Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Justice System

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 30 October 2025 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 8 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Russell Findlay Con West Scotland
link

Claire Inglis was a loving and happy young mum who was tortured and murdered by a man whom she had just begun a relationship with. The judge described Claire’s murder as “beyond sadistic”. The serial criminal who killed her had 40 convictions and was a known danger to women and children, yet he was repeatedly bailed to the home that Claire shared with her young son. Claire’s parents, Fiona and Ian, have spent four years fighting and pleading for information, and they are here today. It is their third time coming to the public gallery during First Minister’s questions. Does John Swinney agree that no family should be forced into the media glare and on to the political stage to get answers from Scotland’s justice system?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

Mr Findlay has raised the tragic case of Claire Inglis with me before, and I had the pleasure—thanks to the assistance of Mr Findlay’s staff—of being able to meet Mr and Mrs Inglis on their previous visit to the Parliament. I extend my sympathy to Mr and Mrs Inglis for the tragedy that they have experienced.

I agree with Mr Findlay that no family should have to suffer as Mr and Mrs Inglis have suffered. The issues in connection with the handling of the case surrounding the perpetrator of the murder of Claire Inglis are being explored by the Crown, and the Lord Advocate has taken independent decisions on the matter.

Russell Findlay Con West Scotland
link

Ian and Fiona are here out of devotion to their daughter and a determination to force the full truth from the authorities. As a result of their pressure, the Crown Office instructed a social work expert to investigate the circumstances of Claire’s murder. The expert’s report is truly damning. It says that Claire Inglis and her son were “invisible in the system” and that the repeated granting of bail to Claire’s home was “a major safeguarding lapse”. The Crown asked the expert to establish whether system defects caused or contributed to Claire’s murder, but Fiona and Ian have not been told the answer to that critical question. That is because the Crown gave them only a brief summary of the report. Will John Swinney back the release of the full report?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

There will be issues in relation to the release of the full report that I am not sighted on today. The Lord Advocate has, in her period in office since 2021, brought to Government an intense focus on the awful experience of victims in our criminal justice system. I pay tribute to her for the work that she has undertaken to bring the perpetrators of heinous crimes to justice. I will therefore ask her whether there can be further dialogue with Mr and Mrs Inglis on the contents of the report in order to ensure that the issues about which they remain concerned can be properly and fully aired.

There may well be issues in relation to data handling, with which Mr Findlay will be familiar, that constrain the release of the full report. If the report can be released, I am very happy for it to be released, but there may well be reasons why it cannot be. I will ask the Lord Advocate to engage further with Mr and Mrs Inglis to ensure that they can have a fuller understanding and to help them to come to terms with the tragic loss that they have suffered.

Russell Findlay Con West Scotland
link

I agree that the Lord Advocate’s focus is sincere and welcome, but the way in which the Inglis family is being treated is cruel and disrespectful. In 2022, Stirling Council held a serious incident review of Claire’s murder, which concluded that a full review was not needed. The expert disagrees, saying that a comprehensive review is “absolutely necessary”. However, to the astonishment of Fiona and Ian, the Crown Office says that it has still not decided whether their daughter’s murder merits a fatal accident inquiry.

Fiona told me:

“When we came here last year, we looked John Swinney in the eye and took him at his word that our questions would be answered, but we are still being kept in the dark.”

Will John Swinney back the family’s calls for a fatal accident inquiry?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

I am trying to be as helpful as I can. I hope that Mr Findlay understands the sincerity of my engagement on the issue. The calling of a fatal accident inquiry is a matter for the Lord Advocate independently. I understand that Mr Findlay is able to call for such inquiries but, as First Minister, I have to respect the independence of the Lord Advocate. For me to act otherwise would contravene my oath of office, which I will not do.

The process of investigation that was originally conceived of in Stirling Council was not acceptable—it was not good enough. That is why I asked the Crown to look at the matter again and why Mr Findlay has the report in his possession. That was at my instigation; I judged that the initial inquiries were totally unsatisfactory.

