditure will be monitored. The problem is that, for each objective—and some even have a target date—we have the what, but not the how or the who.We need to be able to see a more logical progression, even if that means that you have to say that an issue is for people to decide locally. The issue may come down to performance management of health boards and trusts by the central department, and decisions being made locally, but some indication must be given of the cost and the financial path, as well as how the policy will be pursued. We must start spitting it out, so that it does not take a degree in health accounting to read the figures.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

The convener has made most of the points that I was going to make, but those points take us to the central problem with the document. First, by far the biggest block—the hospital and community health services—is not disaggregated. Secondly, no connection is made between the expenditure lines and the objectives. I want to illustrate that and ask some questions about the capital expenditure.Many of the objectives relate specifically to capital expenditure. The eight new hospitals account for the biggest sums and there are also the ambulatory care and one-stop clinics. However, we have no idea how much capital is being spent and in which year, or how much those new facilities will cost. Nor do we know whether it is additional money, whether it comes from some other budget or whether it is a transfer of resources. We are completely in the dark about how those central objectives are being costed. Is not it possible to have a genuine capital expenditure line within HCHS, and possibly even a disaggregated one that says how much money is for the eight new hospitals, how much for the ambulatory care units and how much for the one-stop clinics?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I am happy to take that point on board. It would probably be helpful to have a line showing how much is spent on capital each year. What comes out of the accounts is the figure spent by the health boards themselves, rather than what is also spent by the trusts. In future documents we can certainly provide disaggregated figures that would show what capital projects are in the pipeline and how much money is associated with them. That might not be easily split into the amounts that are likely to be spent in each year, because it will not be certain in advance how much will be spent in a given year rather than later in the project. However, we can certainly include the total cost of those projects.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

You say that the NHS spent around £145 million on capital in 1999-2000. Do you have any idea how much will be spent this year and next year?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The provision for capital in 2000-01 is about £194 million.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

That appears to have gone up quite a lot from last year.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes, it has.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The increase comes from a decision by the Administration that the capital line had got too low and not enough was being spent on capital. There was a deliberate decision in the previous spending round to build in more spending on capital.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

What does "capital" mean? The private finance initiative projects have yet to come on stream. We know that that money is technically revenue. When the PFI projects come on stream, will it appear on a separate line that indicates that that revenue is really capital?

Sarah Melling Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The capital for trusts is given to trusts through the revenue line. The £145 million in the HCHS current expenditure line is mainly trust expenditure. We could split that down to say what capital that is, but it is not given to trusts as capital on that line. We are back in the old capital charges debate again.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

There is an interesting line at the beginning of the document, entitled"Capital spending (by private sector on PFI projects)".The figures, which are for total expenditure by the Scottish Executive, show £473 million for last year and £669 million for this year—the biggest figure in the line. After that, it dips for some reason to £412 million in 2001-02. How much of that spending will be on health?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We should be able to provide you with the health figure, but I do not have it with me today. It is a substantial amount. Three large PFI projects for the health service are currently under construction—Motherwell, Hairmyres and the new royal infirmary for Edinburgh. Together, they will account in any one year for a sum in the three figures of millions.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

So they are not included in those lines yet. Which is the first year in which they will kick in?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

They should kick in next year.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Our favourite topic, capital charges, has been mentioned. How much is included for capital charges in health board allocations for this year?

Sarah Melling Scottish Executive Health Department
link

It is £345 million.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I will come back in later, but I have a quick question on PFI. First, in a written answer, I was told that information on the costs of individual PFI projects in the health service is "not held centrally". That cannot possibly be true. Is such information held centrally and can we have a breakdown of the indices?Secondly, we are all clear that some areas are broken down into minutiae and in other areas vast, sweeping statements are made. Where can we find the figures for health board and trust budgets in an accessible way? On the ground that the NHS management executive is responsible for examining the figures and agreeing the plans on an on-going basis, would not it make sense to have at least a general NHS management summary of the implementation plans as part of the budget so that people can see the flow from allocation to service delivery?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Sorry. I did not quite catch the first point, on PFI.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Presumably there is continuing analysis of the costs of PFI per project in the health service in Scotland. Is that true?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We know what the total contract cost is.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Presumably we also know the various components.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

That depends on the terms of the contract.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We are coming back to the idea that there are some things that are commercially confidential and some that are not. We are concerned with the costs to the health service. Is it correct that those details are held centrally?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We will have the costs that the health service will have to meet in payments per year to service the PFI agreement and the total cost, but those will not be differentiated.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We would not expect it to be, because under the contract the health service pays for a facility.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

In other words, we are going through this process, attempting to discover whether there is value for money in a range of areas, but we cannot do the same for PFI projects?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

It is difficult to answer that question, because I am not clear what assessment you want to do that you are not able to do.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

If we had the figures, we would be able to examine the public sector comparators and decide whether there was value for money. Without the figures, we have to take it on trust.

