link
Going back a bit, with regard to intergovernmental relations, I reflect on my experience in Government dealing with UK ministers in different portfolio areas. I endorse what you said about how reliant the functioning of that system is on having UK ministers who understand and care about devolution. You mentioned Chloe Smith, and I would say that she is somebody who understands devolution and cares about it. I just want to give you the opportunity to reflect more on the importance of the personality of the minister in the UK Government, whatever the policy area is, in terms of intergovernmental relations. Without that, you get the experience, as you have set out, of its just being a tick-box exercise that is badly informed and certainly not meaningful for the Scottish Government or the Welsh Government.