Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Tuesday 25 October 2005 European and External Relations Committee Procedure 76 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Showing Irene Oldfather only · show everyone

Irene Oldfather’s contributions

10 contributions
Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Dennis Canavan has suggested a good proposal that would be an interesting committee inquiry. I almost hesitate to say this, but I suggest that we should expand the proposal a little and develop the idea a bit more. I know that Dennis Canavan is particularly interested in cross-border co-operation with Ireland but, having checked, I am aware that Scotland has had a number of Interreg transnational co-operation projects. Analysing the projects in which Scotland has been involved might well inform and assist the inquiry. I wonder whether Dennis is willing to consider a slight expansion to his proposal, to allow us to consider the transnational element of Interreg. If we consider the new project and programme timescales, I wonder whether we might be able to develop the transnational element as well as the cross-border element. The more money we can bring into Scotland, and the more projects we can develop, the better.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

We are entirely in Dennis's hands. I know that he carried out a good and substantial inquiry for us before, but it was a lot of work. I think that it would be nice if we considered Interreg as a whole, but Dennis might feel that that is too much.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I am happy to start off, but there is no particular order to my comments.I agree with much of what the convener said. If we had to choose between a full inquiry into plan D—which stands for democracy, dialogue and debate—and a full inquiry into structural funds, my preference would be for plan D. From recent visits to Europe and from discussions across member states, I get the sense that people are agreed on the need for a period of reflection but are asking what we will do during that time. We need more than just a vague space, so we need to consider what a period of reflection actually means.We could take the issue forward by considering how we can make Europe work for citizens and by finding out what citizens want from Europe. I am keen to look into that issue a bit further. We could use the committee inquiry as an opportunity to ask civic Scotland and Scotland's voluntary sector what they are looking for from this period of reflection and how we can make Europe work.Although people can see all the advantages to Europe—the competitiveness agenda, the jobs and so on—they get frustrated when they see silly things happening in their communities. People feel that the European Commission is not listening to them on some issues. If we could take on board some of those concerns, we could make the inquiry relevant. The inquiry could also tap into Jim Wallace's proposal that we look at better regulation, but it would cover a much wider area.It would be useful for the committee to take time to think through the European Commission's proposals, particularly as the Commission is keen to engage with regional Governments and regional Parliaments at this point. As the Commission is about to publish a white paper, such an inquiry would provide us with an opportunity to prepare a considered response to that.In addition, the Scottish Executive is undertaking work in this area that we should scrutinise. It would be appropriate for us to become a bit better informed by using our time to consider what plan D means in those areas.My concern about an inquiry into structural funds is that nothing is happening with structural funds at the moment because, as we discussed at our previous meeting, people are still entrenched in their different camps. Certainly, the United Kingdom Government has said that it will deal with structural funds towards the end of its presidency—that might mean December if we are optimistic—but it would be difficult for us to take evidence, agree a report and conclude an inquiry within a timescale that might be relevant. If we are unable to influence those discussions, I wonder whether we might not be better to await the decisions on the final proposals.It is suggested that any inquiry into structural funds might look more at the structures than anything else. The committee paper contains a lot of information about structures and the sort of shape that they might take under future programme initiatives. However, instead of trying to push something through before December, we might find it easier to consider those issues once we know what the financial perspective and budget will look like.Those are my thoughts on the key areas that have been identified as issues that could be the subject of a full committee inquiry.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I did not mention Jim Wallace's proposal, which is very good, because I had assumed from the discussions that we had at our previous meeting that Jim was happy to take the matter on board as a rapporteur and was well on his way to doing so. I thought that we had more or less agreed to such an inquiry. The better regulation agenda is vital. However, it is also important that as regional Parliaments we respond to Commission initiatives on what is wrong with Europe. Part of the communication strategy will be for the Commission to ask us what we think is wrong with Europe. I hope that Jim Wallace will produce a good analysis that will allow us to respond to the Commission's questions about where we are going wrong. It is not just about communications and getting the message across; it is also about delivering better. I would have thought that we would be able to say that.I am fairly sure that regional Governments, the Committee of the Regions and the group of regions with legislative power will want to have input into the communication strategy, which will have a major impact across all member states. It would be remiss of the committee to miss an opportunity to do that. To have an input, we will have to take some evidence and to carry out analysis. We may say that communication is one strand, but the other is getting things right on the ground. We may have good examples of that to provide from the inquiry into better regulation that Jim Wallace is planning to conduct. The committee may want to undertake the inquiry alongside Jim or to support it. It is for him to decide how he wants to take forward the inquiry.Across Europe, regional Parliaments and Governments are talking about having a period of reflection, but what does that mean? I guess that there will be divisions along party lines. For example, the Conservatives would like the issue to die away and for us to forget about it. They say that the constitution is dead in the water, and that should be it. However, if we are realistic, that is not going to happen. We need to think about where we will go from here and what we will do. Will we salvage bits and pieces that concern the role of regional Governments in policy making and the liaison between regional Governments, regional Parliaments and the Commission, to improve the delivery and implementation of services on the ground? The constitution may not come back in the form that was proposed previously, but communication and reflection are partly about considering where we go from here. An institution such as the Scottish Parliament should contribute to that debate.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

I forgot to mention that point myself, but your comment is important. I agree that this is not the right time for a full inquiry on the services directive; however, we must consider closely its implications when its final shape emerges.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Perhaps John Home Robertson would like to be a rapporteur on the issue.

Irene Oldfather Lab Cunninghame South
link

Could Jim take the lead and regularly bring information back to the committee? There could be technical elements, and progress might be much quicker if we have one person talking to a Commission department, as opposed to our waiting for Commission officials to find a date in their diaries when they can come to Scotland. We may be dealing with two or three directives each of which is technical in its own right, and one person may be best placed to focus on the issues.

  1. Scottish Parliament European and External Relations Committee Tuesday 25 October 2005 Committee business · 1
  2. Interests Procedure · 2
  3. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 76
  5. Pre and Post-council Scrutiny Committee business · 3
  6. Sift Committee business · 10
  7. Convener's Report Procedure · 13

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.