Sarah Melling Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Before a project is commenced, a business case will have been produced which will have demonstrated that the PFI scheme was the best value for money.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

But the project is not then open to the rest of us to examine. Even under Malcolm Chisholm's proposal we are being asked, as part of the budget process, to accept a line that says, "That is PFI. That is the way it is and it is not going to be broken down by project." How can we—or anybody else—go back to the man in the street, put our hand up and say honestly, "Yes, that line makes sense. There is value for money and I am pleased that the Executive is doing things that way"? PFI might well be the best deal in some instances, but we need to be able to see that it is. It strikes me that PFI is an area where everyone is incredibly defensive and secretive about something that they should not be defensive and secretive about.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Convener, I am not sure that it is right to say that people are being particularly defensive or secretive. PFI projects, whether in the health service or anywhere else, and the Scottish Executive's part in them are auditable. I understand that Audit Scotland has indicated that it will follow and audit the Edinburgh royal infirmary project. That should give at least some reassurance.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Not really. Whether or not we have an indicative project is not the point. We want to examine the money that is being spent on these major projects, which are trumpeted as a major new investment in hospitals. If people are being asked to decide whether their money is being allocated properly and whether public involvement is wanted, they have to have access to the information. That is the basis of the transparency about which we keep talking. Why does that apply to some areas but not to PFI?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

As I have said, it is because of the terms of the contracts.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Therefore it is impossible to know whether this is value for money.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

As I have said, I do not necessarily accept that. Systems are in place, including provisions for the schemes and the Scottish Executive's part in them to be audited.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Those are systems to which we do not have access and that we cannot mould or justify to our constituents.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

You are saying that there are ways in which the schemes can be monitored but that those fall short of absolute public scrutiny in the form of figures being presented to the Scottish Parliament Health and Community Care Committee. As Duncan Hamilton said, we have to take it on blind trust that the schemes have been monitored for value for money. That may have been done in good faith, but mistakes may have been made. You are saying that the only way in which these figures can be made transparent is if and when an audit is done on a project.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

All the projects are audited. There is no wish to prevent appropriate scrutiny of PFI projects.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

We will move on. I think that we should make a point to the Finance Committee. In a couple of places the document states that there are eight major hospital building projects. We all want new, modern hospital buildings, but if that programme is being used as one of the main planks of health policy, the committee needs the greatest possible powers of scrutiny for such a substantial part of the budget. The committee will discuss this again in due course.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

My colleague, Duncan Hamilton, has more or less taken the words out of my mouth. We have all the figures here on what is being spent—except for what is being spent on PFI, of course. Is money held back in reserve? If so, how much?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We attempt to allocate all the money to particular headings. Most of the money is given to health boards, and through them to trusts. A small amount is held back to deal with contingencies in year.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

For 2000-01, the unallocated amount is less than £3 million at present—out of a total of £5 billion. It is not a large amount.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

How much was the reserve last year?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

At what stage?

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

At the beginning. How much money was put aside at the beginning?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We identified a small amount at the beginning of the year—I do not recall exactly how much. The amount varies during the year. Some activities do not spend on the pattern that was expected and money is added to what one might call a reserve and is certainly available for contingencies and other priorities that emerge in year. Other things may arise that require additional expenditure that had not been forecast. The example last year was the meningitis C vaccination campaign, which had not been planned for and for which the health programme had to find resources in year. The resources were found by reallocating resources from some items and using underspends that had emerged in various parts of the programme.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

How much was spent from the reserves last year and on what was it spent? You mentioned meningitis. Why cannot we know what was spent?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

All the reserves that we had, with some underspending, were used up on the meningitis C vaccination campaign.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

So your total reserves were used up on that?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I think that it was £17 million last year.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

What are the reserves in the coming year?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I have told you already that we have £3 million unallocated at present, but I have no doubt that during the year some items of expenditure will vary from what is forecast, so more resources may become available in year.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

