Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Devolution Post-EU

Thursday 29 June 2023 Constitution, Europe, External Affairs and Culture Committee About 09:00–10:15 Committee business 42 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing Donald Cameron only · show everyone

Donald Cameron’s contributions

6 contributions
Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

The title of the inquiry is “How is Devolution Changing post-EU?”; it is not “What is the State of Devolution at Present?”

I know your general views on this well, cabinet secretary, but you mentioned some aspects, such as the use of section 35 of the Scotland Act 1998, and the UK Government funding in devolved areas, none of which could be argued is against the devolution settlement. Some might say that it is intrinsic to the devolution settlement. To what extent do you think that Brexit has been the catalyst for changes to attitudes, or not?

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

I have two questions—one on Sewel and one on IGR. I will look at IGR first.

There is a dispute mechanism in the current IGR system, and there was a consensus among witnesses who have come before the committee that that remains untried. I do not think that the Scottish Government has sought to trigger the process, although you will correct me if I am wrong. What are your views on the efficacy of the IGR system, both at ministerial and official levels?

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

Is it your view, and the Scottish Government’s view, that that is not even worth trying?

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you.

I would like to touch on the Sewel convention, as it overlaps with some of what we have just been discussing. The committee has taken the unanimous view that the Sewel convention is under strain. There have been some very high-profile examples post-Brexit of the Scottish Parliament not consenting to legislation, but there have also been several examples of the Scottish Parliament consenting to legislation post-Brexit in areas such as fisheries and farming. For example, in 2021, the Scottish Parliament gave consent to eight UK bills. Only last night, we voted on an LCM on the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Bill. Your Government’s legislative consent memorandum to that bill said:

“The Scottish Government remains supportive of the intent of the Bill and believes that engagement has been good overall between officials.”

There are clearly tensions and strains in the use of the Sewel convention, but do you agree that this is about politics and personalities and that, at the official level, day to day, the Sewel convention still works?

09:45

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

On Alasdair Allan’s question about Westminster sovereignty, we all know one another’s constitutional positions but, ultimately, devolution is what it says it is: it is not the surrender of power but the devolution of power. Intrinsic to the 1998 settlement is the understanding that the UK Government can still legislate in devolved areas. Ultimately, however much some people might dislike it and might want Scotland to be independent, devolution entails some reservation of power. As it is set up, that is just the nature of the beast—there is a reserving, or a withholding, of power.

Donald Cameron Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry, convener—I know that you are anxious to draw this to a close.

Section 35 was legislated for, as was the Government equivalent, which I think is section 48. Someone in the Labour Government, at that point, thought that there was a need to enshrine that in legislation. I am sure that there has been a change of views and practice and so on in the past 24 years, but at that point in time, someone believed that.

  1. 09:00 Devolution Post-EU Committee business · 42
  2. 10:15 Culture in Communities Committee business · 32

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.