Finally, PE1829, lodged by Tracy Phillips, calls on the Scottish Government to allow a designated carer or family member into intensive care wards to visit, support and care for their loved ones.
Since our last consideration of the petition in November, we have received written submissions from the Scottish Government’s national clinical director and the petitioner. The national clinical director states that, in conjunction with Health Protection Scotland and Public Health Scotland, guidance has been reviewed and is aligned with policies and recommendations in terms of infection prevention and control. The guidance has been written to allow clinicians the flexibility to exercise their judgment with regard to patient needs.
The submission also states that directors of nursing and person-centred leads representing each of the Scottish health boards convene in a fortnightly forum. The forum provides an opportunity to share experiences of current visiting restrictions, their impacts and how the guidance is helping staff to manage visiting.
In her response, the petitioner reiterates that she believes that had she been able to visit her sister, it would have led to less stress and frustration for her sister and would have reduced the burden on hospital staff.
This is an important and challenging petition. We know that the matter is one with which health and care staff are all wrestling. It is about managing risk, managing infection and trying to ensure that we address the pandemic, while understanding the personal costs. We have heard over the past couple of days a lot of testimony about the impact of Covid and losing loved ones, and the impact of not being able to do the things that one would normally do.
I am not confident to say what the resolution would be, but I feel very strongly that we and the Government need to engage with the matter seriously. We know that we are in exceptionally difficult times; it is a challenge to do risk assessments and to take action to manage the suffering that people are dealing with. Whatever we decide, we acknowledge the petition and the testimonies that we hear every day. It is important that the Government hears them, too.
