Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Health Protection (Coronavirus) (International Travel, Prohibition on Travel from the United Arab Emirates) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2021 (SSI 2021/52)

Tuesday 9 February 2021 Health and Sport Committee About 09:30–11:15 Subordinate legislation 30 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

30 contributions
Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Good morning, and welcome to the fifth meeting in 2021 of the Health and Sport Committee. We began our meeting in private session and now move to the public agenda items. We have received apologies from Alex Cole-Hamilton.

I ask all members and witnesses to ensure that their mobile phones are on silent and that all other notifications are turned off during the meeting.

Agenda item 2 is consideration of two made affirmative instruments relating to coronavirus and international travel. The instruments have been laid under section 94(1) of the Public Health etc (Scotland) Act 2008.

The 2008 act states that regulations under section 94(1) are subject to affirmative procedure, but it also provides that the Scottish ministers may make regulations urgently, if they believe that to be necessary, in which case emergency regulations must be laid before the Scottish Parliament. Such regulations cease to have effect on the expiry of the period of 28 days beginning with the date on which the regulations were made unless, before the expiry of that period, they have been approved by a resolution of the Parliament. It is for the Health and Sport Committee to consider the instruments and report to Parliament accordingly.

Today, we will have an evidence session on the instruments with Michael Matheson, the Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Infrastructure and Connectivity, and his officials. Once we have asked all our questions, we will move on to the formal debate on the motions on the instruments.

I welcome to the committee the cabinet secretary and his accompanying officials from the Scottish Government. Craig Thomson is border measures review team leader, David Pratt is policy lead in the health performance and delivery team and Peter Brown is from the police enforcement, liaison and performance team.

I thank the cabinet secretary for joining us today. Given the nature of the regulations, we intend, with his agreement, to ask questions on both instruments in the same session and then proceed to debate the motions on them together. Questions may be general in nature, but a few will undoubtedly be specific to the terms of individual regulations.

I invite the cabinet secretary to make an opening statement.

Michael Matheson SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Transport, Infrastructure and Connectivity · Falkirk West
link

Thank you, convener, and good morning, everyone.

The country changes in the regulations are all related to the variant of Covid-19 that has been identified in South Africa. Four more African nations have been added: the Democratic Republic of Congo, Tanzania, Burundi and Rwanda. Those countries have been assessed by the joint biosecurity centre as being at risk of probable transmission of the new variant.

The United Arab Emirates was also made subject to the additional restrictions on high-risk countries. That is because cases of the South African variant have been identified in England that have a travel history in the UAE but not in Africa. The implication is that people have become infected with the new variant while in the UAE.

The regulations also restrict passenger flights from the United Arab Emirates, and there are also technical changes and clarifications relating to the passenger locator form, pre-departure testing and definitions of “aircrew”.

I am more than happy to respond to any questions that members may have.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you. Perhaps you could start by indicating your view of the South African variant and whether the provisions have been put in place timeously. Is it the Government’s view that they will prevent the spread of the variant in Scotland?

Before you answer that question, I ask committee members who wish to ask questions to enter an R in the chat box now.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The South African variant is one of several variants that are causing concern, given the way in which it can potentially re-infect individuals who have had Covid. There are therefore concerns about the possible implications of the South African variant for our vaccination programme.

It became clear from the evidence that the joint biosecurity centre provided that we had to move quickly to try to reduce the risk of the South African variant entering the United Kingdom. At that point, the decision was made to move to the red list system. Countries where the South African variant had been identified were put on the list, meaning that flights were banned and any UK nationals coming from those areas were required to self-isolate.

That was the initial approach, but it was clear from the clinical advice that I received from the chief medical officer for Scotland that it would not be adequate to further reduce the risk of the new variant’s introduction and that we would have to move to a form of managed quarantine for those coming in from countries that are considered to be high risk. That is why we agreed to move towards using managed quarantine, or managed isolation, for those coming in from countries rated as red, or risk, countries.

However, from the discussions that we have had with the CMO, it is clear that a system that is designed to respond to the identification of new variants is a reactive system. We know where variants are only because of genome sequencing that takes place in a country. For example, we know about the variant in South Africa because that country carries out a significant amount of genome sequencing. The problem that the JBC and our chief medical officer have highlighted is that, often, mutations circulate that we are unaware of because of the lack of genome sequencing internationally. We can therefore further reduce the risk of the introduction of a variant such as the South African variant only by having a comprehensive system of managed isolation or managed quarantine.