There is a matter of further consideration as to whether a fatal accident inquiry would shed any more light on the issue than the exercise on which Mr Findlay has the report. However, I will raise these issues directly with the Lord Advocate and ask her for her consideration of the matter, to ensure that Mr and Mrs Inglis have as much support as possible to come to terms with the loss that they have suffered.

Russell Findlay Con West Scotland
link

Another reason why an FAI is absolutely critical is that the Crown’s report reveals a major flaw at the heart of Scotland’s bail system. It says that

“social workers are not obligated to verify bail addresses”,

which explains why a violent criminal who was a known danger to women and children was repeatedly bailed to Claire’s home address. The report describes that as a “systemic flaw”.

My party has published a paper today setting out changes that are needed to fix Scotland’s justice system and to put victims first. Fiona and Ian have urged the Government to back that specific change so that courts must check the veracity and safety of addresses. They say that that could prevent another family from suffering such a tragedy. Will John Swinney commit to urgently ending the bail blind spot that is putting women and children in danger?

John Swinney SNP The First Minister · Perthshire North
link

I am familiar with the points that Mr Findlay has raised and, as always with issues that relate to the criminal justice system, we will give them consideration.

I hope that this provides some degree of reassurance, but under the recent legislation that the Parliament approved, the single bail test makes it clear that the court should specifically consider the protection of the victim from the risk of physical and psychological harm before making a decision on bail. In my view, that would provide the type of protection that Mr Findlay is looking for, and it is already in statute.

I appreciate that that is of absolutely no comfort to Mr and Mrs Inglis in the loss that they have suffered, but I hope that it reassures members of the public that the Government is taking action to ensure that the type of experience that Mr and Mrs Inglis have faced will be mitigated in the future because of the steps that we have taken to change the law.

I will, of course, give consideration to the points that Mr Findlay has raised and, as always, I will be happy to see Mr and Mrs Inglis, if that would be of any assistance to them.

  1. General Question Time Questions · 1
  2. Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Modernisation) Questions · 6
  3. NHS Boards (Winter Resilience) Questions · 6
  4. Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (Service Delivery Review) Questions · 6
  5. Social Care (Fife) Questions · 4
  6. NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Questions · 4
  7. Creative Scotland (Funding Awards) Questions · 4
  8. Local Cultural Activities and Festivals Questions · 5
  9. Justice System First Minister’s Questions · 8
  10. Justice System First Minister’s Questions · 10
  11. Wealth Taxes First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. Fishing and Coastal Growth Fund First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Babcock (Fife) First Minister’s Questions · 7
  14. McCloud Judgment First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Fireworks and Pyrotechnic Articles (Scotland) Act 2022 First Minister’s Questions · 9
  16. Nuclear Waste (Dounreay) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  17. Vandalism Charges (For Women Scotland) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  18. Family Protection Plan (Maiden Life) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  19. National Health Service (Investment) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  20. Offshore Wind Park (Community Representation) First Minister’s Questions · 2
  21. Sheku Bayoh Inquiry First Minister’s Questions · 3
  22. Point of Order Procedure · 2
  23. Bank Closures Members’ business · 32
  24. Business Motions Business motions · 5
  25. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 8
  26. Glasgow to Kilmarnock Rail Service Questions · 6
  27. Ardrossan Harbour Questions · 6
  28. Rural Community Transport Questions · 4
  29. Moray Firth FLOW-Park Questions · 6
  30. Wildfire Summit Questions · 4
  31. 2026 Commonwealth Games (Public Transport) Questions · 5
  32. Energy Infrastructure Projects (Objections) Questions · 9
  33. Natural Environment (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 72
  34. Natural Environment (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
  35. Planning and Infrastructure Bill Bill debate · 7
  36. Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 32
  37. Decision Time Decision time · 10
  38. Cholangiocarcinoma Members’ business · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.