PE1946, which was lodged by Sean Clerkin, calls on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to use general taxation to pay for all charges for homeless temporary accommodation, including writing off the £33.3 million debt owed by homeless people for temporary accommodation to local authorities.
We last considered the petition on 13 November 2024, when we agreed to write to the Association of Local Authority Chief Housing Officers and to the Scottish Government. We asked the Scottish Government for an update on the work undertaken by the housing affordability working group, and its submission states:
“the group has explored the underlying meaning of affordability and its different uses within housing debates, policy and practice. The group has not been asked to find solutions to housing affordability problems, nor has it been asked to focus specifically on homeless households. Rather, members have worked together to agree a shared understanding of what housing affordability is and how it should be measured, in order to support a range of policy and sector requirements across relevant areas.”
That might not have been everybody’s expectation, but there we are.
That report’s recommendations were expected before the summer recess in 2024. However, the Scottish Government's submission states that reaching consensus between stakeholders has—and I quote—“taken time”.
In response, the petitioner states that
“The ... exercise is yet another working group going nowhere”,
and, in his submission, he reiterates the increasing numbers of people in temporary accommodation and states:
“General Taxation should be used to pay for the costs of temporary accommodation”.
In its response to the committee, the Association of Local Authority Chief Housing Officers shares its view that it does
“not think that there is any case for the Scottish Government to take on the cost of funding temporary accommodation or to write off existing arrears.”
However, the submission highlights a number of areas where there is a lack of clear data to inform any work that could be undertaken in that area, and it explains that
“Most of those in temporary accommodation are eligible for housing benefit”,
which
“In most cases ... will cover the full cost to the resident with a deduction for heating or ‘board’ where this is included in the rent charge.”
Finally, the submission notes that
“Councils ... take a proportionate approach to collecting any arrears that do arise”,
including debt write-off, when that is the most appropriate approach. The association also suggests
“targeted funding to support the acquisition of additional ... temporary accommodation to support councils to meet their statutory obligations and provide the quality of temporary accommodation that homeless applicants are entitled to expect”,
and calls for
“a more consistent approach to accounting for the cost of temporary accommodation to improve transparency around charges and value for money.”
Do we have any suggestions as to how we might proceed? Mr Torrance, do you want to comment? There is a case for writing to the Minister for Housing, I think.
