Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 24 June 2003 Finance Committee Procedure 19 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Showing Fergus Ewing only · show everyone

Fergus Ewing’s contributions

4 contributions
Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Obviously we have certain work that we have to do and I am sure that we will do it, but I am less concerned about the timing aspects. It is essential that we have a discrete inquiry as part of our role of scrutinising all the public financing of bodies in Scotland. Convener, as you know I argued at the last two meetings, as I argue today, that the matter—other than the Holyrood project, into which there is already an investigation—that is of most concern not only to businesses but to consumers, is Scottish Water and the regulatory regime. It is essential that we have an inquiry into Scottish Water.I note from the work programme that from September to December we have five possible meeting days—9 and 23 September, 7 October, 18 November and 16 December—when we could proceed with a discrete inquiry into Scottish Water; it is therefore plain that we have the time. I am sure that all members agree that we should be prepared to meet weekly rather than fortnightly if we have a job to do. I argue that we do have a job to do; that job is to conduct a thoroughgoing inquiry into the finances of Scottish Water. I wish to make a couple of points about why I feel the issue is so important. We learn—from the briefing that members received from the Federation of Small Businesses—that Scottish businesses pay five to 10 times more for water than do their English counterparts. We learn also that, following the introduction of fixed charges, charges for business customers have risen astronomically. We learn, too, about the debt burden problems that the Scottish water industry faces. The FSB has argued that the committee should review the operational management of Scottish Water, and the Forum of Private Business has also asked specifically that the committee undertake such an inquiry. I understand that every other business body is concerned about the issue and that regular meetings are being held throughout Scotland.I believe that the water industry commissioner is on record as saying that he thinks that £300 million could be saved from the operational budget of Scottish Water. That is almost—but not quite—enough to buy a Parliament building with. Given that the regulator has argued that £300 million could be saved, the committee has an obligation to see whether that claim has merit. Although my view is that the claim is exaggerated, even if we could save £100 million, the people of Scotland would congratulate us on that.There is the question of whether other committees might do such work on Scottish Water. Discussion with the clerks has led me to understand—I hope that they will back up what I say—that the Enterprise and Culture Committee is likely to have an inquiry into top-up fees, which will take it until the end of the year, and that the Environment and Rural Development Committee has other business that will take it until the end of the year. The Enterprise and Culture Committee has said that it is unlikely to be available to carry out an inquiry into Scottish Water next year and I believe that the Environment and Rural Development Committee faces the prospect of considering up to eight bills; the clerk will correct me if I am wrong. As someone who sat on the then Rural Development Committee, I know how time consuming that process can be.Therefore, it seems that the Finance Committee is the only committee in the Parliament that has the remit and responsibility to investigate the serious matter of Scottish Water. That is why I strongly urge members to consider having a thorough inquiry along the lines that the FSB suggests. If such an inquiry is agreed in principle, a sub-committee could formulate its remit, or the issue could be examined at our away day, although formulation of the precise remit is not as important as acknowledgement of the anger that is felt around Scotland about the rises in water charges and the question marks about efficiency, the servicing of the debt and a huge number of other issues surrounding Scottish Water. Scottish Water is the topic of the day; I hope that we can agree to carry out an inquiry into it.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Just before we vote, I agree that the work that the convener has described is necessary, but I think that we could also cope with an inquiry into Scottish Water, because there are five blank days in the diary between now and December. I am not persuaded that those five days will be filled magically by consideration of financial memorandums; that is not likely. I am not suggesting that all five days would be required for the proposed inquiry—four days might be sufficient. I could be wrong but, in any event, it would be for committee members to decide on that. I am not proposing an alternative to the convener's proposition; I am proposing a supplement. I suggest that, in addition to the work that the convener has described, we should hold an inquiry into Scottish Water. I just wanted to make that clear.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I would like clarification. You said that consideration of the financial memorandum might eat into the blank days, which are 9 September, 23 September, 18 November and 16 December. Do you suggest that we act on an ad hoc basis? For practical house-keeping reasons, is not it necessary to pre-book dates?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

With respect, I proposed that we have in inquiry into Scottish Water to start in September and members voted against that. That speaks for itself.

  1. Scottish Parliament Finance Committee Tuesday 24 June 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Adviser (Candidates) Committee business · 15
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 19
  5. Cross-cutting Review Committee business · 7

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.