The next continued petition, on soul and conscience letters, was lodged by Laura Hunter. It calls on the Scottish Government to review the use of soul and conscience letters in criminal proceedings and to produce guidance on their use for the courts and general practitioner practices, including guidance on alternatives to court appearances if an accused person is deemed unfit to attend in person.
Since our last consideration of the petition in September 2020, the committee has received a written submission from the General Medical Council Scotland. It explains that when providing a soul and conscience letter,
“a doctor has an obligation both to their patient and to the court.”
GMC Scotland further explains that when writing a soul and conscience letter, doctors must ensure as much as possible that the report that they provide
“is not false or misleading”,
that it is correct, and that it does not deliberately leave out anything relevant. Letters must also be restricted
“to areas in which they have direct experience or relevant knowledge”.
Doctors must
“make sure any opinion they include is balanced, and be prepared to explain the facts or assumptions on which they are based.”
It is a really interesting petition. The direct experience of the petitioner is quite strong, and there seems to be a sense that perhaps there is a way of avoiding court by getting one of these letters. I feel reassured that people are aware of the issue.
I am struck by what the British Medical Association said, which was that there needs to be a simple procedure. They are quite happy for it to be changed and they did not want it to be overly bureaucratic. I thought that that was thought provoking.
I am interested to see what members think and whether there is anything further that we can do. The petition has afforded a good opportunity for the issue to be flagged up to the relevant organisations.