I want to return for a moment to what Mary Scanlon said. I was rather concerned by what you said about monitoring health boards against the Executive's priorities. I know that people are very concerned about postcode prescribing. Cancer drugs are a topical example of that. In some areas Taxol, Taxotere and various other cancer drugs are being prescribed, but in others they are not because of cost. What can you do to stop that sort of thing happening?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

There is a limited amount that can be done through the financial monitoring of health boards.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

But postcode prescribing is taking place on grounds of cost.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Once the resources are with health boards and trusts, it is for them to decide how to spend them. It is for colleagues in the Scottish Executive to monitor their performance in those areas and to identify what they are spending money on. I accept that postcode prescribing causes a great deal of unease. That is one reason why the Administration is establishing the new Health Technology Board for Scotland, which is designed to provide advice, in the first instance on the use of new drugs, but also on other aspects of health technology, with a view to ensuring consistent use across Scotland of new cancer drugs and so on. It will be for health boards and trusts to take account of the advice, and how they do so will be monitored through the performance management system.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

I would like to pick up on one thing that you have said. The Health Technology Board for Scotland will be an advisory body. Decisions about the use of drugs will remain at local level with health boards. "Investing in You" states as its aim ensuring that people's access to services is not determined by where they live. People are not to be denied services simply because of geography. There will continue to be public concern about the fact that people in one part of the country have access to certain services whereas people in other parts do not because of local decisions. I understand that it is not your place to comment on that.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

I would like to ask a question about VAT, before moving on briefly to another subject; unfortunately, I have to leave the meeting for half an hour. Can you confirm whether the PFI deals are eligible for section 33 VAT shelter? Full public works projects by the NHS and other bodies normally receive section 33 VAT shelter.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I am afraid that I do not know the answer to that question. I will send a note, if that is acceptable.

Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP Glasgow
link

If section 33 VAT shelter does not apply in this case, millions will have been wasted.The Scottish Association of Health Councils is concerned about the lack of growth and, worse, the decrease in the contribution to the voluntary health and community care sector. The figures show either a standstill in the allocation or very little increase. Would you like to comment on how those figures were arrived at?

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Before you answer that question, Mr Aldridge, Irene Oldfather might want to add something to it.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Actually, my point was about national priorities. I have been trying to pick up on Mary Scanlon's point for quite some time.Last week, we were presented with the very impressive record of what is happening in Finland. Their health promotion strategy seems to be tackling national priorities and has changed lives. We were told that there have been 70 per cent reductions in cancer, heart disease and so on. Those are impressive results.Page 57 of "Investing in You" discusses a health promotion fund, the Health Education Board for Scotland and cutting death rates from cancer by 20 per cent by 2010. Are we not tinkering around the edges? We have national priorities and we must implement an aggressive programme to deal with the problems. Does Mr Aldridge have any comment on that?I do not like the language that is used on that page of the report, particularly where it says:"The Welfare Food Scheme serves families receiving social security benefits".We need to consider how to tackle that issue more widely, rather than by targeting families on social security and calling it a welfare food scheme—that is extremely inappropriate.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Perhaps I can pull those two questions together. Last week, we discussed the Finnish example at some length. The voluntary sector is a crucial partner in public health. We discussed ways in which we might ring-fence voluntary sector funding and projects that are vulnerable to cuts when councils face funding problems, but that do good work in health promotion. We want to consider the issue from a radical point of view, although we appreciate that that is difficult in the context of a one-year budget. Could you address the issue of the voluntary sector and public health in general?

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

According to table 4.10, grants to the voluntary sector are being reduced.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Yes. That is the point that Dorothy-Grace Elder was making.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I will deal first with the issue of grants to the voluntary sector. There are two sets of grants to the voluntary sector: section 10 grants, which come from social work, and section 16(b) grants, which come from health. I can confirm that ministers are keen to support the voluntary sector. The apparent reduction in the social work grants to the voluntary sector—down to £1.5 million from £1.8 million—is a consequence of an in-year decision made by ministers last year to add an extra £300,000 to the voluntary sector grants budget. The budget had been flat, but ministers added extra resources for one year because of the importance they attach to the voluntary sector. The figures for this year and future years will be considered in the context of the extra resources that are now available to the health sector. Ministers have not yet reached decisions about that.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

