John Swinney and the Scottish National Party are failing to keep Scots safe. On John Swinney’s watch, our justice system is in crisis, as Scots are paying the price of SNP incompetence. This week, Scottish Labour revealed that there are 10,000 outstanding warrants for arrest in Scotland. That includes seven warrants for murder, five for attempted murder, 40 for rape, 1,253 for assault, 72 for domestic violence and 605 for drug charges. There are potential murderers, rapists and drug dealers on our streets. With 10,000 outstanding warrants in Scotland and prison numbers outstripping capacity by several hundred, apart from letting criminals out early or not arresting them at all, what will John Swinney do to tackle the crisis?
Official Report · Chamber
Justice System
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Anas Sarwar Lab 4
- John Swinney SNP 4
- Alison Johnstone 2
The record
10 contributions
link
The first thing that I would say, to give some context to the issue that Mr Sarwar is raising, is that Scotland is a safer place since this Government took office. Recorded crime remains below the position immediately prior to the pandemic in 2019-20 and is down 39 per cent since 2006-07, when this Government came into office.
I acknowledge that, at any moment, there will be outstanding arrest warrants. The execution of warrants is an operational matter for Police Scotland, which remains focused on the investigation of crime and on keeping communities safe. Police numbers are well supported in the country; the latest official statistics show that there were 16,427 police officers as of 30 June 2025, and there remains a healthy recruitment pipeline for police officers in Scotland.
The Government is taking action to address the size of the prison population, but there are significant constraints in relation to the proposals that the Government puts forward for which prisoners can be considered eligible for early release. Those standards will be rigorously applied in all that the Government takes forward.
That is a woeful answer to the fact that there are 10,000 outstanding arrest warrants in Scotland. John Swinney is unable to admit to his Government’s failure, but if he will not listen to me, maybe he will listen to people who are working on the front line. Only yesterday, the Prison Officers Association published a report that says that our prisons are at crisis point, with
“serious overcrowding and understaffing ... increased levels of violence, widespread drug misuse and self harm”
and
“plummeting staff morale”.
Unbelievably, his justice secretary said yesterday that the SNP will not build any more prisons because, in her words,
“If we build them, they will come.”
Angela Costner—sorry, I mean Angela Constance—thinks that having more prison places encourages crime, but letting criminals out early discourages crime. That might be one of the most incoherent and stupidest things that I have ever heard in my life. What are they going to claim next—that building more hospitals will somehow make people in Scotland more ill? Who does John Swinney agree with: Angela Constance or prison officers?
link
One of the many flaws in Mr Sarwar’s argument as he has just put it to me is that the Government is currently implementing the proposal to build HMP Glasgow to a design capacity of 1,344 prisoners, which will add 357 places to the overall prison estate. That debunks the nonsense that Mr Sarwar has just put to me in his diatribe.
There is a serious issue that the Parliament has to address, which is this: because of the successful prosecution of people who have committed serious crimes—many of them historic—in our society, people are serving longer sentences. Therefore, there are more long-term prisoners in our prison estate. Of the 8,000 or so prisoners who are currently in our prison estate, 2,000 are on remand. A proportion of those prisoners will not end up in the system on a long-term basis. Therefore, there are judgments to be made by the criminal justice system, independently, about the issues in relation to whether an individual should be on remand.
The other issue is about short-term sentences. There have been umpteen reports—indeed, a report that has been welcomed warmly by Mr Sarwar’s colleagues in the United Kingdom Government was produced by David Gauke, who was a very imaginative Secretary of State for Justice in the Conservative Government. Mr Gauke’s report indicates the issues that have got to be considered about short-term prison sentences.
There is a debate that must be had here in the Parliament—which my justice secretary is undertaking with numerous statements to the Parliament and a comprehensive committee appearance yesterday—about the appropriateness of prison in all circumstances for all prisoners.
