Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Specified Type B Procedures) (Scotland) Regulations 2021 [Draft]

Tuesday 9 February 2021 Health and Sport Committee About 11:15 Subordinate legislation 12 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The next item is consideration of more subordinate legislation—this time, a draft affirmative instrument.

For this item, I welcome to the committee Mairi Gougeon, the Minister for Public Health, Sport and Wellbeing, who is accompanied by Sharon Grant from the health protection division and Caroline Mackintosh, from the legal directorate of the Scottish Government. I thank you for joining us today and invite Mairi Gougeon to make brief opening remarks on the instrument.

Mairi Gougeon SNP The Minister for Public Health, Sport and Wellbeing · Angus North and Mearns
link

Thank you for the opportunity to make opening remarks.

I think that it is important—and I hope that it will be helpful to the committee—that I set out the context in which the draft regulations have been laid. The committee will be aware that the Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Scotland) Act 2019 introduced a statutory framework for the authorisation and carrying out of medical procedures that facilitate transplantation, which are termed “pre-death procedures” in the act. They are defined in the act as the medical procedures that might be carried out on a person for the purposes of ascertaining the suitability of an organ for donation or of

“increasing the likelihood of successful transplantation ... after ... death”,

and which are not for the purpose of

“safeguarding or promoting the physical or mental health of the person.”

The committee will recall that, in cases of donation following circulatory death, which account for around 40 per cent of deceased organ donation, such procedures must be carried out before, sadly, the donor dies.

The framework for carrying out pre-death procedures is an important part of the new legislative regime for donation and, essentially, provides transparency for the public about such procedures, which are already a necessary part of the donation process in order to ensure the health and safety of organs for the transplant recipient.

I turn to the regulations. Parliament passed equivalent regulations for type A procedures in March last year. Those procedures are more routine and less invasive, and are regularly carried out in order to facilitate transplantation.

In some circumstances, if the clinical situation requires it, further diagnostic procedures are available to clinicians to assess the health and safety of organs—for example, if there is a possibility of malignancy, which requires further investigation. The type B regulations, which are now before you, list those procedures that, unlike type A procedures, are not expected to be frequently carried out in order to facilitate transplantation but might sometimes be required as part of the donation process.

Such procedures are not unusual in the wider context of patient care in a hospital setting. However, because of their non-routine nature in the context of transplantation, and the fact that they are more invasive than type A procedures, the act permits the setting in secondary legislation of additional safeguards that must be met before a type B procedure can be carried out.

I will briefly set those out. The regulations include a requirement that, unlike type A procedures, which are authorised automatically by virtue of the donation itself being authorised, a type B procedure must be explicitly authorised before it can go ahead. Given the circumstances in which donation takes place, in which the patient will usually be unconscious in an intensive care unit, that authorisation will be sought from the patient’s family. Further, in line with the approach that is taken in the 2019 act, before that authorisation is given, the views of the potential donor must be taken into consideration so that such procedures are not carried out if they would be against the donor’s known wishes.

As well as requiring that explicit authorisation, the regulations require that, further to the safeguarding conditions in the 2019 act, two conditions have to be met before a type B procedure can be carried out. First, the regulations state that a type B procedure can proceed only if two doctors agree to the procedure being carried out, having both considered that all the conditions set out in the 2019 act have been met. In feedback from the consultation, stakeholders requested that the regulations specifically exclude doctors who are involved in the transplantation process from performing that role, and that is reflected in the regulations. The regulations also require that one of the doctors must be the doctor who is responsible for the patient’s care. Those requirements reflect current practice in decision making on a patient’s care in relation to donation, and they provide certainty and transparency around the process.

The second condition is that in order for the procedure to be carried out, the two doctors must also conclude that a lesser intervention—a type A procedure—cannot be used to provide the necessary information for transplantation purposes. That reflects the general approach to the carrying out of medical procedures and ensures that the minimum intervention is made to facilitate the transplantation.

Those additional conditions, taken together with the requirements in the 2019 act and the requirement for explicit authorisation, seek to ensure that, in cases in which it is necessary to carry out a type B procedure so that an organ can be safely transplanted, there are appropriate safeguards in place to ensure that the interests of the donor are protected. In practice, the requirements in the 2019 act and in the regulations mean that a type B procedure will not go ahead without family involvement or authorisation, and that it will not go ahead prematurely or if it is not absolutely necessary to facilitate transplantation.

