The next item on the agenda is a response from the accountable officer to the Auditor General for Scotland's report, "Review of the new General Medical Services contract". Do members have any comments?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports: Responses
“Review of the new General Medical Services contract”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hugh Henry Lab 7
- Andrew Welsh SNP 4
- George Foulkes Lab 3
- Murdo Fraser Con 2
- Caroline Gardner 2
- Mr Black 1
- Cathie Craigie Lab 1
- Willie Coffey SNP 1
The record
21 contributionsOn workforce planning, the Auditor General told the committee:"there is no comprehensive set of important basic information to assist in managing the NHS and planning its workforce effectively."—Official Report, Audit Committee, 10 September 2008; c 611.If we do not have that, what can we do? That links back to the previous discussion: unless the information is correct, decisions are based on incorrect information, which does not make for good decision making. That is a great worry.
link
When we took evidence from the Auditor General, I remember that one of the issues that came out of the report was whether there had been value for money for the public purse from the new contract. We put that specific point in our letter to Kevin Woods. His reply is interesting, but it does not entirely address our point. In the section on value for money, Dr Woods acknowledges:"there is clear evidence that recruitment and retention issues have been addressed successfully, reflected in a significant growth in the number of applications to become GP registrars, as general practice has become more attractive as a career".I think that we all knew that already. If the amount of money paid to GPs is substantially increased, it is no wonder that more applicants are attracted to the profession. The back page of annex B to the letter gives GP income figures and shows how net profit increased between 2003-04 and 2006-07. The money that is paid to GPs as independent contractors increased substantially, so nobody should be surprised that GPs are happier than they were. That was not the point. The point was to examine whether substantially increasing the reward for GPs has been beneficial in delivering improvements in the care that they provide and whether it has represented good value for money. I am not convinced that Dr Woods has replied satisfactorily to those questions.
When was the new GP contract agreed? How many years ago did it start?
The contract started in 2004-05.
That was four years ago.
That is right.
So the contract has run for four years. Under the heading "Impact of the contract elsewhere in the NHS" on the second-last page of his letter, Kevin Woods says:"We are also looking in more detail at the trends in unscheduled care services".We asked about the knock-on effect on such services. The letter says:"We intend to use this work to tell us more about how the GP contract affects these services, as well as how we may be able to influence other, external, factors".Why has it taken four years to start that work? I presume that it has been evident to most people—as it certainly has been to me—how much the GP contract has affected other services. Can anyone answer that question? I know that we should ask Dr Woods—not that we would receive a decent reply.
Given the comments by Andrew Welsh, Murdo Fraser and George Foulkes, the question is what more we can do. Are we at the stage of noting the response? Do we have points that we still want to pursue? Should the Health and Sport committee now consider some issues? The main decision that we need to make today is what we do with the report.
I have a great problem with the whole NHS organisation and system, which is full of acronyms, committees and groups. They all seem to meet and talk, yet the NHS does not have some fundamental information—for example, the letter refers to"a lack of comprehensive workforce data for GPs and GP practice staff."We know from the previous agenda item that we have a national clinical lead for palliative care, who was appointed in 2008, and executive leads for palliative care. The attitude in the whole organisation is lead—as in balloon. It is almost self-perpetuating and inward looking rather than concerned with the task out there in hospitals and GP practices. If the organisation does not have the fundamental information, it cannot make sensible decisions. If, when information is received, it disappears into committees and working groups that produce nothing, there is something wrong with the organisation. I have seen that for about 20 years, if not more.I have difficulty with all that. We have a nice wee answer, but I am not sure whether it takes us further forward. All of us are willing the NHS to be good at what it does and to take the proper action, but I am not sure whether we are seeing that happen.
Does the Auditor General intend to do further work on the GP contract?
Yes. What comes through from Dr Woods's letter is the fact that the task is still work in progress. I noted the observation that the Government should perhaps have been further along the road sooner, but I am not in a position to comment on that.The response says that the Government has attempted to contain the cost through the inflationary uplift and through reducing the money for the correction factor, which provides financial compensation without any direct benefit. It says that the quality and outcomes framework is being used to try to address what GPs are doing. Dr Woods also says that trends in unscheduled care services will be examined in more detail. All that supports the view that the matter is work in progress.We have in mind two studies. One will be a fairly major study of the unscheduled care system, which will throw further light on exactly what is happening.The second study will be in the forward work programme that we will bring to the committee in the new year—it will come towards the end of the next programme. The study will examine the major pay policies that have been implemented in the NHS over the past few years—the consultants contract, the agenda for change and the general medical services contract being the three major ones. We want to take a slightly longer look—after more time has passed—at whether there is evidence of value-for-money benefits coming through. It will be a couple of years before we can bring the results back to you.
So the dilemma is what we do now.
Before we move on, can I have some explanation of the final paragraph on the second-last page of Dr Woods's letter, under the heading "The Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF)"? It talks about"substantial changes to QOF in 2006/07 with 166 points recycled and 9 new clinical areas.
A further 58 points were recycled".What does that mean? Recycling is a good thing to do, but I do not quite understand—perhaps because I am a new member of the committee—what the paragraph means.
It means that the highest level of recycling of any Government agency or department has been achieved.
Cathie Craigie can rest easy, because I am delighted to see that"An even more independent process for the development of new QOF indicators is being considered at present and should in future involve NHS QIS."There you are—we can all rest easy. Over the decades, I have seen a certain attitude of mind—an organisation that exists for itself.
I will throw in another comment. We asked specifically about how to target deprivation. The response in the letter suggests that we should look for communities where there are higher incidences of disease and target additional resources in that way. As everybody knows, the Scottish index of multiple deprivation gives us clear and specific information about pockets of deprivation in Scottish communities. I would expect the index to be used as a more accurate indicator of where we should distribute resources, rather than just looking around for pockets of incidence of disease. I am sure that there is a correlation, but I am pretty certain that the SIMD index is a far more reliable source.
I suppose that we have three choices. One is to pursue further with Dr Woods some of the concerns that we have raised this morning and to consider whether we want to report on those, if warranted. The second option is to refer any outstanding issues to the Health and Sport Committee for its consideration. The third option is to simply note the report.
link
Poor old Dr Woods must think that this committee is his nemesis. I do not think that there is much to be gained from having another torturous evidence-taking session with him. Some serious issues have not been addressed in the response, but I suspect that the committee has taken matters as far as it can at this stage. We should report to the Health and Sport Committee where we have got to and suggest that it pursues the issues further if they are of interest to it.It was interesting to hear what the Auditor General had to say about the work that Audit Scotland continues to do in the area; no doubt we can revisit that in a couple of years when we see what comes out of the Auditor General's office.
We could express our serious concerns to the Health and Sport Committee about the substance behind the work and hope that it monitors the situation and tries to encourage appropriate action. There are plenty of action points that must be followed through to ensure that things happen properly. We are in the land of jargon, which obscures the issue. There should be some fundamental thinking about what the system is meant to do and how it can do it better.
Do we agree to refer the matter to the Health and Sport Committee?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 12 Nov 2008 →- Scottish Parliament Audit Committee Wednesday 12 November 2008 Committee business · 1
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 28
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 21
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 31
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 26
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 21
- Section 23 Reports: Responses Committee business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.