The second continued petition for consideration is PE1683, on support for families with multiple births, which was lodged by Jennifer Edmonstone. The petition calls on the Scottish Government to provide better financial and non-financial support for multiple-birth families.
We last considered the petition at our meeting on 17 September, when the committee took evidence from the Minister for Children and Young People, Maree Todd. During the session, the minister reiterated the measures that the Scottish Government has put in place to support vulnerable and low-income families. However, she stated that the Scottish Government does not see families who have twins or triplets as always being vulnerable. Although the minister confirmed that the Scottish Government had not undertaken direct research to further its understanding of the impact of multiple births on families, she indicated that the Scottish Government could work with Twins Trust to develop research. Following that meeting, the petitioner stated in correspondence with the clerks that she was pleased to hear that Maree Todd agreed to work with Twins Trust in order to undertake research into the area and asked what progress is being made on that.
The minister said that she did not see families with twins or triplets as always being vulnerable, but I do not think that that is the argument behind the petition. The argument is that there are particular things that come with multiple births that should be recognised in the support given to families. I will be interested in what other members think, but I would be keen to hear from the minister on the question of research and whether that can be pursued.
We are still short of information from the minister and we should certainly write to her to get information on what research is possible and on whether the Government has really talked properly to Twins Trust. We should establish what discretion is available to local government, so we should keep the petition open at the moment.
I agree with my colleague. We should write to the Minister for Children and Young People to see exactly where the Government is with Twins Trust, what work has been commissioned and what research has been done.
Being a father of twins, I understand multiple-birth issues. I certainly agree with my colleagues about writing to the minister, and we should also write to the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities.
I agree. We should write to the minister to seek an update on the on-going work with Twins Trust.
I noted a wee bit of a discrepancy. We could write to COSLA to ask what discretion local authorities have to provide day care to two-year-olds, but there is a missing period of time to consider. You can take maternity leave for two years, but you would not get paid for all of it. You would have nine months to a year of paid maternity leave, then you would have another year before you might get a discretionary place in a local authority. That could be a really quite expensive year if you used a childminder.
I do not know what the answer is to that and I do not know who we can ask. If the Government has stated that there is no support for families with multiple births in that situation, I suppose that we are where we are. However, I would like that issue to be included in the letter to the minister, to see whether there is anything at all that can be done about that year. I agree that we should write to the minister and COSLA.
The petitioner makes the point that, for a family who might have planned for a baby and worked out what the childcare will be, if they have multiples they are more likely to have to give up work or maybe reduce their hours and so on. I did not feel that the minister was getting that bit. It was as if she recognised that there was a disadvantage, but not that other things come into play for families who increasingly are having to strike a balance with regard to their income. We would want to flag that up, because the petitioner made that point herself.
The general consensus is that the issue remains one in which we have an interest. We want to check how the research and the work with Twins Trust has been progressed, and we want to raise the question of the impact of multiple births on family income and capacity to work. We should also to write to COSLA to ask how it sees discretion being used.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.