I am sure that ministers consider the voluntary sector to be as important this year as it was last year.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I would be very surprised if they did not.There is much sympathy with the view that we should be more radical in the way in which we approach health promotion and national priorities. The Administration has established the demonstration projects, which are designed to develop a radical approach of attack. One project concentrates on heart problems, there is one on cancer, one on children and one other, the subject of which I cannot recall.Resources have been put aside specifically to run the demonstration projects. Currently, each project is in a different area of Scotland. In the context of the extra resources available to the health programme, the Executive will consider what provision ought to be made to roll out those projects more widely, assuming they prove their worth.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

It is important to nail the issue of the projects proving their worth. Health promotion is a long-term investment by its very nature and it will be very difficult to prove a project's worth in five years; it took 25 years in Finland. I have some concerns that the flexibility of the funding depends on a project proving its worth within five years because I do not think that we will see the changes in five years.We have to make a radical change and an investment in public health. We have the experience of other European countries to draw on. Do you feel that the objective on page 57 is realistic? Should not we be going for a reduction of far more than 20 per cent by 2010?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

When I said, "assuming they prove their worth," I was not suggesting that there would have to be absolute proof that they had achieved all their objectives at the end of five years before they could be rolled out more widely. That is not the intention. The point of establishing demonstration projects is to find out which approaches are more effective than others. Assuming they succeed in identifying the most fruitful ways of approaching an issue, they will be rolled out. If new approaches emerge as well, they will be supported too.I hope that I can reassure you that there is no suggestion that we must wait until cancer has come down by 20 per cent in an area before the demonstration project is rolled out more widely.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

How much of the health budget is targeted at demonstration projects?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I do not have that figure with me, but I can let you have it later. It is a relatively small amount, but it is the amount that is needed to run the demonstration projects. It would take a lot more funding to roll them out across Scotland.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

How much would it take to roll out a project across Scotland?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

It would depend on the project, but you would be talking in terms of £10 million or more.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

That is a small amount for improving Scotland's health.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

It may be a lot more. It would depend what needed to be rolled out.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

The figure for the demonstration projects is included under "Miscellaneous minor items" in table 4.9. In 2001-02, the total expenditure for that line is £20.3 million. Although it is a presentational point, these projects are the kinds that ministers make great play of. We heard last week about a demonstration project in Paisley. We are supportive of it. We are concerned about what happens at the end of a project, when a decision is taken on whether to roll it out. A strategy is required for that. Rather than bury the figures in "Miscellaneous minor items", it would have been beneficial to itemise them in some way. They are major projects and it would have been worth commenting on where they fit in the long-term strategy, particularly in terms of the strategic aims and the major disease groups.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Are we really saying that education and media campaigns form the basis on which we are to improve Scotland's health by 2010? We have a target of cutting deaths from cancer by 20 per cent and halving coronary heart disease by that year. It seems to me that we need a far more radical approach, and much tougher targets.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

There is no doubt that although education and media campaigns have their part to play, they cannot do it alone—that is well recognised.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

Another long-term trend is the shift from secondary to primary care. How can we find out about that from the figures? Can we decipher that, or are there other ways for us to monitor such a shift?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

As far as the financial figures are concerned, there would be some indication from the move, over time, between the "Hospital and Community Health Services" line to the "Family Health Services" line. That is at a fairly high level of aggregation but, broadly speaking, family health services are the primary care services, whereas the hospital and community health services are the hospital-based services.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I have two points about that. First, how much of the HCHS line is going to primary care trusts? How much of it is going to community services, which I suppose I would include under primary care?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I was coming on to speak about that. If we take primary care in the broader sense, including community care, I agree that it is more difficult to find that out from the figures. Approximately £1 billion of the hospital and community health service resources went to the community trusts, the equivalent of today's primary care trusts, but the primary care trusts also have the budget for prescribed drugs, which is about a further £500 million.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

That is the second point that I was going to make. Is it correct that the prescribed drugs budget floats from budget to budget and that it is not under HCHS, but in the unified budget to health boards?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes—that is right.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

That is another confusion. We know the explanation, but that information should be explicit in the document, otherwise there will be a lot of confusion. On the subject of considering shifts towards primary care, much of the increase in the money going to family health services is presumably because of drugs and inflation.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