That is why we made the decision, which the First Minister announced last week, that, rather than just having managed isolation for those returning from what are classed as risk countries, all international travellers arriving in Scotland will be required to use managed isolation. By doing that, we can help to reduce the risk further.

That approach has limitations, because there is cross-border flow between England and Scotland. I have made representations to the UK Government on that and said that we think that there should be managed quarantine across the whole UK, but the UK Government has taken a different view. However, we are taking forward an approach in Scotland that we believe is the most robust approach that we can take in the present circumstances.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you. David Stewart and Sandra White have questions.

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. I have a wider strategic question. You might know of my interest in the development of an internationally recognised digital Covid passport. The idea has been raised by the Greek Prime Minister, is actively being considered in Europe and has also been raised by the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change. In a slightly ambiguous way, it has also been raised in the United Kingdom Parliament. As you will know, the idea is that a Covid passport will get the economy back to work, will be recognised across the world and will be a big boost to tourism. Frankly, it will happen with or without politicians, because companies such as Qantas are already introducing it.

I appreciate that there are technical issues and some civil liberties issues regarding a Covid passport, but we can see from the work that was done around the European health insurance card that such a thing can be done if there is a willingness to do it. You will be aware that the UK will host the G7, which will be a great opportunity to show leadership on the issue. What is the cabinet secretary’s view? Has the Cabinet discussed the idea?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Good morning, Mr Stewart. I am aware of the idea of an electronic vaccine passport, but I am not persuaded that it is the right approach at the moment. Given the challenges that we face with new variants and our understanding of how the vaccine operates in respect of the transmission of the virus, I do not feel that, at present, the introduction of an international vaccine passport would be an appropriate alternative to the use of managed quarantine for individuals who are returning after international travel. It may have a role to play at some point in the future, but we are not at that point yet.

I agree that there are some civil liberties issues that have to be worked through. For example, there could be a good reason why someone has not taken up a vaccine from the vaccines that are available.

It may be that, at some point in the future, a vaccine passport would have a role to play in helping to support international travel. However, I do not believe that, at present, it would be a way for us to reduce the risk of the importation of new virus and new variants.

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I appreciate the cabinet secretary’s honesty and openness on the issue. I simply make the wider point that it is not a zero-sum game—in other words, a passport could be an additional longer-term strategy. No one is suggesting that it would be an alternative to quarantine hotels.

With regard to civil liberties, I was interested to find out that in America, where my son happens to live and work, in situations where individuals had not gone ahead with the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine—as we know, there were some issues in that regard—nurseries and schools refused to accept young people who did not have the vaccine. In a sense, the issue of whether or not people choose to have the vaccine is not for us to consider today; I merely make the point that there will be implications and effects as a result of such decisions. I therefore see a vaccine passport as an additional long-term strategy, not as an alternative to test and trace or to quarantine hotels.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I agree with David Stewart on that. It could be one of a number of aspects that could form part of a longer-term strategy to support a return to international travel. The challenge will be to identify when we arrive at that point. The reason why that is a challenge is because different countries will be at different points in their vaccination programmes and in suppressing the virus, and they will take different approaches in how they go about achieving suppression. I agree that international co-operation will be needed in introducing such a scheme, but we have to wait until we arrive at a point where we think that it may be right to introduce it.

As part of a longer-term strategy and as one of a suite of measures that we can put in place to support international travel when it is safe to do so, a vaccine passport could have a part to play.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. I have some questions on quarantine hotels, if that is what we are calling them. I acknowledge what you have said about the JBC highlighting the need to reduce the risks. To my mind, we should have locked down international travel a lot earlier, but we are where we are.

I am interested to note that, while we in Scotland are talking about international travellers who come up to Scotland via Heathrow or wherever having to isolate in quarantine hotels, Westminster does not agree with that approach. I am disappointed about that. What impact will there be with regard to international travellers who come into Scotland via Heathrow? How will that be managed? Budget-wise, will the Scottish Government be responsible for paying for quarantine hotels if Westminster is not on board with what we wish to do?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Sandra White will be aware that I will be making a statement to Parliament to set out some more details of the methods and process for taking forward managed isolation over the next week. I believe that a comprehensive UK system is the safest and most effective way to reduce the risk of the importation of new virus or variants into Scotland and the UK as a whole, and is in all our interests.

11:00

The UK Government has decided to take an approach to the issue that is different from ours, and to target managed quarantine only at those who come in from the red list high-risk countries. We will introduce managed quarantine for all travellers who arrive at Scottish airports from an international destination. It is clear that a challenge remains around those who arrive at English airports and travel on to Scotland. We are working with the UK Government to see whether we can introduce a mechanism that would allow those individuals to carry out their managed quarantine at the point of entry into the UK, no matter where that is, but we have not been able to get agreement on that.

