Item 3 is further consideration of the committee's work programme. Members have a series of papers that set out a draft schedule of meetings and suggest inquiries and other work, which arose from the trawl that we undertook. The papers were put together following members' raising of particular issues at the previous meeting.First, I refer members to the meeting schedule that the Conveners Group agreed. Each committee has, as a starting point, been given a fortnightly slot. Because of the amount of legislation that I expect the committee to consider during the coming year and the range of suggestions from last week's meeting, I have asked the clerk to arrange provisional additional slots that would give us a weekly schedule. It might be that not every additional slot will be required—we can cancel meetings if that is the case—but I thought it best to secure the extra slots, given the extent of our commitments.The draft schedule should be the starting point. It contains everything that we are obliged to do, and other items to which we are already committed. Our discussion of other items should therefore be conducted in that context.We have three other papers before us, two of which result from the previous committee's recommendation that we undertake cross-cutting expenditure reviews. The third is a paper that was issued on Friday, which brings together all the suggestions that were made by members last week. That paper takes account of the cross-cutting reviews, so it might be productive to consider that first. David, do you wish to say anything on that paper?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Des McNulty only · show everyone- Des McNulty Lab 9
- Fergus Ewing SNP 4
- Jeremy Purvis LD 2
- David McGill 1
- Jim Mather SNP 1
- Kate Maclean Lab 1
Des McNulty’s contributions
9 contributionsI have two crucial points to make: first, because of the truncated nature of the budget process—the fact that we are trying to deal with two stages of the budget process in a three-month period between September and November—our routine work on the budget process will be fairly intense, which limits what we can achieve.It is also the case, as is illustrated in our papers, that a series of legislative proposals will be brought before us, especially because we are at the start of a new session of Parliament. Our job in relation to those proposals is to examine the financial memoranda. For some bills we will want to examine the financial memoranda in depth and to hear from witnesses. The previous Finance Committee was fairly seriously criticised by the Auditor General about its lack of scrutiny of legislation, although that situation was tightened up in the last 18 months of the previous Finance Committee. It is crucial for the credibility of the committee that we give to bills and financial memoranda the scrutiny that is required.Bills will come forward, and we will deal with them at or around stage 1, so quite a lot of work on fairly significant legislation will arrive on our desks. With that in mind, I have serious reservations about whether it will be possible for us to have discrete inquiries in the first three months of the operation of the committee. We can consider having discrete inquiries from November onwards, but I have serious concerns about holding discrete inquiries before then.
The committee faces two propositions. The first is my proposal that we concentrate, in our first three or four months, on developing and refining the budgetary process and on dealing with our responsibilities in relation to new legislation. That is quite likely to lead to our having to meet nearly every week, if not every week.If I have interpreted Fergus Ewing's suggestion correctly, the second proposition is that we hold a specific inquiry on the water industry, which should begin in September. I suggest that we vote on whether to do that.
In principle, I am not opposed to investigating Scottish Water; my concern is about the timetable for doing so. The issue is whether we go along the lines that I am suggesting—in other words, for the first three months or so from September, we scrutinise new legislation that comes forward and the budgetary process, period—or whether we adopt Fergus Ewing's proposition, which is that we also launch an inquiry into Scottish Water as soon as possible after the summer recess. Those are the choices that we have and there is no way to decide on the matter other than to put it to a vote.
I believe that I made it clear that we are pre-booking the dates. The "blank days", as Fergus Ewing puts it, are dates on which I anticipate we will have to meet and engage in detailed scrutiny. The present problem is to identify which bills will emerge and in which order. Four bills have been presented already, three of which merit some detailed committee scrutiny. We anticipate that further bills will emerge in September or October and that they will all require committee scrutiny. My concern is that we have a substantial work load over that period. Our primary responsibilities are to deal with our work load over what will probably be the busiest period that the Finance Committee will face.Fergus Ewing is right to say that the Finance Committee could launch an inquiry into Scottish Water, although particular responsibility for that matter lies with the Environment and Rural Development Committee. I accept that that committee's diary is full, but the Finance Committee's diary is also full.
Fergus Ewing proposes that today we take a decision in principle to undertake a water inquiry.
That is a valuable suggestion and it might even be a precursor to an inquiry on Scottish Water that we may decide to undertake in due course. We can develop those issues during the away day. We have a specific proposal from Fergus Ewing, however, and we should decide on it now.Who is in favour of Fergus Ewing's proposal that we have an immediate inquiry into Scottish Water?
The result of the division is: For 2, Against 6, Abstentions 1.As a result of the vote, let us direct the business of the away day as outlined in the documents that members received before the meeting. I am happy to hear further suggestions.
That is correct. The committee has voted against a specific proposal to launch an inquiry in September. I am happy to develop Jim Mather's suggestion.
In this meeting
Everything on 24 Jun 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Finance Committee Tuesday 24 June 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Item in Private Procedure · 1
- Adviser (Candidates) Committee business · 15
- Work Programme Procedure · 19
- Cross-cutting Review Committee business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.