Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Continued Petitions

Residential Care (Severely Learning-disabled People) (PE1545)

Wednesday 9 December 2020 Public Petitions Committee About 09:30 Petitions 6 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

6 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

Good morning. I welcome everyone to the 21st meeting in 2020 of the Public Petitions Committee. The meeting is being held virtually.

We had hoped to take evidence today from Professor Dipankar Nandi, consultant neurosurgeon and head of department at Charing Cross hospital and St Mary’s hospital, and professor at Imperial College London, on PE1723, on essential tremor treatment in Scotland. Surgery commitments have prevented him from giving evidence today, but he hopes to be able to attend next week. I should emphasise that we are extremely grateful to Professor Nandi for being willing to come before the committee, and we understand why he is unable to be with us today.

The first continued petition for consideration today is PE1545, on residential care provision for the severely learning disabled, which was submitted by Ann Maxwell on behalf of the Muir Maxwell Trust. The petition calls on the Scottish Government

“to recognise residential care as a way severely learning disabled children, young people and adults can lead happy and fulfilled lives and provide the resources to local authorities to establish residential care options for families in Scotland.”

Following our most recent consideration of the petition, the committee wrote to the petitioner to ask what issues they wished the committee to raise with the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport in relation to their petition. The petitioner’s response formed the basis of the committee’s letter to the health secretary. A response has been received on behalf of the health secretary from the Minister for Mental Health, as learning disabilities is within their portfolio. A further response from the petitioner has also been received. Those responses are summarised in the clerk’s note.

Do members have any comments or suggestions for action? I feel a great deal of frustration about the Government’s submission, and you can see from the petitioner’s submission that she feels that very strongly.

Gail Ross SNP Caithness, Sutherland and Ross
link

I agree. I was quite frustrated with the Government’s submission. The thing that struck me about it is that the Government said that the numbers are too small for individual residential units in communities. Basically, reading between the lines, if it was going to make such provision available, it would have to do it nationally, but that would go against its policy of not taking people out of their communities. The irony is that the petitioner has already had to go outwith not just her community, but her country, and has had to access care in England, which seems to be excellent. It is a shame that such provision is not available in Scotland because, from what the petitioner has indicated, there certainly seems to be a need for it. On the opposite side, the Scottish Government has the policy of wanting people to be cared for in their own homes and it says that high-quality care at home can be accessed. I do not know whether that is true all over the country, but it certainly seems to be the case that, in some areas, people would find it very difficult to access the high-quality care that is said to be available.

I think that a lot of issues have been raised by the petition that still need to be addressed, but I worry that this committee is not the place for that. The Scottish Government said that there has been a short-life working group, that it has done the “Coming Home” report and that it is carrying out a review of adult care services. I hope that the work that it is doing with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities will lead to solutions for the people in this group.

I find it very frustrating that where we are in the parliamentary session means that we might not be able to put as much emphasis on the petition as we would normally have done. I would have liked to pass it on to another committee, but I feel that we should close it under rule 15.7 of standing orders. I make that recommendation extremely reluctantly, but given the powers that the committee has, I cannot see anywhere else we can go with it. However, I would like us to mention the petition in our legacy paper so that we can bring the issue to the attention of the Health and Sport Committee for the next session of Parliament, if other members agree.

Maurice Corry Con West Scotland
link

I agree with the comments that my colleague Gail Ross has just made. It is difficult, because we know how frustrating it is for families with offspring in this situation and it is dreadful to think that people have to go down south to get the right provision. We are a caring society in Scotland and we should be able to resolve the matter. I am disappointed that we cannot make any further progress with the Scottish Government at this stage, but it is safe to say that the petitioner can bring the petition back again next year in the new session of Parliament, and I think that she should consider doing that.