The system that we are putting in place is the most comprehensive that we can put in place, given our powers and the scope of our ability. However, if it were applied at the UK level, that would make it even more effective. We are continuing to discuss the issue and to ask the UK Government to consider expanding its approach in order to capture a greater number of people who come into the UK as a whole. Members can be assured that we are taking forward an approach that we believe is the most effective means by which we can reduce the risk of importation of new virus and new variants into Scotland.

The cost—it is a fixed cost—is borne by the traveller who uses a managed quarantine hotel or managed isolation. We will underwrite hotel provision. We will block book the hotel facilities through a joint agreement with the UK Government, so that there is one contract for all the hotels—that is being taken forward on our behalf. Hotels will be block booked to the levels that we believe are necessary. Those who will have to use them will have to pay the daily rate that goes with that. Part of the money will therefore be recovered from those who have to use the isolation hotels.

Sandra White SNP Glasgow Kelvin
link

I apologise: my internet went down for a couple of minutes.

I have a follow-up question. How will those travellers be identified? Will people who are getting on a flight be asked questions? Will they fill in something to say that they are travelling on from Heathrow, for instance, to Scotland?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

A person who comes to Scotland on a flight will need to have completed a passenger locator form, which is a digital Home Office form. That information will be passed on to Health Protection Scotland. We will get information about individuals who travel directly to Scotland from an international destination from the Home Office, and that will allow us to identify individuals who require to use managed isolation.

Emma Harper SNP South Scotland
link

Good morning, cabinet secretary. I want to pick up on what Sandra White said about managed quarantine. I have an interest in internal flights and on-going travel, whether that is by air or even by ferry. A person could go to Dublin from an international destination, for instance, and into Scotland through the port of Cairnryan.

I appreciate that you will make a statement this week. Last summer, we almost had zero Covid in Scotland. I agree with Sandra White that travel restrictions should maybe have been put into place months ago to prevent people from coming in.

How much pressure can you put on the UK Government to show that, for managed quarantine, the first stop for an international arrival needs to be the place where virus transmission can be really reduced? That is a concern for me, because any on-going travel poses a risk of virus transmission.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

You make a good point about the risk of onward transmission. The most effective means of quarantining is at the point of entry to a country rather than waiting until travellers get to their end point, for the reasons that you outlined, which relate to the risk of transmission from someone travelling by whatever means to their end point.

The point of entry is the best place for quarantining. We have made representations to the UK Government, with which I will have a further meeting on Thursday, when we will cover such issues. There are different views about how to proceed, but we will continue that engagement and continue to explain that the system should be more comprehensive across the UK, because that is the most effective means of dealing with the spread.

You made a point about people coming from and moving around the common travel area, which includes the Republic of Ireland. We have raised that issue, as have the Welsh Government and the Northern Irish Government, and the UK Government is now engaging with the Irish Government. The COVID-19 Genomics UK Consortium report that was published at the beginning of December highlighted that a significant amount of virus importation into parts of the common travel area came from people moving between Scotland and England and between England and Scotland and elsewhere.

We must continue to look at what measures we can put in place to reduce that risk further. We are keen to establish a means of helping to reduce the need for people to travel around the UK. However, we are some distance from agreeing on what that would involve.

Given the evidence from the COG report, there is no doubt that progress needs to be made on the issue. We continue to discuss that with the UK Government. All four nations of the UK recognise that action needs to be taken; the question is about the method for acting to address the issue.

Emma Harper SNP South Scotland
link

I am curious about one issue. When we talk about managed quarantine hotels, what projected numbers are we talking about? Will tens, hundreds or thousands of people need to be put up in hotels?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

I am in danger of pre-empting my statement to Parliament this afternoon. Three airports in Scotland—Glasgow, Edinburgh and Aberdeen—still receive international arrivals. Some are more associated with the oil and gas industry—that applies particularly to Aberdeen. We are working to project numbers on the basis of the number of international travellers into Scotland per week. We are looking to have managed isolation available for those who need to undertake it. Some individuals will be exempt if they have a critical role in a certain sector—for example, if they are air crew. The scheme will have exemptions, but we are modelling a system that is based on the number of individuals who have travelled into Scotland in the past couple of weeks. We will ensure that we have sufficient rooms available for those who will have to complete managed isolation.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I will follow on from Sandra White’s questions about the Scottish Government’s requirement for everybody to go into quarantine after international travel. My question is about onward travel on an internal flight after an international flight—Emma Harper raised that issue. Surely we have a system in place that tracks the origin of travel. We must be able to do that quite simply, so that when people arrive in Scotland, no matter where they have flown in from, we should be able to identify them and ask them to quarantine.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The passenger locator form, which the Home Office put in place, is the way in which we get that information. Every traveller coming into the UK is required to complete a passenger locator form before they arrive. It sets out where they have travelled from, where they have travelled through, and where they are going.