I do not want my comments to be misunderstood. People who have committed heinous crimes and have been sentenced to long-term imprisonment should serve those sentences. However, there are debates to be had about the appropriateness of prison in all circumstances, because of the pressures on the prison estate. There must be appropriate disposals for individuals. Community justice authorities, the funding for which the Government has substantially increased, have a role to play. All those factors are relevant in a rational debate about the prison population, and I hope that Mr Sarwar is able to contribute to that.
John Swinney and the Scottish National Party have been in charge of the justice system for 18 years—nobody else. On their watch, the entire justice system is in chaos. The fact that all the SNP has to offer is bizarre comments and rank incompetence proves that we cannot risk a third decade of this incompetent SNP Government.
We face rising levels of violent crime, the legalisation, in effect—[Interruption.]
Let us hear Mr Sarwar.
SNP members do not want to hear it, because that is their record.
We face rising levels of violent crime, the legalisation, in effect, of shoplifting and the existence of 10,000 outstanding arrest warrants, but what does the SNP do in response? It bills the taxpayer £1 billion for a prison that was supposed to cost £100 million; it allows hundreds of drug dealers to walk free; it cuts police numbers; it closes police stations across Scotland; it lets criminals out early; and it pushes our prisons to breaking point. So when will John Swinney finally admit that his record—the SNP’s record—on justice is nothing short of criminal?
link
Mr Sarwar said that everything that has happened to date is the responsibility of my Government. I accept that responsibility. I am a First Minister who stands here every week and takes responsibility—I do not dodge it for a moment. [Interruption.]
We have listened to Mr Sarwar’s explanation. On this Government’s watch, the latest figures for 2023-24 show that recorded crime is at one of the lowest levels since 1974, and that it has gone down by 39 per cent since 2006-07. Police numbers are higher than when this Government came into office. Recorded crime is at one of the lowest levels since 1974. [Interruption.]
Just a moment, First Minister. I point out that those who are attending in the gallery today wish to hear all questions and contributions.
link
I point out to members of the public in the gallery and to members of the public who are watching at home that, in all that diatribe from Mr Sarwar, six months before an election, he did not offer a single solution to the issues that we face.
In addition, when it comes to him putting his finger on the button to vote for a budget that would provide for police numbers, prison officers and prisons, Mr Sarwar does not vote for the Government’s provisions. What we have heard from him is just rhetoric and hypocrisy. I am proud to defend a record that includes our having one of the lowest levels of crime since 1974, and I will set that out to the people of Scotland.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Oct 2025 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Modernisation) Questions · 6
- NHS Boards (Winter Resilience) Questions · 6
- Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Service Delivery Review) Questions · 6
- Social Care (Fife) Questions · 4
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Questions · 4
- Creative Scotland (Funding Awards) Questions · 4
- Local Cultural Activities and Festivals Questions · 5
- Justice System First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Justice System First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Wealth Taxes First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Fishing and Coastal Growth Fund First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Babcock (Fife) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- McCloud Judgment First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Fireworks and Pyrotechnic Articles (Scotland) Act 2022 First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Nuclear Waste (Dounreay) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Vandalism Charges (For Women Scotland) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Family Protection Plan (Maiden Life) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- National Health Service (Investment) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Offshore Wind Park (Community Representation) First Minister’s Questions · 2
- Sheku Bayoh Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 3
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Bank Closures Members’ business · 32
- Business Motions Business motions · 5
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 8
- Glasgow to Kilmarnock Rail Service Questions · 6
- Ardrossan Harbour Questions · 6
- Rural Community Transport Questions · 4
- Moray Firth FLOW-Park Questions · 6
- Wildfire Summit Questions · 4
- 2026 Commonwealth Games (Public Transport) Questions · 5
- Energy Infrastructure Projects (Objections) Questions · 9
- Natural Environment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 72
- Natural Environment (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Planning and Infrastructure Bill Bill debate · 7
- Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 32
- Decision Time Decision time · 10
- Cholangiocarcinoma Members’ business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.