Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 25 October 2005 European and External Relations Committee Procedure 76 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Linda Fabiani only · show everyone

Linda Fabiani’s contributions

32 contributions
Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We will now consider the committee's work programme. Before I make general comments and open up the subject for discussion, I would like to hear from Dennis Canavan about the paper on a reporter's inquiry that he has submitted for consideration.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Before I open up the discussion to other members, I want to ask about the preliminary meeting with the Executive that you mentioned. What resulted from that preliminary meeting and what progress has been made?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

So it took place very recently.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Do other members have any questions for Dennis Canavan?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Perhaps we could do things in tandem. If Dennis starts to put together his programme, the committee could at the same time make its own inquiries with the Executive and other interested and relevant parties into what work has been done previously. That might be better than putting everything into the one remit.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Thank you, Dennis. You will be coming back to the meeting, unless the Parliamentary Bureau meeting goes on for hours and hours, and we will come to the recommendations on this proposal after we have gone through our paper on the work programme.Having heard from Dennis, we will now go back to the beginning of this agenda item and give general consideration to the committee's work programme. I know that all members will have read the paper carefully.I will say a few words of introduction before opening up the meeting for discussion. At our previous meeting, we considered our options and asked the clerks and the Scottish Parliament information centre to provide further details on specific inquiry proposals. I thank all the staff for the very useful papers that we received. We have also had additional information from Dennis Canavan on his proposal for a reporter-led inquiry, and from Jim Wallace on his proposal. I thank Margaret Ewing for giving us additional information that is relevant to Jim Wallace's proposal.An additional proposal appears on the latest draft of our paper. It was prompted by Irene Oldfather's suggestion that the committee should consider the European Commission's communication strategy. Members will have read that proposal. It focuses on what the Commission has called plan D—D for democracy, dialogue and debate. The plan was launched on 13 October as a contribution to the period of reflection following the no votes in the French and Dutch referenda on the constitutional treaty. Plan D will be followed by a white paper next year. Annex C of our paper lays out the background and the objectives for an inquiry.The final section of annex C describes the Scottish Executive-led building a bridge between Europe and its citizens project. That project was also launched on 13 October and it seems to me to be complementary to the Commission's plan D. It is intended to be a contribution to the period of reflection and considers how some of the best features of our legislative process might serve as examples of good practice in the European Union. It includes ways in which the Parliament has engaged with citizens. An inquiry into plan D, or a more widely drawn inquiry into the area of communication, would take that Scottish Executive-led project into account, I presume.We come to the Lisbon inquiry. Members might have other thoughts, but my view—after reading all the papers—is that before we take on a Lisbon strategy subject, it would be better for us to wait until we see the Enterprise and Culture Committee's report on its inquiry into business growth, which will come out in the new year.The situation is similar with the services directive option, which is currently at the European Parliament. I understand that there are 1,500 amendments to that directive, which suggests that we will not see its final shape until early in the new year—I may be being optimistic.There is also a proposal for an inquiry into globalscot and similar networks. I detected at our previous meeting that the committee felt that it had covered much of that ground in its report earlier this year on its inquiry into the promotion of Scotland worldwide.For a full committee inquiry, it seems to me that there remain only two issues on which we could make a fairly prompt start and in which new things are happening. The first of those is structural funds and, in particular, the mechanisms and timing for the distribution of such funds in future. That could be the subject of a fairly short inquiry. The second issue is communication, which is extremely important. Obviously, we will need to keep everything under review over the next 18 months, regardless of which subject we decide on for our inquiry. With those remarks, I open up the discussion for members' comments.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Do other members have any views? I will try to sweep up all the comments at the end.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Would that be in addition to the nutters in this committee?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I will make a couple of points before I bring in Margaret Ewing.John Home Robertson is right. An inquiry into plan D would have to be fairly focused because the Commission is looking for input to its consultation by April next year, if I remember rightly. The Executive will publish its conclusions on its building a bridge project in autumn next year. We could consider those projects together and find out how one is complementing the other, but the timetable would have to be fairly tight if a submission to the Commission is needed by April.I do not think that anyone wants a full inquiry on structural funds. Work would complement the work that the committee has already done on the issue. An inquiry would have to be very short and tight and would have to focus on the Executive's plans to implement the new way of distributing structural funds and co-operation funding. The Executive has been carrying out research and it might be worth while to have the minister along to the committee to tell us how that work is proceeding. The committee could then decide to take complementary evidence on what the minister had said, perhaps over the following couple of meetings. It could then form an opinion to relay to the Executive.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