If someone is transferring through Glasgow from Heathrow after an international flight, we would have that information on the individual. However, my preferred system would be for that person to carry out their managed isolation at the point of arrival, rather than go on to a domestic flight and complete their managed isolation at their destination. There are very obvious reasons for that, including the risk that it creates. That is one of the points of discussion that we are continuing to pursue with the UK Government. We would prefer those individuals to complete their managed isolation at their point of arrival into the UK rather than at the end of their journey.

The PLF is the form that provides us with the data and information on individuals who might be required to carry out managed isolation.

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

I understand that you are saying that you would prefer those people to isolate at their place of entry into the United Kingdom, and that there is a difference of approach. Is there any way in which the Scottish Government can insist that someone like that cannot board an internal flight following an international flight until such time as they have been quarantined? Is there any way in which we can insist on that, if you like?

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

The system depends on the passenger putting the correct information about where they are going and whether they are going on to an internal flight on the PLF in the first place. If they have come by road or by bus, they might not complete the details of their end point. For example, they might land in London and travel on from there but not give that information. There are, therefore, some challenges within the system.

To make what you suggest a requirement would require the UK Government to make regulations to require travellers who are looking to travel on to Scotland to complete their managed isolation at a hotel in England. Legal provision would need to be made by the UK Government to facilitate that. That is part of the discussion that we are having with the UK Government. In our view, the UK Government should be looking to put that in place, but we cannot force it. The UK Government will have to agree to implement that, because it would require legislation.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

There are no further questions. I am confident that Michael Matheson will have enough new information this afternoon to satisfy the Presiding Officer in his statement.

We now move on to the next items on the agenda, which are the formal debates on the main affirmative instruments on which we have just taken evidence. Are members content with a single debate being held to cover both of the instruments?

Members are content. We therefore move to the debate. We are no longer in question-and-answer mode. I invite the cabinet secretary to speak to and move the motions.

11:15

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Given the discussion that we have already had, I will go straight to moving the motions.

Motions moved,

That the Health and Sport Committee recommends that The Health Protection (Coronavirus) (International Travel, Public Health Information and Pre-Departure Testing) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2021 (SSI 2021/34) be approved.

That the Health and Sport Committee recommends that The Health Protection (Coronavirus) (International Travel, Prohibition on Travel from the United Arab Emirates) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2021 (SSI 2021/52) be approved.—Michael Matheson

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Does any member wish to contribute to the debate? Brian, do you want to come back in, or does your request to speak relate to the question session?

Brian Whittle Con South Scotland
link

It relates to the debate. I want to highlight that, given the discussion that we have had with the cabinet secretary, and the straightforward way in which he has answered all the questions, the issue that is raised again is our inability, technically, to do what should be quite simple—to track somebody who is coming into the UK, and their onward travel. From a technical perspective, we do not seem to be able to deal with that. That was my only point.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Thank you very much. No other members have indicated that they wish to contribute to the debate, so I invite Michael Matheson to sum up and respond.

Michael Matheson SNP Falkirk West
link

Convener, I recognise the concerns that Brian Whittle has raised. That is why we need to continue to work with the Home Office—Inaudible.—the passenger locator form and how that information is shared with us. The matter is a concern for us and is part of our on-going discussion with the UK Government. I assure the member that we will try to identify ways in which we can improve the system and how it operates.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Are members content that we put a single question on the motions? I can see that members are content.

Motions agreed to,

That the Health and Sport Committee recommends that The Health Protection (Coronavirus) (International Travel, Public Health Information and Pre-Departure Testing) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2021 (SSI 2021/34) be approved.

That the Health and Sport Committee recommends that The Health Protection (Coronavirus) (International Travel, Prohibition on Travel from the United Arab Emirates) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2021 (SSI 2021/52) be approved.

Lewis Macdonald Lab The Convener · North East Scotland
link

That concludes discussion on those made affirmative instruments.

  1. 09:30 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 30
  2. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
  3. 11:15 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 6
  4. 11:15 Budget Scrutiny 2021-22 Committee business · 49

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.