I heard some good news on that front a week or two ago. Can you update us on the drug cost scenario for the next couple of years?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I would like to make two points about prescribed drugs costs. The good news to which you refer, Mr Chisholm, is that the UK Government—control of drugs prices is a reserved matter—has taken steps to limit the price of generic drugs. The price rose substantially last financial year and consultations are taking place on a proposal to limit the total price of generic drugs to the level of 15 months ago. That would get it back down to its level before the big increases. That is being done because of a feeling that the generic drug manufacturers had taken advantage of the closure of one manufacturer to put up prices beyond a level that was warranted. The result should be a fall in the costs to primary care trusts in meeting prescribed drugs expenditure—although not all the way to the level of 15 months ago because of the growth in the volume of prescribing since then. Also, there are new drugs on the market. That is the good news. The other point about the transfer from secondary to primary care is that new drugs become available on the market and a lot of them are very effective and operate to keep people out of hospital. In may cases, the increase in prescribed drugs expenditure genuinely reflects a transfer of responsibility and activity from the secondary care sector to the primary care sector.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

It is mysterious that there is nothing in the document about income. Can you explain how income from prescriptions relates to public expenditure and why it is not mentioned?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Prescription charges are netted off the total health budget. Charges account for about 4 per cent of the health programme income in Scotland. Those include prescription charges, dental charges and charges for wigs and eye tests.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

We have expressed interest in the joint investment fund. That might not be reflected in the document because it is not yet in place, but could you tell us how we would know when it is?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The joint investment fund does not have any money attached to it; people have identified that as a problem.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

There is no specific money attached to it. However, the intention was that health boards would work with the trusts in their area to identify a part of the budget dealing with a particular service that needed to be reviewed. The joint investment fund would allow health boards to draw together spending and activity in different trusts and agencies in an area, re-examining how they fit together and trying to improve services. Progress in making use of that mechanism has been very patchy. Some areas have gained useful benefits, but it has been difficult to get it off the ground in other areas. To many people, the JIF remains a useful mechanism for bringing together the different parts of the NHS community to consider the pattern of services and how best to provide them.

Malcolm Chisholm Lab Edinburgh North and Leith
link

In future, would not it be a good idea to record that in the document, so that people could see such shifts taking place?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

That is a helpful suggestion and something that we could consider.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I have another helpful suggestion. You will be aware of the furore that sometimes surrounds arguments about health spending increases and that one of the committee's targets is to discover what "real terms" means in the context of the NHS. Am I right in saying that the figures in "Investing in You" are in cash terms?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes, apart from those in table 4.15.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Okay. What is the assumption that you make about inflation? What deflator do you use when you consider the overall picture of health spending?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The only deflator that we apply to the health programme as a whole is the gross domestic product deflator. That is applied in order to express the health programme in real terms, to allow comparison with other programmes. Currently, the GDP deflator is 2.5 per cent.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Your estimate of drug inflation, despite what you have said about the future, is about 9 or 10 per cent.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The provision that we are making is about 9 to 10 per cent, which is the estimate of the increased costs that will have to be met. Those costs are not all inflationary—some of them relate to increased volume and different drug mixes.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We do not have a figure for cost inflation as such. We estimate what the costs for prescribed drugs will be, taking account of likely changes in volume and the mix of drugs—new drugs coming on the market, old drugs dropping out of the market and so on—based on past experience.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

What about inflation? I understand the various components in the overall increase, but it would be useful to know what element of that was inflation. Am I right in saying that you would expect the inflation in the drugs budget to be more than 2.5 per cent?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I am not trying to be difficult, but there is no figure for drug inflation. Each drug changes its price by a different amount—some will go down and some will go up. We do not calculate a figure for drug inflation as such.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

In the sense that all the inflation targets are simply estimates, a more accurate estimate would be not less than the flat 2.5 per cent rate. Take the example of wage inflation. What is your estimate of that?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

In issuing resources to health boards and trusts and in their indicative allocations, we make a judgment about the pressures that they will face because of pay and price increases, which, historically, have operated at a level slightly above that of the GDP deflator—usually by about 1 per cent. We tend to build in that assumption.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

On what basis are you currently estimating wage inflation?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

We do not have a separate wage inflation forecast.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Are you saying that in negotiations with pay review bodies and so on, you have no idea what you think wage inflation will be?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Governments have always taken the view that they provide evidence to the pay review bodies on the resources available to the health service—that is now clear, following the Chancellor of the Exchequer's budget announcements. They also provide evidence on the state of the economy in general and what it can afford in terms of comparative increases for different groups of workers. For example, if average pay increases are running at 2.5 per cent, the Government will draw attention to that. The Government does not say that it is assuming that there will be a pay increase of 2 per cent and so on.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

This is an important question. Are you saying that the Government does not wish to put a particular figure on wage inflation or that the Government does not have a figure for wage inflation?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The Government never makes a specific wage inflation assumption.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The reason I ask is because the information that I have received from the Government is that it has an assumption for wage inflation, but that it does not want to make that public. That might be an issue that me should take up with the Executive.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Can I ask where you got that information?

