The Health and Sport Committee will love us. Item 5 is a response from the accountable officer to "A performance overview of sport in Scotland". The Health and Sport Committee is doing some work on the issue, and what we have is relevant to that. Are there any issues that members want to be clarified or pursued, or do we agree simply to refer the report to the Health and Sport Committee?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports: Responses
“A performance overview of sport in Scotland”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hugh Henry Lab 12
- Cathie Craigie Lab 4
- Andrew Welsh SNP 2
- Stuart McMillan SNP 2
- George Foulkes Lab 2
- Willie Coffey SNP 1
- Murdo Fraser Con 1
- Tracey Reilly 1
- Nicol Stephen LD 1
The record
26 contributionsI have a question of clarification. The last sentence in paragraph 2 of the response states:"Activities take place in and around the school day with over half taking place immediately after school and the rest at lunchtime, break time, before and during the school day as well as in the evening and at weekends."What does that mean? It seems to say that more than half of activities take place after school and, if I am reading it correctly, half during school and at other times. Could we get some clarification on what that means?
We can certainly ask for that. Do you want to hold the report pending that clarification?
No, not necessarily.
Okay, we can seek clarification on that and agree to refer the matter to the Health and Sport Committee, along with any reply that we receive, for its consideration.
I am disappointed by paragraph 7 of the response. The committee has done some work on this, although I have not been involved in all of it. The committee wanted to find out whether and when there would be a survey on participation levels. I am disappointed to note that, after giving all the reasons for the previous survey and stating how things would be calculated, the letter states:"There are … currently no plans to carry out a follow up survey."We all agree that encouraging young people to become involved in sport is good for both their educational experience and health, and therefore good for the future of the country as a whole, so it is disappointing that there are no plans to conduct a follow-up survey on how effective, or otherwise, the policy is.
We could certainly ask either Dr Woods or the minister how they intend to monitor the introduction of two hours of physical education.
link
I agree with Cathie Craigie on paragraph 7. I am sure that parents in Renfrewshire and East Renfrewshire will be delighted with some of the information in paragraph 11, but the letter has not been proofread properly. This is a pedantic point, but it says "form" instead of "from" and "S1 to S"—S what? Some of the responses are shoddy and extremely unprofessional.
Those mistakes prompt other questions. When the letter says that Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Education is "finding schools which are providing more than 2 hours of physical education each week",does it mean that all schools are doing that, or that HMIE stumbled across one such school, enabling it to say that it is "finding schools"?
The response uses such language all the way through. It is empty, and there is nothing specific to home in on.
We could clarify how many such schools have been found—either from Dr Woods or from HMIE directly.
My question also refers to paragraph 11. I thought from our previous discussion that levels of participation in sport were lower in the west of Scotland than elsewhere. That was a very clear message, but paragraph 11 seems to contradict that by dint of the HMIE report finding a couple of isolated cases of good practice in the west of Scotland. It needs to be clarified that the strong message was that there were lower levels of participation in the west of Scotland. We need to understand why that is the case.
link
My question goes back to Cathie Craigie's point and it ties in with Willie Coffey's point and some of the other points that have been made. A baseline survey was done in 2004-05. The convener said that we should ask how the Government intends to assess progress. The answer is in paragraph 7 of the response, which states that it was intended"that HMIE would monitor progress".The problem with the HMIE system is that it is very much piecemeal and it measures individual schools on a case-by-case basis, so we cannot get a complete picture. That is a fundamental issue. It would be helpful, not necessarily now but in the future, to have a further survey so that we can draw a direct comparison with the 2004-05 survey and see what progress has been made. We should make that point.
I wonder whether some of the people who write these reports ever get out and about. I was talking the other day to Gavin Brown, who had been down at Tynecastle to see some of the work that is being done there—lots of youngsters come in as part of Heart of Midlothian Football Club's youth football programme and community programme. I am led to believe that other clubs do something similar. That never seems to come up. All that we hear about is a narrow part of the spectrum of what is happening. There is an awful—I nearly said "hell of a"—lot more going on. Are Scottish Government officials aware of such programmes?
Those issues are certainly relevant to officials, but they are not particularly relevant to the remit of the committee on this issue. I suggest that we refer the response to the Health and Sport Committee for its consideration but indicate that we are pursuing some outstanding issues. For example, we will ask about monitoring and about gaps in the service provided by HMIE, we will ask how many positive examples of schools HMIE found in Renfrewshire and East Renfrewshire and we will ask about a couple of other issues that have been raised. We will ask those questions and come back to the issue but, in the meantime, we will refer the response to the Health and Sport Committee.
link
In respect of the reference to Renfrewshire and East Renfrewshire in paragraph 11, I would be keen to establish what the missing number is in the phrase "S1 to S"
We will clarify that point.
Are you referring the matter on to the health committee?
Yes.
Why is it being referred to the health committee rather than the education and sport committee?
I understand that sport comes within the health committee's remit.
The Health and Sport Committee is currently doing some work on the issue.
Does sport come within health?
Yes, Nicola Sturgeon is the responsible cabinet secretary.
I will follow that point up in relation to HMIE reporting on physical education. Is that still a responsibility of the education department? Is Nicola Sturgeon responsible for PE and sport issues in relation to the development of the curriculum for excellence and the pressures that there might be on the school curriculum in both primary and secondary schools?
We can find that out. HMIE is accountable to and reports to Fiona Hyslop rather than Nicola Sturgeon. We will ask a specific question on that point. Do we agree on that course of action?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Nov 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Wednesday 12 November 2008 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 28
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 21
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 31
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 26
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 21
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.