What are your views? How would you prefer to proceed? In the end, we could sum up on the various recommendations and then decide what to do. Having looked into the matter more deeply in preparation for your paper, which turned out to be quite a few pages long—

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Now that you have started to look into the matter, do you think that it would warrant more investigation and that there could be a reporter-led inquiry on it?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Were you gesticulating there, Derek?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Are members happy for me to try to put something together on the basis of this discussion?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Before I go through the recommendations, I want to ensure that we have reached agreement and got everything right. Would Charlie Gordon like to comment on anything that he has heard?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We should consider the recommendations in the paper, and I will give you my impressions on how I feel the committee is moving forward on this matter. Charlie Gordon is quite right to say that any disagreements are at the margins rather than with the substance.The first recommendation concerns the distribution of structural funds. Members seem reluctant to have another full inquiry into structural funds; however, concerns have been expressed about differences in the way in which structural funds will be administered. From members' comments, I think that one way forward would be to invite the minister to give evidence on how he sees—or she sees—I cannot remember who the minister is.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Oh, it's a he.We could invite Allan Wilson to give evidence on how he thinks the Executive will proceed on the matter. We might find it useful to take evidence from a couple of specific witnesses and then to write to the Executive expressing a general committee view. That would not constitute a full-blown inquiry and might take only two meetings. Is that acceptable to members?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The second recommendation concerns the Lisbon strategy. I said earlier that it seems sensible to wait for the outcome of the Enterprise and Culture Committee's very full inquiry into business growth in Scotland and then to concentrate on one relevant aspect of its report. I do not think that anyone disagreed with that suggestion. Are members agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

The third recommendation concerns the services directive. Because of the late legislative stage that the directive has reached, we should monitor its progress in Europe and then examine what impact the final result will have on aspects of Scottish life.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

So that is acceptable.On the fourth recommendation, which concerns the European Commission's plan D, I have picked up members' reluctance to have a long, woolly inquiry on the matter. I said earlier that we must be fairly tight with this issue because of the time that we have to respond to the consultation. It has been recognised that the issue should be examined in tandem with the Executive's building a bridge strategy. In any case, everyone appears to agree with John Home Robertson that any inquiry into the matter must be focused and we should approach people who would give us the best and most relevant input. As a result, I suggest that, for the next meeting, the clerks put together a detailed focus paper on how such an inquiry could proceed. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I think that I am right in saying that Irene Oldfather was not suggesting that that inquiry should be taken alongside Jim Wallace's proposal.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Members are going to go on for a long time about these Ds. I can hear you all now.Before we consider Jim Wallace's proposal, John Home Robertson has stated that, in retrospect, he has a general interest in what is happening with globalscot and so on. I suggest that we keep the matter on the agenda and revisit it later.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

We will obviously track the issues that are being raised in future work programmes.That brings us to what has been billed in the committee inquiries paper as "Reporter-led inquiries". Members appear to feel that Jim Wallace's proposed inquiry would warrant the use of more than one rapporteur.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

He has already said that he is happy with that.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I am worried about the inquiry becoming too technical and about getting terribly bogged down. We should focus tightly. Such an inquiry would of course complement the plan D inquiry. If the committee is happy, I will suggest to the clerks that they consider how we can move beyond a rapporteur-led inquiry on the matter.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

I suggest that Jim Wallace, Alasdair Rankin and I get together to talk about how we can make progress.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

That brings us to the last of the recommendations in our paper, which is Dennis Canavan's proposal. Dennis has said that he would be keen for his proposal to go beyond being rapporteur-led. Do members have any views?That silence suggests to me that the committee feels that it should be a rapporteur-led issue.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Yes, I took a note of that. It was an excellent suggestion that we seek to have Dennis invited to the—was it the Scottish-Irish council?

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Irene Oldfather suggested that we should also consider transnational Interreg funding, so we will seek information on that. Do members agree that we are formally inviting Dennis Canavan to be our rapporteur?Members indicated agreement.

Linda Fabiani SNP The Convener · Central Scotland
link

Is everyone happy? We are doing awfully well.

  1. Scottish Parliament European and External Relations Committee Tuesday 25 October 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 2
  3. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 76
  5. Pre and Post-council Scrutiny Committee business · 3
  6. Sift Committee business · 10
  7. Convener's Report Procedure · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.