I agree with Gail Ross that to pass the petition on to another committee now would not necessarily solve the issue in the immediate future. The issue deserves more input from the committee and from Parliament, and I think that, at this stage, we have no option other than to close the petition under rule 15.7 of standing orders, on the basis of the comments that have been made and the fact that the Scottish Government feels that there is no more that it can do. To be honest, that is disappointing, but that is the position that we face. I hope that the issue will be picked up again; we can certainly put it in our legacy paper.

David Torrance SNP Kirkcaldy
link

I agree with my colleagues that it is a very difficult petition. I agree that we should close it, but as Gail Ross said, I would like us to bring it to the attention of the Health and Sport Committee in our legacy paper.

Tom Mason Con North East Scotland
link

I agree with what has been said so far by my colleagues. Ideally, matters should not be left as they are, but if the only way forward is to mention the petition in our legacy paper, then so be it. I think that closing it under rule 15.7 is the only way to proceed at this stage. The best solution would be notification through our legacy paper so that it can be picked up in the next session of Parliament.

Johann Lamont Lab The Convener · Glasgow
link

The constant pushback from the Scottish Government is that it has a policy of people being supported in their communities and in their homes. The petitioner is saying that that is not appropriate for a group of people and because the policy is to keep them in their homes, there is a pushback on families who want something different, which is not what the policy should be. It should not involve the provision of only one thing exclusively. It should be a case of meeting the needs of the individuals concerned. If the provision is not there, it is extremely difficult. I found some of the tone of the Scottish Government’s response a bit challenging. I think that, if I was the petitioner, I would be quite annoyed—that is the kindest way of putting it—as it is clear is the case from the petitioner’s submission. I would possibly be slightly insulted by the idea that I had not thought about or did not understand what the policy was.

I think that this will be a theme today: as a committee, we are right up against the fact that we are coming towards the end of the parliamentary session, and we want to be honest with people about what we can do between now and March 2021. We can identify issues that really matter here, but it will be for Parliament to decide in the next session.

I am very reluctant to let the petition go, but I accept what my colleagues are saying, which is that we must be clear that there is a limit to what we can do. We can write to the Education and Skills Committee and the Health and Sport Committee to flag up the fact that they should be thinking about the issue. Is it really our policy that the only way in which we can support people with complex needs is in the community? If members remember, at the very beginning, there was a big issue about whether we even counted the numbers right; it was said that there was a need for a proper analysis of how many people were in this group. I think that the Government’s approach is underpinned by an attitude of, “Why are you asking for that kind of support? This is what we’ve decided,” and I think that that is problematic.

Realistically, we can write to the Education and Skills Committee and the Health and Sport Committee to say that there is a big issue here about having a one-size-fits-all policy, that there needs to be flexibility and that we need to listen to people with learning disabilities and complex needs and their carers so that the issue is not closed down in the way that we have seen. We could agree to do that.

I think that we should agree to close the petition. We should emphasise to the petitioner that we recognise how long a struggle it has been and that, should they wish to return to the issue in the new session of Parliament, they would not have to wait a year—they could do so as soon as the new session of Parliament begins.

I think that this is unsatisfactory, but we agree reluctantly and with no sense of wanting to let the petitioner down that we will perhaps put something in our legacy paper. We will flag up the issue to the relevant committees, and the clerks can advise us which would the right committees to deal with the core issue, which relates to the policy that the Scottish Government has pushed back on. We agree to close the petition and thank the petitioner very much and remind her that she can bring it back as soon as the new session of Parliament is convened. Is that agreed?

Yes, that is agreed. We have agreed to close the petition but to correspond with the relevant committees and to ensure that we flag up the issue in our legacy paper. We thank the petitioner and regret that there has not been the scale of progress that she might have hoped for.

  1. 09:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  2. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 9
  3. 09:45 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  4. 10:00 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  5. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  6. 10:15 Continued Petitions Petitions · 8
  7. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 6
  8. 10:30 Continued Petitions Petitions · 7
  9. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  10. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 6
  11. 10:45 New Petitions Petitions · 8
  12. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 8
  13. 11:15 New Petitions Petitions · 6

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.