PE1768, by James A Mackie, calls on the Scottish Government to ensure that all proceedings in a children’s hearing are minuted or recorded. The petition was considered previously in September 2020, when the committee agreed to write to the Scottish Government to seek its view on the suggestion that there may be scope to establish a way of recording the key points resulting from a children’s hearing without impinging on the intended informal and participative nature of those meetings.
In its response, the Scottish Government explains that, at present, a record of proceedings is kept for each children’s hearing that records why a hearing has been arranged and who is present and absent, as well as the decisions that are taken and the reasons for them. The record of proceedings also includes written decisions that are prepared by panel members. Those should be sufficiently detailed to make clear what the panel members decided, why they made each decision, what information they relied on, what outcomes the decision is designed to bring about and what the child’s views are and that those views have been taken into account.
The Scottish Government also highlights that the statutory procedural rules relating to children’s hearings allow the children’s reporter to record information that is additional to the decisions and actions of the hearing where the reporter considers that appropriate.
This is an interesting issue. A balance always has to be struck in the children’s hearings system. It is about what is in the best interests of the child, trying to address those issues in the round and ensuring that people have an opportunity to participate. Participants have to be comfortable with the proceedings, so they should not be overly formal, but at the same time decisions have to be recorded.
The comments in the Scottish Government submission certainly give me comfort. The Education and Skills Committee keeps the hearings system under review, so it is not something that is not looked at in detail. On the question of recording of decisions, I find the Government’s response reasonable, but I am interested in members’ views.