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I received a parliamentary answer. What percentage of a health board's budget—given that it will have to meet wage increases—is spent on wages?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Pay accounts for approximately 70 per cent of a health board's costs.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

If 70 per cent of the costs are on pay and we think that pay is above the GDP deflator—

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

That is not what I said. I said that in the past, overall pay and price inflation has tended to run at about 1 per cent above GDP.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

You are not suggesting that the rate of inflation in relation to pay will be less than 2.5 per cent. We know that the Government's announcements to the pay review bodies are way above that.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes. The increases announced for the coming year are above that.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

What I am getting at is that when we take away the increased inflation for equipment, wages and drugs—that is above the GDP deflator—there is no real-terms rise in the health budget.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The only real-terms description that the Government applies to the health programme—or any other programme—is in the use of the GDP deflator. That is for comparison purposes across programmes. With regard to extra resources, Governments have always taken the view that increases should be expressed in cash. For the health service, those increases are sufficient to meet cost pressures on pay, prices and developments, taking into account the fact that any organisation can improve its efficiency.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

With respect, "Investing in You" is meant to go out to the public, who are meant to compare one area with another to determine whether enough money is going into health and so on. It is about prioritising. To use a flat 2.5 per cent deflator, which you say is for the comparison of different subject areas, is very misleading. The point about having an accurate real-terms indicator is that it tells us what we get for the money. A flat comparison is meaningless because there are different areas of inflation within different services. That is especially the case in health. With that in mind, how can we tell whether we are getting an appropriate rise in health care funding? How can a flat comparison be meaningful to anybody reading the document?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Because the document compares the amount of money that is put into the system, not the output or the outcomes.

Duncan Hamilton SNP Highlands and Islands
link

How can people tell whether their money is being used well if they cannot measure whether the outcome is worth having?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Because the input and the outcome should be described in terms of what is being delivered. The factors that I have mentioned already—cost pressures, pay pressures, new developments that might save money or cost more, efficiency savings in the health service—must be taken together to identify what the health service delivers in terms of activity, better patient care and improving health. We will not find out what the health service has left to spend by deducting what we think it is spending on pay and price inflation from the total amount of money that it has. The only way that the health service can deliver its services or provide new ones is by employing people of an appropriate standard to deliver those services. It is not true to say that the health service spends its money on continuing to do what it has always done and has a certain amount left over at the end that can be used to do other things.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Part of the problem that we have is that we are presented with an administrative

departmental budget—although I notice that the management executive budget is not itemised either—but the operational end of the spending is in the health boards and the trusts. Efficiency savings and spend-to-save programmes are mentioned, but the document gives us no idea of where major savings could be made to shift allocations around. Duncan Hamilton's point is well made: we know that the major pressure on health budgets is the cost of providing decent pay for the staff. That will never decrease. I accept some of what you are saying, but what you are saying is not in the document. There is a paragraph about drugs and another paragraph that mentions the Accounts Commission's prescribing report, on which we have been briefed. Obviously, that is an area in which efficiency savings can be made, while ensuring that the budget is used better. However, the document makes no mention of which savings might realistically be made. You can argue that costs can be balanced and efficiency savings made, but those savings are not presented in the document. Examples would be useful. It would be helpful to plot trends in areas such as the one that Malcolm Chisholm mentioned. Does money spent on community care represent a saving? We have seen that it does not, unless the standard of care is decreased. The document does not help us get answers to such questions.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Malcolm Chisholm raised a point about income raised from prescriptions for dental and ophthalmic services. I will sleep easier tonight knowing that prescription charges are netted off. Mr Aldridge, you speak a language that I do not understand. I am sure that you know what you mean, but "netted off" means nothing to me.We are examining a budget that has two laudable objectives: walk-in-walk-out hospitals and 80 one-stop clinics. I am not particularly against those objectives. However, how can I make an informed judgment about them when I do not know how much the hospitals or the clinics will cost? We need to know how much investment is needed. What will the hospitals and one-stop clinics cost?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The target is set to launch the first of the additional one-stop clinics and the walk-in-walk-out hospitals by 2002. The centre cannot simply say what it will cost. We have to get business cases from the boards and trusts that will run the facilities, to investigate the costs that will fall to them to build, equip and run the new facilities. We have to consider those business cases and ensure that they provide value for money. Only at the end of that process will we know how much they will cost.There is not much experience of walk-in-walk-out hospitals in Britain. However, where they have been set up, the capital cost has tended to be around the £20 million mark.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