In developing the regulations, we have worked closely with and taken the advice of clinicians who work in intensive care and across the donation and transplantation pathway. I am grateful for their input in helping to ensure that the specified procedures and additional requirements that we have in place are appropriate. We also consulted publicly, and the draft regulations before the committee take into account the responses to that consultation. I am happy to take questions from the committee.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you, minister. The committee took a good deal of interest in the matter when the Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Scotland) Bill was before us two years ago. I invite members who wish to ask questions to type R in the chat box in the usual way. We start with questions from Sandra White.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I certainly took a great deal of interest, as did members of the public, in the type B pre-death procedure. It came as news to me, not being a medical professional, and I think that the committee did a good job of looking into the situation.

I am happy with what the minister has said. The committee looked at the additional conditions with regard to doctors. The consultation was very important with regard to issues around patients, the families, authority and so on.

During the consultation, some religious groups were still concerned. Do we know whether any people or groups who were involved in the consultation are still not happy with the procedure? As I say, I am not moving against it—I think that the committee has done a grand job—but I wonder whether some people still have misgivings on the issue.

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

In developing the draft regulations, we took into account a lot of the points that had been made during the consultation process, and we tried to make the whole process a lot more transparent. As a result of some of the issues that came out of the consultation, we put in place, along with some other changes, extra conditions to require registered medical practitioners to authorise the type B procedures and to specify who those practitioners should be.

Sandra White mentioned the religious element and some concerns around that, too. That aspect was, of course, taken into consideration throughout the consultation process. My officials might have more to add on that point.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Would Sharon Grant like to add anything on that?

Sharon Grant Scottish Government
link

We sent a consultation specifically to faith groups and we did not receive any responses.

Our implementation team has been carrying out a series of webinars, on a weekly or fortnightly basis, with the help of Kidney Research UK. They are held with Muslim, Sikh and Hindu faith groups and faith leaders, who explain the content of the 2019 act and what tests can take place. I am taking part in one today after this meeting. So far, no one has asked any questions specifically about pre-death procedures.

It might help the committee to know that we have a mail drop to every household in Scotland. The letter goes into detail on the type A and type B procedures, so that the public will be aware of the whole donation pathway.

Emma Harper SNP South Scotland
link

Minister, the final words in your statement might have already answered my question. As a former liver transplant nurse, I know that many specialists are involved in communicating with family members about pre-death procedures. My question has to do with the transplant specialists and the teams that are engaging with family members—especially those of minority groups, which Sharon Grant mentioned. The legislation will ensure that specialists will be given adequate education to update them on the specific provisions for type A and type B procedures. I am sure that the clinicians are knowledgeable already, but are they being given the support that they need to carry out their specialist jobs?

Mairi Gougeon SNP Angus North and Mearns
link

Yes, a lot of training has been done. I add that type B procedures in particular are rarely used, and, because of the conditions in the regulations, explicit authorisation is needed for the procedures to proceed.

My officials might want to come in again on this point, but I know that a lot of training has been done. NHS Blood and Transport has on-going training and additional support. There is also an e-learning tool, which I know that people have found really useful so far. That process is under way and will continue.

Sharon Grant Scottish Government
link

Comprehensive training on the whole 2019 act is taking place, as well as on the pre-death procedures framework. Clinicians have told us that they are really pleased with the training so far. All the training is now being done online. We, NHSBT and the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service are also offering additional training and support to clinicians. As the minister said, we have developed an e-learning tool, with which the clinicians are really happy. It explains the processes and is something that they can use whenever they are not sure about some aspect. That will be accompanied by supporting guidance.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

As members have no further questions, we move to agenda item 6, which is the formal debate on the SSI on which we have just taken evidence. As normal, I invite the minister to move motion S5M-23852. If any member wishes to contribute to the debate, they should enter an R in the chat box.

Motion moved,

That the Health and Sport Committee recommends that the Human Tissue (Authorisation) (Specified Type B Procedures) (Scotland) Regulations 2021 draft be approved.—Mairi Gougeon

Motion agreed to.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report

No recorded division on this motion that day: decisions taken without a vote are not in the divisions feed.

  1. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
  2. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
  3. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  4. 11:15 Budget Scrutiny 2021-22 Committee business · 49

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.