The next continued petition on our agenda today is PE1770, on improving water safety, which was lodged by Margaret Spiers. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to work with all relevant bodies across Scotland to improve water safety by ensuring that all waterways have life-saving equipment such as lifebelts and buoyancy throw bags, with ropes, to allow multiple attempts at rescue, and that tampering with water safety equipment is made a criminal offence of endangering public safety.
Since the petition was last considered in September 2020, we have received written submissions from COSLA, Glasgow City Council and Police Scotland.
COSLA states in its submission that it would be supportive of life-saving equipment being available on waterways, where it is deemed appropriate or necessary. However, it urges caution with regard to the establishment of a new criminal offence, stating that it would support
“the promotion of education and preventative activities to avoid the criminalisation of people.”
Similarly, Police Scotland does not agree that tampering with water safety equipment should be made a criminal offence, explaining that legislation is already in place that
“would support Police action where equipment is removed or damaged.”
In its submission, Glasgow City Council highlights the work that it has done, following the intervention of the petitioner, to add distinctive ropes to lifebelts and new additional throw bags. It states that the use of the distinctive rope has been successful in deterring thefts and vandalism, thereby ensuring that the equipment is available when needed.
I think that this is a very important petition. I had the privilege of meeting Mr and Mrs Spiers, who have sought to address a problem as a consequence of their own tragic circumstances. I was struck then, and I think that the committee has been struck since, by their persistence and courage. I do not accept the notion that this should not be a criminal offence. If somebody was blocking off fire exits from a building where there was a fire, I think that people would regard that as a criminal offence. My own sense is that there should be recognition that vandalising life-saving equipment is a very serious offence because at some point in the future somebody may require it and it will not be available.
I understand that people would prefer education. We would prefer there to be a campaign that got people to understand why these things matter and why, if you do this stupid vandalising thing, it can have very serious consequences that people have to live with for the rest of their lives. I recognise the progress that has been made by Glasgow City Council and I think that there has been cross-party support in the council for finding a solution that has been identified with the family.
The question to put to members is: is there more that we can do at this point? My own sense is that we hope that this is something that the Parliament could take on, but we need to think about whether the Public Petitions Committee can realistically do anything more at this stage.