We will have a new generation of those hospitals in Scotland and we will have 80 one-stop clinics—not just one—by 2002. I need to have an idea of how much all that will cost and where the money will come from.

Will we take money from the acute hospitals, primary care, GP services or somewhere else? To move toward this new dawn, we need information.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The capital expenditure would come from the capital programme, as I explained. That runs at £194 million this year. The convener mentioned schemes that will save money. One-stop clinics will do that by reducing the number of times people have to go to hospital.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Does that represent a shift of resources within the acute hospitals?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes. Where walk-in-walk-out hospitals work best, they draw together a number of activities that are scattered around in a traditional hospital so that people can get tests and treatment for minor problems in one location. That should save money.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

So that money comes from the existing budget; it is not new money.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Running costs are from the existing budget; the capital costs will have to be found.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I return to Duncan Hamilton's point: are the projects likely to be private finance initiative projects and open to scrutiny?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I would guess that proposed walk-in-walk-out hospitals will be investigated to decide whether it makes sense to build them under the PFI or to fund them publicly. That will depend on the business case. One-stop clinics tend to be relatively small; I suspect that they will rarely be suitable for the PFI, if ever.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Are one-stop clinics likely to be an extension of general practitioner services in, for example, remote and rural areas?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

There is no reason why they should not be, in some cases. It will be up to people to come forward with proposals for the way in which they think one-stop clinics can best meet the needs in their area.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

When health boards and trusts make proposals for clinics, ACADs and so on, how voluntary will that be? You mentioned the JIFs, and everyone would agree that having JIFs is a laudable idea. However, when we consider the need for a shift in resources from the secondary to the primary sector—whether that be in community care, or in relation to the JIF, or just in general, as Malcolm Chisholm was saying—the problem is that it is incredibly difficult to get resources out of the acute sector and into the primary and community sectors. If you have a fixed parcel of money in the department's budget that is allocated to one-stop clinics, or to walk-in-walk-out centres and so on, we can have more faith—even though we might ask questions about the PFI—in the way in which things are funded. We know that the money is there, and that decisions do not come down to the local health board level on whether resources are available or on whether resources can be shifted from the acute sector out into the community. If the local health board does not have the resources, or the ability to shift the resources that it does have, money will not go into the primary and community care sectors. How can we have faith that that will happen when all the evidence is that it is easier to get blood out of a stone than it is to get money out of the acute sector and into the primary and community care sectors?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Walk-in-walk-out centres will certainly require substantial amounts of capital resources that will have to be provided either centrally or through the PFI—where again the money to pay the contract price in due course would be provided centrally. Any resources for the set-up capital costs of one-stop clinics would be found centrally.I recognise your point that there might be a case for having a special, ring-fenced amount of money for those purposes. We have set up a small fund for service redesign. Health boards and trusts that are redesigning their services—which is often so that they can develop one-stop clinics—can get a bit of help with that. It often helps to have an additional person to help to manage the process of setting up a one-stop clinic, and the fund can provide support for that purpose. We have resisted deciding centrally that another two one-stops are needed in one health board area or that another 10 are needed in another area. Instead, we strongly believe that such proposals should come from the local area, where people can judge what is needed locally. That should be reflected in the HIPs and TIPs that are submitted to the department each year, which form the basis of the performance monitoring and management of the health service through the year.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

In the priorities and planning guidance document, how much financial guidance is given to health boards?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

It does not provide financial guidance as such. Alongside the priorities and planning guidance document, health boards will have their allocations—they will know how much money they have. Guidance is issued from time to time on how they should account for that money.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

That would be for the current year only; it would not indicate to them what they could expect for the three years of their project planning.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

