Hopefully, both voices can be heard as one today. Hopefully, changes can be made for the better after today.
Who was Rhys? Rhys was my first-born child. He was healthy, he was happy and he was loved by his family and friends. He looked forward to living his life to the fullest and shared the ambitions and dreams of many 19-year-olds, but his life ended at 19, just before his ambitions and dreams could start to come to fruition. Rhys was a loving, caring boy. He did not bother anyone, no one bothered him and he did not get into trouble. He was a happy-go-lucky teenager who had his whole life ahead of him. He had a career to establish, he had a future, he had true love to find and a family to build—he had his whole future ahead of him.
Rhys was 19 years old when he was taken from me. The day he went missing was the day that my nightmare started and my world changed for ever. The loss of a child is every parent’s worst nightmare.
What happened? Rhys went missing on 24 July 2019. His half-naked teenage body was later discovered on Thursday, 8 August 2019. Items of his clothing were scattered and missing. Police Scotland closed the investigation into the death on Monday, 12 August 2019—four days but only one full working day later. I believe that those times speak volumes. That was one day spent investigating my son’s death. My son’s life was worth one full working day to Police Scotland. Just to repeat that: Rhys’s half-naked teenage body was found on a Thursday afternoon and the investigation was officially closed on the following Monday. It was categorised as a missing person now found with no suspicious circumstances. My family and I were left to conduct door-to-door inquiries and build up a timeline of Rhys’s final movements. We were also left to chase and secure closed-circuit television footage and statements from different local sources.
We discovered video footage of my son Rhys’s body being dragged by ropes across open land—two football yards—in broad daylight by the police. I will never forget seeing these images as they will haunt me for ever. The police did not bother to try to prevent the public from filming this.
If the body of a half-naked 19-year-old girl had been discovered in an affluent area, I believe that the investigation would have looked a lot different. I believe that the victim’s family would have been treated a lot differently. I believe that the approach of the police would have been completely different.
What do I believe went wrong? When a body is initially discovered, there is a vital window of time where important decisions are made by the police. At this point, if the police cannot see any obvious signs of criminality or a clear cause of death, they have to make a decision despite the cause of death being unknown or, as they say, “unexplained”. In other words, the police have to form a theory based on what they see at the time at the scene, what evidence is clear to them and what the circumstances seem to be. This is where the theory is often made without the cause of death actually being officially established, without post-mortem and toxicology results being consulted. In fact, the investigation into Rhys’s death was closed before he was even formally identified.
I believe there is pressure on the police in terms of time and resources to make those decisions quickly and move on, and that is where mistakes can be made, which cannot be undone, leaving families without answers or closure—leaving families tormented forever.
I believe that postcodes play a significant factor in the decision making of the police and the theories that they form. I also believe that what is going on at the time of a discovery influences the police’s theory. For example, in the summer of 2019, when Rhys’s body was discovered, there seemed to be a high number of suicides and drug-related deaths being reported in the media and many of those involved younger men. So, I believe that, given the climate at that time, when they discovered Rhys’s body in that postcode area, the police’s theory was drawn towards a suicide or drug-related death. I think the police thought, “Just another young man from a housing scheme who lost his life through suicide or an overdose, so let’s not waste any time—just close the investigation and move on”.
Police Scotland failed to fully investigate Rhys’s death. That is not my opinion; it is a fact, as it was upheld by Police Scotland within my complaint in December 2020. Police Scotland did not even bother to conduct door-to-door inquiries. It is the basic stuff like that that could have made a difference both in terms of securing vital evidence and trust and confidence in the police investigation. My family and I were left to conduct door-to-door inquiries and build up our own timeline of my son Rhys’s last movements. Police Scotland then failed to fully investigate my complaint regarding the flawed investigations into my son’s death. Four key points were upheld by the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner recently.
How has this impacted my family and me? I am a mum from a housing scheme—a wee mammy from Barlanark—and I am not accustomed to talking to politicians, especially in such surroundings. I want to connect with you and describe my pain, the void left when a child, a loved one, dies and there is no explanation given. I want to try to explain what it feels like when a loved one is the subject of an unexplained death.
Take a few seconds to think of someone you love, bravely hold that image of that person in your minds, concentrate on that person’s image. As distressing as this may be, imagine the police contacting you and informing you that the person is dead and their body has been discovered half naked in open land—in my case, after the initial shock, I felt like I had been struck by a bow and arrow straight through my heart. The first question you would ask is, “What happened?” You have lost your loved one. You need answers. You need an explanation. You need closure. You need that to start the grieving process and try to move on.
But imagine that there was no explanation given to you. Imagine how you would feel. You have lost your loved one forever and there is no explanation whatsoever. That is what the families face when they lose their loved one to an unexplained death. They cannot move on. They are left thinking about every possible scenario, night after night, week after week, as months turn into years.
Imagine discovering that the police had closed their investigation into the death of your loved one four days—or one working day—later, even before the body had even been formally identified, before a pathology report was made, before a toxicology report was made, before establishing a timeline of your loved one’s last movements—Interruption. Sorry.