That is an important issue. A couple of years ago, the Scottish Office—as it then was—issued for the first time indicative allocations to health boards for forward years. It gave one year's firm allocation and indicative allocations for the following two years. Those allocations could not be absolutely guaranteed, but they were an indication of what the Scottish Office expected health boards would be able to spend in those years. The last year of that is the year that we are in now.The indicative allocation for this year was confirmed last December. Since then, extra money has been made available, which will increase the amount that health boards have. They have been given advance indications. I think that that is a practice that we would wish to continue, to give health boards not only one year's firm allocation, but indicative allocations for future years, to enable them to plan for the longer term.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

In the HIPs and TIPs that have been put forward to you—especially the HIPs—are you satisfied that there are plans for capital expenditure and investment in 80 one-stop clinics?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I have not seen all the HIPs and TIPs.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

But you are supposed to be monitoring HIPs and TIPs.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

The Scottish Executive does that. Colleagues have the specific responsibility of looking at the performance management function.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Can we assume that, within the HIPs, 80 one-stop clinics are planned?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I would expect that, over the period that is covered by the HIPs, there will be additional one-stop clinics to meet the Government's commitment. I cannot say that definitively, because I have not seen them.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

People will have to start building them quickly, because the target date is 2002. As I said at the beginning, there is a difference between the Scottish Executive's targets and what the health boards are doing. Given that there is a target for 2002, we could naively assume that there are plans throughout Scotland for the planning, investment and building of 80 one-stop clinics. Those plans should be there.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

There should indeed be 80 more one-stop clinics in place by 2002.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Therefore, if we got a researcher to go through all the HIPs, we would find out where they are and how much they are costing, because the health boards will have to have those costs in their expenditure already.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

I would like to be slightly cautious: one-stop clinics do not necessarily need a great deal of investment, either capital or otherwise. As I said, they can save money. Sometimes all that is needed is a relatively simple reorganisation of services in a hospital, so a great deal of investment might not be needed, and the one-stop clinics might be achieved very quickly.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

As well as the walk-in-walk-out hospitals. That is interesting.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

What I said is not true of walk-in-walk-out hospitals: they need much more planning because they are large capital projects. A number of trusts around Scotland have plans for walk-in-walk-out hospitals that are being considered.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I will ask a follow-on question. In the acute services review, some health boards are proposing relocation of maternity units. Is that included in the capital programme? Is it included in the figures that we have in front of us?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

In so far as it requires capital investment, it would have to be funded from the capital line. I know that there are a number of proposals for changing maternity services and other acute services. Glasgow is consulting at the moment on a change to its maternity services. There are proposals in Fife and elsewhere as well.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes. In so far as they require capital spending, a bid would have to be put in for capital support with a business case.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Would the bid be put in for this after consultation?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Yes.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

So, in some cases, it will not be in the current capital programme if the consultation exercise has been, or is about to be, completed?

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

As I said, there is £194 million in the capital programme for this year. Most of that has now been committed to projects, either definitely or provisionally, depending on the outcome of further work.For future years, with the capital line remaining at broadly the same level—probably a little higher at about £200 million—as you go on from year to year a smaller proportion of that line is fully committed, so there is capacity to deal with any proposals that come in—for example, following consultation on changes to maternity services—which need to be accommodated.

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

Thank you both very much for coming to the committee this morning. This is a new process for us, and it is for you too. You may be a little more acquainted with the figures than the rest of us, but it is still a new process. We appreciate the manner in which you have answered our questions this morning.There are probably two or three other issues rumbling along. One of our colleagues, Richard Simpson, was unable to be with us this morning and has a couple of questions that he wanted to raise. If it is acceptable to you, we will put those questions to you in writing. Thank you for your contribution this morning.

John Aldridge Scottish Executive Health Department
link

Thank you, convener. I will be happy to respond to any further questions in writing.

Meeting adjourned.

On resuming—

Margaret Smith LD The Convener · Edinburgh West
link

We move to the next part of our evidence taking on the budget process. Pat Dawson from the Scottish Association of Health Councils is with us. Good morning, Pat.

Pat Dawson Scottish Association of Health Councils
link

Good morning, committee.

  1. Scottish Parliament Health and Community Care Committee Wednesday 3 May 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Budget Process Committee business · 296
  3. Organisations (Contacts) Committee business · 1
  4. Invitation Committee business · 3
  5. Budget Process (Report) Committee business · 10

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.